An Examination Of Two Modern Interpretations Of Shakespeare's `a Midsummer Night's Dream.'

1970 words - 8 pages

Modern theatres and audience expectations are very different to the expectations of Shakespeare's time. Shakespeare's Globe Theatre was rediscovered on the South Bank in 1989 which, at the time, was an entirely different experience of any theatre we know today. There was no roof, no cushioned seats, and most of the audience would be standing in a circular space on the floor, whilst cheering on the actors, like fans at a football match. Modern theatre audiences watch the play silently in respect to others and sit comfortably, admiring a radiant stage with professional actors dressed up to scratch and realistic props which take the audience into another world. Whereas, at The Globe, theatre expeactations were very different. The audience depended upon good weather and sunlight to enhance the enjoyment of watchting the play. Only the affordable would sit in the tiers surrounding the edge of The Globe, onlooking the stage with very few props basic costumes and no background. However, the audience were still taken away, but by the visualative words which created a sense of escapism.In Shakespeare's Globe, the audience expectation was very different from todays. The audience did not expect realism from the props and believed anything. For example when Oberon states, `I am invisible,' which is how Shakespeare painted the scenery with his words without the use of camouflaged costumes or blending backdrops. These days, the audience expect much more than just words.Other detail such as stage directions also affect the audience expectations of today. A modern playwright brings much more detail compared to Shakespeare's stage directions. This can be seen from the play `Death of a Salesman,' written by Arther Miller. The first page of the play is filled with stage directions. For example, `the flute plays on. He hears it but is not aware of it,' shows some extent of the detailed instructions a modern playwright uses compared to Shakespeare who used simplicity in his stage directions. Instead of details, he used straight forward instructions such as, `Enter Puck.' Detailed stage directions were not necessary because Shakespeare would have been there at the time telling the actors what to do, and how to do it.Due to the lack of stage directions telling us exactly how Shakespeare imagined his play, modern playwrights must draw up their own interpretations of the play. They can do this through their own choice of actors, lighting, music, effects and direction. As a result of the lack of detail from the original text and wide choice of variations, interpretations can be very different.Shakespeare's `A Midsummer Night's Dream,' is a comedy which shares many similarities to another famous Shakespeare play, `Romeo and Juliet.' They both begin the same with `two star crossed lovers' who were fated in the stars to be together and whose parents disapproved of them being together. In `A Midsummer Night's Dream,' the moon is frequently mentioned by the characters, `Methinks how slow this old moon wanes; she lingers my desires,' the moon being associated with madness throughout the play. In `Romeo and Juliet,' the stars are regularly referred to in a similar manner.The play `A Midsummer Night's Dream' has been interpreted in many different ways. In two of these interpretations, there are very many similarities projected in very different ways. One interpretation is the BBC version directed by Jonathan Miller. The second is the 1998, Twentieth Century Fox version, directed by Michael Hoffman.In the BBC version, the play starts off with Theseus and Hippolyta, who look quite old for a married couple. Hippolyta's tan and hair style suggests that she does look foreign. Theseus and Hippolyta did not seem to be in love and she looked disgusted. Egeus, Hermia, Demetrius, and Lysander are all discussing Egeus's disapproval of his daughter's lover. Helena, who is supposed to be blond and fair, is actually ginger, ugly and has glasses! There is hardly any movement which suggests nobility. There is also hardly any lighting and the atmosphere is dull and dark. The scene did not contain any special effects. In the scene, they were sitting in English Castle- like setting. Although the play was intended to be situated in Athens, Shakespeare would not have been there so he would not have any idea of what it looked like, so he may have intended the play to be in this setting. The room was a library or a study and looked very formal. Theseus was seated for this scene and he was an educated, rich learned man. The room was very dark, with little natural light coming from the windows. The use of the darkened set added prominence to the actors, because the rest of the set was dull. Despite the fact that the play was situated in Athens, the dull coloured costumes were from the Elizabethan period. They were probably modern dressed for Shakespeare's time.The Twentieth Century Fox Version was situated in Italy at the turn of the 19th century. This version of act 1 scene 1, was very different to the BBC version. In the background, there is classical joyous music being played, and lit up fairies fly about which are seen in the film later on. The scene started off with a lot more movement. There was preparation for the Duke's wedding who looked in his forties or fifties. Hippolyta, who looked in her thirties, and Theseus were very much in love compared to the other version. Hermia was pretty, as intended and so was Helena, who had long blond hair and was `fair'. The costumes were more bright and colourful. They were Italian costumes from the 1900's. Theseus and Hippolyta talk in an office or study about their wedding. Theseus talks to Hippolyta, the Queen of the Amazons, by using a lot of war like imagery when he speaks. For example, `with pomp, triumph, and revelling.' The general tone of this scene is that it has more excitement, more liveliness and brightness.Act 1, scene 2 of the BBC version is the gathering of Quince, Bottom, Snug, Flute, Snout and Starveling in a pub or café rehearsing for a play for the wedding. Quince, who is in charge of organising, is very down to earth and serious. Bottom appears to be full of himself, and is always interrupting rudely. Quince asks `Is all our company here?' and Bottom replies, `You were best to call them generally, man by man according to the script.' They are all wearing very simple clothes, putting forward the idea that they are working class men. Although there is hardly any movement in this scene compared to the film, it is the most lively scene in this version so far.In the 1998 film version, many new ideas are put forward. For example, instead of just getting on with rehearsing the play, they turn it into a competition. Bottom flirts with another woman, despite him having a wife. During his flirtatious moments, his wife sees what he does and gives him evil looks. This gives an insight of what Bottom is really like and is all cleverly acted to music being played. Also Bottom creates a scene because of his loud and vain actions. Children spill water over his head and everyone laughs at him. The director creates sympathy for the character and he makes the audience like Bottom, compared to the other version, where Bottom is seen as simply irritating, but funny. The new ideas have all been put forward without the use of adding in extra text, also his wife is not mentioned in the text. The director has deviated from what Shakespeare would have intended the play to be like, because he did not include his wife, the sympathy for the character, or the competition. We know that it has been deviated, otherwise, Shakespeare would have included it in his stage directions. However, it may be similar to what he intended because Shakespeare would have been there at the time so he could have improvised scenes during the practices. In this scene as opposed to the scene in the other version, you can actually tell that Quince is supposed to be in charge because he is louder, more enthusiastic and takes more control over Bottom. The position on the soliloquy is changed to after the rehearsals as a reminder for the viewers of the other plot. In this scene there is generally more camera movement showing people in their everyday lifestyles and exaggerated movement to make it funnier. Also the use of malapropism adds to the comedy, for example, when Bottom interrupts Quince yet again, 'I'll speak in a monstrous little voice, `Thisne, Thisne!' in line 55. The malapropism where he tells them to `rehearse more obscenely and courageously,' in line 111 shows his stupidity.Act II, scene I, of the BBC version starts off with three fairies along with Puck in the woods at night. It is dark, but the moon lights up their faces. They are going round in circles, talking amonst each other. At this point, Puck is inevitably seen as mischeivious. `Sometimes for the three- foot stool mistaketh me; Then slip I from her bum, down topples she,' says Puck to the fairy on line 52. Oberon and Titainia, King and Queen of the fairies are fighting. There is hardly any movement, however the voices and expressions liven it up. They wear creative costumes in a magical yet dull, angry atmosphere. There is no music or sounds other than howling in the background. In the Twentieth Century Fox version, Puck is much more older and the rest of the characters are very attractive. Puck and the first fairy were drunk since Theseus was getting married and wanted everyone to be happy. This added to the comedy. Oberon, played by Rupert Everett in this version, is much younger than the BBC version. Thunder bolts and lightening occur when Oberon enters, this is because they `square', then Titania played by Michelle Pfeiffer, places her finger over her lips and all goes calm. There are spectacular special effects in this scene when the thunder strikes rocks and alights them. However, this is not what Shakespeare would have intended because there were no facilities at the time and also the audience expectation came from the words.The set is illuminated by the fire. The use of SFX throughout the scene in this film shows the power of the fairies associated with nature. Titania and Oberon wear very creative costumes and are dressed like Kings and Queens. In this scene, there is much more movement and the atmosphere is less tense and more comical.As an overall view, I prefer the Hoffman version, firstly because it is more livelier together with more action, and secondly because I believe Shakespeare should be accessible for everyone and eventually original Shakespeare will die out if it is not updated to suit modern tastes. Shakespeare would have not intended his play to be like many of the modern interpretations of today, as stage directions were not given so he would have his own setting in his mind, however, the modern directors of these interpretations can come up with how the scene was supposed to look like because of the words from the original play. This is one reason to how Shakespeare may have intended the play to be like the modern film interpretation.

RELATED

Book Cover Assessment For Shakespeare's Plays - "A Midsummer Night's Dream" And "Merchant Of Venice"

591 words - 3 pages play Merchant of Venice because it has lots of implications about the setting and the characteristics of main characters of the play are well displayed in the picture.In "A Midsummer Night's Dream", fight of love among people takes place throughout the story in the forest. Hermia, Helena, Lysander, and Demetrius try to seek for their own love in the woods. Even though the seriousness of love is relatively high, they get the relax they need between

A Midsummer Night's Dream: The Concept of Dreaming - English - Essay

941 words - 4 pages and mysterious. The concept of fairies and magic flowers falls right into the ‘dream’ theme of A Midsummer night’s dream as the concept of fairies and magic flowers, could only fit in dreams of the Athenian citizens and the audiences themselves as it would be too weird or even insane to consider it as reality. With characters falling asleep, the magic and supernatural make up an even bigger distinguishment between reality and dreams as when we

An Examination Of "O" The Movie: A Modern Adaptation Of Shakespeare's Othello

1936 words - 8 pages states that service should outweigh connections and courtly manner and devises a plan to trick Othello into believing his wife is unfaithful, to benefit Rodrigo. He also includes Cassio in the ploy as Desdemona's "lover" to incriminate him to Othello as well and ruin his credibility and allow Iago a chance to take his position as lieutenant of the army.It is proven in this text that Iago is an old fashioned thinker. Although he is jealous of

Imagination in Don Quixote and A Midsummer Night's Dream - Kean University English 2403 - Essay

1892 words - 8 pages Maria Veligurskaya English 2403/World Literature October 27, 2017 Formal Essay No. 1 “Imagination in Don Quixote and A Midsummer Night's Dream” William Shakespeare and Miguel de Cervantes are two of the most influential writers in the world that have been compared by scholars for centuries. It is commonly believed that the two men died on the same day, April 23, 1616. However, that is not entirely accurate as England followed the Julian calendar

Comedic Intent in A Midsummer Night's Dream - Penrith High School - Essay

1024 words - 5 pages Free Gender Inequality in a Midsummer Night’s Dream Gender inequality is effectively explored through Shakespeare’s use of comedy because it is conveyed and challenged from the start to the end of the play. In a Midsummer Night’s Dream, Shakespeare uses comedy to effectively enhance and explore gender inequality in the beginning of the play to bring forward different opinions and unknown ideas without being considered offensive. He does this by using

Midsummer Night's Dream Critique - English 9th grade - essay

463 words - 2 pages Many aspects of the play, Much Ado About Nothing, seemed very enjoyable and worthy of recognition. Other parts of the play seemed unnecessary. The main focus points of this critique will be on the setting and lighting, the actors’ and actresses’ performances, and the conclusion of the action. The setting and lighting of the play were particularly enjoyable. The modern setting allowed the viewer to identify with the actors and plot. Color and

Theme Of Love In "Midsummer Nights Dream" By Shakespeare

631 words - 3 pages company these days" Through the quote Bottom describes the conflict which the two types of love have in that blind love masks and hides all reasons of love. Shakespeare shows the nonsense and humor of love at first sight.Conflicts in love in "Midsummer Night's Dream" are resolved in all happy endings; Theseus marries Hippolyta, 4 nobles married. This is where Shakespeare loses his reality because it is a play. A conflict caused by love lasts for

gender lens on midsummer nights dream - lit of imagination - essay

649 words - 3 pages Free size and regional centres and  cities grew bigger at a rapid pace as labourers and servants were drawn in from the countryside.  The Plague created an environment so hard for people to find jobs in Europe, It helped  with the development in man labour technology, people started looking for more efficient ways  to work to help with the demands of the European economy. A fantastic invention during the  disease was a Printing press made by Johann

An Examination of Mill's Harm Principle - Philosophy 156 - Essay

516 words - 3 pages Phil 156.101: Reasoning & Critical Thinking - Spring 2018 Paper 1 Due Date: Tuesday, March 6 (in class) Write an argumentative essay of 2-3 pages (double-spaced) on one of the following prompts, answering all parts of the question. You are free to use any resources (in addition to the primary text(s)), but be sure to cite accordingly. I may award an A+ for an excellent paper that also convincingly applies rules/fallacies of deductive or

An Essay On The Speech Of Martin Luther King, "I Have A Dream" And "The Ballot Or The Bullet" By Malcolm X. The Differences And Similiraties Of These Two Speeches

1734 words - 7 pages change for the black race. "Anything you can think of that you want to change right now, the only way you can do it is with a ballot or a bullet." (Malcolm X). Anyhow, I am going to elaborate more on these two great men and their speeches (I Have a Dream by M. L. King and The Ballot or the Bullet by Malcolm X) by comparing them and writing what the similarities and differences in these two texts are.The first text I am going to deal with is Dr

A Tale Of Two Cities

483 words - 2 pages In the novel A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens uses satire in a variety of ways to make a political and personal statement. Two ways that are the most prominent methods he uses are pathos and irony. He uses ironic metaphors and situational irony.With the depiction of a broken wine cask outside Defarge?s wine shop, and with his portrayal of the passing peasants? scrambling to lap up the spilling wine, Dickens creates a symbol of desperate

Evaluate the interpretations in both of these - Westminster - Essay

530 words - 3 pages Evaluate the interpretations in both of the two passages and explain which one you think is more convincing in explaining why the Cultural Revolution began. (30) Passage A suggests that Mao wanted to make society obey his orders and wanted to intimidate his party into being loyal Maoists, whilst Passage B suggests that Mao wanted a permanent revolution in order to make his party loyal Maoists, this was driven by the Red Guard and the PLA as it

An explanation and examination of Critical Analyses of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre - Concordia University Ann Arbor, English Literature II - Research Paper

2594 words - 11 pages Free it comes to the education of young boys and girls who would one day establish it, this begins to lead us into the more modern interpretations of the piece in the mid-20th century. As the women’s suffrage movement and early feministic action already finished the 1950s-1960s brings in a completely new understanding of the piece with the New Criticism movement that followed after the World Wars. The New Criticism was nearly opposite to the previous

An Examination Of How Naivety Is Created To Convey Innocence And Explore Complex Issues In The Boy And In Striped Pyjamas

1028 words - 5 pages Free The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas is an entirely unique book. It follows its main character, Bruno, as he undergoes a big change in his personality and understanding of his environment. In the beginning when he moves to Out-With, he starts off an innocent 9 year old boy, completely oblivious to all the horrors going on just behind his back. Upon seeing the Jews and the huts on the other side of the fence, he concludes that it’s an ordinary

Computer Of My Dream

425 words - 2 pages Computer of my dream First, I need a motherboard because it's like the backbone of the system, without a good motherboard it won't be able to support the CPU, the brain of the system, very well. I choose a Pentium 4 motherboard because I want to keep myself up to date and the ASAU brand is a popular one. Then I chose a Pentium 4 CPU for its speed, also because Intel is a well-known brand. I chose an expensive RAM product, made by HP