The Errs Of Dworkin Essay

1447 words - 6 pages

For many years, preferential treatment has been used to try to make up for past wrong-doings to minorities. There have been many cases tried over racial discrimination, with verdicts of both innocent and guilty. Ronald Dworkin attempts to argue that preferential treatment is socially useful and at the same time does not violate people's rights. This is wrong for many reasons; here I shall illustrate how preferential treatment hinders racial equality, violates people's rights, and can lead to a lower opinion toward a particular race.Dworkin believes that continuing preferential treatment will decrease racial consciousness and the importance of race. This is the total opposite of what truly ...view middle of the document...

That way, minorities don't even have to worry about competing with whites for a position. This does not, in any way, reduce racial consciousness by setting two tracks for admission to medical school, one for the minorities, and one for the majority.Mr. Dworkin supports the idea that preferential treatment does not violate people's rights. His argument is weak here because he attempts to prove this by saying that if two things do not violate people's rights, then neither does a third. The two things that supposedly do not violate rights are the denial of someone to medical school because of their age and because their test scores are just below the cutoff line of admission. He then assumes that because these two do not violate rights, then neither does denying an applicant because he will not reduce racial consciousness as much as an individual of another race would. By taking this argument apart piece by piece, it is evident that all three parts of his argument violate rights.Preferential treatment violates a person's right to be 'judged on merit and merit alone(299).' Dworkin says that another definition for merit is qualification, and for some jobs, race can be a qualification. Given a specific job, certain human characteristics are more desirable than others. People with these preferred characteristics are more likely to get this job. For example, a desirable quality for a surgeon is steady hands; therefore, a person with steady hands is more likely to get this position than a person with shaky hands. Using race in a similar example, preferential treatment would be just if there were a job where one race is more qualified than another. The problem with this is that there are no such jobs. Dworkin says that denying a person admission because of his age does not violate that person's rights, but then, is the individual being judged on his merit and merit alone? No. It is therefore wrong to discriminate against someone because of their age because it violates his rights.A second objection to Dworkin's belief that preferential treatment does not violate people's rights is that people have the right to be judged as an individual. Preferential treatment supports grouping people together according to race and then judging them as a whole. Dworkin agrees with Colvin when he says that people have the right not to be disadvantaged because of one's race alone. Many colleges set cutoff limits to the applicants' scores that they admit. Some applicants that barely fall below the line have much more dedication and enthusiasm than those above the line, and would make better students by these attributes. Unfortunately, these students are not even considered because they are not looked at as an individual, but judged solely by their scores. Now imagine a situation similar to this where race is the determinant of whether a person is accepted or not. If a person were to be turned down from a college because of his skin color before he was given a chance to be...

Other Essays On The Errs Of Dworkin

Socrates on the Soul and Human Happiness - Emory - Philosophy 400 - Essay

4129 words - 17 pages tempting to assert that Socrates is devoid of a coherent stance on the relationship between the individual virtues and virtue as a whole, perhaps it is not as inconsistent as one might think to maintain both that the virtues are identical and that they share a relation of parts to the whole. The Socratic notion that everyone chooses what they perceive to be the good and that no one knowingly errs, allows one to infer that for Socrates, if one knows

Polymer Mechanichemistry Essay

265 words - 2 pages Summary of Polymer MechanochemistrySometimes, curiosity gets the best of you, it did with Aj Boydston, an assistant professor at the University of Washington. Mr. Boydston and his students at the university conducted experiments, used models and imagined what would happen to the behavior of polymers when polymers undergo mechanical stress. This is a field of chemistry called polymer mechanochemistry. Creating models of star polymers on a 2-D

the changing

288 words - 2 pages One hand Reaches out And pulls a lost soul from harm While a thousand more go unspoken for They say what good have you done By saving just this one It's like whispering a prayer In the fury of a storm And I hear them saying you'll never change things And no matter what you do it's still the same thing But it's not the world that I am changing I do this so this world will know That it will not change me This heart Still believes The love and

The Importance Of The Act Of Reading” By Paulo Freire Essay

1423 words - 6 pages 4BredahlHarlie Cheyenne BredahlProfessor Peter EppsComposition II08 September 2014I"The Importance of the Act of Reading" by Paulo Freire, describes the importance of the act of reading beyond numerous experiences in his life as a child, a teenager, and an adult. Freire begins his article by taking readers back to where he was born, in his home city Recife, Brazil. He uses very itemized imagery to describe the trees, the house and the atmosphere

American Dream

765 words - 4 pages The American Dream is the quintessence of a comfortable victorious life, which often includes material prosperity, a house, an improved life for one's kids, and sometimes; it means achieving any goals one may have regardless of what class he or she comes from (O'Connor, Sabato and, Yanus 19). In recent years, it has become more difficult to achieve the American Dream; this is mainly due various issues involving the relationship between the

adadwq sdadasd

504 words - 3 pages Dengan Smarty Ring, Anda bisa membaca notifikasi di handphone Anda melalui jariKetika semua orang membicarakan kecanggihan Google Glass atau smartwatch, tak banyak orang yang berpikir bahwa sesuatu yang ukurannya lebih kecil dari itu juga bisa berguna. Ide itulah yang diusung Smarty Ring, yang memperlihatkan semua notifikasi handphone Anda sehingga Anda tidak harus mengangkat handphone Anda untuk mengetahui apa yang terjadi. Smarty Ring, yang


519 words - 3 pages father's racist views develops his own, to the point of leading a local Aryan Brotherhood/Neo Nazi group in beach side LA. They constantly arm wrestle with local blacks with Derek actually winning the local basketball court rights, after beating them in a game thereby enhancing his position as the leader of his group (encouraged by Stacy Keach's character Alexander who conveniently stays in the background when Derek's group runs amok). The

Miniscribe Corporation

1685 words - 7 pages EXECUTIVE SUMMARYTerry Johnson, a native of Longmont, Colorado established the MiniScribe Corporation, a disk drive manufacturing company that would grow to be one of the largest producers and distributors of disk drives for personal computers in America.This report focuses on relevant facts and figures in the evaluation of MiniScribe's liquidity, profitability, and overall stability aiming to determine whether or not maintaining its stocks on

dream world

384 words - 2 pages Dream worldThe warmth of the blanket upon me keeps my body safe and relaxed. My arms and legs stop trying to interact with this physical world. Peacefully, they give up and rest. My head falls further into the softness of my pillow. My eyes are closed slightly and my mind. I use my intuition to see through the world. I dream…Suddenly, the deafening noise of the alarm clock woke me up with a startling jolt. It seemed as though I had fallen

the adverb clause.ppt

754 words - 4 pages USE OF ARTICLES (a, an, the)What did these words originally mean?A/AN is an old word meaning `one'(in many European languages the ordinary word for `one' is used to translate English `a' or `an' and you can also sometimes use Cantonese `yat go' in the same way)THE is an old word meaning `this' or `that'These words no longer have their full original meaning but if you remember that meaning it can sometimes help you to decide which word you need


537 words - 3 pages Breanna PonceMia Sandoval Dominick KlingbyllAugust 26, 2013Block 2The Effect of Pineapple on Jell-OBACKGROUND:Protein was a big part of this gelatin lab. Protein is a multipurpose macro molecule. Gelatin is a protein made out of Jell-O, we used Jell-O in our lab. The students had to put pineapple in the gelatin to see if it will form. The enzymes in the pineapple prevented that from happening. Enzymes are a biological catalyst. Bromelain is the

Similar Papers

Examine The Controversy That Surrounds The Question Of What Judges Are Doing When They Are Deciding Cases

3717 words - 15 pages which must be addressed is whether or not the largely similar background of judges results in judicial clones that not only think alike but tend to think along conservative or at any rate 'establishment' lines. Positivists, such as Herbert Hart, argue that judges require discretion to fill in criticism gaps. On the other hand critics of Hart, such as Ronald Dworkin, state that decisions in hard cases should be made through the use of legal

Is Pornography Harmful To Society Human Relation Essay

2299 words - 10 pages enjoyment. This, they believe, is reason enough for its abolition. Cheng Yen Ee explains that these feminists 'vehemently refute' the idea that pornography can constitute expression. The late Andrea Dworkin argued that all types of pornography including media that does not depict penetration are means by which patriarchal society subordinates women. Dworkin called the American pornography industry a 'trade in sexual exploitation' that turns women

Rule Of Law And What Are Its Benefits And Defects

2674 words - 11 pages and they are not intended to allow authorities to create new laws by their own personal considerations.Both Hart and Dworkin claim the rule of law consists of both rules and judicial discretion. However, Hart contended there were only rules and judges, where ambiguous rules were clarified by judicial discretion. This is what Hart called the "Open-texture" theory and such a theory did not support the "command" theory, whereby rulers alone

A Brief Summary And Expansion And A Full Proposal On Low Back Pain Technical Writing A Proposal

2315 words - 10 pages Collaboration. A review and proposal for a core set of factors for prospective cohorts in low back pain: a consensus statement. Arthritis Rheum. 2008;59:14–24. [PubMed] 5. Deyo RA, Dworkin SF, Amtmann D, Andersson G, Borenstein D, Carragee E, et al. Report of the NIH task force on research standards for chronic low back pain. J Pain. 2014;15:569–585. [PMC free article][PubMed] 6. Andersson GB. Epidemiological features of chronic low-back pain. Lancet