Two Scenes From Claude Lanzmann's Shoah: A Textual Analysis

898 words - 4 pages

1st scene (2 min 47 sec)The scene opens with the camera slowly closing in on a white surveillance van whilst a voice is singing (in German) a motivation song created by an SS guard in Buchenwald about heading towards an ideological goal involving a small village, Treblinka. The audience is made aware of the singer's identity by a simple white text on the screen: 'Franz Suchomel, SS Unterscharfuhrer'. The camera then cuts to two men presumably inside the van just viewed. They are watching various blue screens. All the while the audio of the song continues. Void of emotion Suchomel goes on to talk about the history of the song and how Jewish work detail prisoners were taught the song and ...view middle of the document...

As in the opening scene of the film, simple white text appears 'Abraham Bomba (Israel)'. There is just six seconds shy of a full minute of silence in the way of speech. Perhaps Lanzmann begins this scene with such silence to command the audience's full attention. This interview is conducted in English. Bomba relates how he was a barber and that because of this, while in Treblinka he was chosen along with others to be in a work detail, cutting the hair of people moments before they were to be gassed.Throughout his testimony Bomba's voice slightly breaks now and then - a sign of the immense pressure he may be exerting to control his voice. Lanzmann wants an emotive response from Bomba; he wants to catch on film just what the horror of the holocaust has done to individuals that survived. This is evident in his repetitive questions "what did you feel?" and "what was your impression?" etc. When Bomba finally replies to these questions, the door to his emotions has been pushed a little further open and his countenance becomes more agitated as he tries to relate the horror of watching his friends, relatives and fellow human beings being sent to death.Bomba then explains the terrible predicament of not being able to tell the victims anything, for the Nazi's were always present. The scene ends with Bomba stating "…they tried to do the...

Other Essays On Two Scenes From Claude Lanzmann's Shoah: A Textual Analysis

"Guilty Pleasures" By Laurell K. Hamilton As Compared To The Buffy The Vampire Slayer Tv Show. Includes Synopsis Of The Book

3119 words - 13 pages pick up Catherine and Monica, since she was their designated driver for the night. The vampire on the stage when Anita goes in to get them is Aubrey, who tries to enthrall Anita and almost succeeds. Aubrey hates it when fight him. He attacks Anita in the middle of the club and Jean-Claude has to step in to prevent them from killing each other. Jean-Claude ushers them offstage, revealing that the bachelorette party was just a ploy to get Anita

25th Sunday Ordinary Time Essay

1852 words - 8 pages an exegetical analysis, which is the interpretation of a text, of the readings from the 25th Sunday in Ordinary Time. I matched each of the readings with one of the three criticisms, form, textual, or source, and tried to interpret what the message from God was in each of the passages. For Matthew 20, using form criticism, I made the interpretation that Jesus was trying to tell his apostles to not blame people for being generous and to expect to

History Of The Holocaust By John Mcenroe

1422 words - 6 pages The Holocaust (also called Shoah in Hebrew) refers to the period from January 30, 1933, when Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Germany, to May 8, 1945 (V­E Day), when the war in Europe ended. During this time, Jews in Europe were subjected to progressively harsh persecution that ultimately led to the murder of 6,000,000 Jews (1.5 million of these being children) and the destruction of 5,000 Jewish communities. These deaths represented two

Cloudstreet

1295 words - 6 pages Cloudstreet, written by Tim Winton, has all the requirements and qualities of a text with textual integrity. Textual integrity consists of structure, form and language which create a meaning.Cloudstreet is a family saga which employs a generally linear and sometimes circular structure. It meets the requirements of a saga in two ways. Firstly, it takes place over 4 generations, and even though the oldest generation is only embodied through

Listening & Reading: Two Tasks Used In Teaching To Develop Discourse Skills In The Classroom

2790 words - 12 pages Introduction.Discourse Analysis (DA) is the analysis of language in use (Brown and Yule 1983). It also examines how stretches of language, considered in their full textual, social, and psychological context, become meaningful and unified for their users. It provides insight into the problems and processes of language use and language learning, and is therefore of great importance to language teachers (Cook 1989).All micro-skills have direct

Why Is Important To Study The Media, Rather Than Simply Consume It?

1788 words - 8 pages make sense of the meaning of the world portrayed to the audience through the media, there needs to be an engagement in an active work of decoding or interpretation, rather than a passive process of purely receiving and consuming media messages. (Morley, 1992). As quoted from Alan McKee;" When we perform textual analysis on a text, we make an educated guess at some of the mostly likely interpretations that might be made of that text." (McKee, 2001

My Ride

318 words - 2 pages other things, the structure of your argument. Successful essays will: 9 Demonstrate an awareness of audience, structure, and the key elements of definitional arguments as discussed in your textbook. 9 Be in MLA format 9 Provide an interesting title, a "gripping" introduction, and a thoughtful claim 9 Have fully developed body paragraphs that lead from one to the next in a logical manner 9 Provide historical, cultural, and/or social context as

Renoir

662 words - 3 pages family group portraits as he was in landscapes; unlike them, too, he did not subordinate composition and plasticity of form to attempts at rendering the effect of light.At the age of 13 Renoir began painting flowers on dishware at a porcelain factory and later painted fans and screens. In 1862 he entered the studio of Charles Gleyre (1808-74) and became friends with Claude Monet and Alfred Sisley, who shared his inclination to take up painting

Week 5 Worksheet Elizabeth The Golden Age

6373 words - 26 pages . In historical movies filmmakers take liberties because all history is interpretation of what has occurred. At some point the film has to take over from history and it was the responsibility of the filmmaker and the cast to tell the story. This film was the director's interpretation of history and simply he just told a story. Step 2: Analysis of Theatrical Elements How does the filmmaker use the following theatrical elements to

Music Viva Voce 1900-1945 (Early 20th Century)

4241 words - 17 pages background. Though adherents of the two theorists argued back and forth, in the mid-century a synthesis of their ideas was widely taught as "tonal theory", most particularly Schenker's use of graphical analysis, and Schoenberg's emphasis on tonal distance. The practice of jazz developed its own theory of tonality, stating that while the cadence is not central to establishing a tonality - the presence of the I and V chords and either the IV or ii chord

Wings Of Desire

338 words - 2 pages Wings of Desire The movie is about two angels, Damiel and Cassiel, who come from heaven to watch over people and can hear the inner voices of them. As they see them in their apartments, moving on the streets, subways and in a library. The two angels are dressed like normal people and are only seen by the camera and children. Damiel and Cassiel's world was seen in black and white. So during the movie I assumed the whole movie was in black

Similar Papers

A Character Analysis Of Hugo's Javert, From Les Miserables

1332 words - 6 pages Character Analysis of Hugo's JavertHugo's character Javert sees anyone who may have commit a crime as simple as the theft of a loaf of bread as a social malefactor, a blight on all of society, a prime evil who needs to be eliminated, removed from the general population, and a devil that can be neither reformed nor tamed. Javert is the true rationalist. Like Medieval philosophers, he believes that people will naturally resort to evil, and that

A Close Analysis Of An Extract From Television Text Drawn From The Sitcom Genre: Friends, The One With All The Cheesecakes, Series 7 Episode 11

1403 words - 6 pages The American television sitcom "Friends" is by genre an ensemble sitcom it follows the everyday lives of six twenty something's living in New York, who are all friends. Although by definition a sitcom the show has established soap elements such as an ongoing storyline and example in this episode is phoebe's ex-boyfriend David from the first series reappearing there is a bleeding over of storylines from series to series. This is known as open

A Historical Analysis On The Study Of Optics From Pre Socratic Times Through The Age Of Newton. By Adam R

4219 words - 17 pages classical natural philosophers' was optics, or the study of light and vision. The word "optics" is derived from the Greek word for eye, "ops". We know that the ancient Greeks were studying optics over two thousand years ago, and that they spent a good deal of effort in trying to understand this faculty. The natural philosophers of this era found a great interest in optics due to the fields inherent properties. Light, as viewed by the ancient

Impressionist Artist Essay

660 words - 3 pages ’s studio, and met with Vincent Van Gogh. Lautrec’s body of work often featured scenes from brothels. He was well respected for his art at the time of his death in 1901. His most famous works are those related with the Moulin Rouge.Pissarro- Camille Pissarro was a French Impressionist painter born in 1830. As a boy, Camille spoke French at home, English, and Spanish. His parents sent him to Paris at age 12 to a small boarding school. It