The Divine Command Theory And The Euthyphro Dilemma

1010 words - 5 pages

The concept that moral actions are those that conform to God's will is within the context of the Divine Command Theory. This theory explores whether an action is right or wrong by determining whether or not an action conforms to God's will. If an action does conform then it is morally permissible, if it does not then it is impermissible. This theory is shattered, however, when the will of God is scrutinized by Socrates in a dialogue with Euthyphro at the entrance of the law courts.Socrates was prompted to inquire into the spirit of piety and his very moral fiber after a politician named Meletus charged him with corrupting the young with his impiety. Euthyphro's dilemma surrounds Socrates' discussion regarding the definition of piety. Euthyphro believes that his actions are pious and Socrates challenges him to define holy and unholy. Euthyphro responds that what he is now doing is holy - prosecuting a wrongdoer (his own father) of murder. Socrates reasons that Euthyphro is prosecuting his father because the person killed must have been a relative. He seems to think that it makes a difference whether or not the victim was a member of the family, but Euthyphro points out that the real matter is whether or not it was right for his father to commit murder.Socrates, interested in Euthyphro's knowledge of all things divine, wishes to become Euthyphro's student so that he can challenge Meletus before the trial. He asks Euthyphro to prove what piousness is using logic, but Euthyphro is unable to do so because the divine command theory doesn't stand up under Socrates' scrutiny.Socrates points out that what is pious must be pious outside of the fact that the gods love it. If the gods love it, there is no information to explain why they love it. The only thing that can be explained is that they love particular acts. The fact that they recognize an act as pious would in fact prove that piousness exists whether the gods love it or not.Socrates, looking for further clarification, agreed with Euthyphro that the gods must love something for it to be pious. Unfortunately, this argument proved inapplicable since the Greek gods were often at opposition with each other and constantly changed their minds. Also the premise of "that which is loved" indicated piety exists due to a label, not because of an internal structure; however, Socrates still sought to understand the essence of piety - the love of the gods is only an attribute of piety, possibly an indicator of morality, but not a summation of all that is good and honorable.Many theists consider God to be the basis of all morality, but does that mean that God is the source of morality and that what God wills is always good and honorable? Does the knowledge of right and wrong exist outside of God? If it does, then God's commands are not arbitrary but rather are formed on the basis of what is good or bad - meaning there is a moral standard greater than God, or at least one that exists separately from God, to which God's laws or word must conform. Is an act morally good because God wills it or is it good because God agrees that it is good?The theist that believes in the Divine Command Theory trusts in the character of God and believes that God is a morally-perfect being that is all knowing, all loving and is the creator of everything and he does everything for a reason. God is all knowing, all merciful, and omni-benevolent, among other qualities of perfection.The Euthyphro Dilemma is problematic for the theist that believes in the Divine Command Theory. God's goodness and rationality cannot be determined without using an outside measure to place God's moral state and intelligence in some context. The knowledge of good and evil would have to exist outside of God. Also, God cannot be said to do all things for a reason if he is the only determining factor as to whether an action is good or bad. Any action taken by God cannot be said to be good or bad until God has deemed it so. This would make at least some of the actions taken by God arbitrary. Obviously, not all of the theist attributes of God can be accepted. To accept the divine command theory one can only accept that God is the creator of all things.Theists, like Euthyphro, want to believe that God is full of piety and understanding. In addition, they hold that God is the source of all things and knows all. This theory doesn't allow a person to easily and logically understand why God would deem any action right or wrong. One must throw his hands into the air and faithfully believe that God's will is beyond the understanding of humans. The concept is that God does in fact will things and that God is beyond morality.Piety describes an essence and any further deconstruction only does damage to the concept. One quality of being human is the ability to think abstractly -something does not have to be classified to have meaning. Theists reject the Divine Command Theory because it is not necessary for others who do not believe in the existence of God to wander down the divine command theory path. Furthermore, it is pointless to contemplate what a supreme creator decrees if the individual doesn't believe in the existence of the supreme creator in the first place.

RELATED

When the Emperor was Divine Questions - CCRI - Research

1599 words - 7 pages Cordon 2 Sandy Cordon Professor Prisco Comp I 1010-154 September 25, 2018 Discussion Questions On Novel 1.) When The Emperor Was Divine gives the reader an intimate view of the fate of Japanese Americans during World War II. The novel accomplishes this through the perspective of families who suffered through it. More specifically, one particular family, a mother and her two children. Though we do not get exactly what is going on in the war, the

Homcide and the Social Learning Theory - CRIM200 - Homicide and the Social Learning Theory

1538 words - 7 pages Running Head: MURDER AND THE SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY Liggin 7 Into the Mind of Serial Murders and Connection to the Social Learning Theory By Elisa Liggin CRIM 200-002 4/30/18 Serial murder has been depicted and dramatized for decades from movies, songs, and the news. As of 2012, there has been 3,204 serial killers within the United States alone, making up 67% of the world’s population of killers. Within this study I

A Synopsis Of The Similiarities And Differences Of The Emergent Theory And The Reductionist Theory In Explaining The World

475 words - 2 pages Reductionism and The Emergent TheoryThroughout time people have always has the desire to understand the world around them. In this pursuit of knowledge many theories have been formulated to try to explain natural phenomenon. Theories of particular interest are those that attempt to give an answer to what is the best way to understand the mysteries of the world. Two prominent views are the reductionist theory and the emergent theory. Reductionism

Battle of the Bulge, GEN Patton, Mission Command - us army, unit assignment - research paper

1061 words - 5 pages Mission Command: George S. Patton & the Battle of the Bulge History will forever remember people and events due to positive and negative actions that contributed to either a successful outcome or total failure. General George S. Patton Jr. is one such individual that will be recognized throughout time in military and civilian forums due to his leadership during his military tenure. General Patton displayed tremendous leadership abilities during

Karl Marx theory application on the german ideology and division of labor - CSU fullerton Theory - Theory application paper

1363 words - 6 pages Unit 1 1 Unit 1 Analysis Austin Chen California State University, Fullerton SOCI 410: Theories of Social Behavior False consciousness is a force that distorts ideas on the nature of life. Through Karl Marx’s work, one can begin to understand human developments and how material wellbeing affects human relationship and their social institutions. In this paper, I will cover the concepts of materialist method and ideology from Marx’s “The German

Karl Marx and his theory on the "Power of Money"

394 words - 2 pages finest establishment, whereas, without the money, a person would not have that power and would have to settle with what they could afford, if they could afford any degree at all. "He can buy clever people for himself, and is he who has a power over the clever not more clever than the clever" (Marx). Money is the ultimate intelligence. Wielding vast sums of money can enable a person to have under his command a multitude of people to do all the

Discuss The Technological Impact On Film Theory And The Advantages And Disadvantages Of The Invasion Of The Digital World

1536 words - 7 pages Free to talk and write about it, and film theory arose from these writings.Why the need for film theory? Because in watching a film, the spectator is not merely a passive receptacle being filled with the film's meaning, but is engaged in a series of interpretations which depend on a whole set of background beliefs and without which the film would not make sense. On the basis of such beliefs or theories, the spectator sees faces, telephones, desert

COMPAIRING PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY IN THE YELLOW WALLPAPER AND THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO - English - Essay

1445 words - 6 pages COMPAIRING PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY IN THE YELLOW WALLPAPER AND THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO Being depressed and seeking revenge can entice a person to a point where they have gone insane and are so inebriated by the enchantment that they are unable of either realizing their madness or opposing the temptation. As a result, their feeling of reality has been changed to the final turning point. Although at first, it might seem as though The Yellow

Desribe and evaluate the filter theory of attraction - A level - Essay

599 words - 3 pages Describe and evaluate the filter theory of attraction in romantic relationships (16 marks). A01; Outline Filter Theory in terms of partner choice we have a field of “availables”, which are the field of romantic partners which we could realistically form a relationship with. -But not everyone available to us is desirable. -According to K&D; three main factors that act as filters to narrow down our range of partner choice. 1. Social Demography 1st

Why the concept of democracy is universally valued and essentially contested? - Democratic Theory - Essay

1516 words - 7 pages makes it more acceptable. In terms of procedure, democracy demands that that everyone agrees on the same rules of the game. This is one of the most desirable characteristics of procedural democracy as it respects, protects and promotes human dignity, at least in theory. It does this through conferring rights unto individuals, rights that concern every aspect of human life, hence Dewy (1970: 14) metaphorically describes it as a way of life. This

The Social Learning Theory Of Bandura

1690 words - 7 pages The Social Learning Theory of Bandura emphasises the importance of observing and modelling the behaviours, attitudes and emotional reactions of others. The Social Learning Theory explains human behaviour in terms of continuous reciprocal interaction between cognitive, behavioural, an environmental influences, suggesting that behaviour can be learned at the cognitive level through observing other people's actions. (Blackburn, 1993) This suggests

the Auteur theory created by Andrew Sarris is the best theory - History of Film - film

742 words - 3 pages question is, what theory is the best? I am a truly believer that the Auteur theory created by Andrew Sarris is the best theory to create a film. The Auteur theory is so unique to me because anything is possible to happen from a director eyes. Now everyone in the world has different eyes and a different mindset, every great director don't have the same eyes and brain so anything is bound to happen while creating a film. The article, Andrew Sarris Notes

Does Organizational Management Theory Have The Answer To Managing Service Organizations And The People That Work There?

3440 words - 14 pages every individual worker.In this manner, the aim of this paper is to seek and inquire whether organizational and management theory provides better approach on managing organization and on facilitating the workforce behind the organization. It also aspires to discuss its implication to the whole aspect of the organization and its relevance to the ride to the crest of competitive advantage.OrganizationThe organization consists of individuals and groups

FREUD Theory: 1. Psychodynamic theory: A topology of the mind - durham - notes

1583 words - 7 pages Consumer psychology lecture 2 FREUD 1. Psychodynamic theory: A topology of the mind ‘心靈的配置configuration of the mind’ · Hysteria conscious (small) ‘Part of the mind that holds what you are aware of’ Can verbalize about your conscious experience and you can think about it in a logical fashion · 10% of the minds work is made up of conscious · not explain those random events created within the mind · Its ability to direct your focus. · Its ability

The Scaffold Plank Case: An Analysis of Effectiveness in an Organization - Eastern/ Organizational Theory and Design - Case Analysis

1859 words - 8 pages company’s only responsibility is to sell lumbar that is up to the specification of the order. He is making the case that they only have a legal obligation to this order and that if the order is not taken then employees and the business will suffer due to some hardships in business recently. Bob left the office confused about the ethical dilemma he was facing. 2. Actors a. Bob Hopkins, trader at White Lumbar Company b. John White, owner/manager of White