Utilitarianism And Its Inherent Flaws Phil 102 Assignment

1073 words - 5 pages

Celyn Flint
Dr. Jonathan Strand
Phil 102A
Nov 22nd, 2018
Utilitarianism and its Inherent Flaws
In this essay, I will argue the weaknesses of Classical Utilitarianism as a whole. In order to argue against Utilitarianism, one must first understand what that means exactly. To break it down into simple terms, Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory of ethics. This means that what determines an actions moral value is the consequence of the action rather than what motivated the action, or even the action itself. To further elaborate on this idea of consequentialism, Utilitarianism deciphers the moral value of an action's outcome based on how much ‘happiness' or ‘pleasure' it adds to the world. In essence, an action is morally right or wrong based on the extent to which it makes people feel good or feel bad. As well as being a consequentialist theory, Utilitarianism is also an egalitarian view. It is egalitarian in the fact that everyone's happiness or unhappiness is viewed equally. To do this, Utilitarians calculate the overall happiness level an action's outcome will be with the principle of utility. The happiness is added up, and then the unhappiness is subtracted, and whichever action will generate the most happiness or generate the least unhappiness is the action one ought to do. The three main objections to this ethical theory are the unforeseen consequences objection, the absurd consequences objection, and the justice objection
The first objection to Utilitarianism is the unforeseen consequences objection. The issue people who object in this manner have with Utilitarianism is that the ethical theory focuses on the outcome of an action to decide its moral value rather than the intent of the action. Why this approach to ethics is problematic is the fact that surely an action can be right, even if it has unforeseen bad consequences and vice versa. If one were to take this theory seriously, the only way one could decide if something was morally correct would be after the fact. In being a consequentialist theory of ethics, this theory does not offer any room for intent in calculating an action's ethical value. This means that for example, if someone were to send their friend's sick mother a bouquet of roses and well wishes to get better, without knowing their friend's mother is allergic to roses and due to this she got a rash, the Utilitarian would say that this action was immoral due to the outcome rather than the intent. It seems to clash with one’s intuitive response that this action was moral due to its intent. This view is troubling as no matter a person’s intent; if unforeseen consequences arise their moral character could be under scrutiny.
Another objection against Utilitarianism is the objection of absurd consequences. Due to its calculatory nature, issues can arise when one has to decide what action one ought to do if both options offer the same results. For example, if one was given a situation where one could either lie or tell the...

Other Essays On Utilitarianism and its Inherent Flaws - Phil 102 - assignment

Construction Productivity and its improvement - University of Florida/ BCN5470 - Assignment

560 words - 3 pages BCN5470- Construction Methods Improvement Assignment Module-1 Q.1- 1. • 2007-2008 Wage- $16/hr Number of bricks placed/day- 240 Cost per brick = $0.54 • 2008-2009 Wage- $16.96/hr Number of bricks placed/day- 242.4 = 242 bricks Cost per brick = $0.56 • 2009-2010 Wage- $17.97/hr Number of bricks placed/day- 244.8 = 245 bricks Cost per brick = $0.59 • 2010-2011 Wage- $19.05/hr Number of bricks placed/day- 247.24 = 247

Corporation Law and its impact on firms - Monash university - Assignment

992 words - 4 pages Exam Revision – Corporation Law [4.01] Through section 124(1) of the Corporations Act 2001, upon the date of registration, a company has the full legal capacity of a natural person where the identity of the company is separate to its shareholders, directors and agents. Thus, a company can sue and be sued. Furthermore, as a company has a separate legal entity, the liability of the shareholders, directors and agents of the company is limited. The

auteur theory and its argument - Ashford University ENG225 Introduction to Film - assignment

428 words - 2 pages New York. How the auteur theory influences audiences and critics, using examples from film criticism, film marketing campaigns, and your own personal experience. The reputation of auteur theory in film analysis and interpretation can influence audiences and critics. According to Goodykoontz, & Jacobs, (2014), The auteur theory is still a generally accepted way of critiquing films. The way a film is generally critiqued is by its technical competence

Essay on the will of the painter Angelos Akotantos and its strengths as evidence - Arts and Humanities - Assignment

1168 words - 5 pages Read carefully ‘The will of the painter Angelos Akotantos’ (Anthology, 2.5.1, pp. 225–8). What information does the source provide for the fifteenth-century artist? What are its strengths and its limitations as evidence about his everyday life and work? Angelos Akotantos has provided us with a brief insight into his world in fifteenth century Candia, the most noticeable trend that can be picked up on is his deep religious beliefs. Angelos begins

keeping a note its an ap english assignment and book that helps the mind grow - AP English - English

3727 words - 15 pages grammar—I mean it literally. The scene that you see in your mind finds its own structure; the structure dictates the arrangement of the words. . . . All the writer has to do really is to find the words.” However, she warns, “You have to be alone to do this.” “‘That woman Estelle,’” the note reads, “‘is partly the reason why George Sharp and I are separated today.’ Dirty crepe-de-Chine wrapper, hotel bar, Wilmington RR, 9:45 a.m. August Monday morning

its lowkey a game im not sure what game but i need access and im not paying - emerson and english - assignment

1795 words - 8 pages #: ____________________________________ 2705 E 17TH ST • Ammon, ID 83406 • 208.346.7500 • fax 208.346.7501 Sliding Scale Plan: Page 2 *If you are without insurance, you may opt to see an Intern (based on availability) or apply for our sliding scale program. To apply for the Sliding Scale Plan please complete the Sliding Scale Application, print and sign and attach any of the following financial documents to the application. * 1. Last current tax filing information (First

professional ethics case 2 study assignment 1 - University of Waterloo, PHIL333 - assignment

1100 words - 5 pages 3 NORMATIVE ETHICAL THEORIES PHIL 333, Assignment 1 Case 2.2 One main issue question pertaining to professional ethics stands out in this case: Was the doctor justified in trying an experimental treatment on Ms. Kay’s dog Sandy even though she had decided against it and asked that the dog be euthanized? In analyzing this case and the ethical issue presented, I would use two normative ethical theories – Rule utilitarianism and Kantian

‘The ends always justify the means’. Do they? Discuss in contrast to utilitarianism - Open Uni - Essay

1612 words - 7 pages also critically appraising the theory. I will discuss the many flaws associated with this moral theory, which make it difficult to justify the mantra that ‘the ends always justify the means’, which I think neither Bentham or Mills versions can justify it. Jeremy Bentham is thought to have been the founder of utilitarianism as a theory, specifically that of ‘act’ utilitarianism, which is its simplest form. Act utilitarians believe that whenever

Marketing – The Ethics of Emotion from a Can - Thompson Rivers University - BUSN 6011 - Assignment

1747 words - 7 pages involves deceiving the consumer. Consequentialist Theory - Utilitarianism The foundation of utilitarianism is the ‘greatest happiness principle’. Its core idea is that whether actions are morally right or wrong depends on their effects. More specifically, the only effects of actions that are relevant are the good and bad results that they produce. The moral standard on which utilitarianism is founded, is that moral agents encourages actions that

Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas - St ambrose college, 6fr - Essay

1523 words - 7 pages purely ‘right’ or ‘good’ based on the fact that it produces pleasure – other principles need to be considered. For Mill, the real moral approach involves the pursuit of these ‘higher’ mental goods: mental, cultural and spiritual. However, Mill’s utilitarianism has its weaknesses. Firstly, people do not always strive for higher pleasures. This is because lower pleasures in many cases are more satisfactory and require little investment. The

Utilitarianism and Capital Punishment - Study of Religion - Essay

1222 words - 5 pages UTILITARIANISM AND CAPITAL PUNISHMENT CARMEN LEE It is not unusual for a politician to say that a piece of legislation was passed due to the fact that it did the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Perhaps you have heard someone justify their actions with the reasoning that it was “for the greater good.” This makes us wonder, what is the criteria for what makes a policy or action morally right? For many, personal morals and ethics

Similar Papers

The Death Penalty And Its Flaws University Of Texas Essay

1554 words - 7 pages Majok| 2 Garang Majok Phil West WRC 1023 02 November, 2018 Capital punishment is a widely accepted belief that legally authorizes killing of someone as punishment for a crime. “At year-end 2016, a total of 32 states and the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) held 2,814 prisoners under sentence of death”( Capital Punishment in the United States). Although only 36 of those prisoners were actually executed the long process and the feelings associated

Justice And Its Implication On South Africa's Education System University Assignment Paper

2629 words - 11 pages to education and how they can help our society. Thirdly we must be able to identify the flaws and inequalities in our education system and how we able to use our theorist ideas to combat these inequalities. Fourthly we will need to conclude on how all these ideas and concepts can help us to better our society and our education system. Justice can be described as “the moral principle determining just conduct” in the context of the assignment

Sia Structure And Its Nature Of Business Kfd 1 A Assignment

2231 words - 9 pages 1. Organization Purpose Singapore Airlines is the world’s most awarded airline, it is also a top-class airline throughout the world. Since 2000 SIA has been named the best airline by numerous magazine and agencies. In Business Traveller USA 2017, it is named the Best Overall Airline in the World for the 27th time, it shows the commitment that SIA commits itself to its service and quality. SIA visions itself to be an excellent company and an

Constitutional Law The Uk And Its Constitution Law Assignment

3275 words - 14 pages Law 1017M Constitutional and Administrative Law 1596860 Word Count: 2440 James Bryce proposed that, “[c]onstitutions are the expression of national character”.[footnoteRef:1] This raises the question as to why the United Kingdom (UK) is yet to produce a written and codified constitution? This essay shall substantiate its argument surrounding four points, including; the development of the constitution in the UK, parliamentary supremacy and the