Jane Addams: Book Review Of A New Conscious And An Ancient Evil University Of Regina Hist 400 Assignment

1062 words - 5 pages

A Sensitive and Fragile Threshold: Jane Addams’s A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil
Joshua Switzer
Dr. Dawn Flood
HIST 333
A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil written at the turn of the twentieth century features Jane Addams, the founder of the socially and culturally philanthropic Hull-House, as the antagonistic narrator of a longstanding gender-based issue that augments with the growth of the “Windy City”. This “social evil”, as it is referred to, is promptly exorcised as Addams formats her thematic arguments around the traps and social snares of the city and the most desirable solutions for them. She critically reveals the modernity of the ancient social and economic evils within the web of “commercialized vice” in Chicago at a time when Addams was becoming the national voice for American women.
Addams rigorously exposes shocking and abhorrent in-detail accounts, narratives and statistics of Chicago’s exploited young females within the grasps of prostitution up until the book’s completion in the winter of 1912. Her message to readers may be more than a hairy and flagrant case of city-wide gender-trafficking. With all of prostitution’s ethically questionable motives, Addams inflates Chicago’s prostitution trade as a deadly and grotesque state-of-affairs, run within the broader context of the dark, manipulative world of surreptitious men who took advantage of women - especially girls under the age of eighteen.
Young girls between the ages of thirteen and eighteen were the primary range targeted for the “white slave trade”. Making lucrative profit by running brothels and “five cent theatres” was two-fold. Men profited, along with the entire city economy, and helped to expand the trade, while women were initially convinced that they were going to be making more money for themselves, or their families, and ultimately benefitting. Addams not only sheds light on these enticements, but also the “scars” of prostitution. Mental instability from traumatic experiences perniciously affected girls as they grew older and matured. Health problems that were associated with long term involvement also surfaced later in life. These outcomes of prostitution further provoked action and protection for young girls, as Addams argues proactively to reshape city-wide opportunities so that females of all ages can flourish in a moral and ethical manner. As Chicago grew to over 2.1 million by 1912, Addams argues, in context, of a formula which should be mandatory for helping to keep young women safe from commercialized vice. Included was increasing the city’s sanitary control and implementing a mandatory educational standard to inform urban youth of the dangers of the dark topic.
What is to be understood by this example is that there was many tricks-of-the-trade in prostitution. Fundamental is the selection process, targeting the most vulnerable young women. Those young enough who initially do not understand what entails the underground trade or are psychologically prone to men or young trade boys were all primary targets in the selection process, while internal ties within the girls’ workplace and even the police force, who helped to keep the vice running smoothly (while being paid by city officials under-the-table for this monitoring) were important affiliates of the vice. Exposing her not only to many new sexual decadences but the most important upside of prostitution: an increase in weekly income. Money is something Addams attributes to the mentality of women, in their ways of forming ideas around prostitution. Girls either kept quiet about their “busy lives in the city” (if they were from rural areas, other cities or countries) while supporting family and loved ones, or decided to live lavishly. An example of the lavish life can begin with “trade” boys. These boys first introduced themselves at social institutions such as dance halls. Gradually, on behalf of the local white slave circuit, he exposes her to the systematically encroaching vice within the ever-expanding commercialized city - one which is meretricious enough to give the girl a sense of opportunity.
Addams subtly but cleverly integrates a perspective that the ‘fallacy of composition’ is at work within the minds of men involved in tempting the girls into prostitution. There are many aspects hidden within the white slave trade that do not lead to guaranteed prosperity for every individual prostitute. Methods to convince a girl include first a rhetoric of trust, then to seamlessly integrate and expose her to the trade and its associating sub-vices including alcohol. The “Income Idea”, as I will informally call it, is the vice’s true fallacy. If the girl, who is being pressured into the vice, understands the possibility of making double or more in a week (to that of her wage in the previous or current average job), or is in dire need of money for supporting herself or her nuclear or extended family, would she not hesitate to think of only one aspect of the offer (quick and easy money!) and consequently the immediate gain?
When money is made in this business, it would seem to thrive on grabbing up females in a desperate state, or those who can preserve their diligence to the business. Intrepid or selfish young girls in comfortable middle class homes, the poor or financially desperate girls, or the immigrant who perseverates on the thought/mentality to find high paying work and believe they will come out of it in better shape financially (since their arrival to America’s “cog in the wheel” economy) all comprise the vice’s demography. They are the ones who are get caught up in the fallacy that if money is made “quickly”, which is only one component that makes up the deranged schema of prostitution, their personal liberty is surely on the horizon. Little do they know how cyclically damaging this mentality is. This demands the question: was there at one point no gendered decency or sexual morality to be found in Chicago?
Surprisingly, Addams bundles up enough evidence, including some verbal portrayals of victims she had spoken to, to prove the fallacy’s effectiveness within the early stages of invading the mind of a potential candidate. More shocking yet is the how she portrays the “booster” rhetoric of early twentieth century Chicago as alive and well as ever: vices contributed to the economic well-being of the city. As vanity-fanatic businessmen exposed little innocents to a disgraceful trade, Addams grapples with the contradictory nature of men and the twisted side of their mentalities in running a legitimate business on the engine of sex


Jane Addams' Concept Of "True Womanhood"

860 words - 4 pages The concept of "true womanhood" put forth by Jane Addams and other women suffrages fulfills the promise set forth by the New Women. These ideas of the women suffrages was to keep women in her own separate sphere, but to allow her sphere to grow outside of the home and into the surrounding world. Jane Addams and the other women suffrages wanted to fight in order to keep their status as a wife, a mother, a nurturer, and a keeper of cultured

Witchcraft and the Malevolance of the Susect: Targetting Midwives and others in Early Modern England - university of regina HISt 225 - Essay

1305 words - 6 pages always under scrutiny to dress right, behave accordingly and be steadfast in the roles they played on a domestic level, and place in the social hierarchy. [1: John Putnam Demos, Entertaining Satan. Oxford University Press: NY, 1982. 63.] [2: Ibid.] At one level, the witchcraft trails were devised to expose spiritual and religious impurities, and on another, drew a community together purging ‘themselves of the evil within, and used the idea of

Chooutla Indian School - The Notes of it, and likewise, a description - univeristy of regina - Assignment

500 words - 2 pages much of the departments over by 1911). The grounds originally housed shacks but the Department of Indian affairs intervened and sought out upgraded facilities in the fall of 1911. It was under the supervision (until his death in 1906) of a Bishop Bompas, a major figurehead in the missionary community in Carcross – where the original motive was to foster an education for orphaned children of the Yukon and neglected children within the territory. The

Class and Community Book Review - HIST 105 - Book Review

610 words - 3 pages Psychology in Film Assignment: Movie Character Psychological Disorder Presentation: A Beautiful Mind For this assignment, you will identify and describe a movie character’s psychological disorder and produce a Case Presentation in the form of a voice-narrated Powerpoint slide presentation recorded as an mp4 video file. Here are the “exact” project specifications for the assignment: 1. File-format: The only acceptable file-format for this

A Book review- ‘The Dream of Delhi as a Global City’ - La Trobe University - Review

1122 words - 5 pages huge traffic congestion and cause huge economic loss to the state. The road safety and security are significant as it increased the probability of road accidents. Thus, this has opened the horizon for new ideas of research. Although I found that this paper had all the elements that formalised a global city, it consists of inadequate details on the environmental impact assessments. It is an undeniable fact that globalised cities (like cities in China

Book review of Sound and sentiment - Hunter College - assignment

556 words - 3 pages Steven Feld has written a in teresting book, an ethnomusicology/anthropology book call “Sound and sentiment: Birds, Weeping, poetics, and Song in Kaluli Expression, it is a book interpreting how Kaluli people read sound and sentiment, and connecting between them with Bird songs, Weeping and poetics. Kaluli people is a small group living in the Southern Highlands Province of Papua New Guinea. The subject of the book is reveal in the beginning

A Critical Review of The Prince - junior, Beijing Foreign Studies University - book review

1550 words - 7 pages Counterarguments and Inconsistencies in The Prince ——A Reader-Friendly Review The Prince is a political treatise written by Machiavelli in 1513 when Italy became the center of intense political conflict. Machiavelli composed the pamphlet as a practical guide for ruling and hoped to gain himself an advisory position in the government by dedicating the book to the ruler of Florence. The major theme addressed in the book can be concluded as ends

The Lost letters of Pergamum Book Review - NOBTS New Testament - Book Review

1123 words - 5 pages A Book Review of The Lost Letters of Pergamum By Jeffrey Basford Longenecker, Bruce W. The Lost Letters of Pergamum: A Story from the New Testament World. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, a Division of Baker Publishing Group, 2016. Dr. Bruce W. Longenecker currently serves as professor of early Christianity at Baylor University in Waco, Texas. He began his time at Baylor University in 2009 having previously taught at St Andrews University

The Life of an ancient Olympian - N/A - Essay

1268 words - 6 pages Free Abhiraj Paliwal A Diary Entry of an Olympian An Olympian undergoes various experiences whilst intending to compete within the Olympics – who knows why? One would say that it is the expectations of your entire city-state resting on your shoulders; another would say that is the fact that those of Greek ethnicity would be watching you fulfil your ambitions and desires. Despite the infinite number of opinions on this matter, what I think, is what

An explanation and examination of Critical Analyses of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre - Concordia University Ann Arbor, English Literature II - Research Paper

2594 words - 11 pages Free ,” (qtd. In Keen 81) in an attempt to warn people from the dubious book. The book was published in the guise of an autobiography written by one ‘Jane Eyre’ and edited by the mysterious Currer Bell (a pseudonym used by Brontë) and was constantly subjected to criticism and questioning over the morality and actions of the titular character. Yet, it is obvious that the book is no longer viewed quite so extremely. It has been widely accepted as a classic

How much is Macbeth a victim of the forces of evil and what degree does he embrace evil - English - Essay

727 words - 3 pages Lady Macbeth was an influencing factor that led to Macbeth letting evil take over. Throughout the play we are see that Lady Macbeth is fearful of her husband’s good nature as it is ‘full o’ the milk of human kindness.’ This leads to Lady Macbeth having to challenge his manliness and provoke him in order for him to follow her plan so he can become King. The audience are able to see how Lady Macbeth starts to become a force of evil, with her even

discussion and comparison of Elizabeth - new jersey city university MHS101 - assignment

1374 words - 6 pages Discussion and comparison of Elisabeth zacharie In middle age of western music, neumes was an effective method to memorize melodies and the frame of a chant. It gave people a sense of what was the melody’s contour, even the exactly accurate pitch and rhythm were missing. This way was useful during the medieval period because people had learned music by using oral transmission for centuries before they invented neumes. According to what we

Bonus Assignment - Choose a topic and write an essay on it - University of Waterloo BIOL 439 - Essay

1990 words - 8 pages mixed with water, it becomes elastic and swells, forming more of a thick dough than a thin batter that is necessary for creating light and airy macarons (Trinh, 2016). If normal flour were added to a meringue base, the end result would be an angel food cake, which while still delicious, is not the product intended (Trinh, 2016). Confectioners’ Sugar Confectioners’ sugar is a finely powdered sugar (Cuq, Berthiaux, & Gatumel, 2013). It is sifted with

This is an essay that is a review on the new video game, Call of Duty Black Ops Four. - English 1101 - Essay

896 words - 4 pages Lawrence 2 Luke Lawrence English 1101 Mrs. Fee 21 September 2018 Blackout Review “Patriots always talk of dying for their country and never of killing for their country.” Call of Duty: Black Ops have created a new game mode in their franchise. Originally, Call of Duty had only had two game modes in their games, multiplayer and campaign mode. With the new rise of battle royale games, they have decided to make their own battle royale mode and put

Assignment was provided to review a Tesco Case Study and provide a review of it. - Strategic Management - Case Study

1101 words - 5 pages Kingdom. Under the leadership of CEO Terry Leahy there was a rapid expansion internationally and the strategy utilized in this expansion was to culturally customize the marketing plan for the international market. This strategy worked initially and in the early 2000’s the revenue had soared to new heights officially breaking the 1 billion pounds mark. The company, which is the only UK based retailer to have overseas locations, unfortunately has not