This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Who Is Most Responsible For The Fall Of Mankind In John Milton's Paradise Lost ? Abingdon Essay

3042 words - 13 pages

Who is most responsible for the Fall of Adam and Eve in Milton’s Paradise Lost Book IX ?
In Paradise Lost John Milton sought to ​“justify the ways of God to man”​, as is noted in the opening
of the Poem adapted from the third book of Genesis. Milton teases the reader, notably in Book
IX, with the culpability for the fall of mankind, and since its publication ,even more so with a
modern readership, this has been greatly debated. While initially one must alleviate God’s
responsibility for the fall of mankind ​in Paradise Lost ​Book IX​ ​ due to Milton’s investment in
typical ecclesiastical doctrine and rejection of determinist lines of thinking, there is no doubt
that the three characters which inhabit the garden of Eden in Book IX, Adam, Eve and Satan
respectively show behaviour that could deposit blame on them. This therefore forces us either
to reconcile 17th century readership of Eve’s responsibility which seemingly is most likely, or
alternatively portion blame either with Adam or with the debased serpentine Satan.
While God is not a noted character in Book IX of ​Paradise Lost​ a select few maintain that
responsibility for the fall of mankind in fact falls on him. It appears however, this must be taken
as a fallacious reading of Book IX, as Milton’s insertion of free will into his understanding of the
Christian God of the Old testament, as far as a reading of the poem is concerned leads to a
recognition of God as an entirely just ruler, who is thus irreproachable. While Milton does not
entirely justify God in book IX, this is due to his previous exculpation of him beforehand in Book
III. The justification Milton grants God in Book III is seemingly synonymous with ideas from his
speech on liberty ​Areopagitica (1644), ​as God states ​“Not free, what proof could they have given
sincere / Of true allegiance” , ​explicitly outlining Milton’s personal theodicy while seemingly
exculpating God from criticisms that might arise. Without Milton’s insertion of such a defense, it
could be argued that God’s omnipotence, omnibenevolence and omniscience ultimately would
deposit blame on him for the fall due to the inability to reconcile suffering in the face of God’s
characteristics, but instead God created man “​sufficient to have stood, though free to fall”, ​again
reinforcing Milton’s belief that as an omnibenevolent being, granting free will is the most loving
thing to do. In ​Paradise Lost​ book IX it appears Eve’s hamartia is ultimately her pride, and
notable arguments have arisen regarding the cause of such pride and ambition displayed in Eve.
As Eve questions ​“for inferior, who is free?”, ​it seems apparent that God’s creation of Eve as an
inferior being created ​‘from the rib of man’ ​partially causes Eve’s predisposition to equalling, or
even surmounting her husband in the Great Chain Of Being. While it can be argued this inquiry
is merely an indication of Eve’s postlapsarian state, adopting a feminist readership could
possibly insinuate God’s...

Other Essays On Who is most responsible for the fall of mankind in John Milton's Paradise Lost ? - Abingdon - Essay

Mockery And Superiority In Canzone: Supported By Areopagitica Examines John Milton's Use Of Mockery And Superiority In The Poem Canzone; Supported By Areopagitica

1210 words - 5 pages indefatigable virtues, I might be justly reckoned among the tardiest and the unwillingest of them that praise ye"(Milton 237). He then presents his idea or side of an argument while continuing to charm, and insinuates that the audience unknowingly has the same opinion as him. Two examples of this are found in Areopagitica: "For he who freely magnifies what hath been nobly done, and fears not to declare as freely what might be done better, gives ye the best

career assessment for anyone who is in need - the university of Memphis scms - business

1200 words - 5 pages taking this assessment is that I share common traits with a zoo vet. In this assessment, independence was one of my biggest strengths. For the most part I do make decisions that revolve around my own believes, however, I am open to ideas and peoples level of perception. Lastly, I do think it’s informative because it was a great presentation of how well rounded I am. I hold some qualities that go beyond the business world. My major is International

The Montague and Capulet are to blame for - Falls Church High School/ English - Who is responsible for Romeo and Juliet's death

895 words - 4 pages is being taxed the more of it that is generated. · By eliminating the capital gains tax it would increase economic growth because it would encourage people to buy and sell more and invest in more businesses without the fear of being taxed for it. · Eliminating this tax would allow average citizens to generate more income because they would be able to buy and sell items to generate more money. · Getting rid of the tax could stop some tax fraud

Paradise Lost on how the Satan manipulates his followers - Lord Randall - Essay

452 words - 2 pages Kelly W, Joyce D Paradise Lost In Paradise Lost, Satan is a character who covers his ambitions with a layer of sweet illusion. Satan is a great leader of the conspiracy; he illustrates fantasies to manipulate his “rebels” to work towards the same goal as him, which is his master plan of revenge and vengeance. When Satan presents his speech to his “followers” in “Hell,” he speaks with influencing emotions such as their “lasting pain.” Having

Who was the most Enlightened Monarch? - AP European History - Essay

797 words - 4 pages he published a book against Niccolò Machiavelli because Machiavelli believed that a king or a prince should do whatever they have to do in order to achieve power and Frederick believed that this was wrong. He got a lot of respect for his book and this is why he was the most respected and liked out of all of the enlightened monarchs. To show even more respect to his people he had a very good religious toleration. During this time period in Europe

Measure for measure; Isabella is the plays most virtuous character, do you agree? - St Kevins - essay

466 words - 2 pages $25,000 AUD. If an economy does not trade with the rest of the world, that is, the economy is a closed economy , and there are no savings, investment, tax or government spending, then, it must be the case that a country’s production, expenditure and income will be of equal value. For example, consider the two-sector (households and firms) model (see below) of a closed economy. In this economy, there are four flows: · flow one (the black solid line

The Ugly Truth: Prohibition of Drugs is a Lost Cause - english 250 - essay

1047 words - 5 pages Talaeai 1 2 Talaeai 5 Aiava Talaeai Dr. Johnson English 251 5 Apr. 2017 The Ugly Truth: Prohibition of Drugs is a Lost Cause People, for many years have said that the War on Drugs is an absolute failure. “With almost a million people in jail, drug use is as widespread as it has ever been” (Miller 23). “Drugs, chemicals and natural substances which affects human body and mind when taken, have been used across the globe for many years” (Isralowitz

How Friar Lawrence Is Responsible For Romeo And Juliet's Death - English 1 honors - essay

487 words - 2 pages her blest, Unworthy as she is, that we have wrought so worthy a gentleman to be her bridegroom?” (3,5,142-145)”This shows us that Capulet is angered that she isn’t thankful for the wedding, when she shouldn’t have been forced in the first place. Lady and Lord Capulet always trying to control Juliet also has a huge effect in the story. If Juliet didn’t feel so controlled because of her parents, she could have told them what was happening and things

How Friar Lawrence Is Responsible For Romeo And Juliet's Death - English honors - essay

487 words - 2 pages her blest, Unworthy as she is, that we have wrought so worthy a gentleman to be her bridegroom?” (3,5,142-145)”This shows us that Capulet is angered that she isn’t thankful for the wedding, when she shouldn’t have been forced in the first place. Lady and Lord Capulet always trying to control Juliet also has a huge effect in the story. If Juliet didn’t feel so controlled because of her parents, she could have told them what was happening and things

The Preservation of Groundwater for Mankind - UCLA / ENGR 185EW - Research Paper

2631 words - 11 pages Le 9 Huy Le ENGR 185EW Session 1B Final Version The Preservation of Groundwater for Mankind With the development of society in recent years, groundwater has become an essential resource that easily accessible in some developed countries specifically in the Central Valley of California. The relying on water resources of mankind makes groundwater a commons which means it is naturally and freely accessible. However, the particular ease of access to

Why the railroad is the most important invention - English - Essay

428 words - 2 pages Steven DeRoche Grade 11, junior Class: Mrs.Roberts Why is the railroad the most important invention during the industrial revolution? How did it shape the world we have today? Well that is the one thing i will discuss in the following paragraphs. The first steam powered locomotive was invented by​ ​Richard Trevithick ​in the year 1804 in great britain. With the start of the industrial revolution there was an increased need for faster

Similar Papers

In Your Opinion, What Is Most Responsible For The Tragedy In Romeo And Juliet?

1663 words - 7 pages There are three key areas that we can look at to see what factors were most responsible for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. These are Fate and Destiny, Circumstances and Characters. These factors should cover the broad spectrum of causes and factors that contribute and perhaps be the most influential in the culmination of the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet.The first group of factors that I am going to look at is the interference of Fate and

Who Is To Blame For The Outcome Of The Crucible English 11 Essay

838 words - 4 pages Branson �1 Grace Branson Tyler Zerbe English Literature 13 September 2018 Who is Really to Blame? Abigail Williams is the pebble that gets the avalanche of the Salem Witch Trials started. Although she is responsible for starting the witch trials, she is not entirely to blame for the outcome of the entire play. Abigail is a cruel and manipulative girl who will do anything to get what she wants and keep herself out of trouble. Abigail did not

Who Is To Blame For The Death Of Romeo And Juliet Grade 10 Essay

756 words - 4 pages into marrying Paris then she would not have committed suicide at the end of the play. There seems to be no particular reason for such a feud yet many people died because of it, including the Romeo and Juliet. Therefore this continuance of rage between Montagues and Capulets is one of the events that is involved in leading Romeo and Juliet to their deaths. It can be said that Romeo and Juliet are partially responsible for their own fate, because

The Heart Is One Of The Most Import Thing In Your Body. Health Essay

457 words - 2 pages Heart Essay (Oxygenation) The heart is your most vital organ and its main job is to pump blood throughout your body. The heart’s job is to replace deoxygenated blood for oxygenated blood. This is a very complicated process that has many pieces working together simultaneously. Starting with deoxygenated blood in the superior vena cava going all the way to the aorta I will begin to illustrate how the oxygenation process occurs. The start of the