Should Horse Slaughter Be Legal In Us College Comp 2 Research Paper

2179 words - 9 pages

Keyes 1
Karley Keyes
Mr. Marcus
EN1113-18
28 March 2018
The Need for Horse Slaughter Facilities in the United States
Is slaughter a necessary evil? Often, a bloody, gory picture is what comes to mind when the topic of slaughter is brought up. Horse slaughter has been a highly debated topic in the recent years. Slaughter facilities are broadly viewed as evil and inhumane. As a result of constant debate on horse slaughter, in 2007 U.S. withheld federal funding for the required inspection of horsemeat. Therefore, resulting in the ban of horse slaughter. This ban will be surrounded with more controversial topics. Many Americans are unaware of or ignore the fact of the large number of neglected and abandoned horses in our country. Is this large number because of the ban? Does the ban increase the welfare of the horse? Will economics be affected by the ban? The ban on horse slaughter should be lifted because it will have positive impacts on the economy, improve the welfare of horses, and also allow the U.S. to produce horsemeat.
The issue of horse slaughter began around 1979 when the high number of deaths in horses being shipped to Europe became a concern suggest writer Natalie Anderson in the article “Protecting Equine Welfare and International Consumers of Horse Meat: A Proposal for the Renewal of Horse Slaughter in the United States”. This lead to the prevention of overseas shipment for processing through legislation passed. As a result, by the end of the 1980’s slaughtered 320,000 horses in 16 plants in the United States (130). Animal rights groups pushed the bill passed resulting in loss of federal funds for inspection. By bearing the expense of inspection three facilities remained open until Texas and Illinois passed state legislation banning slaughter for human consumption forcing them to close their doors (131). Animal rights groups have made numerous attempts to permanently ban horse slaughter as well as the export intended for human consumption, but continuously unsuccessful. (132-133). This ban has severe impacts on this topic. Writer Natalie Anderson believes that “The de facto ban on horse slaughter in the United States, although well intentioned, has resulted in unintended negative consequences on equine welfare, the domestic horse industry, and the safety of international consumers of horse meat.” (159). Writers K.E. Holcomb et.al suggest “Closure of the last US equine slaughter facilities in 2007 and the economic recession that began in 2008 are 2 factors believed to have precipitated the increasing number of unwanted, potentially neglected, and abused horses in the United States.” (4142). In addition to the ethics resulting in the ban of slaughter, authors Dan Lawler and L. Leon Geyer argue that “one must consider the ethics of not slaughtering horses in a world plagued by food crisis; are those calories wasted and could they be efficiently relocated?” (273). Tom R. Lenz, DVM adds “To many Americans, the horse is a symbol of beauty, grace, and the American West and is a cultural icon. This perception of the horse has greatly complicated the unwanted horse issue and the discussion of end-of-life decisions for horses.” (253). Writer Laura Durfee believes animal welfare groups are “emotionally charged” and never acknowledge what will actually result from the ban of slaughter (353). Authors Mykel Taylor and Elizabeth Sieverkropp add the closure of horse slaughter plants as well as the economic recession had an “estimated 12%-16% decline in price” for horses priced under $1500 (61). Animal welfare groups should observe the negative impact the ban of slaughter has had on our country and the welfare of animals.
Than ban on horse slaughter has put horse owners in a tough situation with no economically efficient disposal of the unwanted horse. According to author Laura J. Durfee in the article “Anti-Horse Slaughter Legislation: Bad for Horses, Bad for Society” the number of abused, neglected, and abandoned horses will increase (354). Horses are now forced to die a slow and painful death of starvation and dehydration because of the ban on horse slaughter. As a horse owner seeing these horses suffering miserably is terrible to see. It is pathetic that down just about any country road there is a horse suffering from this ban of horse slaughter. The ban of slaughter also resulted in the loss of $39 billion generated directly into economy as well as about 460,000 jobs (356). In addition to jobs and revenue, slaughter provide disposal of an unwanted horse in an economically and humane way (359). Local government animal control agencies bear the cost and responsibility of these neglected horses. These agencies are funded by your tax dollars, and the cost is estimated around $127 million the first year (367). These cost could be eliminated by removing the ban on horse slaughter, and then money will be brought back into our economy.
The horse slaughter ban should be lifted because the overall welfare of the horse has drastically decreased as an effect. The ban increases the number of neglected and abandoned horse left to starve to death. Horses are now required to travel a significant farther distance, on average more than 200 miles longer. Horses shipped to Mexico must be unloaded into pens on the border where they are required to stay for six hours in the blazing desert sun without adequate food and water (Anderson 140-141). Most horses rejected at the border are abandoned just North of the border, and other taken to feedlots and left to die. Horses are rejected due improper function of Transport Program, shipped even though unfit (Anderson 141-142). At an export pen in Texas, its estimated 35 horses per month die while waiting. Once horses cross the border they are no longer under USDA jurisdiction (Anderson 142). The intent for the ban of slaughter was to increase overall welfare, but instead the welfare of these horses has dropped tremendously. Horses are now forced to suffer because their owner can now longer tend to them resulting in inhumane treatment of the horse. The American Veterinary Medical Association considers two methods of slaughter humane the captive bolt method, and overdose of barbiturate anesthesia (Anderson 145-146). A humane practice of slaughter can be practiced in the United States to prevent and decrease in the horses’ welfare.
Horse slaughter should be brought back to the United States for economic benefits. Authors L. Leon Geyer and Dan Lawler suggest roughly 115,000 horses were slaughter per year by three U.S. facilities prior to the ban in the article “Yea or Neigh? The Economics, Ethics, and Utility of the Horsemeat Filet”. The slaughter of these horses brought roughly $65 million per year directly into our economy that is now being generated in Mexico and Canada (252). In the article “It Cost How Much To Get Rid Of My Horse?!? Why The Economic Down Turn Has Illustrated The Need For Horse Slaughter Facilities” writer Brenna Koehler explains rescue facilities can only care for about 13,400 unwanted horses a year. With roughly 125,000 unwanted horses a year and nowhere for owners to take them leaves owners to abandon or neglect these horses (378-379). The major increase of abandoned horses in the wild has caused tremendous damage to land along with other issues (380). “Each unwanted horse cost local taxpayers $3,600 per year”, with 125,000 unwanted horses that’s roughly $450 million per year (381). The ban of domestic slaughter forced owners to pay to dispose unwanted horses that once could be sold at auction for slaughter. Horse prices decreased 8% to 22% (Geyer et. al 252). The horse industry in the United States offers 460,000 jobs and generates $39 billion directly into the economy (Durfee 256). The ban of domestic horse slaughter has had a negative impact on our economy. These unwanted horses are now benefiting other countries economies, and costing the U.S. and its taxpayers a significant amount of money.
Domestic slaughter should be brought back for the production of horsemeat. The increase in population yearly will result in a need for proteins that horsemeat contains a high percentage of according to author Silvius Stanciu in the article “Horse Meat Consumption – Between Scandal and Reality” (702). Humans all over the world excluding the U.S. consume horsemeat (Geyer et. al 252). Americans believe horses should not be consumed because they consider them a companion animal instead of livestock, which is what they are classified as (Geyer et al. 253). Despite the beliefs of horsemeat being contaminated veterinarians and nutritional data verify horsemeat is healthy and safe for human consumption (Geyer et. al 250). Horsemeat can be closely related to beef; it is also categorized as red meat (Stanciu 701). Horsemeat can be prepared for consumption in a variety of ways (Stanciu 699). Beef and horsemeat are difficult to tell apart during processing (Stanciu 702). With strict regulation and proper facilitates horsemeat for human consumption is a nutritional substitute for beef or other red meats.
Some of our population believes horse slaughter is evil and inhumane describes author Tim Opitz in the article “The Tragedy Of The Horse, American Icon”. These people who are anti horse slaughter pushed for the ban of horse slaughter (357). They believe theses facilities do not follow all the regulations, and the captive bolt method, approved by the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act, is inhumane (364). No slaughter is easy to watch, but even these anti slaughter societies believe horses are being treated significantly more inhumane across the borders (365). The anti slaughter population continues to try to get permanent legislation passed banning horse slaughter but has been unsuccessful so far.
Several solutions have been attempted to regulate the welfare of these unwanted horses forced to travel thousands of miles and horse slaughter facilities, but none have fully succeeded. The Horse Transportation Act of 2009 fell through because of change in positions, and no one has brought it back up (Opitz 374). Recent attempts at a solution have tried banning the transport across borders for slaughter, but they do no think about what will happen to the overpopulation of horses (376). Attempts to open a horse slaughter facility for a solution for the unwanted horses are denied funds, which cause them to be unsuccessful (378).
In order for horse slaughter plants in the U.S. to be successfully regulated, the USDA must fund federal inspections as they do for other livestock. There will need to be strict laws that provide safety for employees and animals, as well as laws to ensure health risk are being prevented. The government must have highly qualified inspectors at every plant, which enforce these legislations and regulations. The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act must approve all slaughter techniques used as humane. This will compromise with the population that believes slaughter is inhumane. The amount of revenue these plants bring to the U.S. will provide enough funding for inspections and employees.
In the future, if the unwanted horse problem from the ban of slaughter is not solved every city will have an abandoned horse left to die. As the horse population increases and no convenient, ethical way to dispose of them the number of unwanted horses continues to grow drastically. The more unwanted horses abandoned and left for the government or city to care for is more taxpayer’s money being spent. The opening of slaughter plants in the U.S. would benefit the problem of the unwanted horses welfare, provide economic benefits, and allow horsemeat for human consumption.
Works Cited
Anderson, Natalie. "Protecting Equine Welfare and International Consumers of Horse Meat: A Proposal for the Renewal of Horse Slaughter in the United States." San Diego International Law Journal, vol. 17, no. 1, Fall2015, pp. 125-164. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,shib&db=a9h&AN=112636504&site=eds-live&custid=magn1307.
Durfee, Laura Jane. "Anti-Horse Slaughter Legislation: Bad for Horses, Bad for Society." Indiana Law Journal, vol. 84, no. 1, Winter2009, pp. 353-371. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,shib&db=a9h&AN=36659936&site=eds-live&custid=magn1307.
Geyer, L. Leon and Dan Lawler. "Yea or Neigh? The Economics, Ethics, and Utility of the Horsemeat Filet." Journal of Food Law & Policy, vol. 9, no. 2, Fall2013, pp. 247-274. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,shib&db=a9h&AN=112566816&site=eds-live&custid=magn1307.
Holcomb, K. E., et al. "Unwanted Horses: The Role of Nonprofit Equine Rescue and Sanctuary Organizations." Journal of Animal Science, vol. 88, no. 12, Dec. 2010, pp. 4142-4150. EBSCOhost, doi:10.2527/jas.2010-3250.
Koehler, Brenna (Robinson). "It Costs How Much to Get Rid of My Horse?!? Why the Economic Down Turn Has Illustrated the Need for Horse Slaughter Facilities." Drake Journal of Agricultural Law, vol. 18, 01 July 2013, p. 375. EBSCOhost,
Lenz, T.R. "The Unwanted Horse in the United States: An Overview of the Issue." Journal of Equine Veterinary Science, vol. 29, no. 5, 01 May 2009, p. 253-258. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1016/j.jevs.2009.04.001.
Opitz, Tim. "The Tragedy of the Horse, American Icon." Journal of Food Law & Policy, vol. 7, no. 2, Fall2011, pp. 357-382. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,shib&db=a9h&AN=112543839&site=eds-live&custid=magn1307.
Taylor, Mykel and Elizabeth Sieverkropp. "The Impacts of U.S. Horse Slaughter Plant Closures on a Western Regional Horse Market." Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, vol. 38, no. 1, Apr. 2013, pp. 48-63. EBSCOhost, doi:www.waeaonline.org/publications/jare/search-past-issues.
Stanciu, Silvius. "Horse Meat Consumption − between Scandal and Reality." Procedia Economics and Finance, vol. 23, no. 2nd Global Conference On Business, Economics, Management And Tourism, 01 Jan. 2015, pp. 697-703. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(15)00392-5.

RELATED

Marijuana Research and Why It Should Be Legal - Writing-101 - Research Paper

1380 words - 6 pages 1 Elias Gonzalez Professor Bucchino WRT-101-12P - Research Paper 15 December 2018 Replacing illegal with legal Since 1937, marijuana has been illegal to possess or transfer in the United States. However, after decades of research, it has been proven that marijuana is safer than other legal substances, can be used for economic strategy to create jobs and generate tax, and also help aid people away from some addictions. As of today, there are 11

Should the Electoral College be Abolished? - english 10 - Research Paper

1325 words - 6 pages Kankel Reid Kankel Ms. Marquez English 10 1 Mar 2017 Should the Electoral College be Abolished? In the past sixteen years politics have become the increasingly important in the United States, and as a result, more and more citizens have gotten involved and have started to care passionately about becoming involved and vocal. In addition to more Americans getting involved in the past decade and a half, two presidential elections ended with the

Why Marijuana should be legalized - Amarillo College - Research Paper

913 words - 4 pages . Legalizing marijuana wouldn't just benefit those who use it recreationally, it could also be beneficial for us in many other ways as well such as medical uses, tax revenues and emptying some of the overcrowded prisons we’re experiencing trouble with. A lot of people today see marijuana just as a recreational drug for individuals to have a good time with, what they dontknow and see is that marijuana is actually very helpful medically. Different compounds

Should alcohol be sold passes 11 - miles college - research paper

511 words - 3 pages Free person has one drink, his/her thinking becomes fuzzy and it’s easy to order another, then another. For the underage drinkers, the maturity level is not yet developed which will definitely cause a misjudgement in their thinking, In my opinion, alcohol should not be sold after 11pm. Most accidents that occur late at night and early mornings are caused by people who were driving intoxicated. I believe if alcohol is not sold after 11pm, the number of

Should PEDs Be Legal in Sports? - Sports Ethics - Essay

1099 words - 5 pages -enhancing Drugs and Masking Agents in Sport Doping: Pharmacology, Toxicology and Analysis." British Journal of Pharmacology 161, no. 1 (2010): 1-16. doi:10.1111/j.1476-5381.2010.00789.x.] [2: "Ivan Waddington, PhD Biography." Should Performance Enhancing Drugs (such as Steroids) Be Accepted in Sports? Accessed November 21, 2018. https://sportsanddrugs.procon.org/view.source.php?sourceID=007337.] [3: Barker, Sarah. "WADA Report: Drug Testing Works, But

why college athletes should be paid - FCC/english assignment - research paper

2285 words - 10 pages Morrison 9 Payton Morrison Professor Contreras English 3 7 December 2017 Why NCAA D1 Players Should Be Paid To Play? The question that was brought this writer was if they think D1 collegiate athletes should be paid to play their sport? In their opinion there could be pros and cons to both sides. It is very difficult for college students to maintain a full time job yet alone along with a sport. College athletes should get paid for putting

Should Prayer be allowed in public schools - Newberry College, Religion - Position paper

1114 words - 5 pages Brooks 1 Brooks 4 Octavya Brooks Dr. Beggs REL 122 April 17, 2018 Position Paper: Prayer in Public Schools Prayer in public schools has been a topic that has been debated on in the nation for a while now and is still continued to be debated on till this day. Many people have been saying and asking for prayer due to recent events and events that have previously been happening especially in public schools. In this paper, I will be giving you my

Lowering the Legal Drinking Age - Tyler Junior College - Research Paper

795 words - 4 pages Free Byrd 1 Molly Byrd Professor Teri Klauser English 1301-900 April 24, 2018 Draft Two: Lowering the legal drinking age In the United States, legal drinking age has been maintained at 21 years for quite some time. in the recent past, there has been a debate as to whether the allowable age should be lowered below 21 years or maintained at 21. Lowering drinking age, however, comes along with some serious consequences. In this piece of work, I will

Should College athletes be paid - english 101 first paper - REsearcb

2756 words - 12 pages Kleam Logan Kleam Comment by Michelle Krueger: There should be a header in the top right corner with your last name and page number. Michelle Krueger ENG 201 March 7, 2018 Should Student Athletes be Paid? College athletes are indisputably some of the hardest working people out there. Student-athletes not only live the livelife of an average student but they also have a tough schedule with their sport. The biggest debate in college athletics is

legal research regarding legal representation in courts - law university - research paper

1942 words - 8 pages litigations in courts are as well caused by people who abandon their legal rights and refuse to be represented by a lawyer. These are some of the disadvantages that people face in court which leaves them with no legal representation therefore, have no option but to self-represented litigation. [2: Chief Justice Faulks, ‘Self-Represented Litigants: Tackling the Challenge’, (2013) National Judicial College of Australia and the Australian National

This research paper articulated why GM should be a stock that one invests in - Investment Analysis - Stock Pitch Paper

636 words - 3 pages driving more, and more Americans are driving; total vehicle miles traveled has now surpassed the pre-recession high, and the number of licensed drivers has grown with the population. These factors should allow for growth in domestic light vehicle sales.Source: Business Insider Comparable Companies & Operational Strength While the above two points make the case for the resurgence of the automotive industry, it must also be determined what makes

Reconstructive Plastic Surgeon Career and Responsibilities - English Comp 2 - Research Paper

2016 words - 9 pages Read 1 Alex Read Mrs. Hendrix Comp 2 – T/Th 9:30 15 November 2016 Reconstructive Plastic Surgeon Career and Responsibilities The field of medicine is a field that is always evolving as new methods, needs, and requirements come into play. This is one field is that is guaranteed to always be around and has little to no chance of people not having a need for. One of the more crucial departments of medicine would be the emergency response personnel

A Study of censorship in history, and should it be used in the school system. - AP Language - Research Paper

1126 words - 5 pages Ryan Hunt Jones P.1 12/12/17 Research Paper Censorship is used by companies, and governments to “tone down” art that people may deem inappropriate for the general public. Many times artists will have to make a “clean” version of their songs for use on the radio, and even certain classic books aren’t allowed in schools because of mature themes, and vulgar language. At what point does censorship go from protecting children from sensitive material

Type 2 Diabetes In Young Adults - Lincoln College/ Eng 102 - Research Paper

3465 words - 14 pages Type 2 diabetes Type 2 diabetes Shalyn McLean Lincoln College This paper was prepared for English 102 taught by Professor Hyde. Type 2 Diabetes 1 Abstract Type 2 diabetes is when your pancreas has trouble making enough or too much insulin. Diabetes can cause dehydration, hunger and swelling of the legs. Blood and urine test are what doctors use to identify and diaganose. Type 2 diabetes can be treated with insulin in the form of pills and liquid

Why Corporal Punishment Should Be Banned - English - Research Paper

666 words - 3 pages the American Academy of Pediatrics. Furthermore, corporal punishment and any other form of violence have been prohibited in many schools in America since authorities have regarded it as illegal. There are alternatives to corporal punishment that have been recommended by psychologists, and which parents should always follow in order to inspire discipline among their children. Research studies have argued about children tend to learn when they