The Bacchae: A Critical Analysis University Of Wisconsin Steven's Point/ English 150 Essay

1269 words - 6 pages

Kastman 5
Kenzie Kastman
Professor Michael Steffes
English 150
2-15-2017
Dionysus and Agave: A Story of Wrath
Walking into the town center beholding the bloodied head of her dead son, she exclaims “Come see the beast the daughters of Cadmus/ hunted down, not with nets, not with spears,/ but with the white nails of our hands” (76). Indeed Agave, had slain her own child under the spell of the Bacchae cast by her own nephew, Dionysus. His role of the god of madness and wine had driven her to act with a sort of intoxicated ruthlessness that the god himself embodies. His wrath is undeniably a force to be reckoned with, however, I am of the opinion that although you can find wisdom in his punishment for Agave, but there is no justice to be found.
We can describe wisdom as understanding of knowledge. Where, then, does this manifest itself in The Bacchae as demonstrated by Dionysus? In his understanding of the fate of Agave, of course. Hardened by the fact that his own aunt, Agave, would dare slander his mother, and resultantly him, he plans very intricately his damnation for his own blood:
When order is established, I’ll go on,
revealing my identity in other lands.
But if, by rage and force of arms and citizens
of Thebes drive the Bacchae from the mountain,
then I lead the army of my Maenads into war. (5)
His goal is simple. Either his family and the rest of Thebes accept him and let him go on with his worship, or he will declare holy war. He takes Agave under his Bacchic spell and, in some twisted poetic justice, she is forced against her own agency to partake in the rituals of the very god she rejected. However, at the same time her son and king, Pentheus, is distraught by her behavior, saying:
I’ll track them down, all of them, even Agave,
my mother and her sisters, Ino
and Autonoe, the mother of Actaeon.
I’ll have them all in cages (19).
His punishment for even his own family is dreadful. One can’t help but wonder if this is all a part of Dionysus’s master plan to punish Agave. She is damned to be either be a part of a nomadic cult for an unspecified amount of time or imprisoned. This understanding that Dionysus has certainly demonstrates wisdom. Nevertheless, how can this be justified when he is very clearly baiting his own cousin, Pentheus, into a trap? Not only has Dionysus taken his mother, but also the rest of the female population of Thebes. Clearly, this doesn’t sit will with the frustrated king who didn’t believe in the wonders of Dinoysus anyway. Dionysus surely knows this and contrives his master plan based off this logic.
After the destruction of Pentheus’s palace, countless warnings from Cadmus, and several signs that the young “priest” possesses godly powers, the young king goes along to spy on the Bacchae dressed as a woman with this young man from the mountain. When Dionysus makes this decision to take him up to the mountain, it’s very clear he is done trying to change the mind of Pentheus. He is caught saying “He’s in the net now, women. He’ll get to see/ his Bacchae. He’ll get what he deserves… to die” (51). Even though Dionysus shows his power in a multitude of ways, he doesn’t exhaust all options. What if he took Pentheus to the mountain and demonstrated the true nature of the Bacchae? If he was so frustrated with Pentheus, why didn’t he drive him to madness with his power as he did with Agave so he wouldn’t have to deal with him anymore? The reason is because what follows is vengeance, not justice. The plan is engineered to maximize suffering.
Without a doubt, what ensues is murder, and a brutal one at that. Drawing from contemporary examples, lets observe the connection between Dionysus and Charles Manson. Both are self-proclaimed gods, both have a cult following, and both use sex and substance abuse in ritual, both have the goal of inciting war, both have extreme control over their following, and both have instructed their following to kill extremely high-profile individuals. The only difference between the two is that Dionysus is actually a god and Manson is not. Cadmus puts it well when he says “Gods should not resemble mortals in anger” (85). If that is true, then Dionysus most certainly fails at this. When do you draw the line between godly and earthly privilege? At this point, you could even argue that what Dionysus does is fear mongering, as if to say “This is what happens when you reject my teachings.” He made an example out of his family, plain and simple.
Agave coming down from her entrancement, she’s completely and utterly bewildered. Under this spell, she had no recollection of what she had done, where she had been, or what she was holding which is perhaps the saddest part of the story. After her stupor, she utters the heartbreaking words:
Who is this person? Who is this corpse?
Who am I? How can I, in all reverence,
knowing that my hands dismembered him
and are polluted with his blood,
dare to touch him, dare take him
to my breast, dare sing his dirge to him? (81-82)
This really drives home the idea that this outcome was never her aim.
As for punishment, Agave and her sisters are banished, Cadmus and his wife Harmonia are turned into snakes, and Pentheus is dead. The consequences are long stretching. Thebes doesn’t have their royal family that has been in power for hundreds of years, let alone their king. What does that mean for the city? Without clear leadership, it could very easily collapse. Agave is forced to wander wastelands and comingle with “barbaric” foreigners, meaning a life of instability. The most disturbing, however is the punishment that Cadmus has. Simply for being the family of those who dared question the authority of Dionysus, he is turned into a snake. Even though he worshipped Dionysus, warned against his powers, and tried to persuade, in the eyes of a god, this just wasn’t enough. And what does Dionysus have to say after ruining the lives of his family? Nothing but blame on everybody but himself:
You beheld him. You beheld his lies.
His impudence. You beheld him
when he tried to chain me and abused me
and tried- and dared to try-
to punish me.
I am Dionysus! Behold me! (83)
If you haven’t already, right here you get a true sense of just how egocentric this god among men is. The whole charade was never about his family because them because he never cared about them. It was all a scheme for him to validate through force his own fragile image he has of himself.
There you have it. We can conclude that Dionysus has a plan to maximize suffering, not for justice. This punishment extends from Agave to the rest Dionysus’s family and takes it a bit too far. Agave’s punishment is not just banishment, but the knowledge she killed her own child and worshiped a vengeful god. Her suffering manifests throughout the duration of the play. Although Dionysus has godly resources, he plays games with mortals, tearing at their heartstrings and destroying the rest of their lives. Conclusively, you can find some degree of wisdom in the punishment that befalls Agave, there is no justice to be found.
Works Cited
Euripides, , and C K. Williams. The Bacchae of Euripides: A New Version. New York: Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 1990. Print.

RELATED

Critical Analysis of Images in the Media - Northern Illinois University/English 104 - Essay

935 words - 4 pages Briana White February 13th, 2013 ENG 104 KUBLY Critical Analysis In the article, “Teaching Kids to Kill”, Lt. Col. Dave Grossman argues that video games and media violence are the roots to violence occurring worldwide. Grossman establishes credibility, evokes emotional responses, and appeals to his readers` ability to reason in an effort to persuade his readers to agree to put an end to violent visual media. Grossman appeals to ethos by

Marco Polo A traveler of the world - History 150 - Essay

937 words - 4 pages Moughan 1 Moughan 2 Randy Moughan Yongguang Hu HIST 101 4/10/18 Marco Polo Sure, we all know and love the name Marco Polo from, our childhood, but most people don’t know how much of an impact that Polo had on the world. He was born in Venice and was raised in Italy, he was born into a family of wealth and notoriety and lived his early life being educated in the Catholic beliefs, major authors, as well as multiple languages and nosiness courses

The Evolution of the Actress: The Importance of Sarah Bernhardt - University of Wisconsin - Essay

3178 words - 13 pages (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2001), 33. ] [13: Susan Harper, “Women in the World of the English Theater,” in A History of the Modern Theater, ed. Margaret Cormack (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2009), 147. ] [14: Berlanstein, Daughters of Eve, 39-40.] The early 19th Century served as a period in which actresses began to make a positive mark on the profession. They were earning wages (generally equal to men), actresses

Theater essay about Cats the play - Theater University of Wisconsin-Superior - Essay

530 words - 3 pages For those of you who don’t know, Cats: The Musical is back on Broadway. That’s right, Andrew Lloyd Webber’s 1982 smash hit classic. Cats has always been a divisive musical. People either absolutely love it and are super fans or can’t stand it and enjoy mocking its existence. To most, Cats is a very strange piece of theater and an even stranger phenomenon. It was is once the longest running musical on Broadway and one of the most internationally

critical reflection of a personal academic journey using the MBTI - University of Gloucestershire - Essay

3345 words - 14 pages Toni-Marie Marsh S1403477 Critically reflect upon your current personal academic journey in the context of educational theory. This essay reflects on my personal learning experiences and how the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) has enabled me to gain a better understanding of my past experiences, and how I can better my future experiences. My targeted area for learning that I need to improve on is procrastination. My choice for this is because

The Great Gatsby -A Critical Analysis Of The Great Gatsby

2704 words - 11 pages continues. "It is all useless. It is like chasing the wind" (Ecclesiastes 2:26). Or is it?Bewley, Marius. "Scott Fitzgerald's Criticism of America." Twentieth Century Interpretations of The Great Gatsby. Ed. Ernest Lockridge. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1968. 37-53."Book of Ecclesiastes." Good News Bible. Manila: Philippine Bible Society, 1980.Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. London: Penguin Books, 1990.Possnock, Ross. " 'A New World, Material Without Being Real': Fitzgerald's Critique of Capitalism in The Great Gatsby." Critical Essays on Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. Ed. Scott Donaldson. Boston: G.K. Hall & Co., 1984. 201-213.

Don't Feed The Wolves: A Literary Analysis of Shakespeare's "Macbeth" - Grade 11 University English - Essay

1190 words - 5 pages LESTER B. PEARSON CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOL DON’T FEED THE WOLVES A LITERARY ANALYSIS OF SHAKESPEARE’S MACBETH J.K. VERESHACK ENG3U - SEMESTER 1.2 MRS. RENEE CAMPEAU TUESDAY, JANUARY 24, 2016 “No evil dooms us hopelessly except the evil we love, and desire to continue in, and make no effort to escape from.” -George Eliot (1819-1880) There’s an old Cherokee saying about our ongoing internal clash between the forces of good and evil. The phrase

Fly Away Peter Novel Critical Analysis Essay - English - Critical Analysis

1034 words - 5 pages FLY AWAY PETER - CRITICAL ANALYSIS ESSAY NAME: FERDY RAHMADHAN SACE NO: 448469E CLASS: ENGLISH STAGE 2 TEACHER: MS. MONAHAN DATE: 06/04/2018 “Symbolism plays an important part in the novel. Discuss the symbolism of the birds in relation to all three characters; Jim, Ashley, and Imogen.” One of the most celebrated Australian writers David Malouf, is known to characterise his writing through his extensive use of symbolism to engage his readers. In

The American Dream Critical Analysis - English 1C - Critical Analysis

1359 words - 6 pages Alejandro Puentes English 1C Critical Analysis The American Dream Tad’s animated film “The American Dream” is like a documentary showing the way the government has always been misleading and cornering the American citizen. In the film, the Americans’ dream was being controlled and taken away from them by the few who control the flow of money. Through the banking industry, the US government expresses how they can support people’s financial

Signing Starbucks, a critical analysis of Starbucks corporations contributions to disabled - university of mary washington - research

1651 words - 7 pages . However, Starbucks uses their company in favor to create awareness about disabilities and to ensure that those with disabilities have equal opportunities such as social interactions and employment. In this essay, I will use critical theory and invitational rhetoric to analyze the circumstances of the disabled culture and how society is rhetorically rewriting the history, the present and the future of “disability’s place in rhetorical history.” (pg

A Clean, Well-Lighted Place Essay - Troy University - Critical Analysis Essay

1151 words - 5 pages 1 Jackson Jackson 4 A’Leeyah Jackson Professor Pam ENG 1102 November 17, 2018 Essay #3 A Rose for Emily Critical Analysis In the novel, “The Wild Palms”, William Faulkner once stated, "Given a choice between grief and nothing, I'd choose grief.”(Goodreads) He further clarifies for what reason he would do this in "A Rose for Emily"; despite the fact that the story isn't about him, indicating the subtle elements, the forlornness, and selfishness

Critical Essay on the novel Speak - University of West Florida : Literature - Critical Essay

699 words - 3 pages Christian Ketchup Literature 2000 March 27, 2019 Speak Up Speak, by Laurie Halse Anderson, is about a ninth-grade girl named Melinda Sordino. Melinda loses the ability to effectively communicate after being sexually assaulted at a party. She wants to tell her best friend, or anyone in fact but the guilt that she places on herself doesn't allow her to. Through this action of silence she believes she’ll just forget what happened and move on. The

“A Hanging” by George Orwell analysing the injustice of capital punishment - Higher English critical essay of A hanging - Essay

1599 words - 7 pages “A Hanging” by George Orwell is a piece of nonfiction which highlights the injustice of capital punishment. Through the clever use of language techniques such as symbolism, irony and metaphors Orwell skilfully engages the reader throughout his essay on the injustice of capital punishment. One of the key language techniques Orwell uses to sway readers is the use of descriptive language and setting. From the very onset Orwell hints at the issue of

"The Shining Houses" Essay - Point Of View

388 words - 2 pages "The Shining Houses" by Alice Munro uses Mary's point of view to show how younger generations mistreat the older ones.Mrs. Fullerton, one who is of the older generation, is an individual that does not fit in with her new, younger neighbors. Despite that, Mary gives her and her story credence. However, Mary feels the division between Mrs. Fullerton's generation, and the younger one that she is a part of, as she felt as though she was going

A Critical Analysis Of A Review Of The Film 'I Am Sam'

636 words - 3 pages James Berardinelli's film review of 'I am Sam' is a considerably biased outlook on an otherwise monumental film with dazzling performances by Sean Penn and Michelle Pfiefer. Berardinelli is convinced that this film was just 'tear jerker' that was created with a sole purpose to win or at least be a nominee for the Oscars. Berardinelli is unenthusiastic and sometimes sarcastic tone add to his cynical opinion of this film.This critic claims that