Torts Essay Damage Duty Of Care Standard Of Care Breach Of Duty Causation University Of New England Law231 Essay

3163 words - 13 pages

I Randall v Kate
A Damage
Randall (the plaintiff) suffered ‘personal injury’,[footnoteRef:1] namely physical harm (right leg amputation) and mental harm (severe depression and anxiety) following the car collision with Kate (the defendant). Factoring in s 32(3) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) (CLA) and the definition of "consequential mental harm”,[footnoteRef:2] we can see that the mental harm was a consequence of the physical injury. [1: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 5(a).] [2: Ibid s 27.]
B Duty of care
The driver of a vehicle owes an established duty of care to other road users including pedestrians.[footnoteRef:3] The standard applied is that of the reasonable driver - this is not affected by a driver’s level of experience, or their possession of a license.[footnoteRef:4] [3: Cook v Cook (1986) 162 CLR 376.] [4: Imbree v McNeilly (2008) 236 CLR 510.]
The defendant would be found negligent in the control and management of her vehicle. She would be liable because it was reasonably foreseeable that her actions (negligent driving) might bring harm to others.[footnoteRef:5] [5: Chapman v Hearse (1961) 106 CLR 112.]
Does the defendant owe the plaintiff a duty of care to avoid the car crash resulting in his severe depression and anxiety? To establish a duty of care, the plaintiff has to satisfy the requirement of the CLA s 32(2).[footnoteRef:6] [6: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 32(2).]
The test under the CLA s 32(1), is whether it was reasonably foreseeable that a person of normal fortitude would suffer a psychiatric illness.[footnoteRef:7] It is reasonably foreseeable that a person would suffer a psychiatric illness after being in a car crash and having his leg amputated ending his AFL career. Factoring in CLA s 33[footnoteRef:8] and s 32(2)(a),[footnoteRef:9] it is likely that the defendant owes a duty of care to the plaintiff on the basis that mental harm was suffered as the result of ‘sudden shock’[footnoteRef:10] from the originating physical injury he suffered from the car collision. [7: Ibid s 32(1).] [8: Ibid s 33.] [9: Ibid s 32(2)(a).] [10: Tame v New South Wales (2002) 211 CLR 317.]
C Standard of care
To determine whether the defendant was at fault for the ‘personal injury’.[footnoteRef:11] As a general rule, the standard of care required is an objective one, that of a reasonable man. In Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks, Alderson B stated that ‘Negligence is the omission to do something which a reasonable man… would do something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do’. [footnoteRef:12] [11: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 5.] [12: Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks (1856) 11 Ex 781 156 ER 1047, at 784.]
In this case, the defendant must exercise the same care as that of a ‘reasonable person’ in the same situation, which includes obeying traffic laws and paying attention to pedestrian’s and other drivers. The defendant has failed to do so as she drove through an intersection containing a STOP...

Other Essays On Torts Essay - Damage - Duty of care - Standard of care - Breach of duty - Causation - University of New England - Law231 - Essay

Racial Barriers Of Accessing Health Care

1896 words - 8 pages functionalist's perspectives, the health crisis is caused by the failure of social structure- the society could not provide equal access to health care for racial minorities. Vernellia R. Randall, a notable professor in the University of Dayton school of Law, states that "since 1975 minority health status has steadily eroded and there has been no significant improvements in the removal of barriers that are due to institutional racism" ("Institutional

An Essay for Tetralogy of Fallot - Neonatal and Pediatric Respiratory Care - Essay

1499 words - 6 pages ventricular dysfunction, decreased functional capacity, arrhythmias and related sudden deaths. (Long, Lee, Lim, & Kim, 2010, p. 311-317) Children born with tetralogy of Fallot and other congenital heart defects are living longer—long enough for new problems to arise, and, eventually, to present to your clinic. In primary care, the presentation of tetralogy of Fallot is still rare, but it is becoming more common. Congenital heart disease was once

The study of falling in health care facilities - nbcc nursing - essay

791 words - 4 pages there was a curb beside the car. This accident resulted in the swelling of my ankle for months. Falls is the most common factor that negatively affects our daily living, especially in the healthcare facility falling and falls related injures are one of the main concerns of a patient’s safety, especially in among those 65 years and older. Patient’s safety, efficient patient care and quality patient care are top priority of healthcare organization

How The Conflict Between Roman Duty And Egyptian Sensuousness Develops The Tragedy Of Antony And Cleopatra Comments: More Focus On Final Scene Was Expected

1764 words - 8 pages Antony epitomizes the traditional tragic hero. The elements that constitute Antony's tragic standing are centrally developed by the conflict between Roman duty and Egyptian sensuousness. The audience empathises with the nature of his demise, as it deems Antony a morally respectable person, and can understand his downfall as a result of the conflict.The conflict embodies his tragic flaw, which is his stubbornness in trying to achieve an elusive

Textual Analysis of Wuthering Heights - University of New Brunswick - Essay

562 words - 3 pages Heathcliff’s return to the story is a key moment in Wuthering Heights that affects many characters in the novel. When Heathcliff first returns, Nelly immediately recognizes his eyes. Heathcliff is described as having “eyes full of black fire” (75) which are symbolic for his mysterious and dark personality. Even though Heathcliff appears to have become a well-mannered gentleman, his eyes show that he has not changed. As a result, Nelly mistrusts

Standard Term Paper Essay: The History Of Animation

1496 words - 6 pages viewing. Traditional animation is not the only class of animation. There is physical animation, video animation and 3D animation. Physical animation involves manipulating physical objects and employs the filming technique known as stop-motion photography. Stop-motion involves taking still pictures, moving the model to a different position, and taking more stills of the new pictures. When the film is played back, the changing of the model gives

Fraud and Breach of Trust at Wells Fargo - Colorado State Business Ethics (BUS220) - Essay

747 words - 3 pages massive breach of financial and personal information, and trust. How can Wells Fargo fix this? They will need to restore stakeholder trust and confidence which will take a lot of time and improvements inside and outside of the company. As the CEO stepped down shortly after the scandal, a new CEO was hired with a new statement regarding the elimination of sales targets to insure customers have the confidence that the bank is working in the best interest

The Detainment of Terrorists Suspects: Does it breach Human Rights - Trinity Anglican School / Legal Studies - Essay

1229 words - 5 pages Joey Muir 3/18/18 The Detainment of Terrorists Suspects: Does it breach Human Rights ‘Human Rights’ are fundamental principles entitled to each person regardless of gender, age, beliefs, or background, these rights comprise of dignity, equality and mutual respect (Australian Human Rights

This Compares American Medical Care In The Colonial Period With Medical Care In The First Half Of The Nineteenth Century

992 words - 4 pages These early immigrants survived the harsh times and difficult American climate as well as the wilderness on primitive basic instincts. The early settlements were often ravaged by starvation and disease.During the colonial era, doctors' education was informal. Most were literate, but some who were raised outside of New England were not. A man who wanted to practice medicine did not need any type of certification. Most did have a period of

Beneficiaries of the Industrial Revolution through standard of living - Economic History - Essay

2565 words - 11 pages the standard of living in an earlier era has been getting more attention. In fact, in Britain, inequality between the rich and poor and concerns about this issue was centred there. Can we trust the data? Although it may be a rough estimate, Britons were unequal in wealth. In the era of 1750-1815, there was most likely an earlier increase of inequality which is still debatable. The response to poverty by England was distinguished. The share of

Witchcraft and the Malevolance of the Susect: Targetting Midwives and others in Early Modern England - university of regina HISt 225 - Essay

1305 words - 6 pages pollution to reinforce threatened boundaries ’[endnoteRef:3]. These elements of motivation of the state and the church imposed tighter social and moral regulations by propagating the witch cases attracting the very ends of the ruling class who are powerful decision makers.[endnoteRef:4] [3: Deborah Willis Malevolent Nurture: Witch-hunting and maternal power in early modern England. Cornell University Press: London, England, 1995. 165.] [4

Similar Papers

Does Standard Of Care In Medical Negligence Provide Sufficient Protection For Patients? Tort Law Essay

1760 words - 8 pages medical profession no longer support such methods. In this way, the standard of care in medical negligence under Bolam and Maynard still maintained ways for a claimant whose well-being was compromised to successfully challenge doctors. [9: The Department of Health issued a list of ‘never events’ which can lead to a successful claim in medical negligence.] [10: Gemma Turton, ‘Breach of Duty’ (professional) Lecture (blackboard.le.ac.uk, 10 November

This Is An Essay That Is A Review On The New Video Game, Call Of Duty Black Ops Four. English 1101 Essay

896 words - 4 pages Lawrence 2 Luke Lawrence English 1101 Mrs. Fee 21 September 2018 Blackout Review “Patriots always talk of dying for their country and never of killing for their country.” Call of Duty: Black Ops have created a new game mode in their franchise. Originally, Call of Duty had only had two game modes in their games, multiplayer and campaign mode. With the new rise of battle royale games, they have decided to make their own battle royale mode and put

Applied Anthropology Final Essay University Of New England And 2021 Essay

1433 words - 6 pages Victoria Morse Professor Mackenzie Crouse Final Essay May 2, 2018 Language is an important aspect in people's cultures and societies. There are over 6,000 different languages in the world today. Language is the key to understanding others. Without languages we would not have an efficient way of communicating with others. Lera Boroditsky discusses the problem of how language changes the way we see the world and the way we think. There are many

Implementation Of The Affordable Care Act Sjc Hcm610 Essay

1437 words - 6 pages Running Head: Implementation of the Affordable Care Act Implementation of the Affordable Care Act Successful Implementation of Affordable Care Act Policy Management Assignment Student’s name: Course: Professor: Date of Submission: An Introductory Overview of the Act itself: The Affordable Care Act is a United States government policy that was implemented under the rule of President Barrack Obama in order to improve health care services all over