The Will To Power As A Neccesary Negation Of Friendship In Lord Of Teh Rings Christendom College/Inklings Research Paper

3273 words - 14 pages

3
Maria McFadden
HIST/ENG 409
Dr. Schwartz
November 29, 2017
THE WILL TO POWER NECCESARILY NEGATES FRIENDSHIP AS SHOWN IN THE LORD OF THE RINGS TRILOGY
In the well-known trilogy, The Lord of The Rings, John Ronald Ruel Tolkien proposes a philosophical question, which he answers throughout the trilogy in the actions of his characters and their rightful consequences. Here is brought to question the relationship between the will to power and the will to love, and the compatibility of the two. Tolkien presents examples of those who desire only the will to power, and contrasts them with those who chose the will to love. These examples prove the point made by writer C.S. Lewis in his work The Four Loves. Lewis firmly believes that the two wills are incompatible with each other and that the will to love is superior. The theme of friendship is an important one in the trilogy, for it is intertwined in the lives of all of the heroes, and is what binds the fellowship together. In Keith Mathison’s article, “Good and Evil in The Lord of the Rings”, he claims, “In Tolkien’s story, the primary means of overcoming evil is through love. This love manifests itself in many ways, but in The Lord of the Rings, the most important ways in which it manifests itself are through the trust and self-sacrifice involved in friendship and through acts of kindness, mercy, and pity.” [footnoteRef:1] In this trilogy the friendships proposed by Tolkien contain the essential elements of honesty, loyalty and mutual respect. This is made evident through the examples of the friendships formed within the fellowship, especially between Legolas and Gimli, which is contrasted by Boromir’s separation from the Fellowship, leading to his death. Tolkien then presents Galadriel as a foil to Saruman, as they are both persons of extreme power and age. Lastly the central focus of the story, Tolkien contrasts the duel character of Gollum or Sméagol and his actions in his past life, with the loving friendship between the hobbits, Frodo and Sam. By analyzing these three figures it is shown that the will to power necessarily negates friendship. [1: Keith Mathison,“Good and Evil in The Lord of the Rings.” http://www.ligonier.org/learn/articles/good-evil-lord-rings/ (Accessed [November 26, 2017]).]
Before analyzing how Tolkien demonstrates the power of friendship we must first examine how C.S. Lewis, a contemporary of Tolkien, defines friendship and show how Nietzsche’s concept of the will to power directly undermines that friendship. The will to power is what Nietzsche believed to be the main driving force in human’s achievement, ambition, and the striving to reach the highest possible position in life. Nietzsche says that “To say yes to life is to ‘yes’ to the will to power.” [footnoteRef:2] He not only combines the act of living with the will to power but glorifies it as an ideal. Michael Lacewing in his article comments on Nietzsche’s concept of the will to power in three different...

Other Essays On The Will to Power as a neccesary negation of Friendship in Lord of teh Rings - Christendom College/Inklings - Research Paper

Metamorphosis in lord of the flies - Marist College - Speech

1025 words - 5 pages Good afternoon, students and teachers. Today I will be analysing Lord of the Flies and We are going and how the writer of both of these texts have displayed metamorphosis. Metamorphosis is a concept often seen in literature and is used as an idea to stimulate complication in many famous texts. Lord of the Flies and We Are Going are texts that both show how metamorphosis occurs within people when certain situations or circumstances arise. Lord of

research paper about erratic power supply in africa (nigeria as a case study) - texas tech university/ grid - research paper

4421 words - 18 pages competitiveness of the industry all through the coming decades. As demand for improved environmental performance grows, metrics will be wanted that are convenient to understand, related to quantifiable environmental impacts, and based on accurate business principles. Emerging Issues: The automobile industry produces vehicles that many regard as requirements in the current world. As a result, the industry's environmental desires are strongly interwoven with

Measure Of Friendship What defining qualities in a person can measure the strength of your friendship with him or her? Loyalty, Humor and Kindness

371 words - 2 pages Measuring of friendship is a hard thing to do. What qualities must a person posses that would make them appeal to you as being a friend? The qualities that you like must be ever present for there will be problems later on if the friend has a change of personality. I measure a friendship by the degree of the following. Loyalty, Humor, and kindness.First and foremost there is loyalty. Without this there can be no friendship for you to measure to

God of Carnage: War as a Constant in Society - Quincy College, Intro to Theater - Analysis

958 words - 4 pages towards the production. As I sat in my seat waiting for the lights to go down, I began to evaluate the set. It was chic and modern. The floor was painted in a way that made it look like a smooth concrete, giving the set a rather industrial feel that has become popular in recent years. It was clean, pristinely so, and well decorated with books, art, and modern furniture. The room had a lot of empty space, giving the set a very “open-concept” type

China The Rise Of A New Power Paper ECO 360

1693 words - 7 pages China 1 China PAGE 6 ChinaThe Rise of a New PowerThe article I read was entitled "The Rise of a New Power: A Communist Economic Juggernaut Emerges to Challenge the West", written by Richard J. Newman and published in the June 20, 2005 issue U.S. News and World Report. The article examines China's growing and changing role in the world, and the struggle by the United States to reconcile itself with the changes.The rise of China as a major

Social isolation destroys innocence, Discuss in relation to Ender’s Game and Lord of the Flies? - A Level/English Literature - Essay

2574 words - 11 pages served children as catalysts to the world of adults". I believe this proves my points that by Ender being isolated the way he is frok people his age, he is forced to become more brutal and violent. Similarly in Lord of the Flies, Ralph is left desperately trying to help rebuild a society on the island that could help the children survive, but rather than listen to his rules, they choose to recklessly play. Roger is a doppelganger of Stilson and

history definitions ranging from letters a all the way to z. this will surely help those in need - 12th us govn. - research paper

4757 words - 20 pages community, such as a grassland or desert, characterized chiefly by the dominant forms of plant life and prevailing climate. Bipartisan - supported by members of two parties, especially two major political parties Boundary – the limit or extent within which a system exists or functions, including a social group, at state, or physical feature. Branches of Government – established in the U.S. Constitution to divide the power of government between

Power And Manipulation In Animal Farm By George Orwell And Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

959 words - 4 pages Themes of power and manipulation are evident in George Orwell's allegory Animal Farm, based on the Russian revolution with animals representing the major players in the debacle, as well as Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, where young children are stranded on a tropical island without any adults or authority figure. Both show how individuals are trapped by their leaders, namely Napoleon and Jack Merridew and their respective followers, who

This Research Paper Is On The History Of The European Union And The Various Aspects And Functions Regarding It, As Well As Its Potential Impact And Influental Power On Global Economics

1944 words - 8 pages extraordinary steps in Europe's long history, forging a common future as an integrated economic power when, just over fifty years ago, many were enemies on the battlefield. It will be the first time the continent of Europe will have its own currency and the first time there has been such an achievement without war. (Europia, 2001, 1)The EU: A Superpower in the MakingIt's hard to believe that just over fifty years ago, Europe picked itself out of the ashes

Wal-Mart: The High Cost of a Low Price - Copper Mountain College, College Composition - Research Paper

1385 words - 6 pages they can not do it, they will find somebody who can. They are asked to work off the clock with the implication that if they do not work off the clock, they will lose their job. They implement fear into their workers, and workers do as their told as a matter of survival. A federal jury in Portland, Oregon found Wal-Mart stores guilty of forcing employees to work unpaid overtime. It is disclosed in a New York Times article that, “In the lawsuit, 400

The Importance of Gender Equality in the Workplace - research college paper - rearch paper/essay

980 words - 4 pages transgender workers fearful of discrimination from deciding to express their identities openly or not. Organizations must create a gender-inclusive workplace to protect transgender workers from discrimination. This paper will prove the need for transgender education, gender-neutral spaces and dress codes to protect transgender workers within the workplace. Transgender employees, as well as the entire transgender population in society, have faced

Similar Papers

"Lord Of The Flies": Compare Any Two Characters And Their Relation To The Theme Of Power In The Novel

1236 words - 5 pages adapting the civilized culture to live in houses so that there will be order on the island. Clearly, Ralph intends to sustain a stable democratic society on the island. However, Jack on the other hand contradicts Ralph's ideas. First of all, Jack disrespected Ralph's leadership by talking while he was not holding the conch. As a result Ralph resents Jack. Second of all, Jack goes hunting instead of helping Ralph to build the huts. Ralph thinks that

Internal Problems Leading To Teh Collapse Of The Manchu Dynasty In China

507 words - 3 pages inevitable demise.There were many internal problems in China leading up to and after the Boxer Rebellion in 1899. After Emperess Hsien Fengs death in 1861,his primary wife Coxi seized power as their son was only 5. Cixi had many poisoned and killed who opposed her. She led a sheltered and materialistic life in the palace and was unphased by the state of her country. However Chinese internal problems started in the 1800's when China's society became

Evaluate The Contribution Of Interview Research To Our Understanding Of Friendship. Undergraduate Psychology Essay

1102 words - 5 pages Evaluate the contribution of interview research to our understanding of friendship. The use of interview has long been used by researchers to elicit information from questions in order to better understand a topic from that person's perspective. In relation to friendship, interviews are a very useful tool as it allows researchers to give rich detail on their thoughts and feelings in response to the question. Despite this, being based on

The Thematic Concepts Of Lord Of The Flies Continue To Play A Large Role In Today's Society (Lord Of The Flies In Relation To The Media)

1564 words - 7 pages democracy on the island. Jack desires power and bloodlust above all else. When he becomes an authoritative figure among the boys, his selfishness and love of authority cause him to work individually as a leader, without making collective decisions. These factors show Jack as a dictator. A crucial event in the novel is when Jack overthrows Ralph democratic leadership and replaces it with a dictatorship society. Near the end of the story, Ralph and