"The Microsoft Monopoly Should Be Broken Up." Evaluate This Claim Using Economic Theory And Evidence On The Welfare Effects Of Monopoly And Competition

2010 words - 9 pages

In the United States, monopoly policy has been built on the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890. This prohibited contracts or conspiracies to restrain trade or, in the words of the later Clayton act, to monopolise commerce. The claim that a company should be broken up is clearly not a new concept in America. In the early 20th century this law was called upon to reduce the economic power wielded by so-called "robber barons," such as JP Morgan and John D. Rockefeller, who dominated much of American industry through huge trusts. These trusts were formed as a number of competing companies agreed to assign the whole of their stock to a group of trustees, receiving in exchange trust certifica ...view middle of the document...

Total surplus in this market is maximised at this output and is the sum of all the areas 1 to 5. Under conditions of monopoly, the producer will produce at Q* charging a prevailing price of P*. (B) This creates a deadweight welfare loss which is defined as the net loss of total surplus. This inefficiency is caused by price controls which leads to the loss in producer surplus exceeding the gain in consumer surplus.The size of the deadweight loss will depend enormously upon the elasticity of demand in the industry. Campaigners that argue for Microsoft to be broken up ensure that, as there are so few substitutes for the Microsoft products such as Windows, the demand is very price inelastic. This means that the deadweight loss be considerably larger as shown below.In figure 2 the demand is relatively elastic and, in figure 3, relatively inelastic. The deadweight loss (shaded) is significantly greater in figure 3.In practice, the social cost of monopoly power is likely to exceed the deadweight welfare loss in triangles 3 and 4. One reason for this is that the firm might engage in such activities as rent-seeking. This is defined as the spending of money in socially unproductive efforts to acquire, maintain or exercise monopoly power. (Pindyck & Rubinfeld) A monopolist may undertake actions such as this in order to avoid antitrust scrutiny. Due to its social cost, antitrust laws prevent firms from accumulating excessive amounts of monopoly power.Microsoft's Anti-trust problems started early in 1990 when the Federal Trade Commission started investigating them for possible violations of the Sherman and Clayton Anti-Trust Acts. After settling the case in 1994, Microsoft agreed to a consent decree as a way of settling the government antitrust suit, and agreed not to engage in particular practices. Microsoft signed a settlement that said they would sell MS-DOS and other operating systems at a 60% discount to the original equipment manufactures if they agreed to pay a royalty for every computer they sold whether it had Microsoft's operating system on it or not. Microsoft was also able to specify the minimum number of operating systems the retailer had to buy and could also sign them up to long-term contracts. This eliminated the chance of any new operating systems becoming popular as the competitors had to create a system faster than Microsoft and beat them to vendors.There are economists who have argued that a monopoly is not always an economic bad. In the 1980's, such theories were released from the Chicago School of Economics. These theories said that the only justification for antitrust intervention should be that a lack of competition harmed consumers, and not that a firm had become, in some ill-defined sense, too big. Some monopolistic activities previously targeted by antitrust authorities, such as predatory pricing and exclusive marketing agreements, were much less harmful to consumers than had been thought in the past. They also criticised ...

RELATED

Walt-Disney, the soon-to-be monopoly - Westchester Community College: Mass media - Research Project

1651 words - 7 pages their business ideals because of how monopoly-like it is. I say this because of the recent $66 billion merger between Disney and Fox. Even though technically Disney is not a monopoly because there is still competition in the film industry with significant amounts of share in the market(Universal Studios,Warner Bros, and Paramount) with the merger of Fox however, a strong amount of shares fell into the hands of Disney who already had a sizeable

The Government, not individuals, should be responsible for healthcare and Welfare Provision. Discuss - modern studies - essay

1545 words - 7 pages intervene when it comes to matters of Welfare. Others would argue on behalf of Individualist approaches which focus on the importance of self-help, self sufficiency and individual responsibility. In more recent times, there has been an uprise advocates have emerged who argue in favour of using elements of both approaches. Therefore clearly it is critical that all approaches should be examined in order to determine whether Health and Welfare

childhood vaccines on the effects,and if it should be admistried - eng 122 - research paper

2159 words - 9 pages Free of their "well-kid" visits to the pediatrician. The CDC has built up an inoculation plan which doctors take after to decide at what age certain immunizations are given. Before a youngster achieves the age of two, he or she will have gotten 32 immunizations on the plan. It used to be that inoculations were viewed as a typical piece of youth, ideal alongside loosing teeth and can preparing. The present inoculation plan for a kid is said to be

Desribe and evaluate the filter theory of attraction - A level - Essay

599 words - 3 pages relationship. A03; Levinger; Lack of Research support One weakness of research into the filter theory affecting attraction is that there is a lack of research support. · Recent research has failed to support the original research of K&D · Levinger et al used the same methods as the original study and found no evidence that either similarity or complementarity influenced progress towards permanence in relationships. This therefore challenges the

Critically evaluate the evidence for and against geographical profiling - Undergraduate Psychology - Essay

1420 words - 6 pages surroundings and therefore shows little concern for additional qualities of the perpetrator or the crime scene. Similarly, the evidence to determine the offender’s base relies on the assumption that the preponderance of criminals are marauders and not commuters. The potential significance of using geographical profiling for any crime is influenced by distance decay and marauding, therefore, the highly controversial topic of using geographic profiling can be seen as inadequate.

Critically evaluate the evidence for a link between life events and illness. - Health Psychology - Essay

1179 words - 5 pages Free Stress and Health Exam question: Critically evaluate the evidence for a link between life events and illness. Stress was first defined by Hans Selye in 1936, where he described stress as “the non-specific response of the body to any demand for change”. There are different approaches to stress such as stress as a transaction, which focuses on the way an individual assesses a stressor and how this affects the way they would cope or respond to the

Comparison And Contrast Of "The Man With The Broken Fingers" And All Quiet On The Western Front

1323 words - 6 pages readers, need to understand is that both sides used similar tactics. The United States used to torture as well in WWII, but we don’t see any of the anti-American poems because we won the war. Sandburg uses the man with broken fingers as an instrument to display how war veterans should be treated. He glorifies battle wounds with a “chicks dig scars” mentality. This poem is eager to play the victim and to claim to have the answers

Critically evaluate the claim that victims of crime precipitate their victimisation. - criminology - essay

2813 words - 12 pages Name: kaanushan shanthakumar Programme of study: Criminal Justice & Criminology Stage: 2 Module: SO745 Assignment title: Essay Date assignment due: 03/09/2018 Word count: 2700 Tick this box if you have an ILP*: ☐ You are reminded that all coursework assignments (with the exception of presentations and certain reports) must be submitted using this template. Work not submitted on this template will not be marked. It is your responsibility to

Can you claim to be a Christian and not believe in the Resurrection?

404 words - 2 pages . Dozens of prophecies were recorded about the life, death, and Resurrection of Jesus hundreds of years before they occurred. Amazingly these prophecies were fulfilled in great detail while He was present on earth. If you don't believe in the Resurrection, it means that many of the Old Testament prophecies are left unfulfilled.The Resurrection is an event worthy of study, evaluation, and knowledge. It is the very event by which Christ identifies His power to save us. If we do not acknowledge and understand this aspect of Christianity then we diminish the love (seen in His death) and power (seen in His resurrection) of God.

An analysis and description of the life of Bill Gates and the beginnings of Microsoft Corporation

434 words - 2 pages thirty-one, Gates joined the Gatesionaires club and became the richest man in the United States.The 1990's are proving to be an exciting time for Bill Gates. In July, 1990, the Microsoft Corporation became the first software company to earn over one Gatesion dollars in sales. In June, 1992, Gates was awarded the National Medal of Technology from President George Bush. On January 1, 1994, Melinda French, married Gates. Jennifer Katherine Gates

Karl Marx and his theory on the "Power of Money"

394 words - 2 pages their education, regardless of the lack of any vocation. "I am brainless, but money is the real brain of all things and how then should its possessor be brainless?"(Marx) Despite any semblance of intelligence, a rich person can have a good education simply because the funds are readily available to that person. With this money, a person finds that they are not limited to any particular institution of higher learning and can seek far and wide for the

Essay on the will of the painter Angelos Akotantos and its strengths as evidence - Arts and Humanities - Assignment

1168 words - 5 pages Read carefully ‘The will of the painter Angelos Akotantos’ (Anthology, 2.5.1, pp. 225–8). What information does the source provide for the fifteenth-century artist? What are its strengths and its limitations as evidence about his everyday life and work? Angelos Akotantos has provided us with a brief insight into his world in fifteenth century Candia, the most noticeable trend that can be picked up on is his deep religious beliefs. Angelos begins

Karl Marx theory application on the german ideology and division of labor - CSU fullerton Theory - Theory application paper

1363 words - 6 pages world, but instead looks at how humans actually live. Marx’s focus on the mode of production emphasizes human beings creating life itself, beyond mere physically existences. This is Marx’s materialist method, where society employs empirical science to look at how humans collectively meet their needs, and how society is actually set up. He emphasizes that material is considered primary and ideas as secondary, human ideas about society results from

Critically discuss the relevant evidence on the relationship between conscientiousness and health. - University of Edinburgh, Psychology - Coursework

4436 words - 18 pages Critically discuss the relevant evidence on the relationship between conscientiousness and health. What mechanisms might underlie this relationship? Of the five personality traits (Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism, Conscientiousness and Openness) Conscientiousness is arguably the most consistent predictor of health. Highly conscientious people tend to be orderly, hard-working and responsible. In contrast, people who are at the extreme

COMPETITION There are a number of weight loss products and services in the U.S. market today

567 words - 3 pages force plenty of competition, whether it being from already existing competitors, the threat of new entrants or the threat of substitute products or services. To gain a competitive advantage would then be up to us to differentiate and improve our product, for example by maybe making the formula more powerful and natural.SOURCES: The textbook www.healthy4life.com Finkelstein, E.A. 2003, 'National Medical Spending Attributable