Why Should We Have A State Or Why Shouldn't We? Politics And International Relations Essay

1517 words - 7 pages

Rebecca Smith
Why should we have a state or why shouldn’t we?
Module: Introduction to Political Ideas PO1IPI
Andrew Levine defines a state as ‘regimes that invest supreme authority over particular territories or populations in a unified set of coercive institutions.’[footnoteRef:1] There are various arguments for and against having a state, however, those that are in favour of a state appear to be more convincing. The protection that the state can offer its citizens and examples of the stateless societies throughout history convey how society is better off in the form of a state. This argument has been backed up by Liberal and Pluralist theorists who argue that the state is neutral and offers a balance of power between differing groups in society. Despite persuasive arguments against the state by Neo-pluralist and Marxist theorists of anarchism and a lack of consent by citizens to the state, the arguments by those in favour of a state appear to be the dominant. Thomas Hobbes puts forward a strong justification for the existence of a state in his work ‘Leviathan’, where he sets out the idea that political obligation is necessary in order for society to function properly and for stability to be maintained. [1: A. Levine, ‘Political Keywords’, Wiley, 2007]
Firstly, some argue in favour of the state due to the protection that it offers its citizens. ‘We forfeit the right to protect ourselves as the state will do what is necessary for us.’[footnoteRef:2] This can be viewed as the ideal situation that a country could be in, however, in many cases states do not live up to this; states often fail to protect their citizens – for instance, many states ignore the needs of unfavoured ethnic minorities, as was the case in the alleged ethnic cleansing in Kosovo in 1999 in which the former Yugoslavian government planned to expel the Albanian population of the state through inhumane measures.[footnoteRef:3] The failure of protection in some states has led to citizens having a lack of faith in the state that is supposed to shield them – for example, in the US, ‘citizens claim the right to own guns in self-defence.’[footnoteRef:4] This is a clear example of how no state can monopolise force and therefore will inevitably fail in their key responsibility as a state. Although this could be an argument for why we shouldn’t have a state, they still do offer more protection than having no state at all, even if it is only minimal at times. Moreover, examples of stateless societies exhibit why society is best off in the form of a state as it provides stability making it less likely of a breakdown in society.[footnoteRef:5] A state can collapse when its claim to exercise sovereign power is successfully challenged by another group or body. Examples of this include the stateless societies of the Lebanon in the 1980’s and what was Yugoslavia in the early 1990’s; both countries display the chaos that can erupt in a state, supporting the argument in favour of a state. [2: J....

Other Essays On Why should we have a State or why shouldn't we? - Politics and International Relations - Essay

Why We Should Care About Deforestation - SVMS - Assignment

1028 words - 5 pages and have larger and more complex brains. They are humans. The other category;plants, are very different from this. All living things that are not humans or animals including algae and fungi, are treated as plants. They get most of their energy from sunlight via photosynthesis. Because of human activities, we are losing our trees at a rapid rate and if we don’t do something about it, soon we’ll have no more trees left. Deforestation has become a

Marriage equality: What we have done and how far do we still have to go - College - Essay

1216 words - 5 pages the legalization of gay marriage. According to Blake Ellis of CNN gay marriage is generating millions of dollars for New York City's economy. “Since gay marriage was legalized in New York state a year ago, marriage license fees, local celebrations and wedding-related purchases have boosted New York City's economy by $259 million,” Ellis continued by saying “More than 8,200 same-sex marriage licenses have been issued over the past year

ADHD - SHOULD WE BE MEDICATING CHILDREN - ESSAY

1688 words - 7 pages afflicted with the disorder have also been found to have an unusual imbalance or lack of, the message-transmitting chemicals present in the brain, the 'neurotransmitters' (Green & Chee, 1995).The link between genetics producing differences in a child's neurobiology and the cause of ADHD can be seen through the fact that the frontal lobe region of the brain as well as the neurotransmitters in the brain (e.g. Dopamine), play vital roles in the

whether we should ban the cigarettes or not - MLC - cigarettes

959 words - 4 pages , you and me, the poor, innocent non-smokers have to inhale tobacco every day and hurt ourselves, then why not making the cigarettes a little bit expensive? The smokers should undertake the price of what they do to our body. Now let’s take a long-term view, increasing the taxes on cigarettes is going to beneficial the society as well. After our previous discussion I believe everyone now knows how awful cigarettes are, either for the smokers or non

do you agree we now have a global economy? justify your answer - social sciences - essay

946 words - 4 pages   poverty and inequality higher, Gap between rich and poor wider,  South and north hierarchy,  exploitation and resource wars   Is their a global economy or more room for exploitation on a larger scale. Carrying on legacy of colonialism and feudal structures, does history repeat itself in with modern means. Global economy we may have but the view of the poor or even developing countries may be worth taking into account.

Should We Keep Columbus Day as a Federal Holiday? - History - Essay

972 words - 4 pages Should We Keep Columbus Day as a Federal Holiday? Columbus Day, held on the second Monday of October, honors Christopher Columbus, an Italian-born explorer who discovered America on his voyage to find a sea route to Asia for Spain (Columbus video). Columbus Day is one of only ten federal holidays, and is only one of two named for a specific individual (Gavin, 2004). Many honor him as a hero for “discovering” America, but really, is he the man we

What should we do about plastic waste - Science - Essay

673 words - 3 pages greater problem because the more plastic people use and discard of the more likely it is that we will eventually end up destroying our environment Most people don’t realize that plastic can have such a negative impact on our world. People don’t realize that they are destroying our environment, when they use a lot of plastic materials. Plastic accumulation in the environment create a big problem one of them is that it creates a problem for wildlife

Should we have one world currency - social studies - social studies, one world currency

594 words - 3 pages Running head: [SHORTENED TITLE UP TO 50 CHARACTERS] 1 Should We Have One World Currency? [SHORTENED TITLE UP TO 50 CHARACTERS] 2 What would you think if the whole world had on currency? Would you think easier trade? More imported goods. Or maybe you would think that this hurts our economies. Well in this essay I am going to tell you why I think international currency is a good thing even though it could cost a lot it makes an ease in

To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? - English Lit - ESSAY

2891 words - 12 pages ESSAY 5: To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? Oscar Wilde’s first, and only, novel published in 1890 in Lipincott’s Magazine. Despite the censorship that the editor made unbeknownst to Wilde, his text still largely offended its bourgeoisie audience due to its critique on moral sensibility and public morality in the upper-class society. Wilde, irrefutably, includes many stereotypical conventions and

Should We Spend Money For Zoos

907 words - 4 pages We should spend money for Zoos and national parks.Zoos play a fundamental role in the conservation of endangered and threatened species all over the world. Aside from breeding endangered animals, conservation consists of the rescue and preservation of existing animals. In tropical rainforests alone, we lose 100 species every day, 4 species per hour, due to tropical deforestation. At current rates, 5 - 10% of tropical forest species will become

US should participate in the International Criminal Court - San Francisco State and IR 308 - Argumentative paper

2612 words - 11 pages US actions because as we all know, there’s a reason why many countries hate us due to our overly selfish actions. United States should be a country that values the importance of justice not a country that protects its own criminals in fear of exposure. At the the time of the ratification, the United States opted out of the Bush administration had many reserves in regards the ramifications and the role of the ICC in its legal and judicial

Similar Papers

Why Should We Help? Essay

486 words - 2 pages Americans. Germany knew that the ship secretly carried arms and had warned America ahead of time. In spite of this tragedy president Wilson continued to believe that Americans should not be restricted from travelling the seas. During this time Wilson got re-elected president of the US with a major campaign slogan being "he kept us out of war".In 1917 a German official named Arthur Zimmerman proposed that Mexico allied itself with Germany and that

Why We Have An Imagination Essay

457 words - 2 pages thinking of what we can only see, smell, touch, taste, and hear.Our imagination gives us many abilities. It gives us the ideas for stories, theories, technology, and many other things that may or may not be able to become realities, but always take us into a realm of exploration. The accomplishments of the imaginations of many people have been amazing. Without imaginations we wouldn't have books, cars, space crafts, hair cuts, and the list goes on

Why We Should All Stop Smoking

589 words - 3 pages Why we should all stop smokingIt's obvious that we are all aware that smoking harms your body. So why do people continue to smoke cigarettes? Maybe they do it because subconsciously you have not yet been hurt by it. There are so many reasons why you should not smoke. Some of theses reasons include health risks, all of the money you spend, and when you do smoke, you are not respecting those around you.It is a fact that smoking affects your health

Why Do We Have So Much Traffic In Miami Miami Dade Coll Ege/Composition Argumentative Essay

507 words - 3 pages Why do we have so much traffic in Miami? The 2017 Global Traffic Scorecard ranked Miami 12th among U.S. cities where the drivers spend more hours in a traffic jam. About 64 hours during the rush hours with the economic cost of approximately $2,072 per driver annually. Many are the causes of this issue, and as regular driver Miami’s fast – growing population, inadequacy of the public ‘s city transportation system, and the rudest behavior of