Was Rockefeller A Robber Baron Or A Captain Of Industry? History Paper

1568 words - 7 pages

Remi Kauderer
Honors History Seminar
Rockefeller: The Wrongfully Accused Robber Baron
For decades, many have argued whether John D. Rockefeller was a robber baron or simply a captain of industry. Matthew Josephson argues that Rockefeller is a robber baron because he became successful through deception, bribery and illegal manners that enabled him to obtain control over the entire oil business. Ron Chernow, on the other hand, argues that Rockefeller is wrongfully accused of being a robber baron because many of the allegations made against him were false. Chernow’s argument is correct. Although he used certain robber baron tactics to achieve success, Rockefeller is wrongfully included in the group of robber barons because many of the accusations against him ignored contrary facts. Moreover, Rockefeller’s philanthropy helps to remove him from the ranks of the robber barons. Comment by Shawn Clybor: Not an inspiring introduction. Try to think of an interesting story or example that somehow connects to the bigger picture that you will be discussing. Also, an introduction should be setting up the topic at hand. You should be discussing the late 19th century in the US, or industrialization, or some other larger issue. Comment by Shawn Clybor: Not entirely. Some may have been false, some he argues simply neglect to acknowledge that he did not act much differently than anyone else, given the chance. That’s different than just saying the charges are “false.” Comment by Shawn Clybor: I’m not entirely sure how this, as an argument really ties into the topics that were discussed in the articles. I think your argument should deal with the issues at hand more.
Before discussing whether Rockefeller was a robber baron, the term robber baron needs to be understood. A robber baron has been defined as, “an American capitalist at the turn of the 19th century who enriched himself upon the sweat of others, exploited natural resources, or possessed unfair government influence.”[footnoteRef:1] Another definition of a robber baron can be found in Merriam Webster, which defines the terms as, “a business owner or executive who acquires wealth through ethically questionable tactics.”[footnoteRef:2] Under the first definition, Rockefeller is generally considered a robber baron because of stories that claim he advanced his own fortunes at the expense of others and because his company, Standard Oil, exploited natural resources. Rockefeller’s alleged exploitation of others is widely considered unethical. Comment by Shawn Clybor: Never state: “According to dictionary X.” It looks bad. Just define a term and then footnote the source. Comment by Shawn Clybor: I would have liked to see specific evidence to back this claim. I cannot just take you on your word that this is true. [1: “The New Tycoons: John D. Rockefeller.” Ushistory.org, Independence Hall Association, www.ushistory.org/us/36b.asp.] [2: “Robber Baron.” Merriam-Webster, Merriam-Webst...


How was the Industrial Revolution a big part of History?

505 words - 3 pages The Industrial Revolution was a large part of history. During this period there were some important figures that made the Industry just a little bit easier in Britain. Three of the many major figures were Thomas Newcomen, James Watts, and James Hargreaves.Coal mining was a major industry during the Industrial Revolution. There were some technical problems of coal mining. One of the most difficult mining problems was water. The deeper the workers

Was Antigone A Strong Woman Or A Brat??

501 words - 3 pages defy Creon’s order and bury Polynices, her brother who died in a battle against Eteocles, for power in Thebes. Ismene tries to dissuade Antigone from her act of rebellion. I personally see Ismene as Antigone’s foil in this play.Antigone was not intimidated by her sister or her uncle Creon. She was determined to bury her brother and she would do whatever she had to in order to achieve her goal. She was determined to bury Polynices no

Antibiotics: A History of Common Antibiotics - Biology 101 - Research Paper

3017 words - 13 pages medication when they are sick. Antibiotics are a form of medication and work really good. Therefore, I should take some antibiotic.” Of course this logic is very flawed but at the time my 11 year-old brain thought it was pretty reasonable. I didn’t really know that antibiotics only work on bacterial infections. A big problem with antibiotics is that overusing them leads to something called antibiotic resistance, bacterial resistance, or

how stalingrad was a major turning point of ww2 - judd school - research paper

731 words - 3 pages Battle of Stalingrad The Battle of Stalingrad was a key turning point in WW2 if not the most important. Germany and Russia (U.S.S.R) fought each other and it lasted around 8-9 months . The nazis were trying to capture the Russian city of Stalingrad while the opposition fought them off. The battle of Stalingrad is most well known for having so many casualties both army and civilian. Hitler had taken over most of Europe and wanted to continue his

Racial Profiling in America: A Thing of the Past or Not? Research Paper

1324 words - 6 pages day times we are faced with new levels of racial profiling. In 2012, Trayvon Martin was shot and killed unjustly. While walking home from the store he was approached by neighborhood watch captain, George Zimmerman. Although the story is told a few different ways, Zimmerman was instructed to not follow Trayvon and he ignored the 9-1-1 dispatchers’ orders. Zimmerman approached Trayvon causing there to be a confrontation and that confrontation

Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power was a legal process - Modern history yr 11 KCAHS - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages Free Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1934 was a ‘legal process’. (10 Marks) The period between January 1933 and August 1943 was a key period for Hitler and the Nazi party to consolidate power in the form of a dictatorship. Hitler’s change of strategy to gain power legally was an effective process as he created a legal image in the eyes of the public. For example the appearance of legality was

A Look back in time, over the course of a 100 years - History - Research Paper

908 words - 4 pages challenges throughout her lifetime that will impact history for years to come. Historical Context Anne Hutchinson was born in Lincolnshire, England during 1591 to her mother and father who were both seen as important figures in the town. Her mother was a midwife and her father a clergyman, teaching Puritan practices. The Protestant Anglican Church of England forced citizens to practice the Protestant religion due to the king’s favor of this religion

A short history of bread growth in American history. - class - Research Paper

5741 words - 23 pages (leaven) and mixing it with a new dough. The Egyptians would leave them for awhile to ferment for a couple hours and then bake it. They were known for creating “50 varieties of bread, paid wages with bread, and painted breadmaking scenes in their tombs”, (BIRT 2018). Leaven is something that is placed in bread dough and allows the bread to rise. Leaven can be yeast, baking powder, beer, or etc. Bread was often used as a way to pay wages, mostly

A History Of The Beatles

2530 words - 11 pages , their first U.S. LP. During the second half of 1963 it was the only Beatles material available in America, and sold incredibly well; by 1964 a court awarded the rights to all Beatles recordings to EMI/Capitol, and the record went out of print, only to become one of the most counterfeited albums in music history. In January of 1964 Capitol released their first U.S. Beatles LP, Meet the Beatles, containing remixed material from their two British

A Brief History Of Time

446 words - 2 pages Uncertainty Principle", and " The Arrow of Time".In " Space and Time" Hawking discusses the history of ideas about cosmology and how our present day understanding of the universe has developed. It dates back to Galileo and Newton. Before them people believed Aristotle, who said that the physical state of a body was to be at rest and that it moved only if motivated by a energy or desire. Aristotle says that a heavy ball would fall

A brief history of computer

325 words - 2 pages The first all-electronic compute, based on vacuum tubes, was developed in 1946 by J. Presper Eckert and John W. Mauchly of the University of Pennsylvania. Atahis computer could make calculation a thousand times faster than earlier devices." The Macintosh must be running system software version 7.5 or higher and be equipped with a drive that supports Apple PC Exchange.1 Save your Windows file to a 3.5-inch floppy disk or a CD-ROM.2 Insert the

’The crisis of the Byzantine Empire was the main reason for the First Crusade’ - DHSB - A-Level History Essay (The Crusades)

738 words - 3 pages Q) ’The crisis of the Byzantine Empire was the main reason for the First Crusade’ Explain why you agree or disagree with this view. The first Crusade was the first of the many Christian expeditions to the East in order to regain land from the Muslims and create states of their own. The crusade began with the letter from the Byzantine Emperor (Alexius Comnenus) in early 1095 and ended with the capture of Jerusalem from the Muslims in 1098/9

How stable was Russia from 1905 to 1914 - A level History - Essay

529 words - 3 pages Free Mohamedamiin Sharif 12S How stable was Russia in the period from the October Manifesto (1905) to the outbreak of war (1914) From the introduction of the October Manifesto in 1906 to the outbreak of war in 1914,the tsar’s position and Russia as a whole was stable to a large extent.However, there were a few occasions where instability rose, and whether Russia was stable or on the brink of a revolution will all be explored in this essay. One

how far was the legue a complete failure? - Hartlepool Sixth Form College History - Essay

1480 words - 6 pages Free Courtney Fishwick Media Histories How far was the League a complete failure? There were both successes and failures of the league. The Corfu incident of 1923 was a huge failure and demonstrated the weakness of the league. There was an incident at the Greek Albanian border where an Italian General, Tellini and his team were ambushed and killed. The league made a decision that compensation would be paid to the league and when the people

Was the American Revolution a Conservative Movement? - COC and history - essay

710 words - 3 pages Form YS-1 Effective 8/30/2017 LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION FOR ADMISSION OF STUDENTS IN GRADES K-12 ADMISSION: Colleges in the Los Angeles Community College District (“LACCD”) may admit as a special part-time or full-time student anyone who is a student in grades K-12 who has met the LACCD’s admissions requirements and who, in the opinion of the College President (or designee), may benefit from instruction