What Is The Difference Between New And Old Wars? Warwick Assingment

3179 words - 13 pages

PO135 Summative Essay: 1506013
What characterises the nature of contemporary warfare?
This essay will focus on the most popular contemporary warfare theory, Mary Kaldor’s ‘New War’ thesis which contributes a formulaic approach to the revolution in warfare following the Cold War Era. Working with Kaldor’s lens, I will examine the supposed defining features of ‘new wars,’ including the role of civilians within the framework of modern-war and the methods used to finance the War Economy. Many have speculated that an equation-like approach to contemporary warfare is not complete and fails to capture its complex and multi-varied nature. This essay will engage with these notable critics, like Berdal, Hoffman and Booth to evaluate the limiting features and usefulness of her theory. Kaldor places great significance on the spread of globalisation that has arguably lead to the death of territorialized sovereignty (Agnew, 2009, p. 9). I will call into question the effect of this, namely focusing on war driven by identity politics and the decline of political legitimacy. The reduction in numbers of inter-state warfare has been furthered by technological advancements in precision weaponry, like drones. Argued by Kaldor to be a ‘technology intensive’ (Kaldor, 2012, p. 180) form of Old War, I will consider what effect a physical detachment to ongoing conflict has on our interpretation of war and its place in society. Using Kaldor’s suggestion of a more civilised form of security that established a viable legal system, I will consider the problems posed by the aims of contemporary war. In addition, this essay will engage with the ‘Network War’ and ‘Hybrid War’ theses’ from a critical point of view, to extend Kaldor’s existing argument.
One of the most frequently cited aspects of contemporary warfare has been the eradication of inter-state conflict, now shifted to be conducted by both state and non-state actors. Kaldor attributes this change to be driven by globalisation ‘breaking up…cultural and socio-economic divisions (Kaldor, 2012, p. 72),’ therefore characterised by conflict based on conflicting social identities. In the supposed era of ‘post-truth’ politics, populist movements clash over immigration in the West whilst Hindu and Chinese nationalism drive policies in the Indian and Chinese governments respectively. However, the most extreme form of identity politics today has been manifested in the rise of Islamic State (Lind, 2015). Kaldor’s position that identity struggles are ‘new’ is open to doubt; it has been noted by Ken Booth that political mobilization on the grounds of identity was the very hallmark of nationalist movements against anti-imperialism half a century ago (Booth, 2001, p. 166). Nonetheless, both writers agree that modern warfare must be understood in the context of what Kaldor calls a ‘global dislocation’ (Kaldor, 2012, p. 72).
The role of civilians within the framework of modern warfare has been frequently debated. Kaldor asserts that...

Other Essays On What is the difference between New and Old Wars? - Warwick - Assingment

The difference between Baba and Amir - English Grade 12 - Essay

939 words - 4 pages The Differences Between Amir and Baba in The Kite Runner By Nathan Strub Usually children take after their fathers, however, In The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini it is the opposite. Since Baba and Amir have many differences including their hobbies, their personality, and their expectations of each other. Because of this, they are unable to understand each other. Therefore Amir feels as though he is the son Baba never wanted. Firstly, Amir is

the difference between electoral college and run off - Government - government

1648 words - 7 pages what it really is. The Electoral College system was established so that the congressman and congresswomen in each state could keep each other updated on political decisions in a timely manner. Over the years the system has updated to accommodate the changing technological advances. We have the internet now to help us, so why are we still using this dinosaur system? There is a number you need to remember, 538. Every state gets a certain number of

What Is The New Kid Thinking!

956 words - 4 pages Butcher PAGE 2Butcher PAGE 1Chloe ButcherProfessor K. KoenigEnglish 1C12 September 2013What is the New Kid Thinking! If the world was a playground, Kim Jong Un is the new kid on the block; and his confusing actions-threats of nuclear war-seem to be his way proving himself to the other countries. A few months ago North Korea (almost daily) declared nuclear war on the United States and South Korea (New York Times.com). The frequency of these

We will focus on the new 707 model and see what the impact is. - Finance - Assignment

1427 words - 6 pages the investment Boeing is making in to the 7E7. Our market return, 5.79%, was the average returns of the S&P 500 index going back 5 years. This was chosen to match the time period and index of our proxy betas. The resulting market premium is 1.23%. Finally, we used these estimated cost of equity and debt figures to calculate the weighted average cost of capital. The only new inputs to this formula were the debt to asset ratio and the equity to

Difference Between Bisecting and Paralleling - Dental - Dentistry

625 words - 3 pages Amber Fajkus MOD B 10-2 PM Difference between Bisecting & Paralleling Techniques Bisecting technique is when the image receptor cannot be placed parallel to the long axis of the tooth. It can be used without film holder when the anatomy of the patient precludes the use of a film-holding device. The Bisecting Angle Technique is an alternative to the paralleling technique for taking periapical films. The film can be held in the mouth with the bite

Interactions and social hierarchy in the new and old kingdoms - AP World History - Essay

484 words - 2 pages C Silverthorne In old kingdom and new kingdom Egypt, things were quite different. One example of this is in Interactions. Throughout first wave Egypt, interactions evolved and the way they were carried out from the old kingdom to the new kingdom changed. For example, in the old kingdom, they traded a lot, and were welcoming to outsiders, whereas in the middle kingdom, they began to be more wary and started to build more military, until finally

Hort book report on Old Man and the Sea, highlighting the relationship between man and nature

541 words - 3 pages In Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea, Santiago is confronted by a series of sharks, which come in a specific order. This order is significant in a few ways. One significance in the order in which the sharks come is that it shows us how nature is organized and arranged. In this book, Hemingway seems to view nature as having a specific arrangement and believes that things in nature work in a specific way. The sequence of the sharks show

What's the Difference between Male and Female Attitudes to work, social and home life

618 words - 3 pages great difference between the attitudes of females and males.In conclusion, this survey appears that both women and men have consistent ideas in work life and home life. But in social life, for the questions about tradition and open-minded, women and men have different thoughts.AppendixQUESTIONNAIREWORK LIFE1. Do you think women should gain higher positions in companies?2. What do you think how do women act in a male dominated fields? E.g. Pilot

difference between living in the city and the countryside - class - research paper

5227 words - 21 pages behind the try line, or take it over the deal ball line. A failed dropout gives a free kick to the other team when it goes straight into touch. TACKLES: 2 hands are placed on the body “between the waist and mid thighs” (essentially the shirt and shorts). The ref counts the tackles: “tackle 1, tackle 2, tackle 3 etc up to tackle 6. After each tackle the player must remain in touch and pass within 3 steps, or else the player is brought back. Once a

Difference between driving in the summer and in the winter - Penn Foster , Science - Essay

515 words - 3 pages car for summer, you’d have to do the same for winter. You have to plan out your trip, and you have to plan it out very carefully. Just like you have to have different materials for winter, you’ll have to have the materials you need for summer. Both can also cause damage to your car, so that is why you have to get your car in the shop and get what it needs for the season. There are plenty of ways that driving in both seasons are very different. In

first of three important wars broke out between the Romans and the North American Empire of Carthage - english - essay

618 words - 3 pages The First Punic War  In 264 BCE, the first of three important wars broke out between the Romans and                              the North American Empire of Carthage. These wars were caused by vicious hungry                          nations that were in the process of expanding their empire or invading other lands. The                              Romans declared war so that they could limit Carthaginians power. ​Rome had become

Similar Papers

What Is The Difference Between Mrs Morland And General Tilney?

383 words - 2 pages What is the difference between Mrs Morland and General Tilney?In chapters 30 and 31, Mrs Morland is shown to have a lot of common sense. This is shown in the quotes 'Wherever you are you should always be contented, but especially at home, because there you must spend the most of your time' and 'Then you are fretting about General Tilney, and that is very simple of you; for ten to one whether you ever see him again. You should never fret about

The Difference Between Extrinsic And I Ntrinsic Learning

438 words - 2 pages Briefly state the difference between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. Which do you think is the most effective? Extrinsic: external, not inherent, not contained or included within, extraneous, Originating from outside. Extrinsic motivation (where we do things for rewards.) Intrinsic: adj. belonging to the real nature of a person or thing inherent. Intrinsic motivation (where we do things for their own sake.) When people are intrinsically

Difference In Leadership Between Moses And Oedipus Rex New York University Essay

1528 words - 7 pages difference in which they were presented the opportunity to become leaders mostly attributes to the difference between characters’ confidence. For example, Oedipus was appointed King of Thebes because of his ability to solve the Sphinx’s riddle and avoid its wrath. This ability to decode the riddle is what made him become the hero of Thebes. However, Moses did not have any valuable accomplishments to attribute to his inward qualities of being a

The Difference Between Cuba And The United States

427 words - 2 pages Osorio KarinaSeptember 29, 2014The Difference between Cuba and the United StatesThe united states is the worlds largest national economy. The U.S dollar is the currency most used in international transactions and is the worlds foremost reserve currency and in many others it is the de facto currency. It's the sixth largest trading partners are Canada, China, Mexico, Japan, Germany, and the united kingdom.The U.S is the worlds largest producer of