Paper On The Communications Decency Act

1415 words - 6 pages

The Communications Decency Act that was signed into law by President Clinton over a year ago is clearly in need of serious revisions due, not only to its vagueness, but mostly due to the fact that the government is infringing on our freedom of speech, may it be indecent or not. The Communications Decency Act, also know by Internet users as the CDA, is an Act that aims to remove indecent or dangerous text, lewd images, and other things deemed inappropriate from public areas of the net. The CDA is mainly out to protect children.In the beginning, the anonymity of the Internet caused it to become a haven for the free trading of pornography. This is mainly what gives the Internet a bad name. There is also information on the Net that could be harmful to children. Information on how to make home-made explosives and similar info such as The Jolly Rodgers and the Anarchist's Cookbook are easily obtained on the Net. Pedophiles (people attracted to child porn) also have a place to hide on the Internet where nobody has to know their real name. As the average age of the Internet user has started to drop, it has became apparent that something has to be done about the pornography and other inappropriate info on the net.On February 1, 1995, Senator Exon, a Democrat from Nebraska, and Senator Gorton, a Republican from Washington, introduced the first bill towards regulating online porn. This was the first incarnation of the Telecommunications Reform Bill.On April 7, 1995, Senator Leahy, a Democrat from Vermont, introduces bill S714. Bill S714 is an alternative to the Exon/Gorton bill. This bill commissions the Department of Justice to study the problem to see if additional legislature (such as the CDA) is even necessary.The Senate passed the CDA as attached to the Telecomm reform bill on June 14, 1995 with a vote of 84-16. The Leahy bill does not pass, but is supported by 16 Senators that actually understand what the Internet is. Seven days later, several prominent House members publicly announce their opposition to the CDA, including Newt Gingrich, Chris Cox, and Ron Wyden. On September 26, 1995, Senator Russ Feingold urges committee members to drop the CDA from the Telecommunications Reform Bill.On Thursday, February 1, 1996, Congress passed (House 414-9, Senate 91-5) the Telecommunications Reform Bill, and attached to it the Communications Decency Act. This day was known as 'Black Thursday' by the Internet community. One week later, it was signed into law by President Clinton on Thursday, February 8, 1996, also known as the 'Day of Protest.' The punishment for breaking any of the provisions of the bill is punishable with up to 2 years in prison and/or a $250,000 fine.On the 'Day of Protest,' thousands of home-pages went black as Internet citizens expressed their disapproval of the Communications Decency Act. Presently there are numerous organizations that have formed in protest of the Act. The groups include: the American Civil Liberties Union, the Voters Telecommunications Watch, the Citizens Internet Empowerment Coalition, the Center for Democracy & Technology, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, the Internet Action Group, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation. The ACLU is not just involved with Internet issues. They fight to protect the rights of many different groups. (ex. Gay and Lesbian Rights, Death Penalty Rights, and Women's Rights) The ACLU is currently involved in the lawsuit of Reno vs. ACLU in which they are trying to get rid of the CDA.In addition to Internet users turning their homepage backgrounds black, there was the adoption of the Blue Ribbon, which was also used to symbolize their disapproval of the CDA. The Blue Ribbons are similar to the Red Ribbons that Aids supports are wearing. The Blue Ribbon spawned the creation of 'The Blue Ribbon Campaign.' The Blue Ribbon's Homepage is the fourth most linked to site on the Internet. Only Netscape, Yahoo, and Webcrawler are more linked to. To be linked to means that they can be reached from another site. It's pretty hard to surf around on the Net and not see a Blue Ribbon on someone's site.On the day that President Clinton signed the CDA into law, a group of nineteen organizations, from the American Civil Liberties Union to the National Writers Union, filed suit in federal court, arguing that it restricted free speech. At the forefront of the battle against the CDA is Mike Godwin. Mike Godwin is regarded as one of the most important online-rights activists today. He is the staff counsel for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and has 'won fans and infuriated rivals with his media savvy, obsessive knowledge of the law, and knack for arguing opponents into exhaustion.' Since 1990 he has written on legal issues for magazines like Wired and Internet World and spoken endlessly at universities, at public rallies, and to the national media. Although this all helped the cause, Godwin didn't become a genuine cyberspace superhero until what he calls the 'great Internet sex panic of 1995.' During this time, Godwin submitted testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee, debated Christian Coalition executive director Ralph Reed on Nightline, and headed the attack on the study of online pornography.The study of online porn became the foundation of 'Time Magazine's' controversial July 3 cover story, 'On a Screen Near You: Cyberporn.' Time said the study proved that pornography was 'popular, pervasive, and surprisingly perverse' on the Net, but Godwin put up such a fight to the article that three weeks later, the magazine ran a follow-up story admitting that the study had serious flaws.The CDA is a bad solution, but it is a bad solution to a very real problem. As Gina Smith, a writer for Popular Science, has written, 'It is absolutely true that the CDA, is out of bounds in it's scope and wording. As the act is phrased, for example, consenting adults cannot be sure their online conversations won't land them in jail.' Even something as newsstand-friendly as the infamous Vanity Fair cover featuring a pregnant and nude(but strategically covered) Demi Moore might be considered indecent under the act, and George Carlin's famous 'seven dirty words' are definitely out. CDA supporters are right when they say the Internet and online services are fertile playgrounds for pedophiles and other wackos bent on exploiting children.Now, parents could just watch over their children's shoulder's the whole time that they are online, but that is both an unfair and an impractical answer. There are two answers, either a software program that blocks certain sites could be installed, or parents could discipline their kids so that they would know better than to look at pornography. The latter would appear to be the better alternative, but that just isn't practical. If kids are told not to do something, they are just going to be even more curious to check out porn. On the other hand, many parents are less technologically informed than their kids. Many would not know how to find, install, and understand such programs as CyberPatrol or NetNanny.The future of the CDA seems to be fairly evident. It doesn't look like the CDA is going to be successful. In addition to the Act being too far reaching in its powers, it is virtually unenforceable. As with anything in print, much of the material on the Internet is intelligent and worthy of our attention, but on the other hand, some of it is very vulgar. The difficulty in separating the two rests in the fact that much of the Internet's value lies in its freedom from regulation. As Father Robert A. Sirico puts it, 'To allow the federal government to censor means granting it the power to determine what information we can and cannot have access to.'Temptations to sin will always be with us and around us so long as we live in this world.

RELATED

The Current FCC Issue And 1st Amendment Rights

641 words - 3 pages government, such as the Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004 ("Decency Act"), are in direct violation of this Amendment. The Decency Act essentially gives the FCC the ability to fine broadcast station licensees for demonstrating or broadcasting what the FCC defines as obscene, indecent, or profane language or images. The main objective of the Act is to monitor indecency. With the passing of the Decency Act, congress made a law that abridged

How To Make Easy Money Essay

442 words - 2 pages Viacom has withdrawn its financial support from Mr. Stern's legal fight against Clear Channel Communication Inc., which dropped his show earlier this year after the Federal Communications Commission began a crackdown on indecent broadcasts.The about-face has infuriated Mr. Stern, who has lambasted Infinity management on the air during his past few shows, but without mentioning the legal issue at the root of the squabble. People close to Infinity

This Essay Covers Different Aspects Of Censorship Such As School Sex Censorship, Book Censorship And Even Library Censorship. Includes References And Standard MLA

3756 words - 16 pages regulations seemed somewhat lax; in February 1996, a notorious bit of legislation known as the Communications Decency Act (CDA) was passed, in an attempt to limit the content available on the Internet and to set up a system of responsibility for content that extended beyond the purpose of the original creator. The proponents of this movement were primarily from pro family and Christian organizations 13 People soon began to realize that this was a bogus

Interaction of media law and online community - Griffith University Media Law - Essay

1660 words - 7 pages ’ on the internet every time it is downloaded and read. This means that the publisher could be liable for defamation in more than one jurisdiction. The article has been read in the United States however the publisher would only be liable for the article itself and not the comments on the site as the Communications Decency Act in the US provides that publishers aren’t responsible for comments made by third parties. The writer in the scenario is

Assignment On steve jobs

551 words - 3 pages . We're all given limited time, and Jobs certainly made a dent in the universe, as he always wanted. Most of us will never make such a large splash.How he did it is also interesting. Jobs' defining characteristics seemed to be narcissism and perfectionism.What is impressive is that Jobs was able to coordinate all these people to act in concert. He could convince smart and capable people to bend to his will and row in the same direction. He could

how the reputations of cleopatra has been presented throughout film - Open University, The arts past and present - Assingment

891 words - 4 pages talking about Colbert in Cleopatra, 2008, Reputations DVD) where there was a continued fight for women’s equality, and groups such as the legion of decency (which was created by the Catholic Church) organised boycotts of certain films which didn’t promote the idea of a stable, moral nuclear family. Like the 1934 film, the 1963 film reflects the political circumstances at the time it was made. For example Cleopatra talks about a single, united world

A Look At The Fair Labor Standards Act

1271 words - 6 pages families. A large majority of those children who did find employment, were forced to work many hours for barely a livable wage.In 1937, President Franklin Roosevelt declared that "All but the hopeless reactionary will agree that to conserve our primary resources of manpower, government must have some control over maximum hours, minimum wages, the evil of child labor, and the exploitation of unorganized labor." In 1938 the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA

A Report On The Play "Incident At Vichy" By Arthur Miller

815 words - 4 pages the major said he doesn't care if Leduc loves him, he believes that individuals don't matter anymore. He does not understand why Leduc has more of a right to live than he.In the end it is the great Prince Von Berg, a man of nobility, who sacrifices his pass out of the detainment room to Leduc, a Jew. Von Berg acts in a very selfless way, the first selfless act in the play, as he places someone else's life before his. Leduc had made him feel guilty

ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS - CMU, MSA 600 - Research Proposal

781 words - 4 pages EFFECTIVENESS 3 collaborate and participate in order to increase employee engagement; ultimately people form the backbone of any organization. Organizational communications and employee engagement serves as a foundation for the previously listed themes. An organizational strategy is clearly communicated, a culture and leaderships style that encourages open communication and engagement, the flexibility needed to deal with changing conditions, and people

Reunion and Reconciliation; The Odyssey and The Iliad - UMass, Greek Civilization - Essay

1301 words - 6 pages ). With great pity for a prince, Apollo sways the other gods to grasp the misfortune that have brought upon the city of Troy by choosing to help Achilles who in their view outranks Hector. However, the “almighty” Achilles has brought shame to the Divine world with such childish actions that the gods cannot help but pity hector. Apollo exposes him for who he really is, “a man without a shred of decency in his heart…his temper can never bend and

Untitled

608 words - 3 pages was a way to support radio Station WEAF in New York charged $100 for every 10 minutes The cost of airing programs was solved Congress Regulates Radio The Radio Act of 1927 formed the Federal Radio Commission under the jurisdiction of the Department of Commerce Limitations of air space required government regulation The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) was formed in 1934 to regulate the expanding wireless medium War of the Worlds October 30

Organizational behavior is the study and application of knowledge about how people, individuals, and groups act in organizations

437 words - 2 pages Organizational behavior is the study and application of knowledge about how people, individuals, and groups act in organizations. The purpose of such study is to help internal incorporation, bring employees from all levels of the company closer together, and boost their performance. Employees are what make up an organization or a company. A company must run successfully; therefore, the employees have to work well together. People work

Behaviour within time of crisis - St Marcus College Year 12 - Essay

1277 words - 6 pages ?)’. This dialogue reveals a sense of discontinuity that suggest he is manipulating the justice of Salem. This exposes his ability to abuse his position in the court to advance his own agenda. Amidst the characterization of Danforth and the Bont’s, Miller and Brooks suggest that a ‘perverse manifestation of panic’ within Salem catalyses ‘vain pursuits’ that enable ‘corrupted’ individuals to act in self-interest. While both authors depict the

literary analysis George Orwell 1984 - English - essay analysis

1132 words - 5 pages war that took place not long after World War II. Oceania’s totalitarianism resembles the more sinister aspects of the Soviet Union when Orwell was writing, at a time when he had become disillusioned with socialism. The population is brainwashed into unthinking obedience, love of Big Brother, and hatred of Eurasia and Emmanuel Goldstein, the leader of the Brotherhood, an underground group of dissenters. His longing for truth and decency leads him to

Hurricanes And Earthquakes

1832 words - 8 pages residents paid in the amount of "…150 billion" (Discovery Communications, 2009)In all, as with Hurricanes Katrina, Charley, Frances, Ivan, and Jeanne it is apparent the mark that this act of nature can cause with areas or environments in its path. It can start at the top of the chain with the individual stories and trickle down through, environmental all the way to government.Catastrophic Disasters Caused by EarthquakesCatastrophic disaster can