Should Welfare Recipients Receive Welfare Delta High School Argumentative Essay

858 words - 4 pages

Nieto 2
Janira Nieto
Professor Anne M. Meyer
ENGL 1110
April 17,2018
Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested
When one first hears about the idea of testing welfare recipients to make sure that they are not using drugs, the idea seems to be sound. Of course, we do not want welfare money going toward the purchase of drugs when it should be going only to necessary and useful things. As with almost any political idea, however, these policies need to be executed. Political intentions are not realized in an ideal world. With welfare testing, the cold reality is that the costs and barriers of following through on the policy trump the benefits. One of the main reasons for this is the sheer cost of it.
Requiring those with limited mobility to travel to an area that has a drug-testing site not to mention the nightmare that causes for individuals living in rural areas and take time out of their day is placing a burden on them that may help to keep them in the same impoverished situation. This is the absolute last thing any welfare policy should be doing. Many people may think that asking them to travel may not be a big burden but that is really a sign of the life situation you are in. Without a car, working a job which yes, many welfare recipients do have jobs, with kids, and all the other things that one often has to attend to, requiring drug testing is a burden that can further trap someone in a specific life situation. All of this is coupled with the finding that the rate of drug users among those who receive welfare is equal to or less than the rest of the adult population. In Minnesota, they’re attempting to institute such a policy, but they found that only 0.4 percent of welfare users were also drug users, as opposed to 1.2 percent of the adult population. This means that the state is spending large quantities of money searching for a problem that doesn’t actually exist. When it comes to drug testing welfare recipients, the cost is too high, and problem isn’t real, and the intentions are off. It may be good politics, but it’s bad policy. Welfare assistance should not be a one-way handout or open-ended privilege. We should provide assistance on the basis of a return obligation. It’s a real issue. Most related studies indicate that one third of people on welfare use illegal drug. As welfare approaches over a trillion a year, taxpayers have a right to insist that their money goes to those who truly need it and it’s not spent on frivolous activities like drug use. Evidence shows that drug testing can reduce unnecessary spending and misuse of money. The cost involved in drug testing would cost taxpayers even more money, including the employees to monitor the drug test and not to mention the cost of the drug test. If the drug testing is done it will save the taxpayers money who feel they are wasting money on drugs. Drug testing will require recipients to stay drug free. A few believe that it is purely discrimination against the poor, who most often receive these benefits. They argue that since some people have jobs where they are never dug tested that poor people should not have to undergo testing either. They also argue That they are basically telling poor people that they have no right to be happy, or experience the full spectrum of human experience, whereas those not on welfare who are not drug tested at their jobs can do this freely. The jobs that do not do drug testing are ones like 7-11 or certain gas stations, all other jobs you have to mandatory drug test and if you refuse a drug test you will not get the job and if they do a mandatory test at your current job they only give you so many hours to submit a drug test and if you do not you are automatically terminated. So, if you receive any kind of benefits from the state you should submit to a drug test, to some collecting a welfare check is just like a job they sit and wait until their money comes on their card and then go out and spend. If you can wait on your check you can wait in line for the drug test so the taxpayers will know where their money is going. A senator stated a proposal for drug testing fears it would allow the government to pick on poor people. The goal would be to keep the state from being an enabler by giving cash to people who are using it. It’s not to be punitive or anything other than giving people to get on the right path. Those who test positive for drugs would be ineligible for three years to receive temporary assistance benefits, which are given to individuals with children for basic needs such as: housing, utilities, and clothing. Children do not lose benefits if parents test positive, but credits for their needs would be redirected to grandparents, other appointed adults.

RELATED

The Government, not individuals, should be responsible for healthcare and Welfare Provision. Discuss - modern studies - essay

1545 words - 7 pages contributions and every citizen, regardless of income and social standing, would receive government support from ‘the cradle to the grave.” Today, the welfare state and collectivists in favour of it maintain the argument that the government should continue to provide to intervene and provide healthcare and Welfare provisions through the NHS and benefits schemes. Collectivist policies that seek to improve health would be the protection of the NHS, the

Reasons for the Liberal Social Welfare Reforms - History - Assignment/Essay

1411 words - 6 pages Reasons for the Liberal Social Welfare Reforms Context For most of the 19th century, most people believed in ‘laissez-fraire’ and accepted that poverty and hardship were not things the government could or should do anything about. However, the Liberal Government (led by Prime Minister Herbert Asquith and Chancellor of the Exchequer David Lloyd George) introduced a range of social welfare reforms to help alleviate the poverty and hardship suffered

Should Welfare Involve Drug Testing? - Ohio University; English 1010 - Argument Paper

937 words - 4 pages money to drug test millions of people, it would certainly be going to good use. I would have a sense of closure knowing that my family’s tax dollars are going to help people, as they should. Tax dollars are meant to help the community and economy. It goes to teachers, police, firemen, school districts, and to organizations ensuring our stability and security after retirement. Although the amount we pay for taxes seems high, at least it is going to

Should college athletes be paid? - Interboro High School - Argumentative

936 words - 4 pages Sean Myers Mrs. Salerno Period ⅚ College Athletes Essay The argument made by Ann Kaufmann in ​College Athletes Should Be Paid​ is that college athletes, specifically football and basketball players, should be compensated for their play. More specifically, Kaufmann argues that since basketball and football bring in the most money by a very noticeable margin, the athlete's for these sports are the only collegiate athletes that should be paid

Argumentative vs. Informative essays - English Class High School - Essay

526 words - 3 pages personal ideas. Another vital difference between argumentative and informative essays is that an informative essay always gives a balanced account of a subject while an argumentative essay may be biased and subjective. It should be also noted that an argumentative essay can contain elements of an informative essay, as argumentative essays also state explanations and information. Another central difference between argumentative and informative essay can be noted in the opening sentence in the essay; the opening sentence in an argumentative essay states the argument, and the opening line in an informative essay introduces the topic.

Through the Tunnel Argumentative Essay - Victor J Andrew High School, English - Argumentative Essay

2058 words - 9 pages Hassen Nadeen Hassen Sophomore English 4th Hour 22 October 2017 Through the Tunnel: Did Jerry Experience the Rite of Passage? “All who have accomplished great things have had a great aim, have fixed their gaze on a goal which was high, one which sometimes seemed impossible,” the American author Orison Swett Marden once said. In the passage Through the Tunnel by Doris Lessing, Jerry, a young boy, has interest in achieving a high goal he set for

"The Microsoft Monopoly Should Be Broken Up." Evaluate This Claim Using Economic Theory And Evidence On The Welfare Effects Of Monopoly And Competition

2010 words - 9 pages were released from the Chicago School of Economics. These theories said that the only justification for antitrust intervention should be that a lack of competition harmed consumers, and not that a firm had become, in some ill-defined sense, too big. Some monopolistic activities previously targeted by antitrust authorities, such as predatory pricing and exclusive marketing agreements, were much less harmful to consumers than had been thought in

high school should make uniform mandatory - Grade 12 assignment - Essay

479 words - 2 pages High schools should enforce making uniforms mandatory to develop student improvement, represents school in an exceptional way and prepares students for the work world. Uniforms should be compulsory because they intend to lead students to become the improved version of themselves. Firstly, uniforms create a sense of equality and prevents students to feel left out or underprivileged. The rich students would wear experience expensive clothes to

high school essay exit exam are fair or not - CRC ENGWR 300 - argumentative

1163 words - 5 pages Jawid 3 Bader Jawid Prof. Gregory Strawn ENGWR 300 M-W. 6:00 PM Exploratory Essay FFD California’s High School Exit Exam Every student who graduates from high school desires to collect a diploma and receive hands of applause from people on the stage. For instance, this achievement had been door trapped by high school exit exam. The exit exam was formed as a pathway to collect the high school diploma. The sections included in this exam were

The Effects of Sleep Deprivation in Students - Victor J Andrew High School, English - Argumentative Essay

1791 words - 8 pages deprivation is a serious matter, especially for high school students, because the amount of stress they go through. Stress in school causes a great loss of sleep and an intense schedule to keep up with. School administrations should create a bell schedule that starts school an hour later than already intended, because students’ sleeping hours will increase which leads to an increase in test scores, a healthy lifestyle, and the ability to socialize

Should high school students have a part-time job? - None - Essay

549 words - 3 pages Having a part-time job has become popular amongst high school students. It is believed that students in high school should do a part-time job while the others argue that they shouldn’t have one and should focus on their study instead. In my opinion, students shouldn’t have a part-time job when they are in high school because when they do a part-time job, they cannot concentrate on their study, they don’t have enough time to complete their

Should ethnic studies be required in high school? - Reedley College ESL - Essay

1000 words - 4 pages first state to adopt legislation that would make ethnic studies a high school graduation requirement. Some educators disagree that ethic studies should be required in high school; however, it should be a requirement for many reasons. One reason ethnic studies should be a requirement for students is to know more about minorities. California has a large and diverse student population. According to the statistics, approximately more than half of

Should African Americans Receive Reparations - English - Essay

962 words - 4 pages receive reparations as well. If they would not qualify, then who would? According to a 2015 study titled The Great Migration and African-American Genomic Diversity, most African Americans are about 78 percent West African and 20 percent European. If reparations were implemented, it should be considered whether deductions would be made dependent on what percentage of a person's provable ancestry is descended from slaves. This is important because the

Argumentative essay why teachers should not give out homework. - high school english - essay

713 words - 3 pages which are rodents, birds and fish. We eat more than 1,800 times the number of pigs than the number used in research, and we consume more than 340 chickens for every research animal.”. So then why should we be concerned about animals being tested on when we ourselves are slaughtering billions of animals yearly for human consumption. There are no other alternatives for testing. Since animals are the closest things on the planet to humans, and if one

High School Students Should Be Drug Tested - English 1510 - Argument

1542 words - 7 pages Tackett 1 Tackett 4 Olivia Tackett Professor Jeffrey Hensley English 1510 4 March 2019 High School Students Should Be Drug Tested Drug abuse: a worldwide epidemic that has spread to our youth. The younger generation determines the future of our society. Can we really rely on the youth to better our world if they’re already starting to abuse drugs at such an early age? Schools try to manage their students’ use of drugs by setting anti-drug