What Truth Lies At The Heart Of Holden's Story? English Essay

3006 words - 13 pages

To Tell You the Truth...
Critic: Susan K. Mitchell
Source: "To Tell You the Truth..." in CLA Journal, Vol. 36, No. 2, December, 1992, pp. 145-56.
Criticism about: The Catcher in the Rye
Author Covered: J. D. Salinger
[In the following excerpt, Mitchell considers the significance of Holden Caufield being an unreliable narrator. ]
In the work, Holden has analyzed his family as a representative slice of society and has concluded that adult society is phony and corrupt. But can we really trust his observations of his family after he has told us that he lies? Is he not, like the Cretan who declared that all Cretans were liars, a person declaring that all people are phony? If everyone is phony, then he is phony, too! Although Holden has claimed that he is a liar, he does not always realize whether he is lying or telling the truth. The distinctions between truth and falsehood become blurred as he often adds the phrase "to tell you the truth" onto whatever he is saying. But does this catch phrase ensure that his words are any more truthful? This unambiguous rhetorical statement is restated in an even more paradoxical way when Holden tells Sally that he loves her and then comments to the reader, "It was a lie, of course, but the thing is, I meant it when I said it." Again we are forced to read the work, as de Man suggests [in his essay "Semiology and Rhetoric," appearing in Contemporary Literary Criticism, edited by Robert C. Davis, 1986], in "two entirely coherent but entirely incompatible" ways. Is he lying, or does he "mean" it? First we may claim that Holden is telling the truth: he is a liar, people are phony, society is corrupt. Or we may claim that Holden is lying: he is truthful, people are genuine, and society is untainted.
There are obvious problems with both sides of this paradox. Can Holden, people, and society be entirely unchanging--always lying, always corrupt, always phony? Or are there internal forces within each that cause them to change (un)willingly? Holden would argue that each is unchanging, labeled forever. In fact, this is how he presents his information to us. He may go out with Sally, but he does not harbor any hope that she will cast off her phoniness. He may loan Stradlater his coat, but he still believes Stradlater is a phony.
Because we view all of the events in the book through the eyes of one narrator, our observations are necessarily biased. Holden is an unreliable narrator not only because he is a self-proclaimed liar but also because he perceives reality in a simplistic way. In his work S/Z[1974], Roland Barthes outlines two ways of perceiving reality: readerly and writerly. Barthes explains these ideas in terms of reading books. He claims that the only way to read a different story is to reread the same book. By rereading, a person can learn how this book differs from itself rather than how it differs from other books. When a reader rereads a work, he is perceiving writerly. When a reader refuses to reread, Bart...

RELATED

The Truth The Truth Within Their Story - athens hs - essay

745 words - 3 pages described much more subtly compared to the story-truth. How the 2 story-truth quote is said and described is very strong compared to the happening-truth which just includes details for the readers to image. His story-truths include better insights of what he saw and a more detailed explanation of what exactly occurred. One example would be, “It was near dusk and we were sitting at my foxhole along a wide muddy river north of Quang Ngai. I remember how

Guilt Trip: The Tale-Tell Heart - Cisco College and 1302 english - Element of a story

626 words - 3 pages Young 2 Guilt Trip When reading Edgar Allen Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart” our narrator is motived to execute an elderly man with an unusual eye. The old man’s physical disabilities “would fancy him mad” (Poe 37), thus leading our narrator to become a cold-blooded killer. However, it wasn’t the death of the old man that would be our narrators undoing, it was his anxiety and the sound of a subtle heartbeat that would unfold everything. In the story

The Ugly Truth: Prohibition of Drugs is a Lost Cause - english 250 - essay

1047 words - 5 pages Talaeai 1 2 Talaeai 5 Aiava Talaeai Dr. Johnson English 251 5 Apr. 2017 The Ugly Truth: Prohibition of Drugs is a Lost Cause People, for many years have said that the War on Drugs is an absolute failure. “With almost a million people in jail, drug use is as widespread as it has ever been” (Miller 23). “Drugs, chemicals and natural substances which affects human body and mind when taken, have been used across the globe for many years” (Isralowitz

The Truth Behind Us Assignment 3 5LOA - English, SOTA - Short story

828 words - 4 pages ” EXPLICIT ANALYSIS “Facts” (Level 1 + 2) 1) What media company made this piece of media? (Who paid for it?) 2) Who are the artists in this piece of media and what style of music do they make? Describe them using as much detail as you saw or know form your own background knowledge. 3) Summarize what is happening in this piece of media in at least three sentences (Think “context”: setting, characters, plot) USE DETAILS! IMPLICIT ANALYSIS “Messages

Who is the main character in Wartime Lies - English 111 - Essay

849 words - 4 pages Washington 1 Washington Cameran Washington English 111 December 11, 2018 Who Is The Main Character? In the novel Wartime Lies, we follow a boy named Maciek who is born into the world during the rise of Nazi-Germany. Thankfully, he is not alone, as he is protected and taken care of by his aunt. The story follows these two as they not only try to hide from the germans, but also live as a broken family. While Wartime Lies is a great story that

The Truth of The Digital Persona - Undergraduate - Essay

2580 words - 11 pages Free such as ‘lol’, ’swag’,’ ‘yolo’, etc in everyday physical interaction. The self that was once divided eventually seeks to be whole and as such, the physical and virtual personalities tend to ‘blend’ into an entirely new persona containing elements of its constituent personae. Ultimately, the idea of the ‘self’ is in constant flux. What one considers oneself to be at a given point of time might not be what the individual would want to identify as

Short Story: Tales of the Eastside - english - essay

1557 words - 7 pages Free thing he said about the eastside. I thought the east side of Detroit was exactly like the west side. Well I was very wrong. This is how it all started. About 2 weeks ago on the weekend I visited my friend Makayla at her house. Makayla is 16 years old. She is very unaware of her surroundings but always tries to be optimistic and have fun. She also loves to explore which is what you’ll find out later. She lives on the eastside in the Jefferson

Harrison Begeron: The Role of Conformity - English - Short Story essay

606 words - 3 pages Free September 19th, 2017 The Results of Conformity The human brain is programmed in such a way that we strive to feel accepted into society. We may not agree with the system of which we have decided to follow, however, due to the fact that everyone is following it, we choose to do the same. This is what is known as conformity. Unconsciously, everything we do is somehow conforming with society. Throughout this short story ​Harrison Bergeron

Heart of Darkness and Kurtz's development - English IV - Essay

1257 words - 6 pages 1 Godoy Coni Godoy Dr.Williams English IV 14 December 2017 Heart of Darkness Midterm In Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, we see that Kurtz has gone through a drastic development throughout the course of the short story. Kurtz enters Africa wanting to help westernize the culture but ends up coming out of it just as savage as the natives inhabiting it. His insanity can be recorded as three main stages in his development. The first stage analyzes

The Truth Of Martin Luther King

2947 words - 12 pages holiday declared in his honor, an honor accorded to no other American, not Washington, not Jefferson, not Lincoln. (Washington and Lincoln no longer have holidays -- they share the generic-sounding "President's Day.") A liberal judge has sealed the FBI files on King until the year 2027. What are they hiding? Let's take a look at this modern-day plastic god.Born in 1929, King was the son of a Black preacher known at the time only as "Daddy King

this is a story about betrayal and how it was overcome - english paper at wcjc - essay

607 words - 3 pages makes him go back to challenge his uncle. ‘And so we are all connected in the circle of life’ the protagonist is told this by his father who teaches him how to be a great king, this is said in a serious tone which tells us readers that the matter had to be taken seriously. The symbolism found in ‘The Lion King’ is the key concept to what the story really means. In the first few minutes of the movie the antagonist is confronted by his brother and

What were living and working conditions in Australia at the start of the 20th century? - history - essay

575 words - 3 pages Year 9 History Submission Sheet 1 Name: Mark: /20 Grade: Date Given: Week 3 Due date: Week 3 Friday - Print the completed sheet ready for collection on Friday. Question: What was the impact of colonisation on Aboriginal people from 1788-1901? Correct use essay style. Focus on a couple of issues. Plan!!!!! January 1788 was when the british invaded the island, known as Australia

Short Story Literary Essay "The Force of Luck" by Rudolfo A. Anaya - St. Basil, English - Short Story Literary Essay

926 words - 4 pages . Although above all qualities, honesty played a large role in the story line. Throughout the story the miller shows to be of honesty in various situations when he loses the money. When the two men in the story still did not believe the miller in the end, he did not give up and tried to prove himself right by showing the two men what had happened. At the end of the story, both men finally believed that his honesty towards them had been true all

Sobibor, Tells The Story Of A Nazi Officer Gone Mad...Losely Based On Edgar Allen Poe's "Tell-Tale Heart"

1734 words - 7 pages The eyeball, glazed over, shifted toward me. Even though he was blind, he seemed to be looking right at me. Holding the gaze for what seemed like an eternity, as my eyes met his my heart seemed to beat as swiftly as the wings of a humming bird. I let the trap door down, stopping his heart with the grisly rope around his neck. This was the first time I ever felt sympathy for those animals those inhumane beasts, but as soon as the rope tightened

Essay on Ain't I A Woman - Sonjourner Truth - English - Essay

586 words - 3 pages was due to her skin colour and gender. The repetitious use of the rhetorical question "Ain’t I a woman?", draws the listeners minds and makes you look at Truth for more than just her gender and skins colour; it makes you imagine a independent, strong hearted, selfless woman who will fight for as long as it takes and as hard as is humanly possible until she achieves exactly what she set out to achieve which is to be allowed to have access to her