Christopher Columbus Vs. Montaigne Unr Ch202 Essay

1358 words - 6 pages

Giacomo Ercole
CH 202
Dr. Adriana Varga
March 1, 2018
The case of European conquest provided a clear assertion of the innate dominance of
Western civilization to its contemporaries. The discovery of unexplored territories sparked a
massive interest in the European countries that were on the hunt for gold, riches, and spice. In
1492, Christopher Columbus attempted to reach the Indies by navigating west on the Atlantic
Ocean and stumbled upon the “new world”; the Americas. He reported the discovery with a
public letter addressed to the King and Queen of Spain for his voyage. Elsewhere, news of the
aforementioned discovery captured the attention of Michel de Montaigne, who challenged
Columbus’ xenophobic views on the indigenous peoples. With such massively contrasting
opinions on the manner in which we should act within the newly mapped territory, we see an
equal contrast in language. Montaigne, with an acute interest in attitudes towards technologically
inferior societies, speaks in a conscientious tone with regard for other life, but Columbus
attempts to extort the lives of indigenous people through religion and for wealth. It is through
this we can see the implied motives between the two writers, and the new ideas and practices of
the “new world” they are attempting to portray to their audience.
In his letter, Columbus provides a vivid description of his encounter within the “new
world” and his views of the “other”. For example, Columbus states “I have taken possession of
them all for their Highnesses, and all are more richly endowed than I have skill and power to say,
and I hold them all in the name of their Highness who can dispose thereof as much and as
completely as of the kingdoms of Castle” entailing that he effortlessly seized the land and lives
of the natives seeing as they posed no immediate threat to Europe. This was because he
attempted to showcase to his audience that another funded voyage would bring indisputable
success, and also further the ideology of European superiority. This sense of nationalism is seen
throughout the entirety of the letter, but more specifically, when describing the natives; “The
inhabitants of both sexes in this island, and in all the others which I have seen, or of which I have
received information, go always naked as they were born, with the exception of some of the
women.” Columbus is illustrating that the native society was imperialistic and incomparable to
that of the Europeans.
While Columbus recounts his own opinions on the “others” within his letter, Montaigne
argues against Columbus’ ideas and in favor of proper treatment for the inhabitants of the “new
world” in ​Of Cannibals.​ It was apparent that Columbus attempted to gain support and funding
for his future expeditions by extorting the lives of the natives, but Montaigne’s goal was to raise
awareness about how individuals should treat those who are viewed as different. By discussing
that all individuals are impermanent and relative,...

Other Essays On Christopher Columbus vs. Montaigne - UNR CH202 - Essay

August 29, 2018 - Pre-Colonial History 1490-1590 - History 1301 - Notes

3345 words - 14 pages August 29, 2018 - Pre-Colonial History 1490-1590 · April 30, 1789: GW Beginning of USA · [1492] CC sails ocean blue, 1st Euro (lots of sailing in China and Euro) · Sailed along/to North Africa, South/West Euro, and China to be safe · Portugal turns down Christopher Columbus, CC gets help from Spain instead · 4 more trips to New World · Pope Alexander VI mandates the Treaty of Tordesillas, Line of Demarcation (1493) leads to Portugal vs Spain

Persuasive Essay Gay And Lesbi

623 words - 3 pages Persuasive Essay - Gay and Lesbian Rights "If anyone says, 'I love God,' yet hates his brother, he is a liar. For anyone who does not love his brother, whom he has seen cannot love God, whom he has not seen," John 4:20. So, why do heterosexual people hate homosexuals? They are ordinary people with a different lifestyle who would simply like to be treated with respect. Many organized religions believe that a 'gay' lifestyle is wrong. But, if

Mark Mcgwire Vs Sammy Sosa

1206 words - 5 pages who battled McGwire for the major league (M.L.) Single season record until the end of the season. Sosa who was trailing McGwire 24 to nine in the home run race came on strong and out homered McGwire 57-46 from May 25 until the end of the season. Sosa who only led the home run race twice during the whole season finished with 66 and McGwire finished with 70. On August 19th vs. St. Louis, Sosa went ahead with a homer in the 5th inning putting

Master and slave. an analysis

495 words - 2 pages Each of the characters in The Tempest finds themselves in bondage. However, by the end of the story, the same characters are set free from whatever enslaves them. A few characters one can see enslaved are Prospero, Miranda, Ariel, and Caliban.Prospero is in bondage to his magic. Since his exile by his brother from his dukedom in Milan, he has had but a few books to help pass the twelve long years. During this time, he becomes very proficient in

Methods Of Therapy

2480 words - 10 pages METHODS OF THERAPY Therapy, from a psychologist's viewpoint, has many different meanings. It can be physical or psychological, or even both. In this paper, several different aspects of therapy will be discussed. First the word therapy will be defined more clearly, and then psychotherapy and how it differs from other interactions yet is also similar. Next therapy will be examined from the Psychodynamic, Cognitive and Humanistic-Existential points

Phineas And Gene A Comparitive

1538 words - 7 pages Phineas and Gene: A Comparative Study Throughout the story, Phineas and Gene, the two main characters, showed a number of contrasting traits. Phineas was a confident, non competitive, naive, irresponsible, and unintelligent person throughout the story, whereas Gene, Phineas' roommate, was insecure, competitive, mature, responsible, and intelligent throughout the story.Phineas had a confident nature in everything he did. As Phineas and Gene first


2008 words - 9 pages Mafia. What does this word mean? The actual members of the Mafia aren't even sure where the word first originated or what it really means. One of the theories as to where the word came from is from Sicily, where people would yell " Morte alla Francia, Italia anela!" (Death to France, Italy groans!), therefore forming the acronym MAFIA. Others claim the word derived from the battle cry of rebels who slaughtered thousands of Frenchmen after a

Baseball Strike

1354 words - 6 pages GAME OVER! "I don't like it. People won't be able to come to these games anymore, and I don't like that". A sad nine - year - old fan voices his concerns on the 1994 major League Baseball strike. The '94 baseball season has come to an abrupt end. Players have ceased play because they feel they are being treated unfairly with the owner's plan to impose a salary cap. Owners are finding it difficult to come to terms with their own disagreements

Worst experience

299 words - 2 pages I wanted to lie down and cry. When I got home from the student/teacher/parent conference in fifth grade my mind was in shambles. After I had done everything possible to pass math, my fifth grade teacher was actually telling my Parents about my alleged poor effort. Poor effort? Didn't I do every homework assignment? Didn't I study every night and miss my favorite television show "Full house"? From an early age, I had been taught that grades are

Multinational Companies

2058 words - 9 pages Multinational Companies: Out for Profit Without Regard for Life                  What a company usually wants for its business is for it to be an successful establishment and to make an abundance of profit. Some businesses do not pose any concern on what they have to do to make this profit as long as it done. Multinational companies are firms with their home base in one country and operations in many other nations. (Molyeux, 133

Middle Adulthood 2

675 words - 3 pages The Dictionary of Social Work roughly defines middle adulthood as the period between forty-five and sixty-four years of age. There are four main tasks in this stage. They include meeting intimacy and family needs, satisfying achievement needs, taking care of elderly parents, and coping with end of life issues. Erikson identifies the need for achievement during midlife, which fits into his stage of generativity vs. stagnation. Success in

Similar Papers

Compare Christopher Columbus And Smashmouth English Essay

1004 words - 5 pages Christopher Columbus is an All Star Kassidy Koch & Megan Burnham Christopher Columbus is one of the most notable explorers, and one of the most known names in the world. His discoveries and voyages have been studied and celebrated in many places by many people. The song “All Star” by Smash Mouth off the band’s album “Astro Lounge” is also a notable song in modern popular culture. Both of these things are fairly notable and popular, and the

Hero Or Villain: Christopher Columbus Survey Of World History Essay

933 words - 4 pages Newberry 4 Rufus Newberry 3/21/18 McDermott HIST 1112 Was Christopher Columbus Truly a Hero? Ever since the year of 1937, Columbus Day has been celebrated every year on the twelfth of October or the second Monday of October. On this day, we citizens are supposed to acknowledge and celebrate what he has accomplished. What is that exactly? We were taught as young children that Christopher Columbus discovered the New World, and that he was a brave

Should We Keep Columbus Day As A Federal Holiday? History Essay

972 words - 4 pages Should We Keep Columbus Day as a Federal Holiday? Columbus Day, held on the second Monday of October, honors Christopher Columbus, an Italian-born explorer who discovered America on his voyage to find a sea route to Asia for Spain (Columbus video). Columbus Day is one of only ten federal holidays, and is only one of two named for a specific individual (Gavin, 2004). Many honor him as a hero for “discovering” America, but really, is he the man we

Black Panther Essay About The Importance Of Diversity On The Film Screen Uwrt 1104 Research Paper

524 words - 3 pages Erin Cannegieter LBST 2102 April 18, 2018 Word count: 503 The Black Panther Essay When a heroic movie hits the screens millions of eyes turn to watch the latest entertainment. These movies often start Caucasian male actors which save the world against a “larger than [regular] life” villainous entity which often aim to dominate a certain population. Movies like “Man of Steel” and “Iron Man” both fall under these characteristics along with many