This Is An Essay Analyzing The Articles Of Confederation As A First Draft For The Constitution

526 words - 3 pages

The Articles of Confederation are considered by some a good first draft for the Constitution. On the other hand, other historians consider them to be full of weaknesses and shortcomings. However, there is evidence to support both points of view on the Articles.There are many points in the Articles that are also used in the Constitution. The legislative branch remained intact and retained the powers to declare war, maintain an army and a navy and coin money. The necessities not included in the Articles of Confederation were an important learning experience as well. After the Articles of Confederation, the founders understood the federal government needed the power to enforce laws, regulate commerce, ...view middle of the document...

On the other side of the spectrum, there are those who say there were no good points to the Articles of Confederation. For eight years, the United States was incredibly weak and vulnerable. The central authority had no power to levy taxes on its citizens, regulate commerce, no court system, no way to settle disputes amongst states, and no plausible way to amend the articles. While they provided for an army and navy, there was no funding for them. In fact, with voluntary tax contribution by the states, there was no real funding for the central government at all. Therefore, if the United States were attacked at anytime, there would be very little resistance. When Hamilton and others stated that it was merely a document full of weaknesses and shortcomings, they were in some respects correct. The document did not have any true power to establish a federal government since the states were the genuine rulers of the nation.In my opinion, the Articles of Confederation was an ineffective, but necessary document in the history of the United States. Every good project must have a rough draft and establishing a nation is no different. Without the experiences of inter state rivalries, lack of funding, and problems with foreign policy, they would not have been fixed or provided for in the constitution. The Articles proved to Americans the necessity of a strong federal government that still delegates some power to the states. With all its shortcomings, it did govern the U.S. for a short time without any huge disasters befalling the country. While not a good document in the long run, it was an excellent learning experience and a great short-term plan.

Other Essays On This Is An Essay Analyzing The Articles Of Confederation As A First Draft For The Constitution

This Is An Essay/Report On The Book "One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest". It Shows The General Runnings/Ideas Of The Book In A Structured Format

886 words - 4 pages CONFIDENTIALReport: #4727829CThis is a report on the findings of an external investigation into the running and daily going-ons of the Institute for the Mentally Disturbed, Operational State Number #MD77685. This report is concentrated on the treatment of the patients and the misuse of a position of power by the staff. Every aspect of patient health, security and care will be investigated to satisfy the requests and expectations of current and

Analyze The Degree To Which The Articles Of Confederation Provided An Effective Form Of Government With Respect To Any TWO Of The Following: -Foreign Relations -Economic Conditions -Western Lands

759 words - 4 pages opposition. The state governments passed lass that denied the British subjects the right to sue for the recovery of property or debts in American courts. Since Congress had no power under the Articles of Confederation to overturn the decision, many loyalists were unable to get back what had rightfully been theirs to begin with. With this decision it gave the British an excuse to main their military posts on the Great Lakes long after when troops were

This essay is an example of abstract writing on Time being the mother, the friend, and the snake

580 words - 3 pages Untitled Alexandria Mendiola Time Time is often taken for granted. Sure, Time is undoubtedly always going to be there, but what people fail to see is that Time does way more than what one expects. Time is the mother who nourishes, the friend who heals, and the snake that suffocates. Time is the mother who nourishes. She cradles us as an infant, and sings us harmoniously through our childhood. She then takes us by the hand

Life Expectancy For The State Of Kentucky. This Was An Assignment In A Math Class... ENJOY! It Is Missing Pictures So If You Need Them Let Me Know

1919 words - 8 pages Have you ever wondered how long the average life expectancy for Kentucky is? Well I have been wondering so I decided to find out by working on a project about the average life expectancy in Kentucky. I figured that after I got done then all of the insurance companies that offer life insurance to Kentuckians and even Kentuckians themselves would use this information. First the insurance companies might charge more if the average death age

This is an essay about industrialization in the united states. IT shows the negative effects of industrialization

456 words - 2 pages Exclusion Act was created to stop the Chinese from coming to America so they would not be able to take over American jobs. With the growing hatred for immigration, Roosevelt had to stop it. There were so many immigrants coming in that the United States had to limit the amount coming in a year. One of the things the United States did was create quota laws. This limited the amount of immigrants coming to the United States. Many acts were passed to try

This essay is bassicaly about how the supreme courts rules in some cases. this is an honors essay

522 words - 3 pages . He distributed antiwar pamphlets to people that were drafted andabout to go to war. This was an antiwar person, though this was still seditious actions. That isillegal. He was threatening the well-being of the country, by trying to lower their guard down.So the Supreme Court had declared the handout of the pamphlets unconstitutional.So, as you can see, these can be used and abused. Still today, people are still arguingabout the "fairness" of the Bill of Rights. Some people agree with the decisions of the SupremeCourt, and some people don't. This is why some court cases take really long to conclude andreach a fair verdict.

This Essay Is A Case On The Caterpillar Company

1105 words - 5 pages segment by producing multipurpose product to the owner/operator or small contractors. As the company strives to serve all the niches in the different segments its product mix become broader and deeper. The product mix is obviously broad because Caterpillar has different product line to serve the different industry. There are also an adequate average number of products in each line for it to be considered as deep product mix.Place

This Is A Simple Essay On The History Of Greek Theater

402 words - 2 pages religious rites that date back to at least 1200 BC. Dramatic and theatrical productions in ancient Greece may have come from the revelry of an ancient Greek festival in honor of the God, Dionysus which was known as the Cult of Dionysus. Dionysus was the God of fertility whose powers applied especially to wine, the wealth of Greece. A part of worshiping Dionysus was the dithyramb, or the ode to Dionysus. This was usually preformed by 50 men known as

This essay discusses the basic mechanics and characteristics of the ways in which we humans use wind as a tool

274 words - 2 pages uses of wind power that come directly from the wind without the use of a windmill, transforming the wind energy into something else.. The very first use of wind power was the sail boat thought of by the ancients. The sails of the boat catch the wind, allowing the boat to move without the use of an engine. Wind Power nowadays is being transferred into energy then used to do chores such as water pumping and grain grinding. It is even used to generate electricity.

Eerything Needed About The Articles Of Confederation, The Federalist, Anti-Federalist, The Elastic Clause, Federalism, Delegated, Express, Reserved, And Concurrent Powers

784 words - 4 pages 1. Articles of confederationIn Philadelphia, 1787 the articles of confederation where revised by 55 delegates. They agree that they needed to write a new constitution, that they where in need of a strong government, that there should be an executive branch (president), and that the states should not be as powerful as a national government. But they also had some disagreements like how many representatives should each state have in congress, how

"Abnormal Psychology" This Is An Essay On The Film 'A Beautiful Mind' Discussing Whether The Ideas And Depictions Of Schizophrenia Were Accurate And Relevant To The Context In Which The Film Was...

881 words - 4 pages hallucinations and though alienation, two symptoms shown by John Nash in the film. The only slight variance here was that in real life John Nash did not see the voices as people like he does in the film, he only hears them. A slight variation to the real story, it is possible that schizophrenic s see things, but it was not the case for Nash. These symptoms in the film still give the film an accurate portrayal of what was looked for in a

Similar Papers

This Is An Essay Regarding The Theme Of Symbolism In Rosario Ferre's Work The Youngest Doll. The Specific Theme Is The Use Of Dolls As A Representation Of Women

617 words - 3 pages first shown when Allende writes, "They [The Captain and Eloisa] had not missed a step once in forty years; they moved with the precision of a couple used to making love and sleeping in a close embrace. This was what made it so difficult to believe that they had never exchanged a single word (Allende 271)." The concept that two people never even attempted or were successful in talking for forty years is simple unbelievable and highly fantastical

This Is An Essay About The Tragedies Of Space Travel

1121 words - 5 pages men and two were women. Four of these people had never even flown in space before. NASA has not yet discovered the reason for this tragedy although there has been speculation.This is not the first time that a shuttle has been lost. It is the second time in seventeen years. This recent disaster has brought back memories of the Challenger shuttle and its demise in 1986 upon take off.Tragedies such as the Columbia and the Challenger that occurred

Is The Character Of Malvolio From Shakepreares Twelfth Night 'notoriously Abused'? This Was My Courswork For As Level English Literature And I Achieved 81 Out Of 90 Which Is An A

2518 words - 11 pages they occurred. The conclusion as to whether Malvolio is 'notoriously abused' may be different and even more complex for an Elizabethan audience. This is because Malvolio is referred to as a Puritan which carries implications of the way he would be viewed by an Elizabethan audience.Malvolio's treatment of the other members of Olivia's household is vital in understanding whether Malvolio ultimately got what he deserved. Malvolio, who is prim, proper

Essay On Marital Rape, As Well As A Historical Background On The Sexual Manipulation And Control Of Women. This Was Written For A Senior Level Behavioral Science Course

4373 words - 18 pages woman goes back for another protective order, it is often harder to get as she does not appear to be in the same imminent danger as she was the first time the order was obtained.Sexually battered women also face the dangers of stalking. Being the victim of a stalker is an extremely frightening experience. Stalking is difficult to prove, as contact is usually made in secret, and is cut off right at the point of terror. The purpose of stalking is to