This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Offence Of Theft Under The 1968 Theft Act Should Have Been Straightforward. Unfortunately, The Courts Have Interpreted It To Become Illogical And Confusing. Discuss

4852 words - 20 pages

A semi optimistic article was published just prior to the Theft Act 1968 in the Modern Law Review, regarding the overhaul of the then law of theft, identifying some of the grass-roots problems instigating the major reconsideration (1):·Making the law easier to understand·Reducing complexity and uncertainty·To focus on ownership rights and not possessory rights·To overcome a myriad of inconsistencies under the then current law·To repeal a large amount of obsolete and redundant statutory and common law offences·Reduce the number of offences through new concepts and redefinitions·Expanding the ambit of some offencesThe Theft Act 1968 replaced the ...view middle of the document...

J.C. Smith, "Obtaining cheques by Deception or Theft" CLR (1997) 3968. J.C. Smith "Obtaining Property by Deception/Appeal: Commentary on R v Clark (2001) CLR 572 at 574-5Theft------------------------------According to s1(1), if a person appropriates property belonging to another, with a specified state of mind of dishonesty and intending to deprive the owner of the property permanently, then theft is committed. For theft, the central element is 'the dishonest appropriation of another's property'. Appropriation has been equated with the AR of theft, whilst 'dishonesty' with the MR.The problems with Theft were summed up by a satirical outburst by P.R. Glazerbrook, (9) as he went on to propose a complete revision of its elements:"…in the matter of appropriation,…. dishonesty; property; belonging to another; intent permanently to deprive…"I will discuss some of the elements that have evoked the most discontent over the last thirty years that should reflect how illogical and confusing the judiciary have found theft under the Act.-----------------------------------------9. "Revising the Theft Acts" (1993) Cambridge Law Journal p191 at 192----------------------------------------DishonestyFor Professor Williams, 'dishonesty' is '…a special mental state..', different from traditional MR, being more an ethical code for social conduct. It is not a legal term but a question of fact inferred from words and conduct. The jury should give it its ordinary meaning to decide D's honesty. It has been suggested that perhaps it is worth considering the D's motive for assessing dishonesty (10).It is an element that applies to all the offences under the act and also other areas of criminal law, and its importance for sound law is unquestioned.The Theft Act preferred 'dishonestly' to replace the phrase 'fraudulently and without a claim of right', which has been criticised as unnecessary (11). The CLRC chose 'dishonesty' precisely because it was easier to understand by the layman than 'fraudulently' (12).However, under s2(1) of the Act, a partial negative legal definition of 'dishonesty' was provided to be applied to s1(1) only and not to the other offences of dishonesty contained in the act. It tells us nothing about the intrinsic nature of dishonesty, but gives three circumstances of appropriation that were not to be regarded as dishonest. However, "this mode of proceeding certainly suggests that the CLRC wished some undefined residue of 'dishonesty' to exist beyond absence of the special cases", although arguments as to why, were not specified. The two main criticisms for the partial definition come paradoxically from two perspectives:i) Widens the gap for Defendants with spurious claims to be vindicated although admittedly rarely (13).ii) Widens the gap for the jury to use different moral values being attached to 'dishonesty' a state of affairs allowed by judges, thereby incriminating unworthy defendants who 'borrow' without consent.At...

Other Essays On The Offence Of Theft Under The 1968 Theft Act Should Have Been Straightforward. Unfortunately, The Courts Have Interpreted It To Become Illogical And Confusing. Discuss

Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?

1258 words - 6 pages slightly disoriented. Surroundings that should have been familiar, her backyard and her house, looked unrecognizable. She shook her head to get her bearings. The day was too hot for her to sit outside, so she went to her room and listened to the radio. After about an hour and a half of listening to "hard, fast, shrieking songs" Connie felt "bathed in a glow of slow-pulsed joy that seemed to rise mysteriously out of the music itself and lay languidly

Should Socrates Have Taken His Death Sentence?

866 words - 4 pages values. Socrates was a great thinker and was ahead of his time. He was simply at the wrong place in the wrong time.It is not a question of what we would do; it is what Socrates should have done. Socrates disregarded to defend himself and thus made compromises to the judges to the point of humiliating himself before them, more or less excusing his actions. Socrates could see, not a practical acquittal for his earthly life but, rather, the eternal

        To Some Many Of The Characters Of 1984 May Have

707 words - 3 pages To some many of the characters of 1984 may have seemed ?unnecessary.? When you really put thought to it and actually look into the book, none of the characters seem to be of any lesser value. All are important assets to 1984, and they all are tied in very well.The characters of lesser value really don?t exist. All add to the book quite clearly and make it flow. Parsons and his family are a prime example. Parsons wife would always ask for Winston

Do I have the right to be Offended?

384 words - 2 pages be offended it has to be asked which standard of rights are they choosing to be offended by and under which set of laws? In this world of diversity in beliefs and personalities, many times someone can be offended by something that they can't take to the government claiming their rights have been violated. The government has rules and standards as do educational institutions and other organizations. But those standards only apply to those within

Who Said You Can't Have It Both Ways?: The Double Standards Of Promisquity Analyze An Advertisement Using Feminist Theories About Sex, Race, And Class

986 words - 4 pages underneath that, a picture of the product; a condom and a bottle of lubrication and the caption "With LifeStyles, you can play it safe and have a great time doing it!".The ad being primarily focused on three drawn characters portrays a sort of fantasy story-line. The male being the dominating character and the two women his play things. Not only do the women seem to only be interested in having sex with the man in the picture, the white female seems

"Suburban" And "Walking The Dog" Have Titles That Don't Give An Accurate Description Of The Poem

711 words - 3 pages . . . but really!", in regard to the large bowel movement that had just been removed from her petunias. Its funny to see how she is so proud and "respectful" that she can't even call the dog feces "a large repulsive object" without saying "forgive me" before hand. Yet, she can make a big deal out of such a small thing like dog shit. The humor is seen in this also due to the fact that many readers probably have at least one to several Mrs. Friar's in

How Have New Media Enabled A Renewal Of The Public Sphere And Extension Of Democratic Processes?

2461 words - 10 pages information over long distances and ready access to information have become conspicuous and important features of human society, especially in the past 150 years.' (Hobbes 1998:14) The most recent form of communication and perhaps the fastest growing medium present in today's society is the Internet. It is common to say that the internet is the most significant new communications medium of our times and that 'the internet changes all' (Cunningham 2002

Does Organizational Management Theory Have The Answer To Managing Service Organizations And The People That Work There?

3440 words - 14 pages organization. Indeed, it needs further and thorough understanding of what the situation or problem needs.It is noteworthy that the implications of theories have the tendency to uplift the management status of an organization. As it has been discussed above, the theories of organizational management that have evolved and developed by scholars whose concern is on the proper management of organization and the people that work there.One of the beneficial

Discuss Representations Of Augustan Power And The Ways In Which This Power Has Been Portrayed As Beneficial For Rome And The Roman Empire

1860 words - 8 pages " (Eder 2005, 13) . Ultimately, under the rule of Augustus, Rome emerged with a far more effective and efficient government, underpinned by a stability that had previously been lacking due to the civil war. Linked with stability came an increase in security for the ordinary populace which in turn lead to unprecedented prosperity, a prosperity that played a vital role in forging the strength of the Roman Empire. These achievements, and indeed the

Does The Caribbean Have An Independent Judiciary?

1376 words - 6 pages Is there an independent judiciary in the Commonwealth Caribbean? The answer for this question is 'yes'. First we define an independent judiciary. The independence of the judiciary refers to the constitutional arrangements which have been put in place to certify that the judiciary, as an institution, is independent of all those who might wish to wield influences over or control over it. Next, we state the countries in the Commonwealth Caribbean

Do You Consider That The Introduction Of The Citizen's Charter/Service First Initiatives Over The Past Decade Have Made Any Improvements To The Law Of Public Administration ?

1655 words - 7 pages it has also provided a remedy if the service falls below an agreed threshold of acceptability. However, citizen expectations can be raised, only to be disappointed, by inadequate delivery on promises. Questions have also been raised concerning the methods of compilation and presentation of statistics which seems at variance with the actual experience of consumers. Furthermore, any redress available seems to be limited to what a charter provides

Similar Papers

The Gap Between Countries Have Become Smaller And Smaller

349 words - 2 pages During the last two decades, the whole world has increasingly promoted their connection and cooperation to such a degree that "the global village" is not a catchword any longer. People can share the same enjoyment, even living at the different corner across the world. In my opinion, the growing popularity of this phenomenon has inspired three main benefits below.First of all, it has stimulated people's aspiration for a higher standard of living

Racism And Racial Issues Have Been Important Themes In Many Films Since The Beginning Of Cinema. Discuss Some Of These Themes Particularly In The Films "Glory" And "Guess Who's Coming To Dinner."

483 words - 2 pages Race related themes have been widespread in films since the early days of silent movies. As the years have progressed, race related issues have been dealt with more openly and with more truth. Since the beginning of the motion picture industry, race related issues have been an important and much visited. During the era of silent films, African-American characters were actually played by white actors wearing black paint; as seen in the silent

What Are Some Of The Disadvantages Of Using Focus Groups? Discuss Two Recent Trends In Focus Group Research And Explain Why You Think These Have Evolved. Use References To Support Your Opinions

1685 words - 7 pages , 2001)Focus groups are normally used to investigate complex behavior in the same time discover how different groups think and feel about a topic and what opinions do they have (Evalued: Focus Groups 2005). There are many advantages of using focus groups. It allows the companies or researchers to evaluate products and services based on real life information on the spot without any excessive costs. But the one thing they have to take into account is

Imagine That You Have Just Been Diagnosed As Hiv Positive

701 words - 3 pages drugs, I should not be excessively optimistic about the finding of a cure for the disease; instead, I would have to regulate my daily routine, exercise regularly, get proper nutrition, and maintain a positive attitude.It would be necessary to tell the people around me about my condition because it would likely increase the feelings of family unity and encourage their comfortability with the disease; if so, I would not have to exhaustively hide my