The Defence Of Provocation: A Law Reform Submission School Of Law Paper

2506 words - 11 pages

This law reform submission will examine the current laws in Queensland surrounding the defence of provocation. Through the incorporation of academic literature and legal documentation this paper will critically reflect and critique the current legislation and will present arguments in support of the abolition of the defence. Furthermore, this paper will present recommendations for a viable solution to the abolition of the current Queensland defence.
An Overview of the Problem & Current Legal Position in Queensland
In the Queensland Criminal Code provocation is defined as a set of events that could be justifiable to cause an ordinary person to lose self-control[footnoteRef:1]. In using this defence a criminal act is regarded as less morally blameworthy than an intentional, deliberate act of vengefulness[footnoteRef:2]. To determine an individual’s liability in a defence of provocation a test of reasonability is done through the fabrication of an ‘ordinary person’[footnoteRef:3]. This is to establish how a hypothetical person with ordinary prudence in society would act in the same or similar situational circumstances[footnoteRef:4]. Currently not all states in Australia include provocation as a valid defence within their criminal code[footnoteRef:5]. [1: Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) s 269.] [2: Ibid.] [3: J Philippides et al, Supreme and District Courts Benchbook (Supreme Court of Queensland, 2017) 91. ] [4: Ibid.] [5: Criminal Code Amendment (Abolition of Defence of Provocation) Bill 2003 (Tas).]
In Queensland provocation is a legitimate partial defence that can only be used in a murder charge whereby if successful the conviction is reduced to manslaughter[footnoteRef:6]. The Queensland Criminal Code differentiates murder and manslaughter by the circumstances of the case: murder being the killing of a person with intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm and manslaughter being any other unlawful killing of a person that does not constitute murder[footnoteRef:7]. Furthermore a person convicted of murder must serve a sentence of life imprisonment and is not to be released sooner unless under exceptional parole circumstances outlined in the Corrective Services Act[footnoteRef:8]. In contrast, the conviction of manslaughter does not have a mandatory life sentence[footnoteRef:9]. Only in the case of manslaughter are mitigating and aggravating factors considered[footnoteRef:10]. Provocation is said to impact the quality of the individual’s state of mind and in-turn weakens their moral blameworthiness, however, the use of this defence has frequently been the topic of legal debate and societal outrage[footnoteRef:11]. [6: Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld).] [7: Ibid.] [8: Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld).] [9: Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld). ] [10: Ibid.] [11: Andrew Hemming, Provocation: A Totally Flawed Defence That Has No Place in Australian Criminal ...


Legal essay about Australian law reform with regards of current issues - Legal studies - Essay

1466 words - 6 pages Free Legal Assessment- Alcohol and Violence By: Hatem, A and Ziad The topic of law reform is beyond just the definition of changing the law, however it is the process in which the law is modified and shaped over time to better reflect the changing social and cultural values that we deem are important. The law cannot stay the same, as the primary function of the legal system is to respond to the changing social values and hence why law reform is

New Deal Reforms classified into relief, recovery, reform with definition of each law - United States History - Assignmeny

1030 words - 5 pages farmers, stopping them from overproducing which would make the prices drop. v. Civilian Conservation Corp 1. This act provided jobs for single males on conservation projects like reforestation and development of the National Parks and Forests. 2. This helped workers because it gave them a job, and thereby a source of income. vi. National Industrial Recovery Act 1. This was a US labor law and consumer law passed by the US Congress to authorize the

Legal Studies essay - Law reform concerning Indigenous Land rights - Legal studies - essay

1221 words - 5 pages To what extent has law reform addressed the concerns of Indigenous Australians, in regards to land rights? To a certain extent, progression of land rights for Indigenous peoples has been addressed through law reform. Their concern, according to Ross Watson, a Murri from the Dawson River, is founded in the significance of land as a ‘spiritual and economic base’, and land rights as ‘an opportunity to once again become a self-determining people

Creating Law: Philosophers Of Law Paper

2129 words - 9 pages Free to be the infamous conqueror. From 335 BC - 322 BC, Aristotle was a teacher, at this time he, as influenced by Plato, wrote "Dialogues". Aristotle contradicted some of Plato's beliefs. He believed "justice should aspire to equality" (Canadian and International Law), he also believe "allotment should not be dependant on the luck of being born into a wealthy or powerful family" (Canadian and International Law). Aristotle was against "oligarchy

Change The Law Of Abortion Essay

749 words - 3 pages Change The Law Of Abortion Each year, one million American teenagers are pregnant and eighty-five percent of these pregnancies are unintended. One and a half million each year are ended by abortion. Now it is time for the government to pass a law to make abortion illegal across the nation because it is a bad influence for the young people, innocent babies are being killed, and it will affect teenagers' lives when they get older.In 1973

Analysis of The Client Law Movie - Law - Analysis, Essay

752 words - 4 pages Analysis of The Client (Insert sentence) The law provides remedy and security to Mark Sway’s family by giving them a spot in the witness protection program, a house, a job for his mom and some starter money in return for Mark’s help in locating the body of the senator. The law also ensures peace in the movie by actively conducting an investigation on the well-known nephew of a mafia kingpin: Barry “The Blade” Muldanno. Putting Barry in jail

Characteristics Of Common Law

1237 words - 5 pages imprisonment must be placed in an institution until they recover.25. Provocation may form a defence - this does not include impulsive insanity. Provocation must be instantaneous - not over a period of time (see main text).4. Judicial Independence:Judicial immunity is designed to safeguard judicial independence on the assumption that judges are appointed from among honest, fair, and impartial members of the society.5. Jury System:At Common Law, the power of

A take on the reformed law of Capital Punishment. Including statistics and it's history - International Law - Essay

983 words - 4 pages officers. This bill did expire in 1973, but on January 26th of the same year, the Solicitor General of Canada decided to continue the partial ban with the goal of complete abolishment in mind. Finally, on July 14th, 1967, a vote of 130 to 124 made the final call to abolish Capital Punishment completely Canada for good.7 This law reform is significant because it gives individuals another chance to right their wrongs. As our society continues

Law Of Reflection

1592 words - 7 pages Testing the law of reflection: The angle of incidence = the angle of reflection.Aim. The aim of this experiment was to test the law of reflection: the angle of incidence equals the angle of reflection. This was done by projecting a ray of light at a flat mirror (ray of incidence) and measuring the angle made by the reflected ray (ray of reflection) and the normal. If the law of reflection is correct the angle between the normal and the ray of

Good Faith In The Law Of Contract

3316 words - 14 pages . Int'l L. 111, 146 (1997) [hereinafter Dimatteo, The CISG and the Presumption of Enforceability].Finn, "Fiduciary Law and the Modern Commercial World" in McKendrick (ed) Commercial Aspects of Trusts and Fiduciary Obligations (1992).Fair Trading Act (1987) Finn "Contract and the Fiduciary Principle" (1989) 12 UNSWLJ 76 In a paper entitled "Contract - The Burgeoning Maelstrom" presented in July 1987 in London and published in (1988) 1 JCL 15. at 30.John

The Law Of The European Union. Nowadays A Creation Of The ECJ

1718 words - 7 pages The law of the European Union. Nowadays a creation of the ECJBrought into existence by the postwar wish to establish a European economical integration, nowadays European legal system has attained characteristics, unforeseen at the time the Treaties were drafted. Most of these tendencies occurred in the first pillar where the ECJ was endowed by the drafters with a broad scope of prerogatives. Taking an advantage of that competence with a creative

Asignment disscussing issues about the future of the world - Harvard Law School - Assessment

1015 words - 5 pages sources to develop an historical enquiry 4.10 Selects and uses appropriate oral, written, visual and digital forms to communicate about the past. TASK DESCRIPTION: There are two compulsory parts. PART A: Research-Based short responses. (10 marks) PART B: In-class report (20 marks) SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS: · Handwrite your responses neatly in the spaces provided. · Clearly label your work with your name and class. · No plastic sleeves, please

Administrative Justice - Public Law 310 - University of Pretoria - Research Paper

2189 words - 9 pages Bank and Others v The Public Protector and Others Case nr 48123, 52883, 46255 (2018) (unreported)] [2: Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000] The application was made on the following grounds: Firstly, the Public Protector had no authorisation and thus contravened section 6(2)(a)(i) of PAJA[footnoteRef:3]. Secondly, that the recommended remedial action was materially influenced by an error of law contrary to section 6(2)(d) of PAJA

Learning Summary of Business Law 2390 - KPU, Business Law - assignment

2044 words - 9 pages Learning Summary Short Summary Business law conclude Contracts, the law of Corporations, and other Business Organizations, Securities Law, Intellectual Property, Antitrust, Secured Transactions, Commercial Paper, Income Tax, Pensions and Benefits, Trusts and Estates, Immigration Law, Labor Law, Employment Law and Bankruptcy. I have learned about the Canadian law which is applied to business including the introduction to the legal system and the

Family law prevalence of adoption - City uni - Law

1564 words - 7 pages general standing of Article 8 and its ‘supremacy’ as such within the law in the European Union, including the UK, has been dealt with to provide the basis of part (a) and (b) in the question. Part (a) will be dealt with first and that is the making of rules in regards to three aspects which are all part of the eligibility requirements and will be dealt with accordingly. In regards to finance it can be said, with confidence, that the UK exercises