This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Did Marx Mean By The Statement That 'capital Is Not A Thing, But A Social Relation Between Persons'?

2416 words - 10 pages

The idea of capital as a social relation can be seen to symbolize the relationship between those who own capital, and between those who must work in order to secure the income stream of capital - it is a relation of both property and power. Ideas of class conflict, alienation and exploitation are thus central to this approach. The aim of this essay is to explain the social relations of capital, and how these fit into the pattern of Marx's thought. I will conclude with an assessment of the relevance of these ideas today.Marx pointed out that 'capital is not a thing, but a social relation' in Capital (v1) and similarly argued in Labour and Capital that 'Capital is a social relation of ...view middle of the document...

As Marx points out, 'the means of production and subsistence, while they remain the property of the immediate producer, are not capital. They become capital only under circumstances in which they serve at the same time as means of exploitation and subjection of the laborer' (Capital V1).Thus we can see that the ownership of private property, and hence control of the means of production, that marks the nodal points in the series of relationships, which manifest the social relations of capital. The first condition of life for people who do not own capital is that they must sell their labour power in order to live. They must labour for the needs of the purchaser of their labour in order to secure the income stream for capital. Employers and workers are thus in one important sense dependent upon one another. The former need a labour force that will engage in economic production; the latter, since they are propyertyless, need the wages that employers pay them. But this dependence is strongly imbalanced in that workers have little or no formal control over type work they do while employers are able to generate profits which they appropriate for their own purposes.According to Marx, capitalism is intrinsically a class society; and the class relations upon which it is founded are intrinsically ones of conflict or struggle. Marx was not clear on what he meant by the term class, but it can be seen as a group of people who stand in a common relationship to the means of production. According to Marx 'The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles' (The Communist Manifesto 1848). Just as primitive agrarian society had yielded centuries before to feudal society, and in Europe feudalism given way to industrial capitalism, so too would capitalism be overthrown. In each of these kinds of societies, a minority of people own or control the means of production, such as land, raw materials, tools and machines, labour, and money. This minority constitutes the ruling class. The vast majority of people own and control very little. They mainly own their own capacity to work.Marx believed that class relations were becoming ever more simplified and held that 'Society as a whole is more and more splitting in to two great hostile caps, into two great classes directly facing each other: bourgeoisie and proletariat' (The Communist Manifesto 1848). The 'bourgeoisie' or capitalists thus controlled the means of production and is attached to private ownership of the means of production, and the 'proletariat', the working class, which arose from industrialization. Marx predicted that eventually the proletariat would overthrow the bourgeoisie and establish a classless society.The social relations can thus be seen to represent the struggle between the classes. The idea of class struggle was based on Hegel's dialectics. The term 'dialectics' often represents the view that conflict, antagonism or contradiction is a necessary condition for achieving...

Other Essays On What Did Marx Mean By The Statement That 'Capital Is Not A Thing, But A Social Relation Between Persons'?

What Is A A Brand ?

2319 words - 10 pages policy contradicts brand building. Companies that opt for a low price strategy will find that short-term volume gains will be at the expense of longer term profitability. Furthermore, not only will there be less funds available for investment but the brand will be devalued in the longer term. For a market leader this is especially so. Negative marketing will have an adverse impact on the brand.INNOVATION.Innovation is by far the most potent weapon

Is The Relationship Between Drugs And Crime A Causal One?

2322 words - 10 pages , that there is a reasonable overlap between the three models. The problem with these models or theories comes when trying to understand and prove them, especially when it comes to using crime statistics as evidence. Crime statistics are usually collected using three different methods - quantitative, qualitative and a mix of the two. When it comes to using data on crime, one must be careful to be analytical of the data as it is not always reliable

Much Ado About Nothing By Shakespeare Much Ado About Nothing Is Considered A Comedy, But The Decision By Claudio To Publicly Disgrace Hero Appears To Be Far From Humorous

674 words - 3 pages victory. This man is Claudio. Because of this Don John has a deep resentment for Claudio and seeks out to make him pay for his part in the war. His first plan backfires due to the fact that he did not think it out properly, but he then learns of the impending marriage of Hero and Claudio but struggles for a plan. It is his sidekick Borachio who then devises a plan to defame Hero by claiming that she had been deflowered before her marriage. He would go

What Is A Witch Hunt?

476 words - 2 pages A witch hunt is the searching out and persecution of supposed witches. It can also mean the harassment of those with unpopular beliefs. I am not sure what causes a witch hunt to occur. Some believe that people embark a witch hunt to find a scapegoat to their problems, others believe that it is just a mass hysteria that spreads like a disease. Anyone can be subject to a witch hunt. From people of a certain decent that others do not like to women

To What Extent Did Cromwell's Rise To Prominence By 1646 Depend On Personal And Social Ties?

840 words - 4 pages Cromwell's relations married into these families does not mean he held the same beliefs as them. Despite this and on the other hand, I agree that these personal links with other important figures in Parliament may have helped him to play more of a significant role in the politics of the Long Parliament by attending similar committees and meeting mutual members, but disagree the eventual status he gained was dependant upon it.Furthermore, the social ties

What Is A Juvenile Delequient

833 words - 4 pages things guaranteed with the birth of a child: they are to instill moral values in (into) the child, to teach tell the child it right from wrong; and to be responsible, at least financially, for everything involving the child until he is eighteen. What then, prevents (is holding the) modern society from holding the parents equally (just as) responsible for their children for a crime just as if the parent had did it? What then, prevents modern society

"The Metamorphosis" By Kafka As A Social Criticism

1343 words - 6 pages subconsciously thought he had control over them.He works at an intolerable job of hard work to support his family,and gets little respect for this. It shows what happens to himwhen he stops working for them, he transforms into a hugecockroach. He is rejected by his family, and he is not cared forproperly which results in his death. Following Gregors death is agleeful ending, which eventually implies that the cycle will berepeated, though this time

Is Everything Political?: Access the dangers and advantages of the statement that "everything is political"

484 words - 2 pages The statement that 'everything is political' has some very strong arguments on either side. Politics does in some way affect everything that happens to us in everyday life, things such as tax, laws and employment opportunity are some examples of what the government has some control over. It is argued that if the concept of politics is stretched too far it loses its meaning, for everything to be political our society would cease to be a

Nothing Is Permanent But Change. This Means That Life Is

751 words - 4 pages the baby in her arms, she looks angelic; yet she's standing there because of sin, and the child is the result of it. Furthermore, the fact that she has an affair also suggests that she once had an extremely passionate nature. But it is what happens after Hester's affair that makes her into the woman with whom the reader is familiar. Shamed and alienated from the rest of the community, she becomes unfilled and indifferent. "It was a sad

What Problems Did The Weimar Republic Face Between 1919 And 1923?

529 words - 3 pages Germany. The Spartakus were led by Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht. The leaders of the Spartakus received help from the Russian Basheuiks, the revolution that turned Russia in to a communist country. The Spartakus wanted to take over the capitalists so that the workers would not be exploited in factories. The Spartakus started their uprising in Berlin in January 1919. Friedrich Ebert saw his power under threat, and took action to stop the Spartakus

To What Extent Was The USA A Racist Society Between 1919 And 1941?

854 words - 4 pages is to retain its stability, it is necessary that properties continue to be occupied by the same social and racial classes." (Underwriting Manual, 1939)"The Great Depression was, of course, an economic disaster for most Americans, but black people suffered a disproportionate share of the burden."(McElvaine). During the Great Depression, and extending to the start of World War II, African Americans found themselves competing with white Americans

Similar Papers

What Are The Main Moral Quandaries In Relation To Moral Relativism? Especially Given Increasing Globalisation, Is Moral Relativism A Suitable Solution To Moral Conflicts Between Cultures?

2101 words - 9 pages to believe that normal is synonymous with moral, without giving us reason to draw this conclusion. Just because something is a normal occurrence does not mean that it is moral. For example, take the young boy who is brutally beaten by his father for mistakes he makes. This might happen to the boy throughout his entire child-hood and he may think it to be normal, but just because it happens and it's a "normal" occurrence, does not mean it's

Crime And Punishment "Is There Not Such A Thing As Crime?" Disdusses Crime And Punishment, By Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, By Toni Morrison, And Utopia, By Sir Thomas More

1221 words - 5 pages Part 2, Question 1 - Is there or is there not such a thing as crime?For this question, I have chosen to discuss the following three works of literature:Crime and Punishment, by Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, by Toni Morrison, and Utopia,by Sir Thomas More.To begin with an omniscient and philosophical frame of reference, crime is onlydefined as crime by the society defining it. When a mass of human beings coagulate to¬gether and form a civilized

Immigration Is Not A Positive Social Phenomenon

609 words - 3 pages considered negative, but there is stillsomething good that immigration brings. Take for example America .sometimes called a nation of immigrants. What would it be without thepeople who came from Europe five centuries ago who settled there, andbuilt and developed the country? Would the USA be the world-leadingNo. 1 authority without the number of foreigners who lived there andbrought huge benefits to the country, enriched it in the field of culture,education and science? Definitely not!When talking about immigration and problems connected with it,people should first realize its contribution to their country before theycondemn all immigrants.

"The Scarlet Letter" By Nathaniel Hawthorne How Hester Prynne Has Romantic Characteristics, But Is Inevitably Transcendental. This Essay Is Also Meant To Be A Short One Page Paper

370 words - 2 pages In society you can be seen as either obligated to it or as an individual separate from it. Hester Prynne is an individual that is separate from it (Puritan society). It is often argued that Hester is a romantic, but with evidence provided by the novel it is apparent that she is a transcendentalist. The romantic characteristics may apply to her at times, but her character in full is inevitably transcendental.If Hester is seen as romantic her