The Similarities Between The Biblical And Mesopotamian Flood Stories Uc Berkeley History Research Paper

2830 words - 12 pages

Arash Akhavan 10
Let There be Flood
The Similarities between the Biblical and Mesopotamian Flood Stories
i. Abstract
Based on the Eurocentric view of the history that is influenced by Judeo-Christian theology, the Genesis version of the story used to be considered as the original and the oldest story of the flood for years even among historians. The discovery of the Near Eastern flood stories and especially the work of George Smith along with other studies on Ancient Near Eastern cultures challenged the originality of the flood story in the book of Genesis. The differences between Near Eastern versions of the story and the Biblical flood are mostly limited to the details such as the number of the ark stories or the kind of birds released to find a dry land. The Biblical version of the story seems to be a modified version of the narrative, making the story more attractive to the people of monotheistic faiths and more compatible with monotheistic philosophies. The vast similarities between the Biblical and non-Biblical flood stories suggest that the Genesis version of the story was derived from the Near Eastern flood stories, or they have the same older origin. In either case, the book of Genesis cannot be the first and only source of the story.
ii. Introduction
The story of a flood is not unique to a single culture or a specific historical period. In fact, the story of a universal flood in which humans and animals are saved by a hero on boat or in other ways is a part of the world literature. The powerful symbolism and philosophical aspects of the story in all versions of it have made the story of the flood one of the most influential and at the same time most controversial stories in the history of mankind. Religious aspects of the story along with archeological challenges to prove or disprove the actuality of the narrative and also the philosophy of life, death and power embedded in the story have made the studying of flood stories a crucial key for scholars to gain a better understanding of history. Also, many fundamental concepts in the relationship between humans and God or gods is introduced in the flood stories.
Other than Atrahasis, Utanapishtim and Noah, there are other flood heroes in many other cultures. There is a Persian flood story with a hero called Yima who gets instructions from his god to build a fortress and to keep pairs of animals in the fortress to be protected from the flood. There is also an Indian flood story in which Manu gets the warning from a fish to build a boat and save himself.[footnoteRef:1] Flood stories are recorded by many different traditions such as Sumerians, Assyrians, Babylonians, Chaldeans, Zoroastrians, Hebrews, Persians, Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, Celts, Hindus, Maya, Toltecs, Zapotecs, and Incas.[footnoteRef:2] Story of the flood is an ancient story which seems be older than any recorded literature and is known in all continents for centuries. [1: Wilson, Ian. 2014. Before the Flood: The Biblical Fl...


Constraint and Freedom: A Search for Independence in The Judgment - UC Berkeley - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages from his failures. The ongoing struggle between his free-willed agency and the constraints in his life cause conflict between self-perceptions as selfish and selfless, which confuses Georg to the extent that he feels he can only find true freedom in his eventual suicide. In the story, the peripheral characters' weaknesses constrain Georg, as they instill a sense of obligation to them. At the start of the story, Georg hesitates to write a letter to

The Similarities & Differences between the American and French Revolution - World History - essay

598 words - 3 pages had no money whenever the revolution began and the Americans did not paid them back since they had been creating their own economy. The bourgeoisie began the revolution with no assistance from other countries or the Americans. Instead countries attempted to hit them like talked about before. Religion usually has an aspect in politics. This may be by far the most apparent distinctions between the 2 revolutions. The American Revolution wasn't

The Great Gatsby--Similarities Between Gatsby and Tom - English - Essay

1230 words - 5 pages real thing, because real books were very expensive. Not to mention Gatsby is wealthy enough to throw such extravagant parties and have an entire staff working for him and around his property. Similarities between people who seem polar opposite is actually very common. In the novel​ ¨The Great Gatsby¨,​ by F. Scott Fitzgerald. The author poses the question: are characters Jay Gatsby and Tom Buchanan truly that different? Readers can infer that

Similarities and Differences Between Christianity and Judaism - Montclair State University - Research paper

2622 words - 11 pages a covenant between God and Abraham (Fairchild, 2010). Judaism however emerged after God`s covenant with Abraham while Christianity developed after coming of Jesus Christ hence Christianity is considered to have grown from Judaism (Fairchild, 2010). This paper addresses on some important similarities between Christianity and Judaism as well as differences between the two faith backgrounds. 1. To be a Christian and to be follower of Judaism How one

UCOR: speaks about the similarities and differences between physicalism and dualism - Seattle U - Religious

703 words - 3 pages Sharif Batroukh Response Paper #1 April 27, 2018 Prompt #2 Dualism is a theory describing the relationship between the body and the conscious mind. It depicts an idea of separate physical and nonphysical entities, with the body acting as a harbor to the non-physical mind. Physicalism, on the other hand, describes the mind and body as one— a physical material object, the brain being the carrying case for your consciousness that only exists within

Social similarities between the Great Gatsby and our current society - High School - Essay

688 words - 3 pages taken at a closer look, it is more common for a famous person to marry a famous person and for a materialistic woman to marry a rich man. Although our society advocates the opposite, there is a faint social class that that shadows people’s relationships. Therefore, there are aspects in Gatsby’s society people may not see in ours but if more closely examined, is still there. In conclusion, there are many social similarities between the society of

Similarities And Differences Between William Shakespeare’S “Sonnet 55” And Robert Herrick’S “To The Virgins To Make Much Of Time”

745 words - 3 pages Similarities and Differences Between William Shakespeare's "Sonnet 55" and Robert Herrick's "To the Virgins to Make Much of Time"William Shakespeare and Robert Herrick are well-known names. They have written many poems that are still relevant and popular. There are some similarities between certain poems they wrote, which makes it possible to compare specific poems of Shakespeare and Herrick with each other. For example Shakespeare's "Sonnet 55

difference between living in the city and the countryside - class - research paper

5227 words - 21 pages behind the try line, or take it over the deal ball line. A failed dropout gives a free kick to the other team when it goes straight into touch. TACKLES: 2 hands are placed on the body “between the waist and mid thighs” (essentially the shirt and shorts). The ref counts the tackles: “tackle 1, tackle 2, tackle 3 etc up to tackle 6. After each tackle the player must remain in touch and pass within 3 steps, or else the player is brought back. Once a

cultural achievements of the mesopotamian empire and ancient egypt - Humanities - Essay

1248 words - 5 pages irregularly often caused massive damage. While the Nile river flooded once a year during summer and left a type of salt that acted like fertilizer for the plants, and even though they both Polytheistic, which means belief in multiple gods and goddesses, the Mesopotamian believed that they had to maintain a healthy relationship with the gods so they will not send an irregular flood. And the Egyptians idea of gods were more loving and kind towards

Differences and similarities between Maryland and Baltimore - University of North Dakota History - Essay

520 words - 3 pages and write on top of many other things. In doing so, he states some similarities and some differences. One of many differences between Baltimore and rural Maryland Douglass describes is that the plantation had long working hours with less food. Overseers would give little to eat and little time to eat resulting in little energy and lots of labor. “ We were often less than five minutes taking our meals” (Pg. 71). As expressed, This is just one

Haroun And The Sea Of Stories

1344 words - 6 pages The story is based on the quote, "What's the use of stories that aren't even true?" The use of these stories is to help people get an imagination, and to help people keep their imagination. One question you could ask is, who are fantasy stories mostly told to? They are told to children and babies. This is probably the reason why they have more imagination. Imagine a child without an imagination. Just think what a boring life it would have. The

Custer and The Little Bighorn - History 203 - Research Paper

3116 words - 13 pages Early American History-Penn State The Battle of Little Bighorn is an event in American history that has been poured over much like many of our prominent military events, such as Gettysburg, Breeds Hill, or The Battle of New Orleans. The most apparent mystique surrounding the battle is how a successful military veteran such as George Custer led himself and 268 of his men into complete annihilation. How could undisciplined, wild savages

Frankenstein: How there are more similarities than differences between Frankenstein and the creature - Valley Christian High School - English - Essay

933 words - 4 pages “emotion-provoking”. A piece by Jean Dubuffet called Visage Scarifié or The Scarified Face was painted with oil paint in 1951. It is supposed to portray a face, filling he entirety of the canvas with almost unrecognizable facial features. This is one of the many paintings that the artist made in the style of Art Brut or raw art where its goal was made to narrow the gap between normal and abnormal and provoke feelings of passion, violence, paranoia, and

atomic diplomacy and the Cold War - history - research paper

838 words - 4 pages radioactivity  Soviet Union-(n)  Communist country in eastern Europe and northern Asia  Casualties-(n)  a relationship between two events where one event is affected by  the other  Espionage-(n)  Practice of spying or using spies  Atomic  Diplomacy  ● The United States was the first country to discover the atomic bomb, the first  successful test of the atomic bomb was 1945. The U.S. were considering all the  benefits that would derive from the

Similarities and Differences between Monopolies and Oligopolies

650 words - 3 pages Similarities and Differences between Monopolies and OligopoliesWhat are some similarities and differences between monopolies and oligopolies?According to Mankiw, N. G. (2004) monopolies and oligopolies can be defined as:Monopolies are based on a market where there are several buyers but only one seller of a product or service whereby the seller sets the price for products and services provided.Oligopolies are based on a market where there a few