The Australian Parliament Should Not Have Members With Dual Citizens - Thomas More College 12 - Essay

1254 words - 6 pages

Stage one: legal studies
“Should MP’s with dual citizenship be made to resign”
There hasn’t been much excitement and interest in the constitution until now with the rise of dual citizenship occurring in the parliament. The thin majority of Australian prime minister Malcolm Turnbull's administration is under threat from a constitutional crisis. A progression of prominent MPs, including the deputy prime minister and another government minister may lose their seats in parliament after disclosures that their citizenship of different nations may exclude them under Australia's constitution.
The Australian constitution is clear in disqualifying anyone who holds foreign citizenship to serve in the national parliament.
As section 44 (i) states, any individual is disqualified if they are:
· under any acknowledgement of allegiance, obedience, or adherence to a foreign power, or is a subject or a citizen or entitled to the rights or privileges of a subject or a citizen of a foreign power. (the grey area of this is entitled)
subsection 44 (i) has generally been interpreted by the high court of Australia as meaning that persons with dual citizenship are not permitted to stand for election and that a person must take reasonable steps to renounce their citizenship of the other country.
Requirements of section 44 states the person must only hold an Australian citizenship and the persons allegiances must be to Australia if seating in parliament. Anyone with a dual citizenship must be disqualified from seat.
With this it should be clear that an MP with a dual citizenship be made to resign. This where the problem occurs in the parliament where some MP’s declare that they had no acknowledgment of them having a dual citizenship. Many MP’s state that the constitution must be followed as required and the following dual citizens must resign their seats. With the matter being taken to the high court if the high court does stick to the constitution, everyone entitled to foreign citizenship was ineligible, it would wipe out a swathe of MP’s and senators who have never tried to claim allegiance to any other country, this means anyone with a dual citizenship would be gone. With this a new election would be made to replace the house that lost most of the seats.
Section 28 of the Australian constitution states that House of Representatives elections must be held ta least every three years. The Prime Minister decides the date for an election (this could be at any time during the three-year term). There are 150 members elected to the House of Representative, one for each of Australia’s 150 electorates. An average of 150000 citizens live in each electorate, with an average of 100,000 voters.
Preferential voting is used in the House of Representative because it is designed to result in the election of a person who receives the broadest support from the electorate, even though that person may not be the first choice of majority voters in the electorate. The political party which wins majority of seats in the House of Representative will form the government. As there are 150 seats in the House of Representative, the party which forms government must win 75 + 1 seats.
Twelve senators are elected to represent each state and two senators are elected to represent each territory. States senators are elected for a period of six years using a system of rotation that ensures that only half the state senators end their term every three years. Territory senates are elected for a period of three years at the same time as the members of the House of Representative and half of the Senate.
In some cases, a by-election could be needed. A by-election is a mini-election held for a House of Representative electorate if a member resigns or dies between federal elections. A casual vacancy occurs in the senate if a senator resigns or dies between federal elections. They are replaced by a candidate from the same political party, chosen by the parliament or legislative assembly of that state/ territory.
If the High court of Australia does decide that the MP’s involved should resign this would case a by-election to take place in the parliament for the… who won by one seat.
Federal elections are organized and run by the AEC, who make sure that elections are free, fair, and legal. (The Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 and the Australian Constitution set out the requirements for running elections).
If the High Court of Australia does decide to change the wording of the constitution a referendum maybe given to thought if the solution has been decided to change the wording. To change the Australian constitution, each proposed alteration must be approved by a double majority of voters in a referendum. A double majority is a voting system which requires most votes according to two separate criteria (in this case it would be should MP’s with dual citizen be made to resign). The mechanism is usually used to require strong support for any measures considered to be of great importance. A referendum is passed when a national majority more than half of voters from all states and territories vote yes and when a majority more than half of voters in at least four of the six states vote yes.
To change Australia’s constitution, you need more than just a majority. To pass a referendum, the yes votes must get a double majority. This means two things must happen:
There must be a national majority: 50%, plus at least one, of the total votes across Australia should be a yes. All votes from all states and territories are included.
There must be most of state (this was introduced to protect the interests of the smaller states): 50%, plus one, of the total votes from the six states has to be yes, this means that at least four states have to vote yes (only the states count not the territories).
With the argument case law is present in the occurring cases in parliament. In 1999 Heather Hill was elected to the senate, her election was challenged in the high court because she held a dual citizenship of Australia and the United Kingdom. The high court in its decision, Sue v Hill, agreed that the dual citizenship made Hills election invalid because it contravened section 44 (i) of the constitution. Legal guidance also states that the people who drafted the nation’s constitution more than a century ago were generally British subjects, they too would have found themselves being kicked out of parliament.
In common law, a precedent is a legal case that establishes a principle or rule. This rule is then used by the court or other judicial bodies use when deciding later cases with similar issues or facts. The use of precedent provides predictability, stability, fairness, and efficiency in the law. With this any cases that occurred in the past that included anything to do with parliament MP’s having dual citizenships must be followed accordingly to what the high court has said.
The constitution commission report of 1988 recommended that section 44(iv) be replaced with more specific provisions. If the recommendation was taken into place in 1988 the problem the MP’s have today would not occur and the high court would know what to do but due to the fact the that the recommendation was dined the problem is still occurring. The high court should take into the MP’s that had a valid reason of why they did not know they were a dual citizen and acknowledge that a change should be made.

More like The Australian Parliament Should Not Have Members With Dual Citizens - Thomas More College 12 - Essay

“citizens Have Become Much More Politically Engaged Because Of Social Media” - Simon Fraser University. Pol 122 - Research Paper

2069 words - 9 pages ... Politics 100 term paper 1 Politics 100 term paper 5 Simon Fraser University Term paper “Citizens have become much more politically engaged because of social media” Word count: 1493 Pol 100 D116 November 29, 2018 Politics has always been a major aspect of any society, as the decisions involved in politics tend to affect every member of society. Historically, the general population of any society has not been involved in the political decision ...

Should The Government Control Citizens? - Grade 12 Social 30-1 - Positon Paper

906 words - 4 pages ... who can’t afford to send their child to school, the government helps. The government cares about their citizens and thus they should be able to control their citizens because without the government we would not have programs that help low income families, and challenging the government would just take away all these programs and make the low income families suffer more than they already are. How do people get around, if they don’t have a vehicle ...

Legal Studies Australian Articles Research - Thomas Hassall Anglican College - Research

632 words - 3 pages ... 21/11/17 13-year-old boy facing trial over Australia Day murder: · One of the youngest murder that Australia has ever seen. · Child admitted to unlawfully killing a man following Australia Day celebrations in Perth in 2016. · The state did not accept the plea. · The now 13 year old boy has gone on trial in Perth Children’s Court charged with murdering the 26 year old man, Patrick Slater near Elizabeth Quay Station in the early hours of January ...

Teachers And Guns. An Essay That Explains Why Teachers Should Not Have Guns In School - English - Essay

784 words - 4 pages ... hands. Lastly, armed teachers make it harder for first responders. They could hurt people not involved in the situation, police officers could get confused, and they could also hurt people already involved in the situation. Teachers should be armed with teachers, not guns. There are so many better ways to handle this situation, For instance, stricter security at all doors. This way we can see who comes in and request I.D, and even have metal ...

Should Childern Have To Say The Plede - Amms - Essay

471 words - 2 pages ... congruent and parallel to each other. ... (See Surface area of a cylinder). 3. prism-A solid object with two identical ends and flat sides. The shape of the ends give the prism a name, such as "triangular prism" • The cross section is the same all along its length. • The sides are parallelograms (4-sided shape with opposites sides parallel) • It is also a polyhedron. 4. Rectangular prism-Rectangular Prism. more ... A solid (3-dimensional) object ...

Balance Of Powers Between The Executive And Parliament - Politics - Essay

1291 words - 6 pages ... noted that the government could not function effectively without such a system of committees, although there is no legal requirement for them. Therefore, the balances of power between the Executive and Parliament has markedly shifted towards parliament. In addition, the House of Lords is more diverse in terms of its political party association. Peers belong to a wide range of parties. In addition, some members do not actually follow a party and are ...

Balance Of Powers Between The Executive And Parliament - Politics - Essay

1291 words - 6 pages ... noted that the government could not function effectively without such a system of committees, although there is no legal requirement for them. Therefore, the balances of power between the Executive and Parliament has markedly shifted towards parliament. In addition, the House of Lords is more diverse in terms of its political party association. Peers belong to a wide range of parties. In addition, some members do not actually follow a party and are ...

People Of The Whale: Thomas And His Connection With The Sea - English - Essay

816 words - 4 pages ... memory” (111). Even 2 though Thomas knew it was the wrong whale to kill, his memories and experiences that he had while in the military sparked him to shoot and kill. As Thomas attempts to rebuild his spiritual connection with the sea, the impacts that war has on him demonstrates that as a character he is not ready to reconnect with the sea. Unable to escape from his memories and the sea, Thomas builds a wall around his grandfather’s house. He ...

Why Young Marriages Should Not Be Allowed - Valencia College - Argumentative Essay

963 words - 4 pages ... month, and one of the most common reasons of disagreement is a partner’s spending habits – 23%. One can easily assume that young people do not know how to spend money correctly, and they have no sense of priority, which means the house full of unnecessary things and empty wallets. In closing, if we live with a person we love when we are so young, it will not be easy. Therefore, people under the age of 18 should not tend to marry because such ...

Why People Should Have The Option To Die With Dignity - English 102 - University Of South Carolina - Research Paper

2206 words - 9 pages ... illness and will never resume a quality life. How does one let their loved one live in pain if they have chosen to die with dignity? The Hippocratic Oath holds doctors to the promise that they will do no harm. Proponents of death with dignity contend that not honoring the choice of their loved one to end life peacefully is doing harm. It should be legal for terminally ill patients to choose medically assisted end of life measures because no ...

How Is Fate And Chance Presented In Thomas Hardy’s The Mayor Of Casterbridge? - St.albans Year 12 - Essay

1968 words - 8 pages ... Lucetta’s meeting with Farfrae would not have happened. As ever since Susan’s arrival there was “something in the air which had changed his luck.” As it is from the moment Susan arrives things start rapidly declining as it is also during a bad harvest meaning most of the townspeople were not in his favour and suspicious of him. Also, it is only by chance that “those men mentioned the name of Henchard” leading Susan to him. Another twist of fate is ...

The Anti-war Movement On Vietnam On The Australian Homefront - St Joseph's College - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages ... peace groups has grown – not only size by diversity as well. The Peace movement in Australia originated through left-wing trade unions and rapidly developed into movement with a much wider range of supporters in terms of their age, sex, occupation and political affiliation. The movement started to include more and more young people – especially university students as well as more middle-class people, women and more of the Australian Labour Party ...

East Timor History And Australian Influence - The Scots College History - Essay

1160 words - 5 pages Free ... reasons why Australia decided to step in and help with the chaos was because they felt that they owed something to the East Timorese. During the Second World War, when a battalion of Australian soldiers were surrounded by opposing Japanese forces, the Timorese took initiative in the situation and helped the Australians by providing them with shelter and food to keep them healthy for the heavy combat against the Japanese. They put their lives at risk ...

Should Police Have Tertiary Qualifications - University - Essay

1608 words - 7 pages ... degree should also promote a lifelong love of learning which should assist police with leadership skills long after they leave their degree. All these factors would contribute to the creation of a ‘Professional’ police force rather than the ‘occupation’ it has been in the past. In this essay I will argue cover these points to conclude that Police do need terry qualifications The community will have more faith in a police force that they do not ...

A Delve Into The Man Behind Cognitive Development - A Biography Of The Great Jean Piaget - Houston Community College - Dual Credit Psychology - Essay

1251 words - 6 pages ... children consistently missed questions that dealt with logical reasoning. It led him to believe that that particular skill is not wholly inherently or genetically gifted to individuals at birth, but rather it was both an inherited and evolved platform. This ran in direct opposition to the dogma of many thinkers of the time as the commonly held belief was that adult were simply just more effective intellects in every regard than children, but Piaget’s ...