Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legalized In Minnesota? Bioethics Paper

830 words - 4 pages

[Type here]
Tenzin Seldon
Bioethics Exam #2 Paper
2) Should Physician-assisted suicide be legalized in Minnesota?
The question of the legalizing physician-assisted suicide is extremely controversial, as it incorporates mixed views of ethics and morality. For this paper, I will focus on three of Callahan’s arguments against physician-assisted suicide: self-determination, the differences between killing and allowing someone to die, and the consequences. Callahan be directly challenged by Lach’s argument in favor of physician-assisted suicide.
Self-determination is understood as the principle by which individuals has an interest of making autonomous decisions for themselves according to their own beliefs about things that make their life good and ways of conducting their lives. Callahan argues that physician-assisted suicide is no longer a matter of self-determination but rather a social decision between two people with one being the killer and the other to be killed. Callahan does not think it is permissible to put out so much power of killing of someone in the hands of another despite having the permission by competent person. He asserts that no one has yet to justify for the idea of waiving our right to life and giving that to a doctor to take it.
According to Callahan, there is a distinction between the stopping of life-sustaining treatment and active form of killing. To consider them the same creates confusion between reality and moral judgment in viewing an omitted action as having the equal causal status as compared to one that directly kills. A lethal injection of physician-assisted suicide can kill both a healthy and unhealthy person while the act of omitting a treatment cannot effect on a healthy person. Callahan focuses on the word “killing” and mentions that it should not be used to describe an action of a doctor stopping a treatment at the patient’s request. The underlying disease is the physical cause of a patient’s death, not the doctor’s act of omitting the treatment.
In discussing arguments against the legalization of physician-assisted suicide, it is significant to understand the likely consequences of it. Callahan list two outcomes such as the inevitability of some form of abuse and difficulty in precisely writing. Callahan states that laws that are based on delicate and controversial matters are to certain an extent abused because not everyone will agree with the way that the law is written and will try to find ways of bending and ignoring it. Abuse is also inevitable because the law is likely to be a lower priority in the criminal justice system. Callahan’s second consequences state that there is no effective way to write or enforce a meaningful euthanasia law that can guarantee sufficient procedural safeguard. He clarifies that acts and discussions of physician-assisted suicide will happen behind the boundaries of private physician-patient relationship where no one can hardly know what happens unless the physician decides to reveal it.
In Lach’s article, he finds that Callahan fails to provide hints of contemporary moral problems that euthanasia and assisted physician suicide promise to resolve. Lachs argues that people that advocate for the legalization of physician-assisted suicide consider them an answer to a serious and growing social problem. Many individuals that suffer from the terminally ill disease of Alzheimer and patients in the persistent vegetative state bear the pain of existence and intensely feel that they are burdens to others. They consider it as an end to suffering and a burdensome life. Lachs argues with Callahan’s assumption about the right to kill oneself cannot be transferred and transferring power over oneself is “is a fundamental morally wrong”. Lachs finds it difficult to grasp the idea that right cannot be handed as he believes that having a right means to be free or to be entitled to have or to do something. Lachs provides another argument in favor of physician-assisted suicide that mentions that certain individuals suffer to the point that they are physically not in the position to end their life. Lachs asserts that those people want physicians to aid in suicide because, without such help, they would not be able to end their lives and continue to suffer.
In the discussion of the legalization of physician-assisted suicide in Minnesota, I am against it. I believe that physician who participates in someone’s suicide is abusing medicine and have no right to claim whether someone’s life is worth living. Medicine should help people in relieving human suffering that is brought by illness, not suffering that comes from despair at the human condition. My ethical reasons for holding my views come from the theory of utilitarianism. The theory of utilitarianism maximizes benefit over harm for the greatest good for the most significant number of people affected by the action. According to the theory of utilitarianism, I am against the legalization of physician-assisted suicide in Minnesota as the consequences of physician-assisted suicide reduces happiness as the act of a physician helping someone in taking their life create pain, sorrow, and suffering in the heart of that person’s loved ones.


Should Euthanasia Be Legalized In Canada? (FOR)

776 words - 4 pages suffering, they are in pain and they simply want to end it. They do not want to see themselves be left with no motility and in a vegetative state. Who are we to prevent them from advancing to a better place than the miserable state they are in right now? That is one reason why euthanasia should be legalized; we should not be forced to experience the degeneration of our own bodies.Secondly, euthanasia is a hot topic because it involves suicide, but hasn

Speech on Why Assisted Suicide Should Be Allowed - COMA103/SchoolCraft - Speech/Research

915 words - 4 pages Skwiera 1 Skwiera 2 Stephanie Skwiera Professor Moylan COMA103 13 August 2018 Specific Purpose: I am going to persuade my classmates that assisted suicide should be legal in Michigan. Thesis: Allowing the option of assisted suicide is the right thing to do. I. Introduction: A. There are two questions that come to my mind: 1. If we put down animals when they are suffering and dying, why would we not offer the same level of compassion for our own

Why Marijuana should be legalized - Amarillo College - Research Paper

913 words - 4 pages medical marijuana. Just think if marijuana were to be legalized, we could help thousands of more people in pain and suffering from these diseases they live with today. Another issue we could solve with legalizing marijuana is help empty out overcrowded prisons. Miles, K. (2014, October 03). Just How Much The War On Drugs Impacts Our Overcrowded Prisons, In One Chart. The Federal Bureau of Prisons released an infographic showing over 50 percent

Euthanasia and Assisted suicide - High school religion - research paper

1020 words - 5 pages all, euthanasia and assisted suicide are acts that are not permitted and are greatly frowned upon in the catholic church and medical field. As of today, there are six states that have legalized physician assisted suicide. Although six is a small number it still gives access to this form of treatment to many people. St John Paul the Second said, “Respect for life requires that science and technology should always be at the service of man and his

Analysis Paper that talks about bioethics and its role in society and religious aspects - BIOE - Essay

628 words - 3 pages This week’s readings focused on the beginnings of bioethics and its early role in society through the descriptions of Jonsen, Engelhardt, and Garrett. In Jonsen’s text, ​The Birth of Bioethics​, he explains how many individuals were concerned with the old tradition of medical ethics; it was believed to be too frail in regards to matching up with the ethical challenges presented by the new sciences and technologies. Similarities in Engelhardt's

Should Prayer be allowed in public schools - Newberry College, Religion - Position paper

1114 words - 5 pages Brooks 1 Brooks 4 Octavya Brooks Dr. Beggs REL 122 April 17, 2018 Position Paper: Prayer in Public Schools Prayer in public schools has been a topic that has been debated on in the nation for a while now and is still continued to be debated on till this day. Many people have been saying and asking for prayer due to recent events and events that have previously been happening especially in public schools. In this paper, I will be giving you my

Should Horse Slaughter Be Legal in US - College Comp 2 - Research Paper

2179 words - 9 pages Free federal funding for the required inspection of horsemeat. Therefore, resulting in the ban of horse slaughter. This ban will be surrounded with more controversial topics. Many Americans are unaware of or ignore the fact of the large number of neglected and abandoned horses in our country. Is this large number because of the ban? Does the ban increase the welfare of the horse? Will economics be affected by the ban? The ban on horse slaughter should

This research paper articulated why GM should be a stock that one invests in - Investment Analysis - Stock Pitch Paper

636 words - 3 pages driving more, and more Americans are driving; total vehicle miles traveled has now surpassed the pre-recession high, and the number of licensed drivers has grown with the population. These factors should allow for growth in domestic light vehicle sales.Source: Business Insider Comparable Companies & Operational Strength While the above two points make the case for the resurgence of the automotive industry, it must also be determined what makes

A Study of censorship in history, and should it be used in the school system. - AP Language - Research Paper

1126 words - 5 pages Ryan Hunt Jones P.1 12/12/17 Research Paper Censorship is used by companies, and governments to “tone down” art that people may deem inappropriate for the general public. Many times artists will have to make a “clean” version of their songs for use on the radio, and even certain classic books aren’t allowed in schools because of mature themes, and vulgar language. At what point does censorship go from protecting children from sensitive material

Why Corporal Punishment Should Be Banned - English - Research Paper

666 words - 3 pages Corporal punishment a very controversial topic is thought to be banned by many. Others disagree including 15 states in America. This can lead to mental trauma and physical trauma even suicide. Many countries have banned it and others haven’t. To begin with, corporal punishment has over the years been used at home and in school as a means of influencing the change of behavior in children. At home, parents tend to punish their children, especially

Should alcohol be sold passes 11 - miles college - research paper

511 words - 3 pages Free person has one drink, his/her thinking becomes fuzzy and it’s easy to order another, then another. For the underage drinkers, the maturity level is not yet developed which will definitely cause a misjudgement in their thinking, In my opinion, alcohol should not be sold after 11pm. Most accidents that occur late at night and early mornings are caused by people who were driving intoxicated. I believe if alcohol is not sold after 11pm, the number of

Should the Electoral College be Abolished? - english 10 - Research Paper

1325 words - 6 pages Kankel Reid Kankel Ms. Marquez English 10 1 Mar 2017 Should the Electoral College be Abolished? In the past sixteen years politics have become the increasingly important in the United States, and as a result, more and more citizens have gotten involved and have started to care passionately about becoming involved and vocal. In addition to more Americans getting involved in the past decade and a half, two presidential elections ended with the

Should College athletes be paid - english 101 first paper - REsearcb

2756 words - 12 pages Kleam Logan Kleam Comment by Michelle Krueger: There should be a header in the top right corner with your last name and page number. Michelle Krueger ENG 201 March 7, 2018 Should Student Athletes be Paid? College athletes are indisputably some of the hardest working people out there. Student-athletes not only live the livelife of an average student but they also have a tough schedule with their sport. The biggest debate in college athletics is

Should Civil Disobedience Be Permitted In A Democracy?

572 words - 3 pages Free to advocate violence, the only weapon we have is the weaopon of protest, and the great glory of America should be free to express their opinions." President Kennedy on the other hand states, "defiance of the law leads to the road of tyranny and could lead to an anarchy." Civil disobedience has had a positive effect on society, therefore it should be permitted in a democracy.Civil disobedience is an effective way of changing laws and protecting

Should PEDs Be Legal in Sports? - Sports Ethics - Essay

1099 words - 5 pages are expected to play by the rules or face the penalties of not abiding by those rules. In the same way, when the use of PEDs is forbidden, athletes should be prepared to face the consequences when they are used. Steroids shouldn’t be illegal just because it says so in the rulebook. Among logistical issues, there are ethical implications with the integrity of sports at risk, that should criminalize steroids. NOT CLEAR ABOUT THE DISTINCTION