Compairing Psychoanalytic Theory In The Yellow Wallpaper And The Cask Of Amontillado English Essay

1445 words - 6 pages

COMPAIRING PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY IN THE YELLOW WALLPAPER AND
THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO
Being depressed and seeking revenge can entice a person to a point where they have gone
insane and are so inebriated by the enchantment that they are unable of either realizing their
madness or opposing the temptation. As a result, their feeling of reality has been changed to the
final turning point. Although at first, it might seem as though The Yellow Wallpaper and The
Cask of Amontillado have very few similarities. The conflict, setting and the life experiences of
Poe and Gilman’s life influences both of their protagonist from a Psychoanalytic Perspective.
Firstly, the narrator The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Gilman and The Cask of
Amontillado by Edgar Allan Poe have psychiatric problems caused by person vs. person and
person vs. self conflicts. For instance, the narrator of The Yellow Wallpaper is in person vs.
person conflict with her husband for locking her up in a room against her will "I don't like our
room a bit…But John would not hear of it"(Gilman, 648). Both protagonists are in conflict with
the antagonist which soon caused them to descend even deeper into their mental illnesses.
Accordingly, the narrators also suffer from a person vs. self conflict, where they are in dispute
with their inner thoughts. A prominent example of this is In The Cask of Amontillado. His
revenge plot did not give him the immediate sense of satisfaction he was hoping to receive.
Furthermore, I think Montressor was about to die when he told this story, he has been paranoid
all his life for the crime he has committed and was haunted by Fortunato last words, “Montresor,
for the love of God!”(Poe, 5). This situation pushes me to believe that Montressor felt guilty for
what he has done and wanted to confess his sins before he dies. After a period, these conflicts
began to create insecurities that cause their illnesses. In The Yellow Wallpaper, the protagonist
feels as if she has been replaced as John’s wife. Her husband has replaced her with a new woman
to take care of their babies named Mary “It is fortunate Mary is so good with the baby.” (Gilman,
649). Furthermore, in The Cask of Amontillado, Montresor portrays a sign of severe insecurities.
Fortunato “...had laughed at my proud name, Montresor, the name of an old and honored family”
(Poe, 68) and needed to pay. Therefore, seeking to murder somebody who threatened your social
class, shows he is a very insecure man. These ideas support the indisputable fact that both
protagonists have several conflicts which influence them to descend into madness.
Secondly, both short stories have settings that are relatively different. However, these
settings are vital for they impact the characters psychoanalytically, and help with the
advancement of the plot. Ultimately, the setting in The Cask of Amontillado is necessary for it
takes place underground during the night which plays a significant role in the story. The dramatic
scene of...

Other Essays On COMPAIRING PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY IN THE YELLOW WALLPAPER AND THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO - English - Essay

The Yellow Wallpaper Book Analysis - Grad 12 English - Essay

1580 words - 7 pages Candelaria 1 Aeron John Candelaria March 30 2018 ENG 4U1 Ms. Bucciacchio “The Yellow Wallpaper”: The Gender Lens A short story of Charlotte Perkins Gillman, “The Yellow Wallpaper” invokes both caution and wakefulness for women who were diagnosed with nervous depression and prescribed rest for recuperation. A tale that was set in an English ancestral hall where the narrator and her husband, John, spend the rest of the summer to recover on her

The Theme in the Yellow Wallpaper - Blinn College - Essay

1801 words - 8 pages Situ 7 Haoneng Situ Professor Almanza ENGL 1302 Sec N07 1 March 2018 The Miserable Truth That Builds on the Hallucination —Women’s Subordinate Role in “The Yellow Wallpaper” Human is the product of time. Human’s thought, consciousness, and behavior are inseparable from the times. During the late nineteenth-century, women suffered from the ideology of separate spheres and the rash of hysteria (Wilson 283); they were in a subordinate position of

perseverance in the yellow wallpaper - harry ainaly high school - essay

620 words - 3 pages Children’s Program Coordinator – Early Start Temporary Full Time Norwood Child & Family Resource Centre provides programs that strengthen and enrich the lives of children and parents in the Edmonton area. Programs are delivered using a holistic approach to support the emotional, physical and intellectual needs of children and families in the community. Reporting to the Children’s Program Manager, the Children’s Program Coordinator provides

Love as a destructive force in Othello and Enduring Love, and The Yellow Wallpaper. - A Level - Essay

3530 words - 15 pages 2 Laura Rumgay Main Essay Laura Rumgay Main Essay Title :Describe how love acts as a destructive force in Othello and Enduring Love, and The Yellow Wallpaper. Introduction: Word Count: 186 This essay asks and answers the complex question ‘Which depiction of love as a destructive force is most powerful?” By comparing and contrasting several texts in addition to referencing others with similar themes, we are able to explore the theme of love and

The Yellow Wallpaper Setting Essay - UW Whitewater - Setting Essay

1707 words - 7 pages Syverson Nicholas Syverson Professor Moran English 101 19 October 2018 The Yellow Wallpaper Setting Essay In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s gothic short story, The Yellow Wallpaper, she uses the settings to illustrate the deteriorating progression of the narrator’s sanity throughout the text. When the narrator first sees the house, she loves it. She thinks the house will be a perfect place to recover from her "nervous depression," but that does not

Trapped Between the Walls of The Yellow Wallpaper - ACC Comp 2 - Analysis Essay

1279 words - 6 pages . Women were treated as second class people in society during this period. Charlotte Perkins Gilman, an ingenious woman, boldly describes the thought process of the society she lived in during the time period in which she wrote “The Yellow Wallpaper”. Using a feminist outlook, one can analyze “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman with both a male and female point of view. Firstly, to examine “The Yellow Wallpaper” through a male’s

Freudian Theory in Lord of the Flies - English 30S - Essay

1412 words - 6 pages Freudian Theory in Lord of the Flies In the story, Lord of the Flies, the exemplification of Freud's Theory of the Id, Ego and Superego looks at different characters throughout the story. Freud primarily agrees with the idea that there are two energies that derive human behaviour. These two energies are the pleasure principle and aggression. The human mind is comprised of the conscious, preconscious and the unconscious. Within these realms of

Character In "The Yellow Wallpaper" By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

1587 words - 7 pages freedom she looked for. The yellow wallpaper which covered the room disturbed her greatly. At the beginning of the story she hated the color. 'The color is repellent, almost revolting, ..Dull...I should hate it myself I had to live in this room long.'(508) Through this the woman expresses her feelings towards the room, but specifically the wallpaper. Throughout her stay at the house and as the oppression sets in even greater, she begins to see

Analysis of the Yellow Wallpaper - massasoit community college - analysis

813 words - 4 pages Last Name 1 Last Name 2 Maidea Pro Sanati English 102 33 April 10, 2018 “The Yellow Wallpaper” Analysis The “Yellow Wall Paper” is a beautifully well- crafted manuscript published in the 1892 by a brilliant writer called Charlotte Perkins Gilma. It captures all the eccentrics of it era. This book puts forth a lot of valid points that can be argued, but for fulfilling my requirements, I will focus on sharing light on how women were disparaged

The Yellow Wallpaper Via American Horror Story

678 words - 3 pages Harmon family moves into a new mysterious house that takes advantage of the family, especially the wife, Vivien. In The Yellow Wallpaper," the wife projects herself as a woman "trapped" in the wallpaper, which is similar to the numerous souls trapped in the house and Vivien's feeling of the houses possession over her. Also in both the short story as well as the show the husband and wife are portrayed in parallel ways, experiencing androcentric themes

The Return of Yellow Journalism - Spokane Community College, English 102 - Causal Essay

910 words - 4 pages Wardell Henderson Amie Schaumberg English 102 October 5, 2018 Causal Essay (Draft) Why has trust in law enforcement decreased among America’s citizens of color? America has had a long, painful and hidden history of police brutality. America's first police and law enforcement officials were slave catchers, which had no police training or instruction what so ever, just unscrupulous individuals that made a living hunting down slaves who were only

Similar Papers

Subordination Of Women In The Yellow Wallpaper College English Essay

1223 words - 5 pages Talley 4 Elizabeth Talley Mrs. Turk English 1302.2 11 November 2017 The Subordination of Women in The Yellow Wallpaper For centuries, women have been viewed as helpless and simple minded by the controlling patriarchal society. In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wallpaper,” the narrator is being confined in her bedroom by her husband, John, who is a physician and believes she is suffering from temporary nervous depression. He

Discuss The Use Of Setting In The Yellow Wallpaper Bournemouth University/English Ba Essay

1168 words - 5 pages Patrick Bird – s5070931 Patrick Bird s5070931 BA English – Forms and Context Discuss the use of setting in The Yellow Wallpaper Total Word Count – 1.164 The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman is a story about one woman’s descent into madness owing to post-natal psychosis after the birth of her child. In this essay, I will be examining the use of setting and analysing how it ties into the story and the characters. In terms of setting

Literary Analysis On The Comparison Of The Yellow Wallpaper And Shiloh Georgia Highlands English 1102 Essay

926 words - 4 pages Doe 1 Doe2 John Doe Professor xxxx English 1102 March 10, 2018 Controlling Homophone Men Primarily, John from “The Yellow Wallpaper” authored by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Leroy Moffitt from “Shiloh” authored by Bobbie Ann Mason appear completely opposite from one another. John the narrators husband works as a physician who solely trusts things he can actually apprehend, while Leroy is a lost soul confused in his past, looking for a motive in

Research Paper On Cask Of Amontillado English 101 Essay

1162 words - 5 pages that it symbolizes the cause of the whole story, in that Montresor has been insulted by Fortunato, and in order to defend his family motto, he is going to take revenge upon Fortunato by killing him (Womack). Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado” is a heart-wrenching story heavily influenced by his use of Gothic stylistic writing. This Gothic style of writing contributes to several themes and other English elements within the story. Of these various themes, the one that saturates the story as a whole is the theme of revenge, which Edgar Allan Poe uplifts with his particular use of both direct and indirect factors.