Undermining Superority Using Satire University Of Guelph Essay

1241 words - 5 pages

Grace Jackson
ENGL *1080
Faron Wade-Lang
March 22nd, 2019
“Undermining Superiority Using Satire”
“Satyr which is most useful, and gives the least offence: which instead of lashing, laughs
Men out of their Follies, and Vices” (Swift, 1738). These are accurate words written by the
author of ​Gulliver’s Travels​ Johnathan Swift. In his novel, Swift attempts to use satire to
contradict the Enlightenment Era’s ideologies. By focusing on examples of comparison between
the relationships in the novel and the views of England in the early 1700s, I will show that both
books clearly display the Enlightenment Era’s foibles, failings, and beliefs of superiority. I will
argue this book uses the other, a person or group perceived as fundamentally different, as a way
to allow the readers to question the superiority of the age of reason. This will be through looking
at scatological humour, the relationship of the main characters with a person of power, and to
what extent humans are similar to the savage Yahoos.
The Enlightenment, or otherwise known as the age of reason, had a colossal impact on
Europe in the 17th and 18th century. Ideas such as weaning away from nature and theistic views
had a egotistical impression on how people viewed themselves. They were too proud of the fast
scientific progress and people had newfound skepticism for God. Humans were placed as the
superior being due to our powerful capacity to reason. Swift countered these ideas by exposing
the failings in the illustrious concepts that the Enlightenment period presented in that time
through traveller Gulliver. In ​Gulliver’s Travels​, Gulliver is not only portrayed as the other but
also encounters multiple forms of otherness. He visits many lands and no matter where he goes
he never quite fits. When he travels to Lilliput, Gulliver is the only giant, and fundamentally
different from all the natives from the island. This inflates Gulliver’s pride as he sees himself as
more capable and excellent because of his size difference. Gulliver attempts to use his body in a
way which degrades the Lilliputians and crumbles their pride, a representation of human pride.
This is because the excremental, used satirically, deflates our pride by showing our pretensions
and repressions to our natural bodily functions. Excreting is usually linked to shame, as it is done
in isolation and rarely spoken about. The values seen in the Enlightenment period are completely
opposite to the natural body as the human mind was presented as superior to the body. Swift uses
this scatological humour to break down this standard and oppose the dismissal of the body.
“...made the wine begin to operate by urine; which I voided in such a quantity, and applied so
well to the proper places, that in three minutes the fire was wholly extinguished” (Swift, 50).
This not only put the Lilliputians in a place of inferiority and lowers their pride, as he puts out
the fire with his urine, but also emphasizes the concern and importance of the human body and
how it functions naturally. It demeans the Enlightenment era’s views of superiority by displaying
human’s as they naturally are in connection to nature, and reminds the readers that we are all
animals with basic needs. This is in contrast to the belief that humans are the superior being,
including being superior to nature due to reason. The otherness of size allows Swift to employ
this scatological humour and belittle what was seen as valuable in Victorian times.
A view of the Enlightenment Era in allowing the superior being to rule is displayed
through Book II of Gulliver’s Travels. In this book, Gulliver encounters a race of giants called
The Brobdingnagians. In this book, the roles are reversed and he is small in size which allows
him to be portrayed as characteristically and fundamentally different from the rest of the habitats
on the island. The Brobdingnagian king is seen as a morally upstanding and good-hearted leader,
which can be a contrast to rulers of the time, King George the 1st and Queen Anne, who both
had greed and were eager for war. Swift points out flaws in his leaders by showing the readers a
leader who is morally different from those seen in Victorian society. Gulliver talks to the King
and tells him of the invention gunpowder and how it could be deployed with guns.
“[Gunpowder] would not only destroy whole ranks of an army at once; but batter the strongest
walls to the ground; sink down ships, with a thousand men in each, to the bottom of the sea”
(Swift, 123). The king is disgusted that the Europeans would harbour such weapons capable of
such destruction and cause so much death. He cannot believe the complete moral disregard and
says he would rather lose half his kingdom than use gunpowder (Swift, 124). This is completely
different than the beliefs of the rulers of 17th century Europe who embraced using weapons and
believed they could cause bloodshed due to human’s capacity to reason and their greed for
power. The king calls the Europeans “the most pernicious race of little odious vermin that nature
ever suffered to crawl upon the surface of the earth” (Swift, 121). Using the king as an
exemplary Swift denounces the European savagery through othering it and allowing it to be
condemned. The reader can experience their leaders being marginalized as the other and
recognized for their flaws.
In Chapter IV Gulliver encounters a species called Yahoos, which Gullivers describes as
“so disagreeable an Animal, nor one against which I naturally conceived so strong of Antipathy”
(Swift, 209). Immediately the Yahoo’s are set up as a separate identity to Gulliver, and he is in
extreme disgust of them. To the reader’s surprise, we are shown later that this species is fully
human, just lacking rational thought. The Yahoos are described as “the most filthy, noisome, and
deformed animals […] mischievous and malicious” (Swift, 253) even though they are physically
humans. Through these characters, Swift opposes the ideology of the Englightemt era that
humans are superior due to reason. These animals who the reader would deem as so different
from our rational minds are actually extremely similar to us. The Yahoos has the same
tendencies as us towards war, avarice, and selfishness. Gulliver says if they had the technology
to own advanced warfare, they would have used it to kill one another (Swift, 242). To be said,
even with the brilliance of advanced humans we still have the same inclinations as filthy,
noisome, and grunting Yahoos. Swift attempts to show the European readers that their view of
superiority is flawed and that even though we are intelligent and rational beings we are no better
than the non-rational Yahoos. He wanted to firmly establish that our ability to reason does not
make us the superior being, and we are not as unlike non- rational beings as the views of that
time.
The age of reason posed many new ideologies for the Europeans of the 17th and 18th
century. The thoughts that humans were the superior being due to our capacity to reason was one
of the main focuses of the Enlightenment era. In looking at the scatological humour in Lilliput,
the relationship between Gulliver and The Brobdingnagian king, and the connections between
Yahoos and humans, we can see how Swift degrades these European's views of superiority.
Works Cited
Swift, Johnathan. ​Gulliver’s Travels​. Oxford University Press, 2005.
Swift, Johnathan. Miscellanies in Prose, 1738.

RELATED

critical reflection of a personal academic journey using the MBTI - University of Gloucestershire - Essay

3345 words - 14 pages Toni-Marie Marsh S1403477 Critically reflect upon your current personal academic journey in the context of educational theory. This essay reflects on my personal learning experiences and how the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) has enabled me to gain a better understanding of my past experiences, and how I can better my future experiences. My targeted area for learning that I need to improve on is procrastination. My choice for this is because

Purpose Of Mandatory Minimum Sentences - University of Guelph Humber - Essay

1626 words - 7 pages The Good, The Bad, It’s Purpose on Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Aaron MacKinnon 1060928 Since it's existence, has taken place a controversial disagreement about the effectiveness of mandatory minimum sentencing (MMS) in its ability to reduce recidivism and regulate deterrence of criminal acts that carry mandatory minimum sentences (MMSs). To understand the effectiveness of MMS in the system of rehabilitation one must understand its purpose in

Religious Satire in It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - University of Arizona Religion in Popular culture - Religion in Pop culture

1459 words - 6 pages there be a firmament in the midst of the waters, and let it divide the waters from the waters. And God made the firmament and divided the waters which were under the firmament from the waters which were above the firmament.”. He sums this verse up as badass water. He then skips to day four when God made the stars. Mac even tries to convince the group by using fear tactics. This use of satire, a person attempting to enlighten his friends by using

Discuss and analyse the importance of responsible business management using the academic literature and company examples to illustrate and support your arguments. - University of Kent - Essay

2410 words - 10 pages Alejandro Colmenares CB311 2017-2018 Discuss and analyse the importance of responsible business management using the academic literature and company examples to illustrate and support your arguments. Table of Contents: Introduction: 1 Body: 2 Conclusion: 4 Bibliography: 5 Introduction: Responsible business management according to Gildas Yombi an African social enterprise leader ‘means acting socially and thinking economically’ (Wegner 2017). I

Essay on how The Bicycle Thief differs from The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari using classical film’s expressionistic and realistic theories as a basis of argument

2205 words - 9 pages 1.INTRODUCTION Pieter Fourie (2011) defines theory as an activity that is not only intellectual but also critical, dealing with unfamiliar questions about the nature of the film as a phenomenon. Classical film however, deals with how film represents reality and whether the representation should be realistic or expressionistic. This essay is going to explain how The Bicycle Thief (1948), differs from The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920) using

Politics of Performance of Black Authenticity - Brandeis University - Essay

1529 words - 7 pages citizenship, English tongue, and lighter skin while contending with a context of disenfranchisement and violence native to American black cis womanhood. In doing so I am asked, both verbally and nonverbally: what business does a person like me have moving between borders? In these ways, travel is always political. This essay is concerned specifically with traveling experiences I’ve had in airports. From the ticket booth to security checkpoint, it

Mathematics Essay 1 Assessment 1 - Swinburne University of Technology - Essay

1123 words - 5 pages Assessment 1: Essay Unit Code: EDU10003 The World of Maths Students Name: Cindy Nguyen Student Number: 100571470 The use of mathematics and numeracy has a become an important aspect in our world. The use of both mathematics and numeracy has become one of the most important aspect in our daily lives. Many individuals in the world assume that they’re both the same but, in fact they are two different concepts that have different roles to play in

Analysis of Unwind Using Setting Conflict and Character - English - Essay

1610 words - 7 pages Khan 1 Daanish Khan Mrs. Marhsall ENG 2DG – 80 March 12, 2017 Desperate Situations Call for Desperate Measures What would one do to get out of a sticky situation? Would one stick to ethics and morals, or sacrifice anything to get what they want? Some might say one would stay true to their morals, but be selfish and self-centered when such a situation arose. We do not know what one would do to save themselves in a potentially fatal situation, or

Sequence Analysis - Sunset Boulevard - University of Tampa - Essay

1000 words - 4 pages -destruction is built on this very theme, and her fans forsaking her is what eventually leads to her expiration. This ending sequence is a perfect example of the scathing satire that Billy Wilder set out to create. Using varied cinematographic techniques, Wilder successfully displays the tragic downfall of the antagonist as she makes her exit and leaves the frame. Works Cited Wilder, Billy, director. Sunset Boulevard.

Journey of life- Life through University - Inside Westminster - Essay

800 words - 4 pages OUR JOURNEY University so far has been quite an extraordinary experience, three weeks in and you have lecturers who guide you, listen to you but especially build a relationship with you to get you to where you want to be in life. It’s more than just a collection of buildings and classrooms, it is a culturally rich society, where teachers, students and admins work together. Many students find difficulty to adapt to the university atmosphere, but

virtue ethics in jouralism question - philosophy, university of warwick - essay

1876 words - 8 pages is not surprised that journalists hack people’s phone to get information for new stories in recent years, when such kind of bad news come out, there is a moral argument within this behavior. In this essay, I will argue that virtue ethics theory requires agent-based theorist and target-centered theorist answer to the question and that strongly and logically prove that it is morally wrong for journalist to hack people’s phones in order to get

Social Media and the Healthcare Industry - University of Nottingham - Essay

3009 words - 13 pages essay will focus on the healthcare industry, exploring how this technological trend is able to drastically affect the present and future of medical services and pharmaceuticals. While social media has created many opportunities for the healthcare industry, it also has its drawbacks that need to be considered. This essay will first highlight the opportunities it provides, covering four of five social media use types as identified by Schlagwein and

Interpretation of Kafka's Metamorphosis. - Modern Fiction, Rhodes University - Essay

2082 words - 9 pages this essay is to explore which aspects of this story produce diverse interpretations. The interpretations which are brought to the fore are those of a modernist, post-modernist, magic realist and biographical approach; the latter two are discussed in tandem. To explore this question references to Metamorphosis made are based on the version translated by Joachim Neugroschel. Although Kafka died before the widespread use of the concept of

Analysis of Ouyang Xiu's Essay on Fundamentals - University of Georgia Hist 3662 - Essay

1207 words - 5 pages 4 Jonathan Book 9/6/2018 HIST 3662 First Essay Trunk Before the Branches Through the use of natural, architectural, and medical metaphors Ouyang Xiu, in his “Essay on Fundamentals,” confronts the issues of lackluster policy and institutions in the Song and the ever-present threat, which he argues, Buddhism poses to the moral fortitude of the citizens in the Song Empire. Ouyang compares empires to trees needing a strong foundation, dynasties to

the murder of Roger Ackroyed and how it threatens masculinity - university of strathclyde - Essay

3142 words - 13 pages of crime’ or the ‘Quarter of muses’. Also, where Ronald Knox wrote a set of rules ‘detective decalogue’. Thus, detective fiction can be seen as a competitive field (Munt,2004). Comment by stewart smith: Sentence structure Comment by stewart smith: Grammar: no subject. ‘It was also where Ronald…’ Comment by stewart smith: What relevance does this have to the essay question? The whodunit has been used in the inter-war-period and has received