The Authenticity Of Homer's Illiad Year 11 Essay

993 words - 4 pages

To what Extent was Homers Account of the Trojan War Historically Accurate?
Homer’s Iliad, written in the 8th century B.C., recounts a ten yearlong war fought in the city of Troy. The Iliad was written five centuries after the conflict, where the stories had been handed down through the oral practice. The Iliad's historical accuracy has been challenged for centuries due to the lack of evidence supporting it. However, through archaeological studies the truth can be deciphered. Archaeologists found a site in which they thought to have been ‘Troy’ destroyed by the powerful country of Mycenae. They also found pottery, engravings, murals and clay tablets, which helped them to understand the culture of the Trojans. There are however shortcomings to the accuracy of Homer's Iliad such as his partially inaccurate historical references and the Iliad’s medium as an epic poem. Due to the archaeological evidence supporting Homer's account of the Trojan War, it is historically accurate to moderate extent.
In A1870 in North Western Turkey, Heinrich Schliemann excavated the site believed to be Troy. This phenomenal break through supported the historical accuracy of Homer's Iliad to a moderate extent through stratigraphical evidence. The site contained nine layers of cities, and one layer was highly likely to be Troy. After examining the debris found in each of the nine layers, it was found that the sixth or seventh layer was Troy. The seventh oldest city at the site fits the description of a city under siege and destroyed by war in 1175 B.C. Archaeologists have found arrowheads in the streets to support this claim, but the city itself was not as grand as the one described by Homer. Archaeologists believe Homer took an element of poetic licence when writing the Iliad by using the stratigraphy of layer six and the destruction of layer seven, and blurred the two into one ten-year-long war. However, recent archaeological findings from Manfred Korfman in 2004 support Homer's account of a 'grand' Troy. Korfman's excavations uncovered far more buildings, 75 more acres of settled land, and remains that suggest Troy at the time of the Trojan War was home to 10,000, just as Homer suggested in his Iliad. These archaeological findings support Homer's account of the Trojan War, making the Iliad historically accurate to a moderate extent.
The Troy from the Trojan War was described in Homer's Iliad to have detailed weapons and armour. Homer also described artefacts that have later been found by archaeologists. These discoveries support the historical legitimacy of Homer's account of the Trojan War. The seventh layer of Troy, when excavated, was found to have many household artefacts such as storage jars, housing plans, building materials and jewellery which all correspond to those used by people in Homers tale. Storage jars set into the floor suggests a state of siege was upon Troy in the seventh layer, which means Homer's account of the Greeks and Trojans at war would be...

Other Essays On The Authenticity of Homer's Illiad - Year 11 - Essay

Belonging Essay of prescribed text - Tempest - Advanced English Year 11 - Essay

974 words - 4 pages Belonging Essay How are aspects of belonging used in your text to convey ideas about the human experience? Belonging is not a fixed state, but a changeable spectrum, ranging from themes of alienation to perfect belonging, with a vast territory of possible human experiences in between. An individual’s sense of placement within this spectrum varies between people and is created from our personality traits, personal circumstances, and the

A Doll's House + The Handmaid's Tale Essay - Year 11 - English Extension 1 - Essay

890 words - 4 pages ESSAY – SILENT VOICES: A Doll’s House & The Handmaid’s Tale Composers challenge the values of their individual contexts through transgressive characters, forms and literary devices, thus creating space and agency for silent voices. This idea is depicted in the play A Doll’s House written by Henrik Ibsen and the novel The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood. Atwood and Ibsen uphold the values within their respective 1970s - 80s context and 19th

Politics of Performance of Black Authenticity - Brandeis University - Essay

1529 words - 7 pages Kesi Kmt Tuesday, 23 2016 Politics of Performance of Black Authenticity Prof. Jasmine Johnson #FlyingWhileBlack Travel is an experience footnoted by race, class, and gender. For example, never am I simply a human traveling. Always, I am a black female identified, poor, person requesting the transition from one local to the next. These political spatial transitions are riddled with contradictions. I must navigate the privilege of American

Complexities of Teenage Life - Holden Caufield - English - Year 11 Close Study of Text 2017 - Essay

1100 words - 5 pages The Catcher in the Rye – Critical Essay In the prescribed novel, ‘The Catcher in the Rye’ written by J. D. Salinger, elaborates on the consecutive complexities of Holden Caulfield’s teenage life. Holden’s youngest brothers’ recent death attributes to his depressive complexities. In correlation with a diminishing school life, these complexities are seen to influence Holden’s mental health. In spite of the fact that, Holden’s future is

How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? - Agriculture - year 11 essay

1445 words - 6 pages , that's when the first crops were domesticated. Since the green revolution in the 1960s (a scheme using genetic modification to increase crop yields in developing countries) crop production has increased close to two and a half times, with only 11% more land being used. (Projects.worldbank.org, 2018) This is a clear example of how genetic modification has worked. When it comes to growing crops and food, it can be a long and arduous process. Most

PDHPE - Better Health for Individuals - Year 11 PDHPE - Essay, Report

2390 words - 10 pages is more prevalent when young people get to the age of 15-17. Source: Australian Health Survey: Physical Activity 2011-12 Percentage of male and female students in year 6,8 and 10 engaging in more than two hours of small screen recreation (SSR) a day The state and behaviour of the health of young people in Australia �3 Pr ev ale nc e of m or e th an 2 h ou rs /p er d ay S SR (% ) 0 20 40 60 80 School Year 6 8 10 Boys Girls According to the NSW

china's economy being affected by communism - year 11 - essay

2680 words - 11 pages Tom Fish MT Question: Has China’s single-party system been the main contributing factor to the country’s recent rapid economic growth? Justification of the title/question I chose this question because we all hear about the importance of China in the news and we saw how Xi Jinping was treated very well on his state visit to the UK last year, perhaps because the UK wishes to cultivate a profitable relationship with the world’s second largest

Taming of The Shrew Gender Discussion - Grade 11 English - Essay

883 words - 4 pages the whole essay, not a thesis. :( Too vague and no clear argument. Comment by Laurie Lascos: Summarize your actual subtopics with play details/specifics. Works Cited Shakespeare, William. Comedy of The Taming of the Shrew. J.M. Dent & Sons, Ld., 1919.

the effect of dynamic instantiation - dhs 11 - essay

1544 words - 7 pages this question paper. Write your centre number and examination number on these sheets in the spaces provided and insert them inside the back cover of your ANSWER BOOK. 9. 10. 11. An information sheet, with formulae, is included at the end of this question paper. Number the answers correctly according to the numbering system used in this question paper. Write legibly and present your work neatly. QUESTION 1 The table below gives a breakdown of the

Conflict Essay - To Kill a Mockingbird and Prelude to War - Magdalene, year 11 - Essay

855 words - 4 pages Conflict Essay “An individual’s perception of conflict is intrinsically linked to their core values and beliefs!”  To what extent is this view represented in the texts studied? Refer to To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and one related text. Through an individual’s perspective and central principles, it is an essential component for the insight of conflict. This is extensively engrained in the texts To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and

new boy short film for englisn internal year 11 - glendowie (english) - essay

587 words - 3 pages This essay discusses the Irish short film New Boy directed by Steph Green. The film shows a young African boy, Joseph, ​adapting to his new school in Ireland. The director uses different techniques to portray how Joseph moves from being lonely, sad and isolated to fitting in and finding some new friends and happiness. In the opening scene Joseph is introduced to the class. The director uses camera angles and dialogue to demonstrate Joseph's

Similar Papers

Essay On The Assassination Of Jfk Year 11 Essay

4415 words - 18 pages 20/20 Essay of JFK Assassination John Fitzgerald Kennedy, the thirty-fifth United States President, was assassinated on 22nd November, 1963, at 12.30pm in Dallas, Texas. The President’s fatal gunshot wounds came when he was riding in a motorcade in Dealey Plaza, with one bullet striking his head. The Governor of Texas, John Connally, who was in front of Kennedy, was also hit and critically injured. Kennedy was rushed to the emergency room of

Comparative Essay Ransom And On The Waterfront Year 11 Essay

943 words - 4 pages A true leader is born when they understand themselves. How does Ransom and On The Waterfront explore this? Leadership often highlights how characters get to where they are by embracing their own values. In the novel ‘Ransom’, written by David Malouf, which takes place during the Trojan War as described in the Illiad, Malouf demonstrates how the king of Troy, Priam, transgresses and becomes more aware of what he is meant to do through recognition

A Look Into The Development Of Ww2 And The Allies Attempts Avoid Conflict Year 11 History History Essay, Ww2

1150 words - 5 pages affected. However, was this human disaster, in fact, a battle between good and evil or just a sporadic plunge into tyranny and disaster leaving the world vulnerable to the thrall of the Nazi regime and its Japanese allies. Examples, statics and evidence of this proposed ‘unimaginable slaughter’ has been cast over the entirety of the second world war, proving to be a key aspect over the course of this 6-year assault. Seeing millions of innocent

Production Possibilities Curves Year 11 Essay

808 words - 4 pages economic growth. Our wants are unlimited but the resources in our economy are scarce. In order to satisfy all our wants, all economies face problems of scarce resources to produce the wanted products. All our decisions affect the economy and contribute to the growth of our economy. The graphs illustrate results of the decisions our economy makes and marks our economic growth. In my essay I will be explaining how production possibility frontiers