This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Themes Of Control Within Susan Douglas's "Narcissism As Liberation," Ralph Ellison's "Extravagance Of Laughter," And Walker Percy's "Loss Of The Creature" Are Explored

1673 words - 7 pages

Although they use different terminology Susan Douglas, Ralph Ellison, and Walker Percy mention and emphasize the importance of control at several points throughout their essays. It can be concluded that all three authors believe that it is important for the individual to maintain control over their own self for to sacrifice control would be to lose the individuality that makes a person. The methods society uses to control the individual varies, according to each author.Douglas discusses the media and the immense power it wields over women and their "narcissistic" selves in her essay. She argues that the media contrives to deceive women into thinking that they are truly the ones in control. ...view middle of the document...

Percy's methods of perceiving the world involve the process of "recovering the creature" from the "symbolic complex." However, society's hold over the individual is so complete that the individual loses his own sense of what he should and should not see in the symbolic complex. As Percy explains in the following passage, the individual gives up his own personal opinions because they do not match the advice of society's "experts." The individual loses control over his or her own thoughts.This loss of sovereignty is not a marginal process, as might appear from my example of estranged sightseers. It is a generalized surrender of the horizon to those experts within whose competence a particular segment of the horizon is thought to lie. ( Percy 518 )The individual places too much value upon the words of "experts" when in fact they themselves may hold the advice themselves. Thus Percy's claim that the individual lacks control over his self leads to the surrender of one's sovereignty, or ownership of one's mind, to experts who are appointed authorities by society.Douglas's "Narcissism as Liberation" views the media as the one in control. She suggests as the following excerpt illustrates, that the media wants women to think they're the ones in control, when in fact, the media is really the one in control.Usually the women pictured were enjoying leisure moments, or what Glamour called "private time." (Douglas 121)In one of my favorites, an ad for something called Terme di Montecatini, we saw the profile of a woman at a spa, covered from forehead to rib cage with a kind of mud we assumed would make her even more beautiful while she just rested. Women like this are passive, inactive, supine. Yet make no mistake about it, these women are in complete control: they are depend on no one, their time is their own, they are beyond the cares of the world, they long for nothing they don't already have. Those symbols of wealth-a huge veranda, the Riviera, art objects, unusual breeds of dogs, the omnipresent glass of white wine,-convey comfort, luxury, insulation from the masses, and control."The passage describes the image that women were supposed to pursue, what they wanted to be like simply because the media mandated. Women were convinced that being a beautiful, calm, laid back, and passive woman was in fact being in control. In truth, women do not really own their bodies. Women's bodies exist as a shrine to media's image of the "ideal beauty." If they do not conform to the media's representation of the ideal female, the woman is not valued. "Women's liberation metamorphosed into female narcissism unchained as political concepts and goals like liberation and equality..."( Douglas 117) She equates the media's exploitation of women's liberation and equality to men as luxury and rewarding oneself for having finally "made it" in this male world. The media was hiding its antifeminist ideas behind its "campaign" which "equated liberation with the freedom" to do whatever...

Other Essays On The Themes Of Control Within Susan Douglas's "Narcissism As Liberation," Ralph Ellison's "Extravagance Of Laughter," And Walker Percy's "Loss Of The Creature" Are Explored

A Brief Overview Of The Susan Smith Court Case

1070 words - 5 pages said, "I don't have time." Susan said that the man pushed her out of her car while he was pointing a gun at her side. Susan continued by telling Shirley that "When he finally got me out he said, "Don't worry, I'm not going to hurt your kids." Susan described how she had laid on the ground as the man drove away as both of her sons cried out for their mother (Crime Library).During the investigation Susan and using the description she provided

The Wife Of Martin Guerre: Short Answer Questions And Themes

3294 words - 14 pages on as usual. However, Bertrande could not, with a clear conscience, justify going against her beliefs and becoming "the wife of Arnaud du Tilh".5) Are those who believe Arnaud wilfully blind, or are they actually completely innocent of his deceit?There are many reasons why many people rejected the notion that Arnaud was not the real Martin Guerre. Most of Bertrande's family believed that Bertrande had gone mad as a result of Martin's long absence

"Lord Of The Flies" - Comparing Ralph Vs Jack

428 words - 2 pages In the novel Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, we are faced with one of the classic dilemmas, Good vs. Evil. We see these characteristics in the two main characters, Ralph the protagonist of the novel and Jack, the antagonist. Throughout the novel we see strong conflicts between these two. We see how ones actions are for the good of the tribe, and ones actions are for greed and selfishness.We first start to see tension between the two boys

Compare how the issue of love is explored in The Taming of the Shrew and 10 Things I Hate About You - Gleneagles Secondary College, 9E - Essay

1034 words - 5 pages Compare how the issue of love is explored in these texts? William Shakespeare's 'The Taming of the Shrew' has a different method of conveying the issue of love, then Gil Junger's '10 Things About You'. While both are that of a romantic comedy genre, dealing with relationships, light hearted and most importantly conclude with a happy ending, in '10 Things I Hate About You' the idea of marriage/relationships has been heavily changed to represent

Essay On Marital Rape, As Well As A Historical Background On The Sexual Manipulation And Control Of Women. This Was Written For A Senior Level Behavioral Science Course

4373 words - 18 pages The torture and rape of women has been commonplace on the society and notably so since at least, the archaic times. While behaviors such as torture and rape are no longer socially acceptable or politically correct, they are still condoned and practiced in all modern societies, as well as endorsed in others. Although women today are not so readily expected or openly commanded to throw themselves at the will of their male acquaintances

Describe how wine and knitting are used as symbols to foreshadow and explain the uprising of the poor

544 words - 3 pages Knitting and wine are elementary symbols to understanding A Tale of Two Cities. Dickens collectively foreshadows the future of the French Revolution with intriguing themes: Madame Defarge's carefully selected list of condemned aristocrats to die in the revolution and the streets stained with wine that are soon to be stained with blood. Both of these themes create an atmosphere of darkness and apprehension that entails the lower class's uprising

The Themes Of Dejection In The Writing Of Wordsworth And Coleridge

796 words - 4 pages , dejection is a topic that is considered very deeply, especially by the poets William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Although their views are sometimes dramatically different, each poet has very intriguing thoughts on the matter of dejection and has different views on dealing with it. While it is to Wordsworth's belief that depression can be conquered by memories of an immortal state, triggered by nature, Coleridge believes that depression is

How are the poet’s ideas, perspectives and experiences explored? - Harvard, 12 - Essay

405 words - 2 pages Poetry Assignment How are the poet’s ideas, perspectives and experiences explored in three of the poems you have studied? There is conflict underlying the Maya Angelou poem ‘Still I Rise’ as the poet is referring to conflict between herself and the people in society who would like to see her tied to the past and are offended by her success as a person. The conflict is with those who want her kept down because she is an African American woman

Merchant of Venice- Antisemitism relating to Susan Pharr's "The Common Elements of Oppression"

557 words - 3 pages blood-thirsty murderers of Jesus who snatch innocent Christian children for slaughter in bizarre Passover rituals seems to provide a potent back-drop for the demonic appellations that are heaped upon Shylock.The Christians techniques of condemning Shylock as an outcast (through stripping him of his name, reducing him to something other than human, and equating his name with the devil), inscribes those elements and cumulatively stacks them in order to define the character of Shylock less as a man and more as a cultural image of the malignant Jew.

Frankenstein: How there are more similarities than differences between Frankenstein and the creature - Valley Christian High School - English - Essay

933 words - 4 pages for the blind where they can have a sample of the texture of the painting so that they could experience the art without actually seeing it, but overall the display was excellent in my opinion. I do not usually enjoy going to art museums as they are usually repetitive with similar skill sets and mediums. However the Museum of Modern Art really changed my perception on places of that manner because it explored different concepts thought forbidden or

The Impact Of Advertisement On Gun Control

769 words - 4 pages . The advertisement chooses a baby girl because they are usually seen as weaker and morelikely to be a target of violence than a baby boy is. The picture stimulates our cultural desire to protect girls. The positioning of the photo itself shows the loss of innocence. The picture is taken at an angle of 45 degrees, similar to that of a picture taken at a crime scene. Also, the bottom half of her body is cut off, just as the bullet cut off her life

Similar Papers

How Are Ideas Of Salvation Explored In 'the Rime Of Ancient Mariner'?

2079 words - 9 pages making the wedding-guest listen to the ancient mariner as he tells of the voyage, the journey and his sin. As Coleridge continues the recapping of the ancient mariner's journey, Coleridge introduces the storm that leads the vessel into "ice, mast-high, came floating high, As green as emerald" and the first encounter of the Albatross. The albatross is built up with hailing of the creature and an indication that there is something special in it as "At

Competition There Are A Number Of Weight Loss Products And Services In The U.S. Market Today

567 words - 3 pages COMPETITIONThere are a number of weight loss products and services in the U.S. market today, ranging from chemical and herbal treatments to various kinds of programs and equipment that people can use. However, for our product our main competitors are other non-prescription tablets such as; Metabolife, Trimspa Fat Blocker, Xenadrine, Cortislim, Curb Your Cravings, Thermo-Burn and many more (www.healthy4life.com). Other competitors include

Both Victor And His Creature Experience Grief Over The Course Of The Novel (Frankesnstein Essay) Year 12 Essay

939 words - 4 pages individual. The similarities between Victor and his creature are magnified through the theme of loss, as both characters experience the loss of a parent, one that is meant to protect and guide their child, the loss of innocence as well as the loss of human connection. It is clear that both Victor and his creature experience grave loss throughout the course of the novel, however Shelley shows the readers that Victors losses mostly come about as a

Comparison Of Leaders: Lord Of The Flies. Aspects Of Leadership Betwen Jack And Ralph

1776 words - 8 pages gain it with the boys. Jack wants full control right from the beginning as he sees Ralph on top of the "natural platform" (Golding 15-16) discussing with the boys what they are going to do until they are rescued (Golding 223). Jack immediately comes into the picture and questions Ralph's ideas and later calls for a vote amongst the boys hoping that he will become elected (Golding 19). Ralph opens the story not quite sure what he has to do and