Comparision Of Pericles Funeral Speech,And Jefferson Declaration Of Independence

2092 words - 9 pages

September 11, 2001, two planes crash into the World Trade Center, people diving out windows to their deaths, a plane crashes into the Pentagon, hijackers overtaken by passengers and crash the plane into a field in Pennsylvania. December 2003, mass graves uncovered in Iraq, compliments of Saddam Husayn. May, 2004, a web page shows terrorists cutting off the head of Nick Berg. August 2004, over 350 children are executed by terrorists in a school in Russia. Democracy is being threatened by enigmatic zealots all over the world.The United States have fought for Democracy as far back as the Revolutionary War, and both World Wars. Once again our military is being asked to make the ultimate sacrifice in the attack on democracy against these zealots.Fighting for democracy has been the cause of wars since the days of Pericles.Pericles states that "Our constitution does not seek to copy the laws of our neighbors; we are an example to others, not imitators of them". During his time there was usually one ruler that had the power over life and death, the mass of people did not matter. In Athens this was far from the case. Athens created its own government, one that was for the people, and benefited the people. Pericles said with conviction, "As far as public life is concerned, we live as free men". The people of Athens had a government that supported them; they were all equal in the eyes of the government. The city of Athens stood by itself; it needed no others to help it. She left her gates open to all and did not concern herself with excluding foreigners. Her military stood alone. Athens never advanced into another territory with Allies; she did it alone. He also marvels in the fact that Athens does not live for the fear of war. He states that they live free, but are always ready if in danger. He even goes so far to say that his enemies are happy with a victory over a small part of the army. Pericles praises Athens for her form of government - democracy - because it is only in a democracy that citizens are encouraged to contribute and participate in self-rule. Democracy brings equality, merit brings public success, social and economic mobility is encouraged, and the law protects all: "We alone consider the man who refuses to take part in city affairs useless," Pericles announces. And he gets in a dig at Sparta by proudly proclaiming that "rather than look upon discussion as a stumbling-block in the way of action, we think it is an indispensable preliminary to any wise action at all."Pericles encourages his audience "to realize the greatness of Athens" and enjoy everything the city has to offer: "Further, we provide many ways to refresh the mind from the burdens of business. We hold contests and offer sacrifices all the year round, and the elegance of our private establishments forms a daily source of pleasure and helps to drive away sorrow. The magnitude of our city draws the produce of the world into our harbor, so that to the Athenian the fruits of other countries are as familiar a luxury as those of his own." What Pericles talks about in his speech is almost dimmed in importance by how he delivers the message. It is Pericles' rhetoric that makes this speech famous and the model for so many others in the course of history. Throughout his speech, Pericles holds up glory as the incentive for men to rush to battle for their freedom: Athens is a glorious city because of the sacrifices of previous generations of men, and this generation, too, must shoulder its burden. And while fighting for your country can help bring about a victory, it also has the benefit of bringing you personal glory, something Pericles believes can be gained in no other way than by dying for your country: "Realize for yourself the power of Athens, and feed your eyes upon her day after day, till you become her devoted lover. Then, when all her greatness breaks upon you, reflect that it was by courage, sense of duty and a keen feeling of honor in action that men were enabled to win all this, and that no personal failure in an enterprise could make them consent to deprive their country of their valor, but they laid it at her feet as the most glorious contribution they could offer. By this mutual offering of their lives made by them all, they each of them individually received that renown which never grows old. For a sepulcher they have won not so much that tomb in which their bones are here deposited, but that noblest of shrines wherein their glory is laid up to be eternally remembered upon every occasion on which deed or story shall fall for its commemoration. For heroes have the whole earth for their tomb." Pericles' speech is certainly persuasive. Its passion is based in reality. It is a powerful to see a nation mourn its war dead. In the end Pericles accomplishes his goal to inspire a city in mass mourning for its lost warriors.Woodrow Wilson was faced with a call to arms when in 1917 he proclaimed American entrance into World War I a crusade to make the world "safe for democracy."Pericles, in his funeral oration, talks of valor as being very honorable. He comments that "Choosing to die resisting, rather than to live submitting" is a bold and courageous act and it deserves praise and glory. He says the soldiers "fled only from dishonor, but met danger face to face".Abraham Lincoln was faced with a similar task. The Gettysburg Address was delivered on November 19, 1863, at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, during dedication of the Gettysburg National Cemetery. Lincoln's speech is more humble than Pericles, but just as passionate. He is careful in not mentioning either side of the war; he only speaks of the nation as a whole. "Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether the nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated can long endure. We are met on a great battlefield of that war. We have come to dedicate a portion of that field as the final resting-place for those who here gave their lives that this nation might live." Lincoln pays tribute to not only the Union army, but the Confederate as well, by saying "The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract."There are obvious parallels between Pericles' and Lincoln's speeches. They both set out to accomplish the same thing just in different ways. Another famous writer and scholar with a similar view of Athenian society, Sophocles, chose to voice his opinion through playwright. Specifically in his two great tragedies Oedipus the King and Antigone. Pericles and Sophocles, although coming from different ends of the spectrum (the aforementioned oratory or rhetoric and the latter fictional), both consider the individual and the state in their works and come to similar conclusions with some exceptions. Pericles expresses his views in his "Funeral Oration", where he boasts of the great qualities of Athens, its citizens and soldiers. Sophocles injects his thoughts and ideas into his two masterpieces, Oedipus the King and Antigone. In the following paper, I will compare the men's ideas and views on the subject of the individual and the state. In particular, their thoughts on the importance of military excellence, honor, courage, and views on women. Both men considered loyalty in battle and involvement in public matters very important. According to Pericles, military achievements and honor make up for anything wrong one does as a citizen (for example, refusing to take part in city affairs). The Greeks obviously looked upon excellence in the military very highly. of all our neighbors, we alone consider the man who refuses to take part in city affairs as useless....For there is justice in the claim that steadfastness in his nation's battles provides a cloak to cover a man's other imperfections; the good action blots out the bad, and his merit as a citizen more than outweighs his faults as an individual (Pericles 58-59, 60). Sophocles expresses similar views on the matter in his play Antigone, Creon talks of loyalty to the state as having utter importance: As I see it, whoever assumes the task, the awesome task of setting the city's course, and refuses to adopt the soundest policies but fearing someone, keeps his lips locked tight, he's utterly worthless....But whoever proves his loyalty to the state - I'll prize that man in death as well as life (Antigone 48-49). Creon backs up his words with actions. He goes on to talk of Eteocles and Polynices, the two sons of Oedipus: Eteocles will be given a proper burial, since he went down fighting for Thebes, being loyal to his city; Polynices, on the other hand, committed treason and went against everything Creon stands for and believes in, therefore "he must be left unburied, his corpse carrion for the birds and dogs to tear, an obscenity for the citizens to behold! These are my principles. Never at my hands will the traitor be honored above the patriot" (Antigone 49). As examined, patriotism was held very highly by the Greeks, as seen in Pericles's oration and Sophocles's plays we again come across an intersection in both statesmen's ideas, this time on the subject of courage. Pericles, in his funeral oration, talks of valor as being very honorable. He comments that "Choosing to die resisting, rather than to live submitting" (Pericles 60) is a bold and courageous act and it deserves praise and glory. He says the soldiers "fled only from dishonor, but met danger face to face" (Pericles 60). Do these characteristics bring anyone we know to mind? The answer is yes, and two people come to mind: Antigone and Oedipus. Sophocles's heroin (Antigone) is the ultimate example of the subject Pericles discusses. True, Antigone was not a soldier, but she went against her uncle's beliefs and commands, and did what was right according to the gods. In burying her brother and then announcing her actions to the world, she "fled only from dishonor, but met danger face to face." Antigone questioned Creon and proudly stated she was the offender, and did not regret her actions. Oedipus, instead of giving in to fate, battled it for as long as he could until fate finally beat him. Although it seems that Sophocles writings parallel Pericles views on women's inferiority, certain excerpts provide a basis that Sophocles' views contradict those presented in the Funeral Oration. Pericles states, "if I must say anything on the subject of female excellence....Great will be your glory in not falling short of your natural character; and greatest will be hers who is least talked of among the men whether for good or for bad" (Pericles 61-62). In an excerpt from Sophocles' Oedipus the King, it is seen that Oedipus gives great weight to Jocasta's opinion. Oedipus compares stories with Jocasta on the death of the king. He listens to Jocasta's side of the story, not putting her in a subordinate position or looking at her as inferior (Oedipus the King 23). In Summation, Pericles and Sophocles (although coming from different ends of the spectrum) both consider the individual and the state in their works and come to similar conclusions with some exceptions on the different aspects of the relationship. They both praise loyalty, involvement in state affairs, and honorable death. To note, in my research I found more expression of Sophocles's views which correlate with Pericles's in Antigone and not so much in Oedipus the King. All three of three of the pieces were written in times when the definition of freedom, independence, democracy were still new and not well defined in their respective societies. But still in each piece the message is similar and very clear. That message is that it is necessary and good for people to sacrifice themselves for their beliefs and the good of their society.


Compare the U.S. Constitution, Declaration Of Independence, and Thomas Jefferson Letters - Liberty University/ GOVT200 - Comparison Paper

1116 words - 5 pages Comparison Paper Takareathia Rose GOVT200, L30374945 America has built its foundation off of a few founding documents, which include The Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, and was supported by Thomas Jefferson Letters to the Danbury Baptist in 1802. These documents were intended to set a foundation for the lifestyle that will be enforced throughout the population. However, these documents differ in many ways such as goals, content

Issues And Claims About TJ In The Declaration Of Independence

271 words - 2 pages Issue, Claim, and Reasoning of T. JeffersonThe main issue of The Declaration of Independence by Thomas Jefferson is to declare the colonies' independence from the Crown of Britain. They believed this to be within theirRights gifted upon them by their Creator. The Declaration of Independence discusses that we were under religious persecution and certain forms of "absolute tyranny" from Britain, so it was necessary to break the bonds that

The Declaration of Independence - school - essay

1005 words - 5 pages statement showing the colonists resolve to be free of English rule. The Declaration of Independence was the starting point for the United States effectively serving its purpose, making it the most important document in history. Thomas Jefferson the author of the Declaration of Independence was a well-educated man graduating from The College of William and Mary in 1762. Born in Virginia 1743, Jefferson went to school learning French, Greek and Latin

Declaration of Independence Essay - History - Essay

694 words - 3 pages Zac Cobos History 8 2/12/2018 Declaration of Independence Essay In the 1700s The English settled in America and made 13 colonies. These colonies were fighting for freedom. They were fighting because the English took away many of their rights and taxed them through acts. Some of the major acts passed between 1765 – 1775 was the Quartering Act, Tea Act, and the Declaratory Act. These Acts are what later lead to the Revolutionary War in 1775. These

Comparison paper between the declaration of independence and the constitution - GOV 200 - comparison paper

721 words - 3 pages . Constitution. Let’s start with the one that came first, The Declaration of Independence. The Declaration was adopted by The Second Continental Congress on July 4, 1776. It was authored by Thomas Jefferson with the help of others. The main theme of declaration of independence document was to demonstrate that all people are equal, and no government should have the power to oppress its. The Declaration told Britain that it had stomped on the

Declaration of Independence FEDERALIST No. 44 - Gregory Portland High school - Essay

441 words - 2 pages and entitled to participate in. As previously mentioned, such actions that “coin money” or exercise the excess use of the fabrication of the American dollar may lead to inflation, which in turn diminishes the value of the American dollar that we deem worthy and symbolize with a revolutionary aspect; a national outlook; and our persistency as a nation to have endured bloodshed and grievances in order to gain our beautiful independence that should

Analyze the contributions of Washing and Jefferson in helping establish a stable government after the adoption of the Constitution

495 words - 2 pages In 1789, the first person was elected to become the first president of the United States of America under the Constitution. The first person was Washington. Following Washington years later was the third president, Jefferson. The first few presidents of the United States contributed to establish a stable government after the adoption of the Constitution. They stabilized the government through international affairs and internal affairs.Washington

rhetorical anylasis on decleration of independence - english - essay

557 words - 3 pages Takia Anderson Ms. Spensieri English 11A December 2,2018 In one of the most important documents in the United States history, The Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson argues that American colonies have God-given rights that gives them the right to be free from Great Britain and that they must demand freedom. He utilizes these natural laws throughout the document by elaborating on unalienable rights that are given to all men, regardless

The War Of 1812 - A Second War For Independence?

1083 words - 5 pages On June 18, 1812, the United States declared war on Britain. This declaration was the result of almost thirty years of stormy relations between the two nations subsequent to the signing of the Treaty of Paris in 1783. This treaty ended the Revolutionary War and established the United States as a nation; however, it did not guarantee that Europe would respect its rights or neutrality. The "second war for independence" is the term that historians

Speech of sexism in advertisements - Gess - Speech

552 words - 3 pages Slide 1 Good afternoon, my name is Rayyan and I will be analyzing how sexism in advertisements has portrayed women and how it changed throughout the years . Sexism included advertisements dates far back as the 1950s and I will be presenting the sexist advertisements in chronological order starting from the 1950s to modern time. Slide 2 To start of, advertising may influence behavior through, seducing, shaping social reality, and simply creating

Internet speech, freedom of speech and hate culture; cyber bullying - Orange County community college English 1 - research

1520 words - 7 pages Lima 1 Addison Lima Prof. Meagher English 101 Nov 29 2018 Internet culture: Free speech and Hate speech It is most likely safe to assume that very few people predicted the internet becoming so widespread as it is today in the United States.. The average person interacts with it daily, using its near infinite reservoir of knowledge for education, business, leisure activities, and just about anything else you can think of. The internet connects

Jefferson time from the over of the east coast - His 144 - Assignment

568 words - 3 pages Naeshun Thomas 2/9/19 Darwinism has been around in the American society since 1859, even though that early time Charles Darwin had only been addressed to animal and plant-based evolution. In 1871, with The Descent of Man, he brought to the public’s attention his views and theories on natural selection. Most people do not know much of what Darwin wrote, due to the criticism leveled against it, as well as people mistaking the Survival of the

The revolutionary vision of human equality that Thomas Jefferson attempted to achieve. - Intermediate English Composition - Essay

1617 words - 7 pages Morrison Dorian Morrison Professor Smedley English 1B May 8, 2019 Speculating About Causes “When Alana started a website for lonely people struggling to find love, she had no idea it would become linked to a community of hate and anger directed at women” (Taylor). This was quoted from an article about the woman who had started the Incel Movement back as early as the 90s. Little to her own dismay would her creation be the start of a movement that

Freedom of Religion related to the freedom of speech and press

355 words - 2 pages to different people, whether they understand the full extent of it or not. Most people take for granted going to church on Sunday, or praying before a meal. In some other places, terror reigns over the citizens when they pray or try to worship their god in public. Is their ruler so insecure that he forces people to go against what they believe?Freedom of press, speech, and protest has impacted our economy greatly. Americans would not have

A speech about the importance of legacy - St John - Speech

522 words - 3 pages This Is For My Legacy This is a line from a song called K.O. While listening to this I began to think about my future, and what I what my goals and expectations were. It also made me think about what legacy planning to leave behind at the school. We all begin at St johns at go, as we all lead to our final destination. The difference what we do on our way. There are paths chosen, actions taken, and lots of decisions are made lead ultimately to a