Why Plea Bargaining Is Necessary For Court System To Function

1426 words - 6 pages

The Importance of Plea Bargaining in Criminal TrialsScreeech! That is the sound of our court system coming to a grinding halt, if plea bargaining were no longer utilized. Not only does plea bargaining save taxpayers an enormous amount of money, it often provides the evidence for a conviction and allows public defenders and other court officials to concentrate their limited resources on more important or difficult cases. Some people may believe that plea bargaining with criminals is wrong. The entire basis of the argument against plea bargaining says that criminals should not testify or have anything to do with the prosecution because they were involved with the crime. We fail to realize that ...view middle of the document...

In the words of John Stewart Mill, the father of utilitarianism, 'The creed which accepts as the foundation of morals utility, or the greatest happiness principle, holds that actions are right in proportion as they promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness'. This means that in a world of compromise, the most success is achieved by giving the greatest good to the greatest number of people.This belief applies directly to plea bargaining. In this case, the most justice must be given the greatest number of criminals. Currently in the state of New York, 79% of all first degree murder cases are plea bargained. Without plea bargaining, many of these criminals would never even see a jail cell. Barry Kinsey, a sociologist at The University of Tulsa, said 'Without plea bargaining the court's could not function unless there were drastic increases in budget allowance' . The courts are at present full and running over and if all the cases were to be tried the courts budgets would have to be increased by 900% (according to Tom Wallace, a public defender from Baltimore, Maryland).It is also important to consider the length of time that would be required to try every person indicted for a crime. With the courts as over burdened as they are, taking every case to trial could clog up the courts almost indefinitely. Since every person in this country is guaranteed a speedy trial (courtesy of the sixth amendment), banning plea bargaining without tremendous budget increases would violate the constitutional rights of those accused.The affirmative speaker believes that plea bargaining does not reveal thetruth. He has said that there is often lying and inaccurate accounts of thetruth as a result of plea bargaining. I believe that the opposition is wrong. There may be cases where there is lying but every part of the court system will have a little of that. The affirmative speaker has totally contradicted himself. He stated that plea bargaining is when a person admits to his crime and therefore is rewarded with a lighter sentence. Is the affirmative side saying that criminals admit to other crimes than what they have done. It appears to me that he is stating that a person who is charged for a crime is admitting to a totally different crime. Therefore he will be sentenced for that crime and still go through his original trial. Second of all he said that most of the time the actual truth is known, if it is how is this accused person going to lie. I am saying that plea bargaining definitely reaches the truth and that is one reason why it is used because the truth is know and the defendant is simply agreeing with it, therefore the affirmative speaker has no validation for this argument.The speaker also referred to how plea bargaining was inaccurate and unfair.It was stated that plea bargaining...

Other Essays On Why Plea Bargaining Is Necessary For Court System To Function

Dell Case Study, Questions as to why Lead time is so long and suggestions for solutions - Liberty University BUSI740 - Assignment

1991 words - 8 pages desired products increasing the demand for more costing the company more money for product recall (Sarkar et al., 2015). False forecasting is another reason why the costs of L5 are high. Production of chipsets and the demand is unbalanced, and there is a need to meet the order to maintain customer loyalty. The company must therefore strategize and find ways to reduce the lead-time of the chipsets and also cut the freight costs, mainly due to the

Democracy is the only viable system for governing - Both - essay

1225 words - 5 pages upon which democracy is built. Furthermore, democracy is ‘inherently a system of rights’ (Dahl, 1998, p. 48). Democracies, by definition, grant basic political and civil rights to its citizens, so that they may participate fully in the democratic process. For citizens to participate, to hear the ‘voice of the people’, it must therefore be necessary to grant them the right to freedom of assembly that would not be granted within an authoritarian or

to what extent is a model penal system - criminology - essay

936 words - 4 pages deadline has passed and the Senior Tutor has not approved an extension request or if the SSPSSR template has not been use. Things you need to take note of when preparing/writing your essay: 1. Read the question and make sure that you understand what is required. For example, if the question asks you to ‘critically appraise’ then the answer requires you to formulate an argument and make a judgement. You’ll need to illustrate how you came to it by

Why is Bastion Point Significant to New Zealand? - History - Essay

4807 words - 20 pages offer them opportunities for trade, protect them from oversea enemies, provide a sound basis for relations between the races. Other tribes were not as keen to sign the treaty, some not even wanting to sign it. In 1840 Ngati Whatua, the owners of the Auckland isthmus had sold 3000 acres of their traditional lands to the British government, these 3000 acres were to help the thriving community that is now known as Auckland. Orakei was not included

Why football is important to me - Lodi High/ English - essay

1139 words - 5 pages going to go. We told each other that we needed to go in confident and at the top of our game. One of my teammates, Dominic stated, “We could go down in history for this school. We need to make this community and school proud.” As we all left our separate ways for school, all I could think about is the game that night and my teammates. All of us are like family. We push each other in school, sports, and outside of school. We were all very close

Why Say "Yes" To Reparation for Slavery - College Writing - Essay

1956 words - 8 pages falling textbook because it will remind them of the shooting gunshot in the middle of the jungle. Same goes to African American, nothing is more important than making up for the crimes American had created centuries ago. “American slavery embraced the depravities of theft, rape, torture, and murder. When it ended, something not completely unlike it followed.”(Randall Robinson, NYT). In the article, “Ten Reason Why Reparation For Blacks Is A Bad

adoption system and why it needs to change - pshs - research paper

634 words - 3 pages here till we have ten dollars.” Everyone in the congregation will pitch in. The reason for doing so is too important, and the reverend is being forceful. No need to upset the preacher while in the house of the Lord. (Making a prediction) Calpurnia p. 165 “I just have it on Christmas, it’s easier to remember that way—I don’t have a real birthday.” What is Cal’s approximate age? (Asking a question) Calpurnia p. 167 “It’s not necessary to tell all

Daisy Miller, by Henry James: (I) To what extent is Daisy Miller's character a reflection of the American character? (II) Was Henry James' ending artistically necessary?

495 words - 2 pages complete antithesis of the stuffy Mrs. Walker, whose social traditions are so deeply imbued that it leaves no room for compromise within her Old World character. While Mrs. Walker represents the graceful sophistication and controlled demeanor of the European aristocracy, Daisy's boundless energy exudes from her body, carelessly spilled as she flounders here, frolics there.It is precisely this unrestrained energy that leads to Daisy's demise. If

trademark is a common problems between companies. wherefore Asda will be taken to the high court because of the claiming which Specsavers make it against it.

572 words - 3 pages Untitled summary trademark is a common problems between companies. wherefore Asda will be taken to the high court because of the claiming which Specsavers make it against it. The problem start when Azda ran an online and in-store advertisement claiming: "Be a real specs saver at Asda." Which considered by Specsavers as distortion of the company's reputation. The other object was the elliptical shapes which Azda use it

Why Our Universe Is The Best Laboratory For Understanding And Determining The Fundamental Physical Laws

2285 words - 10 pages laws that we have determined locally can apply to the rest of the universe? I am going to discuss why our universe is the best laboratory for understanding and determining the fundamental physical laws and then I will make an argument against this premise using dark matter, dark energy, Standard Candles, and Type 1a supernovae as a basis for discussion.A great reason why our universe is such a good laboratory is that everything is right in front of

Why is blood work such an amzing things for - lehman college - ajhk

3591 words - 15 pages using the previous techniques. Only ONE presumptive test for blood is necessary to determine if your sample is consistent/not consistent with blood. Record your observations in the data sheet provided. 4. Compare your evidence results to the results obtained with known samples to make your identification. Then answer the group questions. 5. Make a conclusion regarding the identity of the unknown associated to your piece(s) of evidence and report

Similar Papers

To What Extent Is Evidence Based Care Necessary For Providing Effective Care?’ Undergraduate Essay

1758 words - 8 pages judicious use of current best evidence in conjunction with clinical expertise and patients values to guide health care decisions. (The Open University 2018) In answering the question ‘To what extent is evidence-based care necessary for providing effective care’ I shall look the advantages and disadvantages of evidence-based care and try to explain its place in our current healthcare system. Also, how research in used order to inform practice, ensure

Explain Why The Adversary System Of Trial Is The Best System For Achieving Justice In Criminal Trials?

1168 words - 5 pages criminal trials, the adversary system is the best system for accomplishing justice.Legal representation- small paragraph. Case studyThe adversary system is the best system for achieving justice in criminal trials because of its use of several different elements. These elements combine to produce an effective and working system that provides justice to a majority of cases and instances. The implementation of plea bargaining, the standard of proof and

Compulsory Voting Is Not Necessary For Democracy Jcu Law Speech

1871 words - 8 pages feel the need to go out and earn peoples votes. They now rely on the compulsory voting system, which guarantees them a vote by default. In conclusion, a right is not a right if we are unable to choose whether or not to exercise it. This is why the right to vote is no longer a right and has become a duty, all for the sake of voters’ participation rates. Compulsory voting gives off an illusion of democratic legitimacy, as democratic legitimacy

Rogerian Argument: Is It Necessary To Go To College? Baylor University/Eng 1304 Essay

990 words - 4 pages Richards 2 Kendy Richards Dr. Hanchey ENG 1304 16 February 2017 Is It Necessary To Go To College? The question of whether or not attending college benefits one’s livelihood plagues many young adults. It becomes something every person must ask themselves at some point in their life. Many people today believe going to college plays a necessary role in preparing you for the next phase of your life. They argue that most jobs require a college