Why Our Universe Is The Best Laboratory For Understanding And Determining The Fundamental Physical Laws

2285 words - 10 pages

Cosmology is the study of the origin, current state, and future of our Universe. With recent technological advances, we have been able to probe deeper and deeper into the large scale structure of the vast universe and the small scale structure of matter. Our basis of understanding and determining fundamental physical laws in assumed to be correct when measured locally in laboratory experiments. These laws are verified over and over again so that they can be extrapolated to a distant time and place where they can be investigated with modern astronomical methods. The universe is basically used as a massive laboratory. The universe as defined by Dr. Green, is "everything that can be measured now or at any time in the future." What if our current understanding of the universe is not as perfect as we believe it to be? Our just we being egocentric in assuming that the fundamental physical laws that we have determined locally can apply to the rest of the universe? I am going to discuss why our universe is the best laboratory for understanding and determining the fundamental physical laws and then I will make an argument against this premise using dark matter, dark energy, Standard Candles, and Type 1a supernovae as a basis for discussion.A great reason why our universe is such a good laboratory is that everything is right in front of us; it is just a matter of us looking in the right direction at the right time using the right tools. A standard candle is a term used for an astronomical object, often a star, of well understood intrinsic brightness which enables us to determine cosmic distances (CAS online). If an object can be found whose luminosity you knew absolutely just from looking at it, then by comparing the apparent luminosity with the absolute luminosity, you could figure how far away it was. As the light from a distant object travels to Earth through an expanding universe, the cosmic expansion stretches the distances between galaxy clusters and the wavelengths of the photons emitted from the object. By the time the light reaches us, the spectral wavelength will have been redshifted by exactly the same factor that the universe had been stretched in the time interval since the light left the source. In order to get the time interval, the speed of light (3*10^8 meters/second) must be multiplied by the object's distance from earth. The apparent brightness of the object must then me compared to a local "standard" of the same class of object. When the redshift and brightness of the distant object is recorded, we can see the expansion of the universe since the time the light was emitted (California Academy of Sciences online) In cosmology, Type 1a supernovae are the standard candle of choice because they have a very well determined maximum absolute magnitude as a function of the shape of their light curve. A light curve as defined by the Cyprus Astronomical Society is: "Brightness or intensity of light plotted against time on a graph. Astronomers discover dark stellar companions using the light curve of the star. As a dark orbiting object eclipses the star, the brightness falls, producing a dip on the light curve. Careful analysis of the light curve reveals the masses of the star and dark companion plus the distance to this eclipsing binary system" (Cyprus Astronomical Society online) Using very distant supernovae as standard candles, one can trace the history of cosmic expansion and try to find out what's currently speeding it up.In Edwin Hubble's discovery of cosmic expansion in the 1920's, he used entire galaxies as standard candles. But galaxies are hard to match against standard brightness since they come in many shapes and sizes. They can grow fainter with time or brighter if merged with other galaxies. In the 1970's it was suggested that the brightest member of a galaxy cluster could be used as a standard candle, but in the end it was realized that all of the proposed galactic candidates were too susceptible to evolutionary change (Perlmutter 53) A supernova with no hydrogen features in its spectra had always been classified as Type 1. If a silicon absorption feature was present, it determined if the supernova would be further subdivided into 1a or 1b. When the Type 1a supernovae were studied in greater detail, their light curves and spectra matched. Also, astronomers could tell that the same physical processes were occurring in all of the massive explosions. The type 1a supernovae were studied when they brightened and faded. (Burrows 727 EBSCOhost) With this breakthrough, there was an immediate interest in trying to use them to determine the Hubble constant, which measures the present expansion rate of the universe. This could be done by finding and measuring type 1a supernovae that occurred 100 million years ago just beyond the nearest cluster of galaxies. If a standard candle supernova could be found 10 times further away, we could sample the expansion of the universe several billion years ago and possibly see the expected slowing of the expansion rate from gravity. We would be, in effect, weighing the universe because the deceleration rate would depend on the cosmic mean mass density. The changing expansion rate would also determine the curvature of space and determine if the universe is finite or infinite and if mass density is the primary energy force of the universe as was generally assumed a decade ago. (Perlmutter 53) After many measurements were made and compared of type 1a supernovae, it was evident that there were some major errors in our understanding of the universe. Dozens of distant supernovae appeared surprisingly faint leading to the conclusion that the universe is accelerating disproving the belief that "gravity always wins." We could only do this by making direct measurements on the universe itself.If the universe is in fact accelerating, there has to be some mysterious force causing this. This force has been labeled dark energy by physicists and astronomers. Dark energy would be almost impossible to detect in a local laboratory because of its tiny density and its very weak interactions. The best way to try to understand dark energy would be to thousands of type 1a supernovae. This is exactly what the SuperNova/Acceleration Probe (SNAP) is going to do. SNAP is going to orbit a 3-mirror, 2-meter telescope circling the globe every 14 days. It will discover and accurately measure over 2,000 type 1a supernovae a year. This would be 20 times the amount that was found in a decade of ground-based research. It will have a very wide-field camera with a billion pixels that will collect images hundreds of times larger than its predecessors. Measuring spurts or slowdowns in the expansion history of supernovae will provide an excellent way in understanding dark energy (Preuss online).While using the universe to measure such forces as dark energy may be the best laboratory, at the same time it demonstrates how our understanding of the universe is not perfect. What if we created dark energy so we would not have to face the slight chance that gravity may behave differently on large scales? Gravity is arguably the most important of the 4 known fundamental forces. If we don't even fully understand gravity, how can we justify saying that the universe itself is the best laboratory in understanding and determining fundamental physical laws. Maybe on a large scale structure, gravity acts in a completely opposite way as currently understood by repelling instead of attracting.According to recent results from NASA's Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe 73% of the universe consists of a mysterious dark energy. Because it seems to be a property of space itself, dark energy will grow along with space. When the universe is twice its present age dark energy will comprise 97 percent of the total, rendering matter insignificant. It is believed that "dark energy will ultimately expand our universe, but not our horizons. Due to the fact that light travels at a finite speed, only the light from galaxies within a certain range will have enough time to travel to us. As space grows faster and faster, what we will be able to see of the universe will only be a diminishing fraction of the large whole." (Nadi Diagram 2 EBSCOhost) When the universe is about 10 times its current age, we will only be able to observe objects within a 40 billion light year radius. University of Pennsylvania cosmologist, Max Tegmark theorizes that after about 100 billion years dark energy may decay causing the universe to contract again into a "Big Crunch" (Nadi 42 EBSCOhost) We may not be absolutely certain about the true nature of dark energy, but it proves one thing. We do not understand the fundamental forces of nature as well as we would like. If dark energy is evolving, couldn't the other 4 forces be evolving as well which could possibly give us false measurements when we apply them to large scale structure such as the universe as a whole.Dark matter is another topic which we still are very unclear on even though it is believed to make up 90% of the mass in the universe. Scientists can tell that the matter is there, but they can't see it. Bruce H. Margon, chairman of the astronomy department at the University of Washington, told the New York Times, "It's a fairly embarrassing situation to admit that we can't find 90 percent of the universe." Dark matter has never been directly measured. It has been detected numerous times mainly through gravitational lensing, galaxy rotation, gravitational bonding of clusters of galaxies, and the fact that large scale structures of the universe require a certain amount of mass which is vastly more than we can see from luminous matter. The two main categories that scientists consider as possible candidates for dark matter have been named MACHOs or Massive Astrophysical Compact Halo Objects, and WIMPs or Weakly Interacting Massive Particles. MACHOs are the big, strong dark matter objects ranging in size from small stars to super massive black holes called baryonic matter. They are searched for by astronomers. The two main ways that MACHOs can be detected are through gravitational lensing and circling stars. Gravitational lensing occurs when a massive object such as a galaxy bends light from a more distant object behind it, creating multiple images of the farther object. If the object is heavy enough, the star or galaxy will become measurably brighter. Another way to detect a black hole is to notice the gravitational effect that it has on objects around it. If stars are observed to be circling around something that can't be seen, astronomers will assume there is a black hole causing the circling motion. Particle Physicists search for WIMPs, which are tiny non-baryonic particles that are smaller than atoms. The physicists are trying to directly detect WIMPs by detecting them in a medium that is almost absolute zero. The physicists will be able to detect the WIMP energy by measuring any registered heat. Particle physicists have a chance of directly measuring dark matter unlike the astronomers who can only detect it. If our universe is dominated by matter that we have never measured and we don't even have a true name for, how can the universe itself be the best laboratory in understanding and determining fundamental laws?We are very fortunate to be living in this epoch of a rapid accelerating universe. I think with the proper funding and technology, we will have the capacity to understand our universe much better. Our universe has the capacity to be the best laboratory in understanding and determining fundamental laws, but until we can fully understand darkness of the universe I don't think we can say it is. I agree with the many scientists, astronomers, and physicists, who believe that type 1a supernovae hold the key to understanding our universe. I think our outlook on the universe should be "Carpe Diem," seize the day, or in a cosmologist's term, seize the epoch because if our universe is truly accelerating exponentially then this is our only chance as humans in understanding and determining the fundamental physical laws of the universe.Works Cited1. Burrows, Adam. Nature, "Supernova Explosions in the Universe." February 17 2000, Vol. 403 Issue 6771, p727, 7: EBSCOhost online, December 6, 20032. Powers of Ten Group, California Academy of Sciences, "Standard Candles," January 5, 2003: California Academy of Sciences online, http://www.powersof10.com/, December 6, 2003.3. Cyprus Astronomical Society, "Astronomical Glossery-Standard Candle, Light Curve", 2003: online, http://www.cyprusastronomy.com/Astronomical%20Glossary.html. December 5, 20034. Nadis, Steve; Ford, Holland; Benitez, Narciso; Illingworth, Garth; Clampin, Mark; Hartig, George. Astronomy. "Will Dark Energy Steal All the Stars," March 2003, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p42, p6, 3 diagrams: EBSCOhost online, December 5, 20035. Perlmutter, Saul. Physics Today. "Supernovae, Dark Energy, and the Accelerating Universe." Apr2003, Vol. 56 Issue 4, p 53, 8.6. Preuss, Paul. "Satellite to Unveil Dark Energy that Drives Accelerating Universe," October 2, 2000, Berkely Lab: online, http://enews.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/SNAP-1.html, December 6, 2003.

RELATED

Explain Why The Adversary System Of Trial Is The Best System For Achieving Justice In Criminal Trials?

1168 words - 5 pages Explain why the adversary system of trial is the best system for achieving justice in criminal trials?The adversary system of trial is the best system for achieving justice in criminal trials for a number of different reasons. The use of a jury, the standard of evidence relied upon and the standard of proof, the cross-examining of witnesses and the ability to plead guilty, contribute greatly to reaching justice in the adversary system. They are

Why Halifax is the best city in Canada - NSCC Communications Foundations - Essay

583 words - 3 pages Why Halifax is the best city in Canada Introduction How many of you would rather live in Montreal, Toronto, or any other city right now. Montreal has hockey games, Amusement park, and concerts, and wrestling. Toronto has the Eaton center which is a shopping mall, sports game, the CN tower, and many other things. Those cities along with many others may be a great place to take a trip to for a few days, but I’m going to tell you why Halifax is the

Why Is The Issue Of Gender Important/Unimportant In Understanding International Politics?

1504 words - 7 pages dominant places. This is a tangible understanding, because the men are accustomed to being seen in all spheres of working field. Even here men are more indispensable than women. It is hard for women to find a good job, and the raising of their unemployment is obvious. Women always face with difficulties in finding any job corresponding with their specialties after graduating universities. From nature, women are the mothers and the same time; have to

Essay On The Best

680 words - 3 pages Jennifer R. Lewis Freshman Seminar Assignment 0ne Do you love to party, cut loose, or have a good time? During high school, did you spend your four years having carefree fun? Well if so college is not the place for you.College-secondary education after high school, established to further personal growth and career opportunities. Many students

this is for the county wide laws of life essay, her is my story and maybe you can relate to it too. - north forsyth highschool / literature - essay

493 words - 2 pages Savannah McDowell Laws of Life Essay Going through a traumatic experience at a young age such as i ,16 can alter a child in ways you would never think of. At night when i lay down i think of how my mental status could be if maybe what is going on rn and what has happened to me in the past had not of happened at all.Would i be a normal mentally stable kid who doesn't know what she wasn't supposed to learn yet,i will never have the privilege

The Facebook Data Leak and is it okay for Companies to Sell our Data? - Management Information Systems - Essay

2444 words - 10 pages THE FACEBOOK DATA LEAK AND IS IT OKAY FOR COMPANIES TO SELL OUR DATA? Page 2 The Facebook Data Leak and is it okay for Companies to Sell our Data? Trevor Lineburg West Virginia University Table of Contents Abstract……………………………………………………………….. page 3 Introduction…………………………………………………………… page 4-5 Review of Literature………………………………………………….. page 5-8 Discussion…………………………………………………………….. page 8-9 Conclusion…………………………………………………………….. page 9-10 References

Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets od the Universe Book Essay - QISS - Essay

1009 words - 5 pages conflicting feelings or emotions. Like things happened in Benjamin Alire Saenz’s Aristotle And Dante Discover the Secrets of The Universe. This book’s plot is about Aristotle and Dante who become best friends at the beginning of the book, and then spend the rest of the book going through the trials and tribulations of being teenagers and going through life and finding out who they are and what they want to be. They are exact opposites, they learn

This essay is about best friends and how after 13 years they still can spend so long together and not regret it. MY BEST FRIEND is the title

345 words - 2 pages and held each other when some guy has broken our hearts and even yelled at each others parents. She is as much a part of my family as anyone else, no matter what anyone says. We are best friends and so much more, everyday I am thankful that we found each other so many years ago because neither of our lives have ever been the same.

The debate whether or not globalization is good for our economy - Economics - Essay

927 words - 4 pages without international trade. A large reason why people from all around the world are able to gather in large cities in developed nations is due to Globalization.” Culture is seen as an important factor in our everyday lives, losing it would be heartbreaking.These factors show that is some eyes, cultures are shared, but in others eyes, they are ripped apart. All in all, the idea of globalization and its impact is very complicated. There are so many

Evaluate the contribution of interview research to our understanding of friendship. - Undergraduate Psychology - Essay

1102 words - 5 pages children grew up. This transition from qualitative to quantitative data enabled these developments, which is now regarded as a key foundation of our understanding of friendships and this would not have been possible using a pure interview method as the conclusions could not be drawn from qualitative data. McLeod et al (2008, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) used the method of interviews to investigate the social context and reasoning for smoking and its

Assess the reliability and usefulness of the documentary 'Prelude to War,' in determining the failure of the League of Nations

532 words - 3 pages failures. This documentary is unreliable due to its transparent bias and is reasonably useful in explaining an aspect of one of the key failures of the League.The reliability of this documentary is severely detracted by the one-sided viewpoint and oblivious bias. The documentary was produced by the U.S Army Service Forces in 1943 to 'give factual information as to the causes and events leading up to our entry in to war, and the principles for

The Best Summer

335 words - 2 pages , sometimes it is impossible to work in summer at all for its hot in our city. If I do not have a summer vacation I would be sitting in stuffy office. Why must I spend this precious time on my work? Next, in summer I can spend more time with my little kids because they have a vacation too and it is not optional. Moreover, I can not find enough time for my family during the rest of the year. So the summer is perfect for me to acquit. For example, we have

An Essay Portraying A Basic Understanding Of Bilingualism In Children, Including Definitions, Adavantages And Disadvantages, And Critical Ages In Which Learning Is Best

615 words - 3 pages languages have the same root language. For example, Spanish, French, Italian, and English are all 'Romantic Languages' with roots in Latin. That is a reason that Latin is still taught in highschools and universities across the country: so that we may better understand our own language.

The Correlation Between Physical Appearance And Shyness

3937 words - 16 pages Researchers have hypothesized that behavioral problems are accentuated when a shy person wants to be with other people. This need to be with others--sociability--is a related but separate construct from shyness. The purpose of the present study was to examine the correlation between physical appearance and shyness. Shyness is often a considerable handicap in social and occupational situations, and it can be inwardly distressing. Alfano, Joiner

My Individual Plan For the future - Physical Education - Essay

1050 words - 5 pages for the students to access sport with ease; for example the students have the ability to join in sports that are based on their schedule, they have coaches, equipment and many more opportunities and enablers. But once they leave school it is a lot harder to be involved in sport, as they don’t have these same enablers and opportunities. To make sure I don’t stop playing sports after I graduate I have constructed an individual strategic plan (ISP