What We Mean When We Say 'race Is A Social Construct' English English Report

1471 words - 6 pages

theatlantic.com
What We Mean When We Say 'Race Is a Social Construct'
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Walter White. Chairman of the NAACP. Black dude. (The Walter White Project)
Andrew Sullivan and Freddie Deboer have two pieces up worth checking out. I disagree with Andrew's (though I detect some movement in his position.) Freddie's piece is entitled "Precisely How Not to Argue About Race and IQ." He writes: The problem with people who argue for inherent racial inferiority is not that they lie about the results of IQ tests, but that they are credulous about those tests and others like them when they shouldn't be; that they misunderstand the implications of what those tests would indicate even if they were credible; and that they fail to find the moral, analytic, and political response to questions of race and intelligence.
I think this is a good point, but I want to expand it. Most of the honest writing I've seen on "race and intelligence" focuses on critiquing the idea of "intelligence." So there's lot of good literature on whether it can be measured, its relevance in modern society, whether intelligence changes across generations, whether it changes with environment, and what we mean when we say IQ. As Freddie mentions here, I had a mathematician stop past to tell me I needed to stop studying French, and immediately start studying statistics -- otherwise I can't possibly understand this debate.
It's a fair critique. My response is that he should stop studying math and start studying history.
I am not being flip or coy. If you tell me that you plan to study "race and intelligence" then it is only fair that I ask you, "What do you mean by race?" It's true I don't always do math so well, but I understand the need to define the terms of your study. If you're a math guy, perhaps your instinct is to point out the problems in the interpretation of the data. My instinct is to point out that your entire experiment proceeds from a basic flaw -- no coherent, fixed definition of race actually exists.
The history bears this out. In 1856, Ralph Waldo Emerson delineated the significance of race:
It is race, is it not, that puts the hundred millions of India under the dominion of a remote island in the north of Europe. Race avails much, if that be true, which is alleged, that all Celts are Catholics, and all Saxons are Protestants; that Celts love unity of power, and Saxons the representative principle. Race is a controlling influence in the Jew, who, for two millenniums, under every climate, has preserved the same character and employments. Race in the negro is of appalling importance. The French in Canada, cut off from all intercourse with the parent people, have held their national traits. I chanced to read Tacitus "on the Manners of the Germans," not long since, in Missouri, and the heart of Illinois, and I found abundant points of resemblance between the Germans of the Hercynian forest, and our Hoosiers, Suckers, and Badgers of the American woods.
Indeed, Emerson in...

Other Essays On What We Mean When We Say 'Race Is a Social Construct' - English - English Report

What ancient writers say about excessive pride - english - Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Trojans” (Woodhouse 201). Odysseus pride is experienced when he proclaims himself as the winner of the Trojan War and this is what marks the beginning of his downfall. Ancient writers explain that a pride warrior or person is the one who goes looking for trouble. There are several occasions in which Odysseus explores his world only to discover trouble. For example, he is the one who explores the caves only to find the Cyclops. “After he enters the

Analyze a Film that we saw in our class. - Richland College - English 1301 - Essay

1111 words - 5 pages Mutum Mutum (2007) is a Brazilian drama film directed by Sandra Kogut. The film is based on the novel Campo Geral (1964) written by João Guimarães Rosa. The Mutum film depicts a ten-year-old quiet little boy, Thiago, who lives in a small, hardscrabble farm named Mutum with his family. Although he is a child, Thiago observes the adults and their world is filled with violence and treacherous silence. It seems like a sad story when we see these

Notes about a book we have studies in Year 11 called "Night" - English - Notes

498 words - 2 pages felt little sadness”. Pg 21 - “ They will have to dig to find it, so much easier to do when the owners are on vacation. Chapter 3 - Elie has been separated from his mum and his sisters. - He is trying to deny the horrors that he is about to face, believing its only a nightmare. - His father wishes Elie had gone with his mother. - He kept dreaming about his mother. - Remorseful is what has become of his attitude. - “My Father had just been struck in

how we truly come to know thyself - English - research

2133 words - 9 pages 1 Patterson Calista Patterson Professor C English 1C 11 July 2019 How we Come to Know Ourselves Know yourself. A simple statement that has been pondered by philosophers, and even individuals alike; ever since Socrates first brought this notion to light, but what does it truly mean? I can attest to what it is not, finding out oneself, is not something that can be brought upon by any person, outside objects, or actions. There is nothing that is

Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? - English - Language analysis

900 words - 4 pages DOT 1 // Language Argument Analysis Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? Written by Jeff Flocken, Analysed by Lachlan Tranter The editorial titled Opinion: Why are we still hunting lions? and subtitled How can we save lions when Americans are killing them for sport? written by Jeff Flocken, National Geographic, August 4th, 2013, is written in response to the United States government’s consideration of including lions on the Endangered

For english we had to write and essay on dear martin - English - Essay

883 words - 4 pages Tomas 1 Kiersten A. Tomas ENG1D-03 Ms. Million 7 June 2018 Struggles A great person once said, "With a little devil on my left shoulder and an angel on my right, both telling me what I should do,". Friendship is a dominant theme in the novel Dear Martin by Nic Stone, but friendships are not always good. Throughout the novel, Justyce struggles with decisions about school, making the right choices, and deals with legal issues. Justyce is

Huckleberry Finn as a commentary on race - English - Essay

1505 words - 7 pages Jim realizes he’s been tricked, he says, “En when I wake up en fine you back agin, all safe en soun’, de tears come, en I could a got down on my knees en kiss yo’ foot, I’s so thankful. En all you wuz thinkin’ ‘bout wuz how you could make a fool uv ole Jim wid a lie. Dat truck dah is trash; en trash is what people is dat puts dirt on de head er dey fren’s en makes ‘em ashamed (Twain, 85).” Huck is made apologetic and regretful by Jim’s remarks

Women rights and why we are all equal - English 2 honors - Assignment

455 words - 2 pages Garcia Christopher Garcia Mrs. Dehaan English 10 Honors 6 December 2017 Women Rights The issue regarding women’s rights is not a new one. In the past there were distinctive differences between men and women between their roles in society and their models of behavior. As of today women have the most rights they have ever had but there is still a major difference between a women’s rights and a man’s rights. Women have come a long way to get where

Nature vs Nurture in We Need to Talk About Kevin - Spokane Community College English 102 - Essay

1097 words - 5 pages .” (Stern, Marlow) The way that Kevin is treated when he was a child plays a big part into what happened on Thursday. He was never truly loved by his mom and felt her emotions didn’t mean anything. She never wanted him. As children we feel when our mothers have something wrong with them and we thrive off of their emotions when we are babies and toddlers. Something was clearly wrong with Kevin’s demeanor as a child that Eva obviously chose to ignore

The individuals in our lives shape who we become - English - Essay

851 words - 4 pages focused on school and never indulged in the  temptations. The experience he went through is an example that individuals around  us do influence who we become. Because of what happened to him this has also  influenced myself. It shows me what happens when you indulge in this temptations of  recreational drugs. I would say without a doubt this has influenced me. The people we  are involved with will have an effect on who we become whether it benefit

abortion argument should we ban abortion in the united states - english - essay

1939 words - 8 pages reasonable based on all of the ethically relevant factors. The line dividing a “cluster of cells” from a “person” is similar in this respect. Science can discover many important facts, such as the point at which a fetus can feel pain, or the point at which it can survive outside the womb. But science cannot tell us when a “cluster of cells” becomes what we understand to be a “person.” It’s up to us to answer that question. A critic might reject

Similar Papers

Say Mean Matter Ap English Language Ap English Language Assignment

427 words - 2 pages 1. Say-Mean-Matter SaySay   MeanMean   MatterMatter   “But time is the one thing we have been given, and we have been given to time.” ch 6 pg. 87 We have been given a lot of time to use. What are we going to do with all our time? We should use our time wisely. It’s important to manage your time. “Dragonfly nymphs, for instance, are easily able to shed a leg or two to escape a tight spot, but even dragonfly nymphs get stuck in the algae strands

Use Of Stereotypes And Social Construct In Hamlet English Essay

1095 words - 5 pages only is the use of femininity used as a point to set character’s roles in this society but Shakespeare also uses hypermasculinity in order to set the tone of what a male, specifically Hamlet, should be in during this time and how they should adhere to it. When Hamlet was mourning over the death of his father, Claudius comes to him and says In obstinate condolement is a course Of impious stubbornness. 'Tis unmanly grief. It shows a will most

Listening To What We Do, Not What We Say Culture And Nonverbal Behavior Research Paper

1459 words - 6 pages Running head: LISTENING TO WHAT WE DO, NOT WHAT WE SAY LISTENING TO WHAT WE DO, NOT WHAT WE SAY Listening to What We Do, Not what We Say: Culture and Nonverbal Behavior We might be living in a global world but nonverbal communication in different cultures shows such drastic differences that might present the feeling that we are from different planets. No matter where we are, it seems, we must remember that our bodies are always saying something

To What Extent Should We Consider The Picture Of Dorian Gray To Be A Gothic Novel? English Lit Essay

2891 words - 12 pages ." “When is she Sybil Vane” "Never." "I congratulate you. “ Finally, yet not entirely distancing itself from the notion of social morality, is the theme of the British class system that seems to resurface throughout the entirety of the novel, taking many different forms in the process. This theme allows Wilde’s novel to be viewed through a Marxist lens. The first evident and significant appearance of the concept of hierarchy is exhibited through