"the Prince" By Niccolo Machiavelli Vs. "book Of The Courtier" By Baldassare Castiglione

466 words - 2 pages

The Prince vs. Book of the CourtierWhen you read The Prince and The Book of the Courtier, you notice they are both how-to guides for Princes, royalty in general, and nobility. However, there are some very distinct differences in the philosophy of Niccolo Machiavelli and Baldassare Castiglione. Castiglione advices his readers to practice all things with nonchalance, and things will fall in their place. He also put high importance on knowledge, gracefulness, and appearance. Machiavelli agrees with Castiglione on some issues, but on others, they strongly differ.Knowledge of arms and military is necessary for ...view middle of the document...

Castiglione wished a Courtier to be pleasing at first sight, and loveable to all who see him. Opposing that view, Machiavelli thought a Prince needed to destroy all resistance, using cruelty to be secure. The Prince cautions a Prince must also appear to be good, but know how to be evil. The following excerpt from The Prince contrasts the result of taking Machiavelli's advice, "You can gain an empire by slaying citizens, deceiving friends, and being cruel, but you cannot obtain glory in that manner."Going about securing an empire once obtained is also told differently by the two authors. Castiglione's advice is mostly about the importance of reputation and favor by the people. His suggestion is to gain favor by remaining humble. Being the bearer of bad news is never good when trying to earn the favor of those around you. Machiavelli has several ideas about securing an empire that are very blunt, but true. A Prince would encourage art and craft, use only capable servants, and keep them under control if following Machiavelli.Both authors have two almost totally opposite theories of how to obtain and secure a position of royalty. Machiavelli's ideas are more cruel, violent, and suppressive in nature. Castiglione is almost completely opposite in his theories of a mostly peaceful rule. A Prince/noble himself must select what route he wishes to take by personal preference in deciding what kind of Prince/noble he will become.

KEEP READING

Essay On The Prince By Niccolo Machiavelli

1758 words - 8 pages ... Book ReportThe Prince by Niccolo MachiavelliIn the early sixteenth century Italy was divided up into several isolated city states. It was the battle ground between the papal armies, France, Spain and the German kingdoms in the North. One of these city states was Florence which at that time was under the rule of a free republic government. One of the government officials was Niccolo Machiavelli. He was born in Florence and lived from 1469 to 1527 ...

Essay About The Book Of The Courtier - Purdue SCLA 101

1009 words - 5 pages ... , behaviors, and activities. Baldassare Castiglione talks about all this in his book, The Book of the Courtier. He shows the mindset of that era through dialogues between nobles at the court of Urbino. The nobles used to play games where they described the ideal courtier in one of them. The goal of this perfect courtier was to excel in everything and have a good reputation for getting more power. Both women and men were expected to be an ideal courtiers ...

Book Review Of The Time Machine By H.G. Wells

1394 words - 6 pages Free ... mentioning of their lack of intelligence, short attention spans, and their lack of gratitude were some examples of reasons why he did not want to be considered similar to the Elois as he did earlier in the book. He outright attempts to turn his back on the Eloi in the following point in the novel: "Then I tried to preserve myself from the horror that was coming upon me, by regarding it as a rigorous punishment of human selfishness. Man had been ...

A Critical Review Of The Prince - Junior, Beijing Foreign Studies University - Book Review

1550 words - 7 pages ... Counterarguments and Inconsistencies in The Prince ——A Reader-Friendly Review The Prince is a political treatise written by Machiavelli in 1513 when Italy became the center of intense political conflict. Machiavelli composed the pamphlet as a practical guide for ruling and hoped to gain himself an advisory position in the government by dedicating the book to the ruler of Florence. The major theme addressed in the book can be concluded as ends ...

Niccol Machiavelli's The Qualities Of The Prince

964 words - 4 pages ... Vice- immoral or wicked behavior Miser- a person who hoards wealth and spends as little money as possible Papacy- the office or authority of the Pope Usurper- a person who takes a position of power or importance illegally or by force Reference Machiavelli, N. (2013). A World of Ideas: Essential readings for college writers (9th ed. ). L. A Jacobus (Ed. ) The qualities of the prince (p. 219-233). Boston, MA: Bedford/St. Martin's. ...

Can Machiavelli Be Defended By Strauss?

2213 words - 9 pages ... directly to Lorenzo De' Medici because he believes the De' Medici family are the one to claim to restoring Italy. Regardless of his torture by Medici Machiavelli chose to still write the Prince."Machiavelli in many ways a characteristic product of Florence, the city in which he came of maturity, in whose government he served from 1498 to 1512, and for which he wrote the series of dazzingly original books for which he is chiefly remembered: notably The Prince, the Discources on the First Decade of Livy, the History of Florence and the Mandragola" . [7: Niccolo Machiavelli Contributor Anthony Grafton (2004). The Prince Penguin classics. 2nd ed. UK : Penguin .p13. ] ...

This Is The Book Report Of, "of Mice And Men." By John Steinbeck. Also Includes My Opinion Of The Book

1586 words - 7 pages ... he tried to conceal in his pocket. George told him to throw away the mouse and get more wood for the fire. Lennie hesitated, then finally threw the mouse and left for more wood.As night began to fall, George heated two cans of beans by the red glowing fire. As the cans sat by the fire, George and Lennie began to talk about how they would live and work in the future, without a care in the world. When the beans were finally heated, they ate hungrily ...

The Suffering Of May In The "book Of Ruth" By Jane Hamilton

909 words - 4 pages ... One of the major themes in the Book of Ruth by Jane Hamilton is that throughout our lives we all suffer, but its how we deal with the suffering that determines the quality of our lives. Many individuals suffer their entire lives and never come to grips with it until it is too late. While others suffer and deal with that suffering, leading to much more happier lives May is a character in the Book of Ruth that has dealt with a lot of suffering. It ...

Literary Analysis Of "the Unwanteds" By Lisa Mcmann - Grade Nine Language Arts - Book Report

1550 words - 7 pages ... Name of Book: The Unwanteds Author: Lisa McMann Publisher: Aladdin Date of Publication: August 30, 2011 Type of Fiction: Fantasy Theme: The theme of The Unwanteds is “not everything is as it first seems.” This theme is shown multiple times throughout the entire book. For instance, in the eyes of the High Priest Justine, Mr. Today kills all the children who are sent to elimination because they are Unwanteds. In actuality, Mr. Today makes ...

Edmond Halley By Barbara Hooper Heckart Intro: The Book Gives

446 words - 2 pages ... Edmond Halley By Barbara Hooper Heckart Intro: The book gives a brief summary of what the book is going to be about. It describes Halley's Comet and shows its orbit.Chapters 1 & 2: In these chapters, information about where Halley was born and about the time period he lives in is given (mid 1600's). There are details about his parents and about how he became interested in astronomy.Chapters 3 & 4: The book talks about his studies at ...

This Is A Report On The Book "gorgias" By Plato

520 words - 3 pages ... In the book "Gorgias" by Plato the concept of ethics is discussed. Gorgias is a professor of oratory. In the book Gorgias and Socrates are having dinner with some friends. Socrates believes that proper knowledge leads to proper conduct. He also thinks that "One should avoid wrong doing with more care than being done wrong," and that wrong doers must suffer for there actions. He believes that oratory is not an art form.Oratory is the process of ...

Hatchet By Gary Paulsen The Book - English - Assignment

1173 words - 5 pages ... Hatchet summary by: Miryah lee In Hatchet written by Gary Paulsen, the main character Brian Robeson, a thirteen-year old boy, is stranded in the Canadian wilderness. In order to survive, Brian must overcome many obstacles with bravery and determination. In a series of intense events, Gary Paulsen demonstrates that each cause leads to a beneficial effect which aids Brian in his survival. At the beginning, Brian is now on a plane to Canadian ...

Book Repory On "beyond The Blame", By Jeffrey Kottler

2243 words - 9 pages ... "tendency to concentrate on the other person's role in obstructing my goals" and that in addition, "The focus most of my energy is on trying to place blame on other people, on things outside of my control, rather than addressing what I am ... or ....could be doing, to resolve disputes and reach my stated objectives." (Page 3).This sets the tone of the rest of the book and explains the significance of its title. To abandon this seeking blame and focus ...

Book Report On "the Cherry Orchard" By Anton Chekov

794 words - 4 pages ... "The Cherry Orchard: A Comedy in Four Acts"By Anton ChekhovW.W. Norton & Company, New York, 1977The Orchard that Is LostThe Cherry Orchard by Anton Chekhov is a very good play. However, I dislike how the ending is sad. It occurs during the early years of the 1900s in Russia in the estate of Mrs. Ranevsky. Mrs. Ranevsky loves her cherry orchard because it brings back memories of her whole life. However, Lopakhin, a merchant, buys the orchard ...

Machievelli The Prince Review - Assignment

1116 words - 5 pages ... the end it gains the best results and embodies all the factors survive for a long time and to stay in power if done correctly. Bibliography Machiavelli, Niccolo. The Prince; Translated by Harvey C. Mansfield. Chicago, Ill. : U of Chicago, 1998. Print. Plato. Plato's Republic. Trans. Joe Sachs. Newburyport: Focus, 2007. Print. Roth, Veronica, and Veronica Roth. Divergent. N. p. : n. p. , n. d. Print. ...

"the Prince" By Niccolo Machiavelli Vs. "book Of The Courtier" By Baldassare Castiglione

More like "the Prince" By Niccolo Machiavelli Vs. "book Of The Courtier" By Baldassare Castiglione