Where's The Happy State: A Comparative Literature Analyzing Freud And Rousseau

1936 words - 8 pages

We have always been led to believe that civilization is something favorable for humans to have over the "savage" and "inferior" species. However, before taking the greatness of civilization for granted, we should speculate upon the validity of this belief. After all, the very entity that teaches "obvious" fact to us is our civilized society! The two great thinkers, Freud and Nietzsche, question and contemplate the benefits that society imposes on us and conclude that civilization actually does more harm to society than benefits it, although they disagree on how this occurs. Even though both Freud and Nietzsche believe that civilization is based on the taming of human instinctual life with ...view middle of the document...

Nietzsche claims too that civilization represses the aggression of the people, especially the strong, so that the undeserving weak can survive. Despite the parallel about the taming of civilization, the purpose of this suppression is quite different between the two thinkers.Freud claims that civilization is the struggle between the human instincts, death drive and Eros, and its ultimate goal is to prevent self-guilt and achieve security from the aggression of others. The death drive is the compulsion to return to inanimate state. Freud states that "The aim of all life is death," clearly indicating our instinctual tendency to end life. The Eros, in contrast, is the sex and love drive, which resembles life and being with others. According to Freud, the entire development of evolution is based on the struggle between these two instincts. Aggression and any kind of destruction behavior represent the death drive as it directs it compulsion of death outward. Freud states that aggression is a "primary mutual hostility of human beings" and "an original, self-subsisting instinctual disposition in man" that "constitutes the greatest impediment to civilization." He believes that aggression is in our natural instinct that disrupts our society's harmony. However, unlike Nietzsche, he also identifies that along with this desire to destroy, one also develops the need for love.Freud believes that the fear of losing the love from the father inhibits an infant's aggression. "His aggressiveness is introjected, internalized" as his Eros prevails over his death drive and plants the seed of the superego. The Eros is what binds a family or society together as the primitive family formation is based on the husbands need for regular sexual satisfaction and the woman's need for protection against the aggression of others. In primitive families, the father set up rules to satisfy all his Eros and aggression needs at the expense of the instinctual desires of the children by having all the females in the family. According to Freud's story of "Totem and Taboo," a band of brothers slay the father due to their release of suppressed aggression and their need for sex. The band of brothers then decides to make taboos, or laws, to prevent the aggression between each other and allow each person to satisfy his sexual need by prohibiting incestuous sex. Aggression and some Eros is restrained in order to achieve security and fair satisfaction. Thus, the first civilization is formed in society.In contrast to Freud, Nietzsche believes that the restraining function of civilization is the result of spiritual revenge from the weak to inhibit and prevail over the strong. Nietzsche claims that during the aristocracy period, morality was defined by what the powerful and rich were. "The judgment 'good' did not originate with those to whom goodness was shown! Rather it was 'the good' themselves, that is to say, the noble, powerful, high-stationed and high-minded, who felt and established...

Other Essays On Where's The Happy State: A Comparative Literature Analyzing Freud And Rousseau

Significance of the Title in the Novel Quicksand - Comparative Literature - Essay

2002 words - 9 pages Igneri Nicholas Igneri Professor Runciman COLI 211B 14 March 2019 Significance of the Title Quicksand by Nella Larsen The novel Quicksand was published in 1928 by Mulatto-American woman Nella Larsen. During this period of time, the Harlem Renaissance was at its peak. The Harlem Renaissance was a social movement for African-Americans where art and music exploded onto the scene. Larsen’s novel Quicksand can be considered an embracement and

A Comparative Study Of Greek And Celtic Pagan Religions, The Variations Between Them And Their Demise Through The Christian Movement

3023 words - 13 pages Variations exist within all religions. These variations are formed as a result of a number of influences experienced by not only individuals but the society as a whole. Throughout history religions have developed, diminished as well as formed the basis for many contempory religions, notably Christianity. It is the latter however which caused the downfall of Paganism, in particular ancient Celtic and Greek belief and which resulted in the church

Make A Comparative Study Between The Passionate Shepherd To His Love And The Nymph's Reply To The Shepherd

1050 words - 5 pages ", "fancy" and "fall".Rhyme skip isAabb ccddIn passionate shepherd here the shepherd promises many imaginary things.But in nymphs reply here the poet wishes to know that his promises are not possible because time changes.Images--Marl owe portrayed many imagery things. Ex--rocks, bed of roses, a cap of flowers etc.But Raleigh use many imagery thing The images are real, but are taken from the Passionate Shepherd to His love, and go beyond their meaning

FREUD Theory: 1. Psychodynamic theory: A topology of the mind - durham - notes

1583 words - 7 pages Consumer psychology lecture 2 FREUD 1. Psychodynamic theory: A topology of the mind ‘心靈的配置configuration of the mind’ · Hysteria conscious (small) ‘Part of the mind that holds what you are aware of’ Can verbalize about your conscious experience and you can think about it in a logical fashion · 10% of the minds work is made up of conscious · not explain those random events created within the mind · Its ability to direct your focus. · Its ability

The arts (painting, music, literature etc.) reveal the otherwise hidden ideas and impulses of a society

439 words - 2 pages Arts is needed to make nation a better place for humans overall. Many times, it is the arts through which hidden ideas and impulses of the society are revealed. The various forms of arts like painting, music and, literature depicts the invisible aspects of our society.Consider one of the cardinal forms of art, paintings: the source through which artist elaborate reality of the world, that cannot be seen through open eyes. Consider the frescoes

Juvenile And Adult Courts – A Comparative Analysis Write A 1,000- To 1,500-Word Paper Comparing And Contrasting Juvenile Court With Adult Court. Include The Following In Your Paper:

1163 words - 5 pages Untitled Juvenile and Adult Courts - A Comparative Analysis Mike Lemke University of Phoenix CJA 393 Len Swadlow May 10, 2010 Abolishing the juvenile court system is part of a long process. The process may derail justice from taking place in a timely manner. An intricate replacement plan needs to be in place if society decides to move juvenile cases to criminal courts. Chaos would take place without a

The Prince and Julius Caesar Comparative Study - SSCBWB - Essay

1036 words - 5 pages allegory of the ensuing chaos and social instability that arise as consequences of a quest for power, one that is driven by political pragmatism and expediency. A comparative study demonstrates how the intertextual perspective on leadership and other political values and attitudes are inherently shaped by their social contexts. Machiavelli, in The Prince, emphasises that leaders must rule with political expediency and an abandonment of morals to

Hag-seed and The Tempest comparative study - Oakhill College - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages “How does the relationship between The Tempest and Hag-Seed show how composers are influenced by another text’s concepts and values?” The relationship between The Tempest and Hag-seed, written by William Shakespeare and Margret Atwood shows how composers are influenced by other text’s concepts and values through textual conversation. Atwood’s appropriation of The Tempest reflects and adapts the text to a post-modern contextualisation whilst also

Comparative Essay - Ransom and On The Waterfront - Year 11 - Essay

943 words - 4 pages A true leader is born when they understand themselves. How does Ransom and On The Waterfront explore this? Leadership often highlights how characters get to where they are by embracing their own values. In the novel ‘Ransom’, written by David Malouf, which takes place during the Trojan War as described in the Illiad, Malouf demonstrates how the king of Troy, Priam, transgresses and becomes more aware of what he is meant to do through recognition

Comparative Essay "The Great Gatsby" And "Talented Mr Ripley"

1116 words - 5 pages the idea of failure and corruption of the American Dream and self reinvention to reflect the futility of pretence in a post war context.In The Great Gatsby, self reinvention mirrors the rapidly changing society of post war America 1920s, where social barriers are fluid, enabling the transversal of previously rigid social boundaries. In this context, Jay Gatsby's reinvention is not to fulfil a lust for power and wealth, but due to a naïve

The Great Gatsby comparative essay on Daisy and Myrtle on how they are similar - Comparative essay - essay

1368 words - 6 pages Despite Their Differences Men Look At Them the Same The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald is a book based on the 1920’s where money was at a pinnacle of it’s value. The era of old money. In the book there are two lead roles played by females named Daisy and Myrtle. Daisy and Myrtle are from different parts of the world when it comes to being treated by men and how no matter what their status was, they are looked at as object by all men

Similar Papers

A Small Place Comparative Essay Comparative Literature Essay

957 words - 4 pages the story as the writer puts her own point of view to express her feelings. The writer’s uses a sarcastic tone to deliver this specific paragraph to show her hatred towards the tourists as she starts the passage by saying “slightly funny feeling”. The word ‘funny’ may seem like the writer is happy and okay with the tourists but actually she is being sarcastic as she is really angry with them because the tourists have a selfish behavior. It is so

Comparative Essay Of L'amant And L'africain French Literature Comparative Essay

1528 words - 7 pages , despite the fact that they are impoverished. However, for the same reason, her family experiences isolation due to the difference of their skin colour from the majority of the population surrounding them. The fifteen-year-old protagonist escapes this isolation and dissimilitude as she develops a sexual relationship with a significantly older and wealthier man from China as she crosses L’Écriture Migrant Comparative Essay Neshann Lacuesta the Mekong

Love & War: The Odyssey Vs The Ramayana Comparative Literature Essay

1406 words - 6 pages Rhiannon McCarthy Comparative Literature 358 Second Essay Assignment Word Count: 1392 LOVE & WAR The Odyssey vs. The Ramayana Love is a powerful human emotion as it is able to transcend both time and culture. It is apparent, then, why love is often a theme in literary works including The Odyssey and The Ramayana. Despite having thousands of miles separating the two stories geographically, The Odyssey and The Ramayana have a lot in common. The

A Comparative Essay For Old Man And The Sea Rhhs/ English Essay

1965 words - 8 pages Wei 1 Patrick Wei Mr.Cimetta ENG3UE 23 November 2016 Common People, Real Hero While humanity is overwhelmed by Heracles’ extraordinary physical strength and splendid adventures, the majority of us are just ordinary ones with common ability. It is human’s nature to stay in comfort zone, and make a concession when facing with difficulties. In the beginning of the movie The Secret Life of Walter Mitty the main character Walter Mitty is just an