‘The Ends Always Justify The Means’. Do They? Discuss In Contrast To Utilitarianism Open Uni Essay

1612 words - 7 pages

Joel Cassells F346235x
‘The ends always justify the means’. Do they? Discuss in relation to the contrast between Mill’s and Bentham’s utilitarianism
Utilitarianism is a well known and relatable moral theory. A form of consequentialism, the belief is that actions can be morally right or wrong depending on their production of utility, or happiness. The pursuit of pleasure and avoidance of pain takes precedence over any other effect. The two most common types of utilitarianism are Act and Rule utilitarianism. Act utilitarianism, popular with classical utilitarian Jeremy Bentham, focuses on a more simplistic hedonic calculous of an action. Rule utilitarianism, product of which spans from John Stewart Mill, focuses on the types of actions categorising them into higher and lower pleasures. In this essay I will mark the distinctions between the two types of theory from Bentham and Mill whilst also critically appraising the theory. I will discuss the many flaws associated with this moral theory, which make it difficult to justify the mantra that ‘the ends always justify the means’, which I think neither Bentham or Mills versions can justify it.
Jeremy Bentham is thought to have been the founder of utilitarianism as a theory, specifically that of ‘act’ utilitarianism, which is its simplest form. Act utilitarians believe that whenever we are considering which decision to make, that we should make the one which will created the greatest overall utility. Their belief that to do whatever action, made by a sentient being, makes the greatest utility. This method was revolutionary at the time, as at the turn of the 18th Century began the growth of scientific research to answer many unanswered problems of the time. These decisions must be applied on a case-by-case basis by converting moral dilemmas into empirical solutions. (Barber, p57) He provides hedonic calculous which decides the value of pleasure by seven measures of quality; intensity, extent, purity, propinquity, duration, certainty and remoteness. (Cottingham, p.579) What sets apart Bentham’s utilitarianism from the rest is that it is egalitarian at heart. All pleasures in life experienced by sentient beings are of equal value, and that one should never attempt to value one pleasure over another. Only the seven measures matters when one makes a decision.
Utilitarianism has had an influence in modern day life, in particular in government policy. The pursuit of making peoples lives happy can be applied to many government departments all over the world. Indeed Bentham was aiming for this when he first set out his version of utilitarianism. He began his career as a lawyer, and was particularly interested in improving the criminal justice system (reference) using the utilitarian principle. He saw the criminal system as barbaric and scientifically ungrounded (textbook). When explain gin how human beings act, to focuses more on pain than pleasure. In his book, ‘The Purpose of Punishment’, Bentham believes...

Other Essays On ‘The ends always justify the means’. Do they? Discuss in contrast to utilitarianism - Open Uni - Essay

Assessment in social work – application to a case study - The Open University - Essay

2097 words - 9 pages by the warden and the GP making it seem this was the only option. Other benefits of a multiagency approach together with good communication means I can share the gathered information from the GP, caregiver, OT and Angharad to then discuss further options possible to keep her living independently (The Open University, 2016h). I must always promote the service users views and help support them to make choices about their own lives and help them

Theatre essay about the different kinds of theatre - Uni - essay

501 words - 3 pages both would benefit hugely from the study of theatre and literature as a tool to integrate into society better and grant them a positive sense of purpose and belonging in the community. In conclusion, the Clean Break theatre does not offer neither a youth programme, a writer`s programme or a programe for people of color but it is ore gender based. It seem that the Royal court has a wider variety of programmes that they offer with the possibility of reaching and inspiring a broader part of the community however the work that The Clean Break company do is no less and possibly even more important in terms of people who are in a more urgent need for integration and support.

open letter to the Tennessee Governer - writing composition - open letter, essay,

785 words - 4 pages Cottingham 2 Cory Cottingham Dr. Minichillo English 1010 25, September 2018 An Open Letter to the Tennessee Governor Governor Bill Haslam, I implore you to help change the current Tennessee laws pertaining to discrimination in the workplace, specifically to include protections for sexual orientation. The current discrimination laws don’t protect the hundreds of thousands of LGBT employees that reside in Tennessee, that needlessly suffers from

Social media has made the uk less democratic - Uni - Essay

2318 words - 10 pages democratic. ‘In politics, transparency is used as a means of holding public officials accountable and fighting corruption. When a government's meetings are open to the press and the public, its budgets may be reviewed by anyone, and its laws and decisions are open to discussion, it is seen as transparent.’ [En.wikipedia.org, n.d.]. Transparency is the government being liable for their actions, this means they open for public scrutiny all the time

"How the Planets Came to Be". This essay is a personally interpereted version of how the planets were created, and why they sit where they do now

429 words - 2 pages Some say God gave the Sun the power to create all matter in the Universe. When the Sun created all matter it was everything but unique. Some of his creations included very small stars but nothing spectacular.One day while creating matter he met a woman named Moon. It was love at first sight. He fell deeply in love with her. Sun was his happiest when his was with Moon. Together they created many more beautiful stars and expanded the universe

Discuss The Significant Differences Between Men's And Women's Talk - The Way They Interact, Their Choices Of Words And Phrases And The Topics They Like To Discuss

1949 words - 8 pages differences between men's and women's talk in the way they interact, their choice of words and phrases and the topics they like to discuss. We will begin by first looking at how men and women use compliments in their interactions.A study involving American, British, Polish and New Zealand speakers, both male and female, have shown that the use of compliments is more predominant among the women as compared to men, and that they are complimented

How to be a veterian and what they do in this world to make it better - southeast Halifax - Essay

439 words - 2 pages also become noisy due to sick or distressed animals. Veterinarians have the risk of being bitten, kicked or scratched due to working with distressed animals. Veterinarians work in many different kinds of environments. Most veterinarians work in private clinics and hospitals some travel to farms and classrooms or work in laboratories. They work outdoors in all kinds of weather and may have to perform surgery in remote places. Employment outlook

Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas - St ambrose college, 6fr - Essay

1523 words - 7 pages purely ‘right’ or ‘good’ based on the fact that it produces pleasure – other principles need to be considered. For Mill, the real moral approach involves the pursuit of these ‘higher’ mental goods: mental, cultural and spiritual. However, Mill’s utilitarianism has its weaknesses. Firstly, people do not always strive for higher pleasures. This is because lower pleasures in many cases are more satisfactory and require little investment. The

criminal law discuss peters potential liability in the circumstacnes given to you below - university - essay

1462 words - 6 pages Discuss Peters Potential Liability As the defendants’ actions did not lead to death he would be charged with Non -fatal offence. These offences are against a person that don’t result in death but does however result in various degrees of injury. Grievous bodily harm if found under section 18 of the Offences Against the Persons Act 1867 ‘whosoever shall unlawfully and maliciously by any means whatsoever wound or cause grievous bodily harm to any

To define personality one must understand exactly what the term personality means. - psych/645 - essay

1962 words - 8 pages Pervin (2010), “A correlation coefficient is, a number that reflects the degree to which two measures are linearly related” (p.48). When a person scores higher on variable I may score higher on variable II, this means that person is positively correlated (Cervone & Pervin, 2010). A negative correlation is when a person scores higher on variable I than variable II (Cervone & Pervin, 2010). However, if the two variables do not go together in a

Explain the types of economic systems and what they do - Economics - Essay

998 words - 4 pages often in Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Middle East. Societies that produce goods and services in traditional ways are found today in some parts of South America, Asia, and Africa. There, people living in an agricultural village still plant and harvest their own food on their own land. And they ways they produce food, clothing, and shelter area lost exactly the same as those used in the past. Traditional decides what these people do for a

Similar Papers

What Are Stakeholders? Why Can They Influence Organisations? Do Stakeholders Always Have The Same Amount Of Influence Over An Organisation? Why Or Why Not?<Tab/>

427 words - 2 pages great influence on organisations.Stakeholders do always have the same amount of influence over an organisation and the organisation has to take into account when formulating its strategies. It is because stakeholders have a great influence in the organisation. They can simply just withdraw their support from the organisation. Stockholders may sells their shares, employees leave their job and customers but elsewhere. Besides that, suppliers are

What The World Ends With You Means To Me English, 7th Grade Essay

1308 words - 6 pages Sheridan Vahldieck 12/11/13 Essay English What The World Ends With You Means To Me Joshua Kiryu once said “ Give up on yourself and you give up on the world” This quote means a lot to me and in this essay I’m going to show you why as well as what the game this quote came from means to me. I got this game at a very hard time in my life. I was bullied and didn’t know what was going on as far as whom to be. One part of me wanted to block the

Exploring Body Identity In Relation To The Development Of Technology And Socialization Uni Essay

3521 words - 15 pages the perfect house and family. Claire responds with ‘whatever we do, we always want to look our very best. Why imagine if our husbands saw us in worn, dark, urban sweat clothes with stringy hair and almost no makeup.’ She aims this patronising comment to Joanna showing the fact that she doesn’t agree with her appearance. Even when the men are not around, their presentation must be precise and excellent, as if they are being watched and can never

“Discuss Some Of The Ways That Stressful Experiences Can Be Managed. The Open University Essay

2038 words - 9 pages discuss how different stressful experiences affect different people in terms of socio-economic status, environment and personal resources and how they cope or not in some cases. In addition, this essay will discuss some of the ways that stress can be managed in terms of building resilience and managing stress in order to reduce its impact on health and wellbeing. Stress can be described as a common but complex phenomena (The Open University, 2013a