What We Mean When We Say 'race Is A Social Construct' English English Report

1471 words - 6 pages

theatlantic.com
What We Mean When We Say 'Race Is a Social Construct'
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Walter White. Chairman of the NAACP. Black dude. (The Walter White Project)
Andrew Sullivan and Freddie Deboer have two pieces up worth checking out. I disagree with Andrew's (though I detect some movement in his position.) Freddie's piece is entitled "Precisely How Not to Argue About Race and IQ." He writes: The problem with people who argue for inherent racial inferiority is not that they lie about the results of IQ tests, but that they are credulous about those tests and others like them when they shouldn't be; that they misunderstand the implications of what those tests would indicate even if they were credible; and that they fail to find the moral, analytic, and political response to questions of race and intelligence.
I think this is a good point, but I want to expand it. Most of the honest writing I've seen on "race and intelligence" focuses on critiquing the idea of "intelligence." So there's lot of good literature on whether it can be measured, its relevance in modern society, whether intelligence changes across generations, whether it changes with environment, and what we mean when we say IQ. As Freddie mentions here, I had a mathematician stop past to tell me I needed to stop studying French, and immediately start studying statistics -- otherwise I can't possibly understand this debate.
It's a fair critique. My response is that he should stop studying math and start studying history.
I am not being flip or coy. If you tell me that you plan to study "race and intelligence" then it is only fair that I ask you, "What do you mean by race?" It's true I don't always do math so well, but I understand the need to define the terms of your study. If you're a math guy, perhaps your instinct is to point out the problems in the interpretation of the data. My instinct is to point out that your entire experiment proceeds from a basic flaw -- no coherent, fixed definition of race actually exists.
The history bears this out. In 1856, Ralph Waldo Emerson delineated the significance of race:
It is race, is it not, that puts the hundred millions of India under the dominion of a remote island in the north of Europe. Race avails much, if that be true, which is alleged, that all Celts are Catholics, and all Saxons are Protestants; that Celts love unity of power, and Saxons the representative principle. Race is a controlling influence in the Jew, who, for two millenniums, under every climate, has preserved the same character and employments. Race in the negro is of appalling importance. The French in Canada, cut off from all intercourse with the parent people, have held their national traits. I chanced to read Tacitus "on the Manners of the Germans," not long since, in Missouri, and the heart of Illinois, and I found abundant points of resemblance between the Germans of the Hercynian forest, and our Hoosiers, Suckers, and Badgers of the American woods.
Indeed, Emerson in 1835, saw race as central to American greatness:
The inhabitants of the United States, especially of the Northern portion, are descended from the people of England and have inherited the traits of their national character...It is common with the Franks to break their faith and laugh at it The race of Franks is faithless.
Emerson was not alone, as historian James McPherson points out, Southerners not only thought of themselves as a race separate from blacks, but as a race apart from Northern whites:
The South's leading writer on political economy, James B. D. De Bow, subscribed to this Norman-Cavalier thesis and helped to popularize it in De Bow's Review. As the lower-South states seceded one after another during the winter of 1860-61, this influential journal carried several long articles justifying secession on the grounds of irreconcilable ethnic differences between Southern and Northern whites. "The Cavaliers, Jacobites, and Huguenots, who settled the South, naturally hate, contemn, and despise the Puritans who settled the North," proclaimed one of these articles. "The former are a master-race; the latter a slave race, the descendants of Saxon serfs." The South was now achieving its "independent destiny" by repudiating the failed experiment of civic nationalism that had foolishly tried in 1789 to "erect one nation out of two irreconcilable peoples."
Similarly, in 1899 William Z. Ripley wrote The Races of Europe, which sought to delineate racial difference through head-type:
The shape of the human head by which we mean the general proportions of length, breadth, and height, irrespective of the " bumps " of the phrenologist is one of the best available tests of race known. Its value is, at the same time, but imperfectly appreciated beyond the inner circle of professional anthropology. Yet it is so simple a phenomenon, both in principle and in practical application, that it may readily be of use to the traveller and the not too superficial observer of men.
To be sure, widespread and constant peculiarities of head form are less noticeable in America, because of the extreme variability of our population, compounded as it is of all the races of Europe; they seem also to be less fundamental among the American aborigines. But in the Old World the observant traveller may with a little attention often detect the racial affinity of a people by this means.
Two years later, Edward A. Ross sought to apprehend "The Causes of Race Superiority." He saw the differences between the Arab "race" and the Jewish "race" as a central illustration:
It is certain that races differ in their attitude toward past and future. M. Lapie has drawn a contrast between the Arab and the Jew. The Arab remembers; he is mindful of past favors and past injuries. He harbors his vengeance and cherishes his gratitude. He accepts everything on the authority of tradition, loves the ways of his ancestors, forms strong local attachments, and migrates little. The Jew, on the other hand, turns his face toward the future. He is thrifty and always ready for a good stroke of business, will, indeed, join with his worst enemy if it pays. He is calculating, enterprising, migrant and ambitious
You can see more of this here.
Our notion of what constitutes "white" and what constitutes "black" is a product of social context. It is utterly impossible to look at the delineation of a "Southern race" and not see the Civil War, the creation of an "Irish race" and not think of Cromwell's ethnic cleansing, the creation of a "Jewish race" and not see anti-Semitism. There is no fixed sense of "whiteness" or "blackness," not even today. It is quite common for whites to point out that Barack Obama isn't really "black" but "half-white." One wonders if they would say this if Barack Obama were a notorious drug-lord.
When the liberal says "race is a social construct," he is not being a soft-headed dolt; he is speaking an historical truth. We do not go around testing the "Irish race" for intelligence or the "Southern race" for "hot-headedness." These reasons are social. It is no more legitimate to ask "Is the black race dumber than then white race?" than it is to ask "Is the Jewish race thriftier than the Arab race?"
The strongest argument for "race" is that people who trace their ancestry back to Europe, and people who trace most of their ancestry back to sub-Saharan Africa, and people who trace most of their ancestry back to Asia, and people who trace their ancestry back to the early Americas, lived isolated from each other for long periods and have evolved different physical traits (curly hair, lighter skin, etc.)
But this theoretical definition (already fuzzy) wilts under human agency, in a real world where Kevin Garnett, Harold Ford, and Halle Berry all check "black" on the census. (Same deal for "Hispanic.") The reasons for that take us right back to fact of race as a social construct. And an American-centered social construct. Are the Ainu of Japan a race? Should we delineate darker South Asians from lighter South Asians on the basis of race? Did the Japanese who invaded China consider the Chinese the same "race?"
Andrew writes that liberals should stop saying "truly stupid things like race has no biological element." I agree. Race clearly has a biological element -- because we have awarded it one. Race is no more dependent on skin color today than it was on "Frankishness" in Emerson's day. Over history of race has taken geography, language, and vague impressions as its basis.
"Race," writes the great historian Nell Irvin Painter, "is an idea, not a fact." Indeed. Race does not need biology. Race only requires some good guys with big guns looking for a reason.

RELATED

listening to what we do, not what we say - Culture and Nonverbal Behavior - research paper

1459 words - 6 pages Running head: LISTENING TO WHAT WE DO, NOT WHAT WE SAY LISTENING TO WHAT WE DO, NOT WHAT WE SAY Listening to What We Do, Not what We Say: Culture and Nonverbal Behavior We might be living in a global world but nonverbal communication in different cultures shows such drastic differences that might present the feeling that we are from different planets. No matter where we are, it seems, we must remember that our bodies are always saying something

When we obey God’s voice message - Homiletics 2 - Preaching sermon

755 words - 4 pages -2 1) What a great test that Abraham confronted having to sacrifice his only son to God! 2. When we obey God´s voice, many times God makes us willing to go where he wants.  Vs. 1 – “…and he said, Behold, here I am.” 1) God is calling many people to serve Him as pastors, missionaries, faithful workers in their church – but most are not willing. 3. When we obey God´s voice, many times God sends people to us to help us fulfill His plans in our life

Say-mean-matter AP English Language - AP English-language - Assignment

427 words - 2 pages 1. Say-Mean-Matter SaySay   MeanMean   MatterMatter   “But time is the one thing we have been given, and we have been given to time.” ch 6 pg. 87 We have been given a lot of time to use. What are we going to do with all our time? We should use our time wisely. It’s important to manage your time. “Dragonfly nymphs, for instance, are easily able to shed a leg or two to escape a tight spot, but even dragonfly nymphs get stuck in the algae strands

Use of Stereotypes and Social Construct in Hamlet - English - Essay

1095 words - 5 pages Free only is the use of femininity used as a point to set character’s roles in this society but Shakespeare also uses hypermasculinity in order to set the tone of what a male, specifically Hamlet, should be in during this time and how they should adhere to it. When Hamlet was mourning over the death of his father, Claudius comes to him and says In obstinate condolement is a course Of impious stubbornness. 'Tis unmanly grief. It shows a will most

To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? - English Lit - ESSAY

2891 words - 12 pages Free ." “When is she Sybil Vane” "Never." "I congratulate you. “ Finally, yet not entirely distancing itself from the notion of social morality, is the theme of the British class system that seems to resurface throughout the entirety of the novel, taking many different forms in the process. This theme allows Wilde’s novel to be viewed through a Marxist lens. The first evident and significant appearance of the concept of hierarchy is exhibited through

What Did Marx Mean By The Statement That 'Capital Is Not A Thing, But A Social Relation Between Persons'?

2416 words - 10 pages Free estrangement of individuals from themselves and others; it is a feeling of noninvolvement in and estrangement from one's society and culture. Marx saw human estrangement as rooted in social structures, which denied people their essential human nature. The process of production is one of 'objectification', whereby men makes material objects, which embody human creativity, yet stand as entities separate from their creators. Alienation occurs when

What ancient writers say about excessive pride - english - Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Trojans” (Woodhouse 201). Odysseus pride is experienced when he proclaims himself as the winner of the Trojan War and this is what marks the beginning of his downfall. Ancient writers explain that a pride warrior or person is the one who goes looking for trouble. There are several occasions in which Odysseus explores his world only to discover trouble. For example, he is the one who explores the caves only to find the Cyclops. “After he enters the

What does Lenin mean when he says the state is an instrument of class rule - Newcastle, Politics - Essay

544 words - 3 pages What does Lenin mean when he says the state is an instrument of class rule. Unlike Bernstein who believes that the capitalist state will adapt and change, to protect the interests of the working class. Lenin disagrees with his suggestion that it would in theory be possible for the state to put measures in place for this to happen through socialist democratic reform. He thinks that it is the state itself which perpetuates the oppression of the

Analyze a Film that we saw in our class. - Richland College - English 1301 - Essay

1111 words - 5 pages Mutum Mutum (2007) is a Brazilian drama film directed by Sandra Kogut. The film is based on the novel Campo Geral (1964) written by João Guimarães Rosa. The Mutum film depicts a ten-year-old quiet little boy, Thiago, who lives in a small, hardscrabble farm named Mutum with his family. Although he is a child, Thiago observes the adults and their world is filled with violence and treacherous silence. It seems like a sad story when we see these

Notes about a book we have studies in Year 11 called "Night" - English - Notes

498 words - 2 pages felt little sadness”. Pg 21 - “ They will have to dig to find it, so much easier to do when the owners are on vacation. Chapter 3 - Elie has been separated from his mum and his sisters. - He is trying to deny the horrors that he is about to face, believing its only a nightmare. - His father wishes Elie had gone with his mother. - He kept dreaming about his mother. - Remorseful is what has become of his attitude. - “My Father had just been struck in

what can we learn about social cohesion from the presence of discrimination? - BICC - discrimination

1025 words - 5 pages Carol Zhu Jan.12.2018 What can we learn about social cohesion from the presence of discrimination ? Discrimination includes but is not limited to racial discrimination(oppose individuals on the basis of their race), national origin discrimination(It occurs when individuals are treated differently because of his/her ancestors), geographical discrimination(based on where a person lives or was born), employment discrimination(employees who are

how we truly come to know thyself - English - research

2133 words - 9 pages 1 Patterson Calista Patterson Professor C English 1C 11 July 2019 How we Come to Know Ourselves Know yourself. A simple statement that has been pondered by philosophers, and even individuals alike; ever since Socrates first brought this notion to light, but what does it truly mean? I can attest to what it is not, finding out oneself, is not something that can be brought upon by any person, outside objects, or actions. There is nothing that is

Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? - English - Language analysis

900 words - 4 pages DOT 1 // Language Argument Analysis Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? Written by Jeff Flocken, Analysed by Lachlan Tranter The editorial titled Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? and subtitled How can we save lions when Americans are killing them for sport? written by Jeff Flocken, National Geographic, August 4th, 2013, is written in response to the United States government’s consideration of including lions on the Endangered

do you agree we now have a global economy? justify your answer - social sciences - essay

946 words - 4 pages Do you agree that we now have a ‘global economy’? Justify your answer. Yes we do, but its full of inequality Globalisation is a system where goods and services re transferred It’s a local market gone global What is an economy? Economy is where income... Resource and wealth distribution... Introduction/Thesis Yes we have global economy but rid with inequality and poverty. DEFINE The Market is a place where people buy and sell. Commodities

Huckleberry Finn as a commentary on race - English - Essay

1505 words - 7 pages Jim realizes he’s been tricked, he says, “En when I wake up en fine you back agin, all safe en soun’, de tears come, en I could a got down on my knees en kiss yo’ foot, I’s so thankful. En all you wuz thinkin’ ‘bout wuz how you could make a fool uv ole Jim wid a lie. Dat truck dah is trash; en trash is what people is dat puts dirt on de head er dey fren’s en makes ‘em ashamed (Twain, 85).” Huck is made apologetic and regretful by Jim’s remarks