Critique Essay: Cosmetic Surgery And Individual Identity

1458 words - 6 pages

Summary:Elizabeth Haiken, "The Making of the Modern Face: Cosmetic Surgery," Social Research, Spring 2000. The American culture that produced cosmetic surgery is the increasingly visual, psychologically influenced culture of the twentieth century United States. For those surgeons who perform cosmetic surgery, the relationship between the physical face and the construction of individual identity has always been and continues to be central. "In our modern twentieth century United States, our attitudes toward cosmetic surgery have been based on a series of assumptions: that inside every person who looks different is an American struggling to get out; that inside every homely girl a confident ...view middle of the document...

She goes on to discuss the future stating, "Imagine a not too distant future, in which babies are made to order, down to the size of their noses and the longevity of their hairlines, a future in which post birth alteration is remembered nostalgically as the primitive practice of well-meaning but technologically handicapped medical practitioners." The author's purpose is to inform society of the misconceptions that have been formed over the history of cosmetic surgery, and what will happen if the trend continues. (3.) The author conceives her role not only as a scholar, but also as a prophet. Haiken is seen as a scholar when she further advances the knowledge of American society when discussing the history of cosmetic surgery and how it evolved. Haiken is also seen as a prophet when she predicts the future of the procedures of cosmetic surgery if there is a future in store at all. (4.) Haiken writes in a straightforward but slightly slanted tone. She is very straightforward when she addresses the issues that many Americans know but are afraid to acknowledge. She is also biased because she talks about the issues surrounding surgeons' influence on what identity has become, but she does not address the issues of how cosmetic surgery has positively influenced the self-esteem and confidence that people who undergo the procedures gained.Questions of Craft:(5.) The article's content is structured mainly around surgeon's who perform cosmetic surgery and their patients who are changing their "identity" solely based on external appearances. The article is physically structured opening with a narrative from the CBS television show The Twilight Zone. Then Haiken reviews the history of cosmetic surgery and dates it back to BC in India when members of a brick maker caste tried to reconstruct noses cut off as punishment for adultery. Haiken goes on to address the current trends in cosmetic surgery, and concludes with what she feels the future holds concerning the extinction of the procedure. (6.) The phrase that best crystallized the article is physical construction of identity. This phrase describes the article as a whole because it's main idea is all about how and why Americans feel the need to reconstruct their exterior to fit the mold society has created for the "perfect identity." (7.) Haiken gives substance to her explanations by referring to several experts on the topics of cosmetic surgery, self image, and culture. First she refers to Richard Stark wrote an article titled "The History of Plastic Surgery in Wartime." Stark discusses issues concerning the history of cosmetic surgery. Secondly, Haiken uses Warren Susman as a reference. Susman wrote an article called "Personality and the Making of Twentieth Century Culture." This referred to the American society and the overall views of what type of appearance is acceptable. A third expert Haiken refers to is David Thomasma who wrote "The Goals of Medicine and Society." This article discussed the surgeon's...

Other Essays On Critique Essay: Cosmetic Surgery And Individual Identity

Compare And Contrast Two Theories Of Motivation. Suggest How A Team Leader Might Use These Theories To Motivate The Team

2206 words - 9 pages execute these strategies suggested by the relevant theories effectively within the workplace in efforts of motivating his/her team. Throughout the essay, definitions and arguments will be presented and supported by academic literature prior to reaching a conclusion.This essay encapsulates the definition of 'motivation' in regards to work which is defined by French et al. (2011: 666) as referring to the 'forces within an individual that account

Sexism Essay

1130 words - 5 pages of the sexes to justify social inequalities' (Bullbeck 1998:512). Sexism is discrimination between people based on their gender rather than their individual merits (Bullbeck 1998). According to the dictionary definition of feminism is defined as a movement demanding 'the full social, political and economic equality of men and women' (Richards 2005). The next section of the essay will discuss gender identity according to the Faucauldian feminist

Identity Themes In "Naruto"

1066 words - 5 pages sound devices, while Unreliable Memoirs uses humour , exaggeration and anecdotes to convey his identity. In both Naruto and Unreliable memoirs it is apparent the influence society has over an individual’s identity. Like when Clive James suggests homosexuality could result in “rape, torture and perhaps death.” This is a hyperbole, emphasising how being homosexual was undesirable. The use of anecdotes and exaggeration in Unreliable

Robert Louis Stevenson And The Book" Dr Jekyll And Mr. Hyde"

1902 words - 8 pages with age, observing that they can occasionally be drastic and amount to reversals. He himself, the essay tells us, was once a socialist but tended toward conservatism as he grew older. Leaving aside questions of historical accuracy in Stevenson's assertion, it is possible to note that he saw the crisis of the Damascene moment as being characterized by both change and continuity: despite the extreme nature of the event, something of Paul's character

Beauty And The Beast

1523 words - 7 pages efficient, and women were even beginning to wear pants, though this trend will not catch on for decades. Women suffered the great pains of the emerging style of the boyish figure of the 1920's, many women going into the, then experimental, cosmetic surgery, to decrease the size of their bosoms. In the 1930's, voluptuous breasts were back in style, as women horded back in to get their breasts enlarged.CorsetsCorsetry has been around for centuries

Buddhism Vs. Hinduism

661 words - 3 pages Ashley Pradhan Ashley Pradhan 9/15/09 C/C Essay Per. 1 Buddhism vs. Hinduism The similarities between Hinduism and Buddhism are the following: both Buddhism and Hinduism stress compassion and non-violence towards all beings, both religions are more philosophical than religious, and both had a strong belief in reincarnation and the after life, and the differences between Hinduism are these: Hinduism is polytheistic while Buddhism

Marketing Management And Strategy For Myer Comapny. Nick HSU

4034 words - 17 pages family, not only did Sidney Myer achieve great business success, he also became a leading philanthropist (Myer, 2002).In 1989, Myer joined with Grace Bros to become the largest department store group in Australia. Myer now employs approximately 29,000 people nationally and they focus on a high standard of individual personal development. With over 73 stores nationally, Myer is the market leader in the Australian large retailer industry. They are

Anzaldua

1469 words - 6 pages Cover Letter While write this summary & analysis paper the thing that I think was working well was that I knew what I was doing. The reason I believe this is because everything of how the essay should have been done was clearly explain during class and in the outline. I think also, because I was working in it in sections. For example for one day in class I had to do part of the essay. Then for another day I needed to do another part and like

Sociological Criticism and “The Rocking-Horse Winner”

614 words - 3 pages Sociological Criticism and "The Rocking-Horse Winner"Daniel P. Watkins relates "The Rocking-Horse Winner" by D.H. Lawrence, to sociological criticism through his critique of the family's need to show off and of the capitalist society they live in. The family lived in style but always felt anxiety in the house because they didn't make enough money for the social position in which they had to keep up (Lawrence 592). The society, culture, and

How Does Class Influence Identity In Contemporary Society?

892 words - 4 pages How does class influence identity in contemporary society?The class structure involves some degree of shaping our identities. Income and paid work are important sources of individual and collective identity. Social class is a means of classifying the economic and social divisions of a society, which involve some degree of inequality. For example classifying some people as ‘poor’, ‘working class’ or ‘middle class’

Article By Thomas Sowell " Afrocentric Escapism"

603 words - 3 pages Determining an author's point of view. State the author's point of view. Give your evidence. State your point of view. Give your evidence. Explain the authors bias. In this essay I will be examining the views and bias of Thomas Sowell in Afrocentric Escapism. The author's piont of view will be discussed along with evidence to support. By the end of this essay the author's bias will have been explained. Also my point of view will be stated with

Similar Papers

The King And I Had Land

403 words - 2 pages Olivia MullinsLIT 2100LIT 2100 Students10 Oct. 2014Second Essay InstructionsA critique is a formal evaluation of a text, and one of the most common forms of critique in literature is the review. In a review, you - as the reviewer - get to evaluate the text. For your 2nd essay, choose one of the novels I've assigned to review. Your 4-6-page review should include quotations from the text wherein you will cite your sources according to MLA

Psychic Surgery Essay

1175 words - 5 pages In the entire area of paranormal research today there is a great deal of controversy that swirls about psychic surgery. The question that comes to many people when studying psychic surgery is: "Is it possible that certain individuals can channel energy to the extent that they can literally part human flesh with a mere gesture, remove individual organs with there bare hands, then instantly rejoin the penetrated body without leaving a mark or

Black History Essay

320 words - 2 pages in question. It is not yet commonly understood as work essential to the knowledges these disciplines hope to groom and disseminate." Lindon Barrett, "Identities and Identity Studies:" Reading Toni Cade Bambara's "The Hammer Man" in Cultural Critique 39 "Traditions and the canons that confirm them are made not born, constructed not spawned. . . . the African American literary canon is an exclusive club whose roster is determined by the tastes of a handful of intellectuals."

Identity Essay

558 words - 3 pages totally the same. A person's identity is established over many years and put together by the person. A person's identity is developed over many years from the time they become aware of what is around them. As people's dreams and goals are accomplished their identities will change with the individual. Identity starts with your family. Your family will be there with you for a long time and they will have a impact on what you become in the future