Shared Sorrows: The Plight Of Homosexual Prisoners In The Concentration Camps Topics In Literature Essay

748 words - 3 pages

Analysis: Shared Sorrows and The Men with the Pink Triangle
Most of Holocaust literature depicts Jewish victimhood. One will imagine images of Auschwitz, gas chambers, and furnaces. Images of the countless dead thrown into vast pits come to mind. However, there was more to the Holocaust than the extermination of European Jewry. Hitler planned the extermination of all “Undesirables” from Germany. This group included not only Jews, but Gypsies and homosexuals. Books like Shared Sorrows and The Men with the Pink Triangle describe the plight of these little mentioned groups during the Holocaust.
In Shared Sorrows, the author is an outsider not only to the survivors she interviews but also to the whole Sinti Gypsy community. But the mutual affection between Toby and the Mettbach and Hollenreiner families is evident as she is told memories that are rarely shared. For example, Rosa Mettbach speaks of horrors. She makes four failed escape attempts, each time punished more harshly. Yet, she survives several concentration camps. Sonneman relays detailed memories of the camps; the smells of burning flesh, the ashen air, the lice crawling about one’s head.
Toby Sonneman is given a glimpse into a society that is not understood by the outside world. Instead of giving the usual lecture on what happened, what they suffered through, Toby gives the events and characters a humanity—a face. The author writes about the pastries she and Rosa Mettbach eat during the interviews. Rosa is mentioned as a chain-smoking grandmother who indulges in her own prejudices. The Sinti were (and still are) victims of prejudice, but they have their own prejudice. Some of this prejudice rubs off on Toby. The author struggles at how to view the Germans she comes across, were they all compliant or did some stand up and help the helpless? Toby examines this question when visiting the home her family was forced to leave and meeting Germans who stayed. The people of Dachau must have heard or smelled the atrocities at the edge of town. I also pondered over Sonneman’s question. I found Shared Sorrows to be more than a collection of testimonies, but rather a study in human nature itself.
One can admire the author’s conscience in listening and recording the testimonies, but Sonneman keeps a journalist’s voice. I believe this is what lets the reader understand all that she heard. She brings her readers into a universe of unspeakable memories we must all remember.
There were others who suffered under Nazi cruelty. The Men with the Pink Triangle is one man's account of the harshness and cruelty faced by gay men at the hands of the SS, as well as by the other prisoners—criminals and political prisoners—who viewed "filthy queers" as scum. They were distinguished by the large, pink triangles sown onto their prison outfits, making them targets of denigration. Also, homosexuals labored through the worst of the forced work details and were forced into deadly medical experimentation.
Heinz Hegel's book brings the harsh facts surrounding the persecution of gays under the Third Reich’s Section 175 anti-homosexuality laws. We are given the shocking historical context which few of us know, that people even suspected of same gender love relationships were tortured and killed by the Nazi regime.
This is testament of survival against all odds, mixed with humor, not overbearing in tone or content. However, I found the book not essentially about the “men with the pink triangle”. It was more of a personal memoir. The other characters in it were at the edge of his horrific story.
While we can appreciate that Hegel survived six years of extermination camps, he ends the book by reminding us that "the progress of humanity" has largely ignored his minority group. When Hegel's book was written (1970), homosexual / lesbian relationships were still illegal in his native Austria. As if that wasn’t enough, we learn that homosexuals remain the only minority persecuted in Nazi camps omitted from compensation by the new German government.
I believe we need more books like this one. We need more testimonies from the homosexual survivors. But as Hegel explains that many of those gays who survived the camps are still unwilling to speak, and that is in part of how they were treated after the camps were "liberated." The Nazis were brutal in their treatment, but their reign of terror would not last. The new German government’s bureaucrats, however, were much more sinister. One could explain that the Third Reich’s Section 175 is still in effect.


Jewish Resistance in the Ghettos - English Topics Literature - Research Paper

580 words - 3 pages they resisted anyways. They would fight back in the ghettos, the forests, and in the death camps. In their hearts, they would also resist. Although their livelihood and their dignity had been torn from them, the Nazis could not steal their hope. Memoirs of a Warsaw Ghetto Fighter is an example of Jewish resistance – hope for the Jews. Simha Rotem, also known as Kazik, the author of Memoirs survived because he was a member of the Resistance. In his

Comparison Of Concentration Camps To Japanese Internment

839 words - 4 pages Germany and Poland, many of which had served the very countries who were persecuting them during World War One) were all unjustly and unfairly treated for many years, until the liberation of the Concentration camps, and the release of the prisoners in the 'relocation centers'.While some may argue that the Japanese in these internment camps were treated fairly, many returned to their houses after their captivity to find another (white) family living

The Power of Words in Literature - Fiction/English - Essay

1020 words - 5 pages The Power of Words in Literature and Culture The importance of words is a theme seen hundreds of times throughout literature. During times of censorship, the words still found a way to break through. During war, the words still helped soothe the readers. Words can help change the way people live their lives and how they think about their lives and how they think about themselves. We are going to take a look at two works of literature and a

The Age Of Romanticism In American Literature

364 words - 2 pages The Age of Romanticism was a short yet meaningful period in American literature. American literature developed in dramatic ways during this age. Moving away from their European roots American writers started composing more and more articles unique to American culture. For the next two decades, American writers such as Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Walt Whitman, Edgar Allan Poe, Nathaniel Hawthorne, produced scores of

The Essay Is A Research Paper That Arguments A Law In Florida That Prohibits Homosexual Men And Women From Adopting Children

1251 words - 6 pages many tiresome attempts to prevent this law from passing, the law was approved by senate on June 7, 1977.Evidently, what many failed to perceive was the effect that this policy would inflict on society: indirectly and directly. For example, Doug is a homosexual who is in a court room struggle against the Florida policy because he wants to legally adopt Oscar, a child who was given to him at the age of three by the boy's father (Ferrero, Frecker

The Rise of Humanity in The Fall of Man: Acceptance of Sin in The Scarlet Letter - American Literature - essay

1447 words - 6 pages letter had endowed her with a new sense. She shuddered to believe, yet could not help believing, that it gave her a sympathetic knowledge of the hidden sin in other hearts” (57). The ability to identify sinners along with her own experience as a sinner allows her the “power to sympathise” (99) with members of her community. She becomes a heroine figure to which many Puritan women bring “all their sorrows and perplexities” and beseech “her counsel

The significance of jealousy in the first half of 'Othello' - English Literature - Essay

1308 words - 6 pages Explore the significance of jealousy in the first half of the play Jealousy is introduced as a key theme within the first half of Othello, the ability for personal jealousy to consume and influence the actions of characters emphasises its power and importance within the play. It is epitomised within the definition as ‘the green eyed monster which doth mock’, this personification further demonstrates jealousy as a power. The theme is revolves

Sacramento City Schools' 2018 Budget Shortfall - Vanderbilt University, Special Topics: Cities in the 2 - Briefing

899 words - 4 pages To: Mayor Darrell Steinberg, Governor Jerry Brown From: Austen Sandoval Re: Sacramento City Unified School District California’s significant changes in educational policy have potentially been a boon for the city of Sacramento’s ~47,000 students. However, a gap remains between the reforms themselves and ensuring that education providers have the necessary resources in order for the consequences of these reforms to be realized. Background

Significance of the Title in the Novel Quicksand - Comparative Literature - Essay

2002 words - 9 pages Igneri Nicholas Igneri Professor Runciman COLI 211B 14 March 2019 Significance of the Title Quicksand by Nella Larsen The novel Quicksand was published in 1928 by Mulatto-American woman Nella Larsen. During this period of time, the Harlem Renaissance was at its peak. The Harlem Renaissance was a social movement for African-Americans where art and music exploded onto the scene. Larsen’s novel Quicksand can be considered an embracement and

Essay describing women in the Medieval Times - British Literature - Essay

1034 words - 5 pages Going back into periods of time as far as history can be remembered, women was highly discriminated in almost every society. They were always discriminated against and oppressed towards any society that they lived in. Although, they were discriminated that period of time, it brought women to defining their stereotype of their own sex. Women went against discrimination by speaking out. With the amount of the strength and intelligence they had

“Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God”: A Brutal Enlightening - american literature - essay

1236 words - 5 pages Morales 1 Morales 2 Javier Morales Mr. Walker ENG-231-01 3 October, 2018 “Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God”: A Brutal Enlightening On July 8, 1741, Jonathan Edwards gave a sermon known as “Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God.” The sermon was given inside the Enfield congressional church in Connecticut. On this day, church attendants experienced one of the most important sermons in American literature (Arkin). This sermon describes how the

Why Did The First World War Break Out In August 1914? Is Any One Particular Nation Especially "Guilty" For What Happened? Or Should Responsibility Be "Shared" Among All Of The Major European Powers?

1396 words - 6 pages fighting, and then other nations joining in because of its huge scale. The responsibility should be shared, but not equally shared, as Germany's ruthlessness is what caused the original European war, which escalated to form the First World War.

Essay on one of the topics for Financial - financial reporting - report

1107 words - 5 pages February 27, 2019 Ms. Carolyn Ringer Treasurer Menotomy Health Services Subject: Menotomy Health Services Financial Position Dear Ms. Ringer, This document contains information regarding the Menotomy Home Health Service 2011 financial statements and reconciled pro-forma. In addition, the non-for-profit organization can continue its line of credit as it has a good credit score. Menotomy Home Health Services is a health service that is growing

Identity in The Great Gilly Hopkins - The City College of New York for Children's Literature - Essay/ Analysis

1694 words - 7 pages , and troublesome behavior in an attempt to distance herself and hopefully end up with her biological mother. Throughout her stay in Maime Trotter's house, she begins to have new experiences, face consequences for her bad behavior, and receive patient love that helps create both an understanding of the world around her and her identity. When we first meet Gilly, we learn that she doesn't like to be called her full name, as she reserves that for

Reading Response of The Sorrows of Young Werther by Johann Wolfgang Von Goethe - Humanism 101 - Reading Response

564 words - 3 pages allowed his self-absorption to rule him – in the most extreme way – that it cost him his life, and therefore is he is not an example of a good human being. However, Lotte on the other hand, is a person of great virtues and have devoted her life to service others and because of this she becomes an example of an excellent human being. Thus, it has been established that this crucial, humanistic insight can be found in Goethe’s novel The Sorrows of Young Werther.