The Argument From Design Fact, Fantasy Or Wishful Thinking?

4575 words - 19 pages

The Argument from Design - Fact, Fantasy or Wishful Thinking ?Tell me why the stars do shine,Tell me why the ivy twines,Tell me why the sky's so blue.Then I will tell you just why I love you.Because God made the stars to shine,Because God made the ivy twine,Because God made the sky so blue.Because God made you, that's why I love you.1Tell Me WhyIn Darwin's Dangerous Idea Daniel Dennett wistfully recalls this simple melody from his youth, but does not lament the demise of its literal meaning at the hands of the hero of his book. No thinking adult could still cling to the myth of the loving God who fashions each of us from earth and breathes life into us. There is no future in myths, no matter ...view middle of the document...

"We see that things which lack knowledge, such as natural bodies, act for an end, and this is evident from their acting always, or nearly always, in the same way, so as to obtain the best result. Hence it is plain that they achieve their end, not fortuitously, but designedly. Now whatever lacks knowledge cannot move towards an end, unless it be directed by some being endowed with knowledge and intelligence...Therefore some intelligent being exists by whom all natural things are directed to their end; and this being we call God."2This is the archetypal meaning of the Argument from Design. Unintelligent and unconscious things seem to act in purposeful and "intelligent" ways. They do things as if they are acting for a reason or end. But inanimate, unconscious beings cannot possibly be intelligent or have reasons and purposes. Therefore, some intelligent being guides these natural things to their end.The Evolution of an ArgumentAquinas' use of the Argument from Design was intended to explain the apparent purpose of natural bodies. However, during the Enlightenment modern science took off and began to throw light on the workings of the natural world. Where before we had intuitively invoked a Prime Mover to explain all motion; now Newton told us that motion itself did not require explanation (Law of Inertia), and that changes in motion were brought about by other natural bodies. Where before we had thought the Earth the stationary centre of the universe for anthropocentric reasons (we being the zenith of God's creation); now we found that not only did everything not revolve around us, but that counter to every intuition, the Earth rotated at an incredibly high speed. The new laws of physics displaced the role of God in the universe. The purposeful action of natural bodies did not seem to need God after all. Our previous intuition that only an intelligent, uncaused being could explain motion, action and order (non-random events) was wrong.However, there was another subtle angle of the Argument from Design available to be exploited, and it took centre stage during the 18th century. Perhaps the action of planetary bodies and physical bodies (think billiard balls!) could be explained without God, but what about the sheer complexity and magnificent design of Nature's creations - especially living things. Science had brought both technology and great interest to the study of nature. And the more we studied, the more intricate, complex and ordered it looked.In Search of a WatchmakerThere were two seminal figures in the new 18th century version of the Argument from Design : David Hume and the theologian William Paley. Paley's formulation in his treatise Natural Theology was published after Hume's, but is better known. In it he asks the reader to imagine crossing a heath and pitching one's foot against a stone. If one were asked how the stone came to be there it would not be absurd to suggest it had lain there forever. But suppose you had found a watch on the...

Other Essays On The Argument From Design - Fact, Fantasy Or Wishful Thinking?

Coping With Hard Times Essay

3330 words - 14 pages sports and games as he travels to the country and saw the farmers living there. However, since the factory workers are too tired from work to do any additional exercises, city life as a whole did not grant them the opportunity to have such leisure.During the Victorian period, many who are so poor that they cannot afford to indulge in alcohol, gambling, or even food commit themselves to the habit of stealing and deceit. With low wage jobs, many

Aquinas 5 Ways Argument Essay

3651 words - 15 pages only by some design or purpose, which is called "the argument from design" (Melchert 279). Intelligent beings act in a way to achieve a goal and everything happens as though it were planned to happen that way. As Melchert uses in the book the way rabbits are so quick they can escape a fox and a fox is so cunning it can catch a rabbit is that everything happens for a reason. And what is controlling these goals is a higher intelligence, which "we

"Harry Potter And The Philsopher's Stone"

707 words - 3 pages In the British version of--what us American's call-- Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone by J.K. Rowling there are many qualities of the book that are good. To name just a few there is her wonderful plot design, and the fact that Rowling makes great use of forming rounded characters. With Rowling, she knew where she wanted to go with the novel and followed through in a way that was ever pleasing and attention grabbing to the plot. It starts

Is The Character Of Malvolio From Shakepreares Twelfth Night 'notoriously Abused'? This Was My Courswork For AS Level English Literature And I Achieved 81 Out Of 90 Which Is An A

2518 words - 11 pages snobbish as it is not Malvolio's fault he must work for a living. Malvolio may not personally have a problem with the other members of the household's behaviour, but is carrying out Olivia's demands. Sir Toby and Feste also sing a song to purposely annoy Malvolio, so his behaviour is understandable. This argument is countered by the fact Malvolio seems to be unnecessarily severe when trying to quieten the noisy group. And although Sir Toby's

"Canticle For Leibowitz" By Arthur M. Miller Jr

891 words - 4 pages think ahead of what the pollution would do to the air.Reading the book, A Canticle For Leibowitz, it is apparent that today's society is an image of the monks society. We copy things out mindlessly without thinking, an example is homework, and we do not really know what we are really doing. The monks also copy mindlessly when Francis copies the blueprints. Today's society is also dependant on a spiritual being that could or could not exist. The

Human Nature

2126 words - 9 pages with them selves. Twain insinuates that humans have been created in a manner that causes them to not consider some very important things about themselves, and therefore, they are flawed from the beginning. Twain seems to question whether or not God knew what he was doing when he created human beings because they are such flawed creatures and they have created such mayhem in the world. Human beings will perform negative acts all while speaking

Silencing Gender: 5-Hour Energy Ads

1801 words - 8 pages are things that we shouldn't have to be talking about in this day and age. In fact, should be well past this way of thinking but for some reason it is turned and gone the other way.How can we expect our younger generation to succeed and flourish when they are constantly being reminded of these stereotypes that are silencing the female population? The fact is, something has to change or we will see generations of intelligent and able women get

The Artwork That Caught My Eye

339 words - 2 pages All my life I have always loved scenery base art that has a futuristic or fantasy look to it. So when I started to look for my art at the Dallas Art Museum I already had a basic idea of what to look for. In the beginning when I was looking for the art of my choice I was just playing around talking about the arts that seem to me to have no uniqueness to them. About twenty minutes of looking around and playing I came to a painting by Antonio Canal

Haroun And The Sea Of Stories

1344 words - 6 pages animals? No. In this content we mean reality. So lets rephrase the question, what is reality? Reality is something that exists or that is fact, but truth is not always found in facts. If for example, ten people look at the same fact then ten different, but yet all true things could be found from that one fact. So what exactly is the nature of truth if nature is fact and truth is not always found in fact or there are different truths in nature? The

That Eye The Sky - Supernatural Analysis

1258 words - 6 pages Ort who is in his last year of Primary school, going onto High School. It's through his eyes that we are able to see how different Ort perceives the world from other people. He comments on many ordinary things but turns them into extraordinary things for example the heavy description of the setting, the human sense of sight, Ort's visions of clouds or light and significance of the number 3. This essay will analyse and comment on the supernatural

"Araby" By James Joyce

869 words - 4 pages story oddly enough the girl initiates the communication. When Mangan's sister addresses him, she tells him she is unable to go to a bazaar called "Araby" and seems rather upset. The boy takes the chance to include his fantasy (the girl) in his life and offers to bring her something from the bazaar.The boy is still innocent and dependent on others, so the boy ready to embark on his journey and incorporate his ideals to his really life, is once

Similar Papers

Play, Art, And Subject In Freud And Gadamer

1205 words - 5 pages neglected and replaced with the idealized events of the past. He gives the example of an orphaned boy given the opportunity of a job whose wishful play through fantasy leads him to imaging one day taking over the business from his employer, becoming the owner and marrying the man's desirable daughter, herself the mere product of imagination. Freud explains the elemental piece of this work, saying "You will see from this example the way in which

To What Extent Does Psychological Profiling Assist Criminal Investigations And Avoid Miscarriages Of Justice?

2895 words - 12 pages , N. (2008) 'Offender Profiling in Comparative Perspective', in Offender Profiling in the Courtroom: The Use and Abuse of Expert Witness Testimony, Portsmouth: Greenwood Publishing Group.Eysenck, H. (1964) Crime and Personality. London: Routledge.Meehl, P. (1954) Clinical versus statistical prediction: A theoretical analysis and a review of the evidence.Muller, D. (2000) 'Criminal Profiling Real Science or Just Wishful Thinking?', Homicide Studies

Critical Thinking Term Notes Essay

2659 words - 11 pages defensivenessOur Response to Differences:Celebration ToleranceAnnihilationRespect AssimilationTolerance:Willingness to allow people whose opinions or ways of life differ from our own to express those opinions and live life in those different ways; recognizing the right of others to think, live or worship according to their own beliefs, and to refrain from taking action to prevent them from doing so, even if we disapprove of those ways of thinking

Carroll Vs. Juster A Literary Comparison

2565 words - 11 pages towards childlike ways of thinking. He was greatly inspired by the nonsensical sayings of children, and his own prolifically created stories. His use of language was typical for his time, though early critics regarded his storytelling as haphazard and difficult to grasp.Norton Juster wasn't quite as much a character as he was a skilled creator. The Phantom Tollbooth was published in 1961 while its author was an Architect and Design Professor at