What Constitutes Non Combatant Immunity War And Morality Essay

1391 words - 6 pages

A Just war according to Just war theory is one that is morally justifiable; it also seeks to protect fundamental human rights. Among the various moral constraints on the conduct of war, the principle of non-combatant immunity is historically one of the most dignified. This principle aims to protect all non-combatants against intentional attacks. Although it is undoubtedly a ruling principle in warfare, the principle has sparked debates due to a lack of agreement on what constitutes its underlying basis. In this essay, I will compare theories by Nagel and Walzer of what purports non-combatant immunity. I will start by defining the principle and explaining each philosopher’s theory for its basis. Some noble points to compare include the base assumptions, restrictions and how the consequence of the restrictions ground the principle of non-combatant immunity.
Non-combatant immunity
Non-combatant immunity is a principle that issues the protection of non-combatants against attacks in war. Adhering to this principle requires that belligerents discern between combatants and non-combatants and only target the former, although this can be difficult to implement in practice (Lazar, p.3 ).
Non-combatant status
To conduct a Just war, discrimination on behalf of the warring parties is necessary because the innocent are not liable to attack. The status of innocent, according to Nagel refers to persons who are “currently harmless,” meaning they do not pose an immediate threat to anyone (Nagel, p.139). Civilians, prisoners of war and medical personnel are included in this in this view. Like Nagel, Walzer defines the innocent as a class or persons who are not direct threats and those who have not forfeited their right to immunity (Lazar, p.2 ).
Nagel derives the principle of non-combatant immunity from an absolutist approach. He builds his theory from the assumption that the restrictions and rules of warfare are not arbitrarily established but have a moral basis (Nagel, p.123). Recognizing the validity and of analyzing the consequences of military strategies, he argues for a qualified absolutist view of the foundation underlying the principle of non-combatant immunity. The absolutist stance is one that claims that no justification can be offered to excuse an act that is not permissible and therefore prohibited . Within that ambit is the act of deliberately killing the innocent (Nagel, p.126). The absolutist argument for non- combatant immunity can be constructed as follows.
1. Intentionally killing innocent people is murder which is prima facie wrong
2. There is an absolute prohibition on murder
3. Non-combatants are innocent
4. There is an absolute prohibition on targeting non-combatants.
The necessity argument
Walzer argues that the basis for non-combatant immunity stems from the assumption that necessity drives war conduct (Lazar, p.1 ). He defines necessity as anything that increase the chances of victory while reducing ...


Morality and Survival The Road Essay - English - Essay

1075 words - 5 pages Kho 1 Trisha Mae Kho Ms. Cecchetto ENG4U1 29 April 2019 Morality and Survival in Cormac McCarthy’s The Road Imagine a devastating and dreary world that deteriorated with scarce supplies of food and shelter and there are only a few survivors left including yourself and one of your family members. In hopes of survival, what measures would you take? Would you go to the extreme by cannibalism or committing suicide? On the other hand, would you

What is a price war? - High School Essay

2023 words - 9 pages players will merchants will follow suit if they can. At some point, merchants find that they cannot gain profit if they cut the price further— so the sticky price remains. How to Fight a Price War In the battle to capture the customer, companies use a wide range of tactics to ward off competitors. Increasingly, price is the weapon of choice—and frequently the skirmishing degenerates into a price war. Creating low-price appeal is often the goal, but the

A feminist perspective about what constitutes being a woman - GWST 4113 - essay

632 words - 3 pages Free Breann Barfield GWST 4113 Paper 2 “What is a woman?” Many feminist scholars have theorized about gender and what defines a woman. Views vary from biological standpoints to socially constructed norms, to oppression and more. Irigaray argues that women do not exist and that ‘woman’ is based on unique attributes that separate them from men that should be acknowledged and celebrated. Wittig differs in her claim in that she views the term ‘woman

Essay describing the benefits of Organic foods and the cons of non-organic - FYP- Health - Research paper

1693 words - 7 pages Organic vs. Inorganic Meats Life is based on decisions. You wake up and decide what to wear, what to eat, and decide how to get to work. While choosing your next meal at a grocery store, ask yourself this question; are you more likely to buy organic or inorganic meat? Some may think this is a scam, that food industries reel you into for a couple of extra dollars. Does one really know about the backstory of these organic or nonorganic animals

what were the long term international effects of the Vietnam war? - history - essay

4401 words - 18 pages What were the long-term international effects of the Vietnam War? Analyse with respect to America’s experience. This essay explores the long-term impact of the Vietnam War (1955-75) on America’s role in the international system. This 20-year conflict had a catastrophic total death toll of over two million and caused the deaths of 58,000 American soldiers, with 150,000 wounded and many more psychologically harmed; it toppled a president, altered

DBQ essay on french and indian war - APUSH - DBQ essay

1027 words - 5 pages DBQ Essay The final colonial war also known as the French and Indian War lasted from 1754-1763, where conflicts were attempted to be put to an end between the Indians and English, but created conflicts between the English and colonists. The French and Indian war created new economic and political situations on Colonists through England's new found debt with imposition of tax after the war, and England’s political restrictions through laws passed

The Tsar and the First World War - Year 12 - Essay

1195 words - 5 pages . According to Corrin and Fiehn, “During the war the Tsar had the chance to make some concessions to political reform that might have saved him”- meaning the war might not have been his death sentence after all. In light of the role the Tsar’s power played in his own downfall, the view that “what made that kind of revolution possible was the protracted, disruptive, exhausting conflict of the First World War” seems weaker. The people had already begun to

Remains and war photographer comparison - Year 9 - Essay

1224 words - 5 pages Free range of techniques to explore the idea of conflict and its evil nature. As said before, metaphors are used like ‘half formed ghost’ to portray the photograph that he took was of a dying man and to get the reader to understand the severity of war and the lives cost in it. The overall point of this poem is to convey the cruelty of war and what it accomplishes. The poet expresses the dilemma faced by the photographer in these circumstances through

Economics, Manhood, Sex, and War - HUIS 501 - Research Essay

4790 words - 20 pages against African Americans across America. Even some northern men would feel hate because of the human cost of the Civil War. It was easier to take it out on what they felt was the cause of so much death and destruction. White men coming home to mulatto babies, wives with black lovers, any number of sexually charged substantiation to support this as a primary cause. The holes in this theory are the lack of academic inquiry of the causation of racial

Conflict Essay - To Kill a Mockingbird and Prelude to War - Magdalene, year 11 - Essay

855 words - 4 pages Conflict Essay “An individual’s perception of conflict is intrinsically linked to their core values and beliefs!”  To what extent is this view represented in the texts studied? Refer to To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and one related text. Through an individual’s perspective and central principles, it is an essential component for the insight of conflict. This is extensively engrained in the texts To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and

What motivates and sustains terrorist movements - Politics - Essay

1536 words - 7 pages Free What motivates and sustains terrorist movements Word count: 1086 Gus Martin defines terrorism as ‘the unlawful use of, or threatened use, of force or violence against individual or property to coerce and intimidate governments or societies, often to achieve political, religious or ideological objectives’ (2008, P.8). However, there is a great obstacle in allocating a universal definition of terrorism as the motivations differ so broadly from

What is qualitative and quantitative research approaches? - Denver - Essay

3096 words - 13 pages quantitative research, this material builds directly on the epistemological foundations presented in the package `What is Research?' For example, in exploring the distinctions between qualitative and quantitative forms of research we need to consider the different ontological and epistemological questions we considered when discussing positivism, interpretivism and critical paradigms. Thus, on first consideration, the use of questionnaires as a research

Essay on the morality of capital punishment and why it is wrong - English 10 honors - Essay

822 words - 4 pages from someone. KIlling has been seen as wrong throughout the ages, throughout many major religions, and throughout society today. Yet the death penalty is used, a punishment that promotes murder. If we truly think that murder is wrong then we can not make any excuses for killing someone regardless of what they did. Life is either sacred or it's not. If we want life to be sacred then capital punishment can no longer be legal. A common defense of

Reason why the United State get involved in Korea and Vietnam War - U.HISTORY 2 - ESSAY

787 words - 4 pages region, and their provision of economic and military aid to South Korea and Vietnam. There were however, other reason for the U.S involvement such as their military confidence. The Korean war was a war between South (Non Communist) and North (Communist) Korea. It started when the leader of North Korea, Kim II Sung, invaded South Korea to unite North and South into a fully Communist Korea. U.S involved in the war because they saw Communism as a

The Major Cause of the Second World War and the Rise of Nazism - History - Essay

3240 words - 13 pages and came to be. I also was able to find components in the book regarding information on Germany’s reaction and effect from the treaty which was essential in my essay. Strachan, Hew. ​The First World War: A New Illustrated History​. London: Simon & Schuster, 2003. The First World War is a well written secondary source other than text consisting of illustrations, maps and photos of the first world war. This source is packed with information on the