Seeing Double: Why Cloning Breaks Ethical Boundaries Cox Mill High School, English 3 Honors Research Paper

1670 words - 7 pages

Kruse
Parker Kruse
Mrs. Ramsey
English 3 Academy Honors
13 November 2018
Seeing Double: Why Cloning Breaks Ethical Boundaries
Dolly, born on July 5th, 1996 was the first ever cloned mammal. Dolly’s first years of life as a normal sheep were great. In her later years, the drawbacks from the cloning started to appear. These drawbacks eventually caused her suffer until she died at half the age of an expected sheep. Cloning animals is very unpredictable and can cause major health issues to the animal cloned. Some of these issues may be long term or short term effects, and the animals are suffering all for the sake of testing and experimenting. Cloning results in many problems, and there are many possibilities that something will go wrong, so to ensure the safety of animals cloning must end. Cloning animals is not ethical because cloning animals decreases genetic diversity, cloning animals causes animals to suffer, and an outcome of cloning animals can give rise to medical issues within the animal.
Cloning animals decreases genetic diversity and affects the long term health of livestock and other animals. Cloning livestock has many cons, one of them being that the outcome of cloning livestock for a long period of time can affect the genetic diversity in the livestock in the far future (Goldsmith). Animals that are cloned far to much tend to suffer much more, “cloning animals threatens the long term health of livestocking greed as genetic diversity declines”(Goldsmith). As a result of cloning animals it decreases the diversity within the animals. This also proves the point that a decrease in genetic diversity will cause the long term health of livestock to be affected. Additionally, cloning animals decreases the amount of animals that have different characteristics and genetic makeup, considering the amount of animals cloned each year society can expect species of livestock to all look the same in the future (Goldsmith).
If one animal is cloned multiple times because of the valuable characteristics it has, it will result in a reduction of the distinction in the genetic makeup within the animals. In the future if farmers have the same animal everywhere and no genetic distinctiveness, diseases or issues may rise within the cloned animals. Farmers around the world clone their best livestock to hopefully use them again, “farmers clone the same animal multiple times causing the entire herds genetic diversity to decrease” (Goldsmith). Farmers wanting to clone their best animal causes the genetic diversity to decrease because the same animal is cloned over and over again (Goldsmith). At the moment it looks very good to have the best animal cloned many times but in the future when all livestock have the same genetic makeup it can lead to disease within the livestock. However, when cloning livestock their are bound to be failures, causing each animal to suffer.
Cloning animals cause them to suffer and Dolly is a perfect example of this. Dolly was the first cloned livestock born on, July 5, 1996, and lived a painful life (Dolly). A scientist at the Roseland Institute where Dolly was born said, ”After Dolly gave birth to her last lamps and September 2000, it was discovered that she had become infected by a virus called jaagsiekte sheep retrovirus“ (Dolly). Because Dolly was the first mammal cloned there was many unpredictable factors that led to her early death. At the cost for Dolly’s early death scientist around the world got more information on how to clone animals and what exactly will happen when an animal is cloned (Dolly). With more scientist learning to clone animals, the more animals that will suffer at the cost of experiments.
The world has seen many deformities and medical issues in cloned animals, causing each animal to suffer. Often times when cloned animals are born, they are born like a normal animal, but a small percentage suffer greatly because of the deformities cloning has caused them. Roxanna Maas mentions the issue in an article saying, “Cloned cells however, may lack the programming necessary to tell genes when to turn on and off. The result may be disorganized cell growth or inappropriate cell functioning both of which can harm the organism”(Maas). Each animal’s lives matter and if there's a chance of an organism dying because of cloning, it should be considered animal cruelty. The cruelty caused by cloning is devastating, the deformities caused my cloning are severe, and their is a chance of death for every cloned animal (Maas). In conclusion, each animal cloned has a chance to suffer, but deformities are not the only thing causing them to suffer.
Cloned animals that attempt to reproduce have a high rate of failure and many suffer from the process. There are many cases of the parent giving birth dying or even the babies dying directly after birth caused by cloning. Many times the embryo has a very little chance of surviving, “pregnancy might fail if the embryo has failed to develop properly, or it may survive for a short period of time, then die later”(Maas). Each embryo has the option to turn into an animal, but if these embryos are used for experiments its may causes the animal that has the embryos taken from them to suffer. Even if the embryo survives it is a high rate of failure, meaning it was a waste of an essential life (Maas). Furthermore almost every animal involved with cloning suffers, either their embryos are taken or the cloned animal never sees the light of day.
Cloning animals has a chance to give rise to medical problems and many offspring produced by cloned animals die or have major health problems. Major health problems can consist of many things, for instance, unusually large organs, breathing dysfunctions, immune system failure, and many more. Society needs to rethink cloning animals with the risk of all these major health problems, “Many cloned offspring die within 24 hours of birth”(Hare). Offspring of cloned animals are more likely have some form of a medical issue than a regular animal (Hare). As mentioned before cloned offspring have a higher chance to have medical issues, some not even seeing daylight. To ensure that animals can see the light of day, society needs to end cloning.
Many medical issues may come about as a result of technology constantly changing. Technology is changing daily, it affects experiments on cloning animals and at times has drastic accidents involving animal deaths (Center). Technology being unpredictable makes the cloning process much more unsafe and can cause catastrophes to occur, “we have had many cloning failures, because of technology advancements”(Center). Because of the issues when cloning, it causes many medical problems for the cloned animal, usually resulting in death. Changing technology not only hurts the organisms but it also affects the animals they are taking cells from because the more failures, the more cells needed (Center). Furthermore many cloned animals that die from change in technology helps set cloning agency’s back preventing them from producing more cloned animals.
Cloned animals giving birth can have severe medical problems before, during, or even after reproduction.(Maas) As mentioned earlier, Dolly had many issues and one of them was that when she was born her health drop drastically and many medical issues arise. The scientist that took care of dolly made a statement saying “when dolly was born she was very normal but as her life continued she got arthritis and a virus in her lungs“(Dolly). Both of these issues caused her life to be half the lifespan of an average sheep . According to researchers, Dolly’s medical issues were because of the mitochondria and her cells not being totally comparable to the DNA from her parent clone (Dolly). Lastly, people need to stop cloning animals because their life expectancy is much shorter than the average animal.
One argument that supports cloning is that it can be beneficial. If society were to clone specific parts of an animal, in order to save an animal that is suffering, it would be very beneficial. Many animals could recover from major injuries or even diseases in certain sections of the body. For instance, if an animal suffers a major injury in their leg and needs either a new leg or have a leg amputated. Cloning would help with this process, because you could clone a replica of the animal and use the leg to recover the animal to how it was previously.. We could also use this for human somatic cells and even treat human issues. For instance if a person needs a new organ, the organ can be replicated and transplanted to the human in need. On the other hand the amount of test, and amount of animals that are required for this to be accomplished would be unpleasant. Most of the animals they experiment on suffer, which is why cloning animals is not ethical.
Each animal that is cloned is likely to suffer, decrease genetic diversity within a population, or give rise to medical issues, which is why cloning animals is not ethical. Dolly was a living example of the effects cloning has on an animal. Animals do not have a choice whether or not they are cloned and they cannot express the feelings they have. Every cloned animal has an increased chance to die, have deformities, have disease, or even pregnancy failure. Society needs to think about the harm each cloned animal and animal being cloned receives, and asked themselves if cloning animals is truly ethical or not.
Works Cited
Center for Veterinary Medicine. “Animal Cloning - Risk Management Plan.” US Food and Drug Administration Home Page, Apr. 2015
“Dolly Part One: The end of the beginning in mammalian cloning?” Nature Genetics, vol. 24, Nov. 4, 2000, p. 347. Opposing Viewpoints Center
Goldsmith, Edward. Cloned Animals a ‘Threat to Genetic Diversity’ The Ecologist, 17 Nov. 2017.
Hare, Doug. Cloning : Opposing Viewpoints. Greenhaven Press / Gale Cengage Learning, Aug. 2012.
Maas, Roxanne. What are the Risk Associated with Cloning Animals? [Opposites Attract]. Biological Questions, 24 Aug. 2015.

RELATED

Cloning Research Paper

2959 words - 12 pages . Deliberate cloning is as old as horticulture itself. Thousands of years before anyone understood the physical nature of heredity, specific genetic constitutions were preserved through cloning because they bestowed on the plant desirable qualities such as disease-resistance, high yield and predictable growth. Cloning is as important to the production of fine wine, the supply of rubber and the fruit harvest as it is to the variety of an English

Symbolism/ Allegory in the Scarlet Letter - the high school for health professions/ English 3 H - Research paper

707 words - 3 pages Name Yasmine Howell____________ Date February 13, 2019 Hour 1st English 11 – American Literature Author Biography Worksheet Answer the following questions on this paper or by downloading this document from the network and typing your answers. Be sure to answer all parts of every question. Use the two column format to help you study for tests by covering up the right side and quizzing yourself with the questions on the left. 1. Author name Walter

William Shakespeare Research Paper - Honors English 9B - Research paper

730 words - 3 pages -upon-Avon and was the third of eight children. Shakespeare went to grammar school and learned Latin and literature. He went on and married a woman named Annie Hathaway on November 27, 1582 and had three children. His first daughter was named Susanna and was born on May 26, 1583 and then, two years later, he had twins-Hamnet and Judith-that were born on February 2, 1585. By 1592, Shakespeare was a well-known popular actor in the Elizabethan

Discrepancies Between Early School Start Times and Insufficient Sleep - High School English - Research Paper

2096 words - 9 pages Franklin 1 Chenoa Franklin Mr. Crossetti Honors English 11 March 12, 2018 Discrepancies Between Early School Start Times and Insufficient Sleep Early school start times can have potentially negative health impacts on some students, leading to an increase in poor academic performance and a decline in personal wellbeing. Insufficient sleep is greatly associated with early school wake up times. Countless numbers of teenage students struggle

essay lord of the flies. is a high school english honors 10 level paper. garnered to get you a b - english - report

771 words - 4 pages Townsend 1 Avery Townsend Ms. Harker English 10 Honors 26 September 2018 How symbolism affects the theme The author of ​Lord of the Flies​ spent time at war and saw how an idea can change people?​ Lord of the Flies ​is a book about boys who are stranded on an island. The boys become more and more savage throughout the book. In the Postmodern novel ​ Lord of the Flies, ​William Golding uses the symbol of the beast to portray the boys fear of

Psychology of Standardized Testing - Lonestar Honors English 1301 - Research Paper

2715 words - 11 pages Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas, 81(3), 138-140. doi:10.3200/tchs.81.3.138-140 Graham, G., Parker, S., Wilkins, J. L., Fraser, R., Westfall, S., & Tembo, M. (2002). The effects of high-stakes testing on elementary school art, music, and physical education. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 73(8), 51-54. doi:10.1080/07303084.2002.10608330 Heissel, J. A., Levy, D. J., & Adam, E. K. (2017). Stress, sleep, and performance on

How the Drug War Failed and How It Can Be Improved - Credo High School/English - Research Paper - Research Paper

5581 words - 23 pages Luther Gennert  Gennert 1  Ms. Bliquez  Research Paper 10A  3 October 2017  The Failure of the Drug War and A Better Solution  “America's public enemy number one in the United States is drug abuse. In order  to fight and defeat this enemy, it is necessary to wage a new, all-out offensive:” With  those words, Nixon started the War on Drugs. According to the government, the  purpose of the drug war was to eliminate all drug use, creating a perfect

Childhood Trauma Creates Inner Strength in Adulthood - Garfield High School English Composition I - Research Paper

1150 words - 5 pages Sanabria 1 Emily Sanabria Mrs. Robbin English Composition I 1 May 2019 Childhood Trauma Creates Inner Strength Y​ou're rushing around your house and you accidentally knock a precious vase to the floor. It smashes into pieces immediately. What do you do next? Do you see the vase as garbage now and throw it in the bin? Do you collect the pieces and try to put them together exactly as it was? Or do you pick up your favorite pieces from the pile and

Abandonment and Dark Imagery in Sylvia Plath's “Daddy” - la jolla country day school, honors english 3 - Poem analysis

2206 words - 9 pages �1 Abandonment and Dark Imagery in “Daddy” Leila Bitarafan Honors English III Daddy You do not do, you do not do Any more, black shoe In which I have lived like a foot For thirty years, poor and white, Barely daring to breathe or Achoo Daddy, I have had to kill you You died before I had time------ Marble-heavy, a bag full of God, Ghastly statue with one gray toe Big as a Frisco seal And a head in the freakish Atlantic Where it pours bean green

An essay on love and the concept of love - Havelock High School English 3 - essay

1119 words - 5 pages Susan Hester Comment by EDNA DONALDSON: You are a natural Philosopher! Consider it as a profession. February 5, 2018 1st period Love What is the one emotion that has everyone mystified?Love.What is love to you? Do you love your family, your friends? What about school, yeah I know not many people love school do they?Well I can’t describe love in words but I know love when I feel it. When I hug someone in my family I feel a warmth in my heart

This Is A Research Paper That Introduces The Well Known Huma Research Project: HUMAN CLONING

1773 words - 8 pages could change our future. The practice of cloning human beings may finally be a reality and research continues this very moment. Although the moral and ethical issues can be overcome, cloning is still a major innovative break-though and is a potential solution to our health problems.According to Dr. Robert Lanza, vice president of the Advanced Cell Technology, "Our intention is not to create cloned human beings, but rather to make lifesaving

Art History Paper on Double Crocodile Pendant - AP Art History - Research Paper

754 words - 4 pages curled up nose of a bat, and the crest of an iguana (“Double Crocodile Pendant”). This metal ornament is thought to have been a symbol of status and power and would have been commissioned and worn only by someone with wealth and high class. In Macaracas culture, animals were often used in artwork to depict a certain strength or attribute of the person it was commissioned by, which could be a reasoning behind the multiple animal features present in

Correlation Between Parenting Style and Creativity Found in Adults - Piedmont Hills High School English Class - Research Paper

1309 words - 6 pages Newell 1 Sandy Newell Ms. Kravitz English April 15th, 2017 ​Correlation Between Parenting Style and Creativity Found in Adults Debates on the association between the three different types of parenting styles and creativity oscillates amongst many research studies. Permissive parenting style portrays a friend like relationship between the parents and the children, showing little rules and authority (Miller). In contrast to permissive parenting

Euthanasia and Assisted suicide - High school religion - research paper

1020 words - 5 pages lifestyle. In contrary, the church also states that “In our society, human life is under direct attack” (“Life and Dignity of the Human Person.” ). This means that although we believe everyone should participate in this idea of respect for life, there are things that counteract it. Abortion, domestic violence, human trafficking, stem cell research and human cloning are just a few of the ways human life is being attacked. One specific topic that is

Bipolar disorder and It's Affects - Moorestown High School - research paper

3622 words - 15 pages relationships, poor job or school performance, and even suicide. But bipolar disorder can be treated, and people with this illness can lead full and productive lives. Bipolar disorder often appears in the late teens or early adult years. At least half of all cases start before age 25. Some people have their first symptoms during childhood, while others may develop symptoms late in life. Bipolar disorder is not easy to spot when it starts. Some people