Sailor Vs Agamemnon Comparison Of Conflict Weston Collegiate Institute Essay

1522 words - 7 pages

Shah 2
Hetvi Shah
Mr. Reed, Ms. Van Leur
ETS4U7
05/03/18
The Opposite Implications of Sacrifice in The Sailor who Fell from Grace with the Sea and Agamemnon
Aeschylus’s Agamemnon and Yukio Mishima’s the Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea (referred to as the Sailor from here on) were written in completely different centuries. Despite the difference in the times the texts were written, both pieces of work convey many similar themes. One of the themes presented in both texts is sacrifice. The theme of sacrifice is present throughout the book but there are specific sacrifices substantial to the plot in both the books. In Agamemnon, the sacrifice of Iphigenia helps the reader understand the connotation associated with the theme of sacrifice, and in the Sailor, the sacrifice of Ryuji is helpful to understand the theme. In Agamemnon, sacrifice is presented with the association of bloodshed and negative repercussions however it is quite the contrary in the Sailor, since Yukio Mishima presents the idea and practice of sacrifice as a glorified act.
Primarily, the readers can note the opposite connotations that attached to sacrifice by examining the placement of the act of sacrifice in the book. In both novels, the theme of sacrifice is constantly present throughout the book however, the climatic sacrifice scene is not placed at the same area in the plot for both the books. In Agamemnon, the most substantial sacrifice is the one of Iphigenia done by Agamemnon. The readers learn about this event early on since it is placed in the beginning. In the beginning of the book, the chorus describes that there has been a “sacrifice unholy” and “the child shall be avenged.” (Aeschylus 151/155) The unholy sacrifice refers to the sacrifice of Iphigenia and avengement indicates the problems that will follow. The placement of the sacrifice in the beginning implies the author’s utilization of sacrifice as the root cause of problems. In fact, it was the sacrifice of Iphigenia is what provoked Clytaemnestra against Agamemnon and therefore caused much of the conflicts in the play. Since the readers are informed about the sacrifices early on, it makes it possible to note the repercussions that follow with it as the book advances. Overall, the sacrifice is the instigator of the problems and hence is placed early in the book. However, in The Sailor, the climatic sacrifice of Ryuji takes place in the very last chapter. The placement of the sacrifice at the end implies that sacrifice is the resolution. According to the chief who lead Ryuji’s sacrifice believed that the sacrifice was essential to returning Ryuji back to glory as he stated, “this is our last chance…to perform the deed essential to filling the emptiness of the world” (Mishima 167). This implies that the gang believed that sacrificing Ryuji was the right thing since the sacrifice was the only wat to put an end to the problem, the problem being Ryuji’s growing distance from glory. Therefore, in complete contrast to Agamemnon, The Sailor uses sacrifice as a positive conclusion rather than a problem instigator. Looking at the preceding observations, it can be concluded that Agamemnon sacrifice is presented with the association of bloodshed and negative repercussions since the sacrifice leads to problem development in the plot however it is quite the contrary in the Sailor, since Yukio Mishima presents the idea and practice of sacrifice as a glorified event which acts as a resolution.
Secondly, what sets the theme of sacrifice apart in both the books are the vastly different attitudes towards sacrifice. In Agamemnon the idea of making human sacrifice is regarded with attention since it is not very normal. They believe that the one who commits the sacrifice may pay great repercussions and consequently leading to violent consequences. Therefore, when king Agamemnon sacrifices Iphigenia there is a lot of opinions and talk around it. His sacrifice of Iphigenia is not taken lightly and as a consequence Clytaemnestra murders him for revenge. Soon after she takes revenge for the controversial sacrifice she states, “Iphigenia of the tears he dealt with even as he has suffered.” (Aeschylus 1525-1526) Essentially, Clytaemnestra believes that What Agamemnon suffered he made others suffer equally. Clytaemnestra’s revenge exemplifies that in Agamemnon, sacrifice posses many repercussions that the practitioner might face and some of which may include bloodshed, in this case the murder of Agamemnon by Clytaemnestra. On the contrary, in the Sailor, the gang attempts to normalize the practice of sacrificing. The gang perceived emotion as unnecessary and hence they trained themselves to a point in which sex, murder, or sacrifice did not invoke emotion. To achieve such a state, referred to as “absolute dispassion” they believed that everyone should be able to sacrifice and consequently practice it many times. The gang meets to practice killing a cat to achieve the emotionless state of mind. After committing the sacrifice, Noboru is content that he was able to commit the sacrifice of the cast without hesitating, and “a distant hand reached into Noboru’s dream and awarded him a snow-white certificate of merit.” (Mishima 61) This conveys that the gang believed that everyone should be able to sacrifice since it is normal, and hence when Noboru did succeed, he felt accomplished and a part of the regular. Overall, the attitudes towards sacrifices are greatly difference. Since in Agamemnon, it is believed that the practitioner may face grave consequences, however in the Sailor sacrifice is glorified by the gang and hence they believe that it is an act that everyone should be able to complete.
Lastly, the objective and results of the sacrifice also enhance the understanding of sacrifice in both novels. In Agamemnon the purpose of the sacrifice is more selfish compared to the sacrifice in the Sailor. The motives behind the sacrifice is what differs the negative connotation in Agamemnon and glorified version of sacrifice in the Sailor. Firstly, in Agamemnon the sacrifice done by the king of his daughter Iphigenia is solely for selfish reasons. Agamemnon “endured then to sacrifice his daughter to stay the strength of war waged for a woman, first offering for a ships’ sake.” (Aeschylus 223-227). Essentially, the sacrifice of Iphigenia was to please Artemis so that his fleet could sail, and he could be victorious in the war. It can be concluded that he wanted to sacrifice his daughter for tangible results and results that will solely benefit him. In fact, the selfishness associated with the sacrifice is what set the negative tone and resulted in Clytaemnestra’s crave for revenge. Conversely, in the Sailor the sacrifice is not executed for personal benefits, or a selfish reason. In fact, the gang sacrifices Ryuji to stop chaos and return Ryuji back to his destined glory. While planning the execution of the sacrifice, the chief explains that, “if a gear shifts out of place it’s our job to force it back into position. If we don’t order will turn to chaos.” (Mishima 162) The gear refers to Ryuji and putting him back in place means to return him to glory, which they believe is only possible by sacrificing him. The gang believes in the sacrifice is for a greater good, which is to avoid utter chaos. Unlike the sacrifice done in Agamemnon, this sacrifice did not have tangible results but was done with a will to improve and aid others. Thus, the difference in the objective of the sacrifice is what showcases the different connotations applied. Since the sacrifice was done selfishly in Agamemnon the entire theme of sacrifice was regarded with a negative connotation which ultimately lead to revenge being plotted and bloodshed. On the other hand, the selflessness motive of the gang behind the sacrifice of Ryuji is what glorified the theme of sacrifice in the Sailor.
In conclusion, there are constant occurrences of sacrifice in Agamemnon and the Sailor, but the tone associated with sacrifice is different in both pieces of work. In Aeschylus’s Agamemnon the sacrifice of Iphigenia is known to the readers from the beginning therefore all the problems proceeding after, such as the bloodshed of Agamemnon by the hands of Clytaemnestra are repercussions of sacrifice. However, in the Sailor, the sacrifice is the resolution ending all problems, therefore giving the act of sacrifice a more esteemed status within the book. The attitudes about sacrifice are different in the texts as well. In Agamemnon, sacrifice is a big deal to society and the practitioner faces consequences however in the Sailor the gang specifically believes that sacrifice is an essential skill everyone must be able to do. Lastly, negativity and bloodshed are associated with sacrifice in Agamemnon as a result of the selfish motive behind the sacrifice but however is glorified in the Sailor since the sacrifice was done for a greater good. Overall, sacrifice is constantly present within both the pieces however their connotative meanings suggests association of sacrifice with bloodshed and negative repercussions in Agamemnon and a glorified version in the Sailor.
Works Cited
Grene, David, et al. The Complete Greek Tragedies. University of Chicago Press, 1992.
Mishima, Yukio. The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea. Vintage Classic, 2015.

RELATED

Transgression in Everybody's Son - Glebe Collegiate Institute - Essay Assignment

2086 words - 9 pages Taylor 1 Anthony Taylor Ms. Loughrey ENG4U May 22, 2019 Transgression in ​Everybody’s Son In modern society, mankind is classified into groups called “races” based on skin tone which has led to the mistreatment of many different races in history. In the novel, Everybody’s Son by Thrity Umrigar, Anton is put into a transgressive community where everyone around him including his mom, his adoptive father, and mother, and himself. In society, people

Analysis of Unwind Using Setting Conflict and Character - English - Essay

1610 words - 7 pages warehouse before he is flown to the ‘Graveyard’. He meets Roland, a power-hungry teen that stops at nothing to be at the top of the food chain. Risa warns Connor of Roland, as he has the adeptness to stop him. Connor is thrown into another person vs person conflict, but “a kid like Roland doesn’t want to fight [him]. He wants to kill [him].” (Shusterman 147). Once again, Roland will stop at nothing to win the conflict, including murder, due to his

Comparison Essay of Tuck Everlasting and Peter Pan - Dawson, English - Comparison

1141 words - 5 pages Comparison Essay of Tuck Everlasting and Peter Pan The novel Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbitt follows the story of an overprotected girl named Winnie Foster and her journey with the Tuck family. She learns from them about a different way of life as well as the secret of their immortality and comes to understand how important the cycle of life really is. Similarly, in Peter Pan, the 2003 movie, directed by P.J Hogan, we observe Wendy Darling

Comparison between different versions of Blue Beard - English 120 - Essay

994 words - 4 pages Tyson 1 Jackson Tyson Professor Pristen Wichelson ENG 120 15 October 2018 Perrault’s Blue Beard vs. Willingham’s Bluebeard A pioneer in the novelization of Folklore, Perrault has established himself as a spearhead in the advancement of the genre. Centuries later, we have authors like Bill Willingham, taking more creative approaches of representing folklore. Through his work in his adaptations of these fairytales, Fables, written by Willingham

explore Williams’ presentation of the conflict between Blanche and Stanley so far. - School Lit - Essay

1440 words - 6 pages ‘A streetcar named Desire is a play concerned with the conflict between the old world and the new.’ In light of this comment, explore Williams’ presentation of the conflict between Blanche and Stanley so far. In your answer, you must consider relevant contextual factors. In ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’, Williams has crafted characters to transcend the limits of their literal expression by having each individual identify with key themes such as

African Origins Of Homo Sapiens Vs Multiregionalists - Morehouse - Essay

1800 words - 8 pages Ronnell Fuller Page 1  Dr. Ligon  English 102  November 20, 2017  African Origins Of Homo Sapiens Vs Multiregionalists   For the past few decades, hypotheses based on sacred excavations and paleontology have  to lead to the thought and wonders of how the modern human came to form. Questions such as  how he lived, his intellectual ability, what he used to hunt with, and most importantly where he  came from have all revolved scientists minds

divergent conflict man vs. self and enviorment - english comp - essay

539 words - 3 pages Allison Sparks Mrs. Musgrove ENG123-lec-a 2 February 2017 Divergent Conflict Divergent is the first book in the trilogy by Veronica Roth. It was first published in 2001. It is a book about the ride of passage of 16 year old, Beatrice Prior, Tris, who must choose which faction is her best fit in society. The book is first set in post-war Chicago. The city is dilapidated, buildings are crumbling, sidewalks broken, roads are collapsed; open sewers

Discourse: Privileges of Private vs. Public School - English - Essay

1417 words - 6 pages Free Maria Alejandra Villabon Professor Foley English 17 September 2018 Discourse Essay: The Privileges of Private School vs. Public School There is one thing that a myriad of people in this world find essential in someone’s life; school. Schools are used to teach students about a variety of subjects, develop mathematical and english skills, but mainly to prepare people for the 21st century workplace. However, schools are distinguished by two words

macbeth Essay of elementalization for chemists - Copenhagen Collegiate School, Grade 11 - Essay

1063 words - 5 pages OCDSB 716 Curriculum (April 2012) Page 1 of 2 COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT NOTIFICATION AND ACTIVITY COMPLETION SHEET Student Name Student ID No. Principal School Telephone Community involvement hours completed to date Student’s Signature Date Parent’s or Guardian’s Signature Date Please provide the information requested below about the community involvement activities in which you are involved. Approval of the principal or designate is

A comparison of Right & Left Realism in Criminology - Westminister University - Essay

2151 words - 9 pages Free Crm2500 – Criminology in late modernity Priyesh Bhangoo – M00627199 Discuss one example of crime prevention or control inspired by right realist ideas, and one inspired by left realist ideas. Compare them, considering their strengths and weaknesses. This essay will focus on the comparison between the strengths and weaknesses of both Right Realist and Left Realists ideas in regards to the control and prevention of crime. Realist Criminology

European Union and United States Comparison Report - University of Phoenix/GEO 155 - Essay

490 words - 2 pages European Union and United States Comparison 3 European Union and United States Comparison Report Asdrubal Castillo GEO/155 July 1, 2013 Mr. Robert G. Prescott The European Union (EU) was founded was founded after the end of World War Two in 1948 and consist of 28 European countries with the goal to promote stability and economic cooperation between its members. It consists of a Council that represent national governments, the European

Shakespeare's Hamlet Act IV-scene v comparison of Branagh vs Almereyda's film adaptations - Shakespeare and film - Essay

1070 words - 5 pages Hamlet Act IV –scene V comparison of Branagh-1996 and Almereyda’s-2000 Hamlet Max Castellanos Student # N00461858 3/27/2018 Two directors: Kenneth Bragnagh and Michael Almereyda , have taken the Shakespeare classic : Hamlet, and adapted it the play for the silver screen . Being released only 4 years apart from eachother, both directors have taken their respective approaches to interpreting the Shakespeare classic. What we will be taking a

Comparison Essay: Nazi Germany's Dictatorship Vs. Australian Democracy

2974 words - 12 pages Historical events have shaped our world to create the societies we exist in today. People like the Greeks, Romans and English have had immeasurable impacts of the way we comprehend, rationalize, analyze and respond to events. There are events in history that alter the state of being, either for the good or for the bad. Nazi Germany; one of the most horrific societies to have ever endured, compared to Australia's democracy in the 21st century. As

Comparative Essay: “Republicans vs. Democrats: A quick glimpse of the divide” - WRI1001 - Essay

1000 words - 4 pages Democrats vs. Republicans 1 Democrats vs. Republicans 1 Comparative Essay: “Republicans vs. Democrats: A quick glimpse of the divide” Jesse Millstead Florida Institute of Technology Abstract The United States maintains a 2-party political system, while striving for the common goals of a strong United States that is the envy of the world, there is a sharp difference in the policies they believe will achieve those goals. Mainly these differences

Positive and Negative Consequence of Legal Euthanasia - Florida Institute of Technology/Human Behavior Perspectives - Essay

765 words - 4 pages Running head: Effects of Euthanasia 1 Effects of Euthanasia 8 The Positive and Negative Effects of Euthanasia Yasmina S. Davis Florida Institute of Technology Keywords: doctor-assisted suicide, euthanasia, consequences, positive effects The Positive and Negative Effects of Euthanasia As humans, we have basic rights like freedom from discrimination, freedom from slavery, or the right to life, liberty, and personal security. But what about the