This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Is Socrates’ Argument That No Harm Can Come To A Good Man Thompson River University Phil 1110 Philosophy Paper

1524 words - 7 pages

[Type here]
4
Question: What is Socrates’ argument that no harm can come to a good man?” Do you agree?
“Yet the deeply exciting thing about human beings is that
when the individual is free he chooses as the good life the process of becoming.” ~ Carl Rogers
Socrates, according to his own logic, dispels the fear of death and harm as basis for his argument that, “I am certain that nothing can harm a good man either in life or after death” (pg. 9). Following his conviction Socrates informs his jurors that death cannot harm him based on three strong ideas. They include: death as nothing to feared, the telling silence of his conscience and the existence and eternal nature of the soul. This paper will provide examples of the aforementioned ideas and explain his meaning of “good” as in “good man” and “harm” within the context of Socrates time and his philosophies, and conclude with an opinion on the generalizability of his argument.
The first of Socrates ideas concerns death. Then, as now, death was something uncertain and to be feared. The prospect of pain and suffering, of annihilation and the loss of being alive and in the world, scares most people and to be afraid would certainly be a form of harm. Socrates dispels these fears by saying that death (for a good man) is naught but one of two things. Firstly, death is either a long period of “annihilation” (pg.8) much like a long, refreshing sleep without dreams, and what could one possibly fear from that? Or, he goes on to say that it is a “migration of the soul” (pg.9) from this world to the next. The next world will be a reward, a type of heaven in modern terms and that he for one, would be quite happy to spend eternity conversing with the like of Homer or Odysseus, and with perhaps a bit of glee, unjustly accused like himself (pg.9). It is quite clear that Socrates has no qualms about what will follow his death. He will either enjoy a long eternal sleep or long and satisfying conversations with old friends. He omitted the third possibility of going to Hades, since logically and in accordance with his firm belief in his own goodness, he would not find himself there anyway.
His second idea that we will examine is his absolute belief in the veracity of his personal daemon and that it never spoke up when it came time for him to decide whether or not to fight his charges. He says that his daemon would have opposed him if death was an evil (pg. 8). Socrates’ daemon, or “prophetic voice” (pg.8) as he called it would be what we refer to in today’s terms as his conscience. Socrates seems to have a remarkably developed conscience so much so that he would go into deep trances when he was communing with it. He explains that it would speak up even over “quite trivial things” (pg. 8) and so it most certainly would have held him back from going to death if it was not the right and moral thing to do. So convinced was he of the power of his conscience to guide him in doing the right thing, and despite the...

Other Essays On What is Socrates’ argument that no harm can come to a good man - Thompson River University PHIL-1110 - Philosophy Paper

Arguing a position- What it's like to be a man by Phil Christman - English 112 Writing and Research - Research paper

711 words - 3 pages What Is It Like to Be a Man? By: Phil Christman English: 112-806 12/7/2018 2 Vega Cordero What defines a man in the 21st century? How they are handling new expectations? Is it possible to bring up a healthy generation without a father figure? What it’s like to be a man: The Male role in Modern day society A few decades ago, men were providers and protectors; today, a lot of discussions are centered around gender equality, and nowadays women

“Discuss some of the ways that stressful experiences can be managed. - The Open University - Essay

2038 words - 9 pages .  These feelings, if not alleviated, could become problematic. It is thought that stress may be experienced in two separate ways.  Firstly, as a force acting upon the person, for example the stress of a job. Secondly, as a reaction to circumstances - a feeling of being stressed (The Open University, 2013b). p56 Both can affect our physical and mental health and also affect the way we behave. It is this link between stress and health that, although

Romeo and Juliet Essay on how they were so in love and that no one can interrupt their elationship. - Monsignor Paul Dwyer Catholic High School - Essay

908 words - 4 pages Jackson 1 Tuoyo Jackson Mrs. Prebble ENG1D1 November 24, 2016 Romeo and Juliet Essay Assignment “The fool doth think he is wise, but the wise man knows himself to be a fool.” “Love all, trust a few, do wrong to none.” In Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Romeo and Juliet are doomed as they had no way of preventing the inevitable due to the outside forces such as the secrecy, parental influence and the lack of responsibility of Friar Laurence and

What is Truth? A literature review - GMU PHIL 253 - Final Paper

1814 words - 8 pages Erika Dyer Professor Brandhorst PHIL 253-004 10 December 2017 Final Paper What is truth? Is truth merely a lie we all tell ourselves to agree upon? Is truth a singular type of story? Can it be multiple things? Perhaps it can be all of the above. Lispector’s The Passion According to G.H., O’Brien’s The Things They Carried, Nietzsche’s “On Truth and lies in an Extra-Moral Sense,” Cixous’ “The Laugh of the Medusa,” and Freud’s “Infantile Genital

This is a paper that tells what the American Dream is and how today's society have lost perspective - University of Toledo/Composition 1 - Essay

2273 words - 10 pages define ! Gabalac 7 our dreams for us. In the process, someone makes an extra buck but often are left dissatisfied. It becomes a vicious cycle of greed and want. Yet, the American Dream is as alive today as it was before the Constitution was signed, as long as each individual citizen is willing to consider, actively seek out and determine for themselves what gives life meaning. That is no simple task, and it is easy to let others tell us what we

Evil versus Good in "A Good Man is Hard to Find" - LSU 102 - Essay

1003 words - 5 pages encounter with the Misfit. The grandmother’s thoughts of only herself are shown when O’Connor says, “hoping she was injured so that Bailey’s wrath would not come down on her all at once” (419). These swayed personal morals cause the grandmother to use the term “good man” wrongfully. Red Sammy and even the Misfit are referred to as good men by the grandmother since they follow a part of her morals or values. These values of the grandmother are

Culture Shock Paper: a paper that defines culture shock and what it means to have culture shock - Troy University, Diversity - Essay

701 words - 3 pages 1 Culture Shock Sarah Bradley Troy University After being in the United States for a long time, or even for your entire life, adjusting to a new way of living can be quite difficult. This can be especially true if you are going to be living in this new place for an extended period of time like a college student studying abroad for a semester. If you have ever experienced culture shock, you’ll know it is quite interesting in how it manifests

A paper on free will and what it means to you - Philosophy - Research paper

1552 words - 7 pages both determinists and indeterminists are not compatible with free will so no matter the case made for determinism, it is not possible to have free will (Nahmias & Murray, 2011). Compatibilists offer a possible solution to the problem of compatibility between free will and determinism. What this approach suggests is that free will and determinism are compatible. Some compatibilists go as far as suggesting that determinism is necessary for there to be

Rene Descartes Philosophy Paper - UBC phil 100 - Essay

800 words - 4 pages Rene Descartes is known to be the father of philosophy and for his famous cogito argument. It is more than 350 years ago ever since Descartes presented this cogito argument. He contemplated on proofing of existence of Gods by distinguishing the mind and the body. He wanted to preserve the church doctrine at the same time encourage scientific matters. He used a strategy of the method of doubt which advocates that one has to start doubting

Flannery O'Connor A Good Man is Hard to Find - English 102 - Essay

2622 words - 11 pages shot, the grandma took it upon herself to act as a preacher in what she determined could be her last moments alive. What brought The Misfit pleasure was to kill, but upon killing the grandma he found that the moral code he had been abiding by no longer had the same meaning and it had just been glorified for the entirety of his life. Flannery’s definition of a good man seemed to be distorted in this story; the grandma identified with a dark

Source Summary A Good Man is Hard to Find - English 1302 - Source Summary

647 words - 3 pages in an efficient way to where it is not bombarding or overwhelming but still interests the reader (Mellard 640). Many writers do not think about the addition of imagery in their work and the ways it can enhance their writing (Mellard 640). Imagery is most definitely a factor of writing that should be included in literature more proficiently (Mellard 640). In the story, “A Good Man is Hard to Find,” O’Connor describes the situation they are in as

Similar Papers

Marketing – The Ethics Of Emotion From A Can Thompson Rivers University Busn 6011 Assignment

1747 words - 7 pages dramatic differences and that represents radical approaches to ethics. These are collectively known as relativistic normative ethical theories which shares a common doctrine – moral relativism [5]. Moral relativism is the philosophical position that there is no absolute or universal good or right and so there are no absolute or universal moral principles. From a moral relativism standpoint, the use of neuroscience-based marketing techniques, may

Argument Synthesis: Can Biased Media Be 'good'?

1642 words - 7 pages personal biases: such as which presidents he enjoyed working under, and his opinions on what journalism should be. However, he does agree that biased media in the public sphere cannot be good as it is inherently damaging to society. Moyers’ view of media is best stated by this quote he uses from journalist Martha Gellhorn: “ ‘journalism is a means… the act of keeping the record straight…’ ”. This philosophy of

The Essay Is A Opinionated Essay That Takes About How One Man Can Co Anderson Cvi Essay

880 words - 4 pages 1 Onabolu Elijah Onabolu Mrs. Bureau ENG 3U1 25 March 2019 The Charmer by Budge Wilson There is always that one person in the family who has a cause and an effect on the family’s dysfunction. The Charmer by Budge Wilson demonstrates the themes of manipulation. It illustrates how Zachery can manipulate any type of situation to whatever he desires. Interestingly, Zachary uses his charm and distinct features to disguise the pain he was experiencing

One Of The Cornerstones Of Marketing Theory Is The Notion That Marketers Can “Segment” The Market University Of Western Essay

1575 words - 7 pages what a market segment is), but also some evidence that you can apply that theory (e.g., by explaining how the theory is useful, and by giving good examples). In some respects, answering the application part of the question is more important. Most people can explain a simple theory like segmentation, but real knowledge is demonstrated when someone can apply that knowledge, and give good examples. 3. When reading the suggested answer below, note