Liberal Or Authoritarian? How Would You Evaluate The 1993 Russian Constitution? Draw On The Constitution To Illustrate Your Answer

2666 words - 11 pages

Liberal:[adj.] Tolerant of change; not bound by authoritarianism, orthodoxy, or tradition or;[n] A person who favours a political philosophy of progress and reform and the protection of civil liberties.Authoritarian:[adj.] Characterized by or favouring absolute obedience to authority, as against individual freedom: an authoritarian regime, or;[adj.] Of, relating to, or expecting unquestioning obedience.To understand the fabric of the Russian constitution approved in December 1993, it is important to appreciate the political turmoil that coincided with its drafting and endorsement. During the early 1990s there was a concerted effort amongst the Soviet regime to reform the 1978 Russ ...view middle of the document...

While there was a fifty-eight percent approval for the constitution, the results were still contested, with opponents claiming Yeltsin had artificially inflated the turnout figures above the mandatory fifty percent required for the referendum to be valid. Even assuming the official figures are accurate, only slightly above thirty percent of the electorate gave their backing to the 1993 constitution. Due to the suspicion about Yeltsin's role in the creation of the constitution, there has been much debate over its ideological grounding.The second chapter of the constitution dealing with human and civil rights is its most perceptible liberal section, especially when considering the human rights violations that were commonplace under the Soviet regime. Article 22 for example prevents the authorities from detaining a citizen for more than 48 hours without a judicial review. While article 27 provides the right for Russian citizens to travel freely around the Russian Federation, and to 'choose his place of stay and residence' thus rendering the propiska residence permits unconstitutional. Continuing on this theme Article 61 states that a citizen of the Russian Federation could not be expelled from the country.The constitution established a series of republics, krais, oblasts and cities of federal significance, within a federal structure. Included in this was a guarantee that while Russian was the state language, the citizens had a right to retain their mother tongue and that 'numerically small' indigenous peoples had equal rights within the federation. Both of these are issues that had been contentious under the Soviet regime. This enabled Russia to become less centre orientated, with more power at the local and regional levels. This devolution of power to lower levels and recognition of a multi-cultural state is a clear step away from the centre dominated authoritarian past of Russia.A reversal of policy from the Soviet era also takes place in the economic rights set out in the constitution. Article 35 provides the right of private ownership, including the entitlement to buy and sell land. Article 8 reinforces this, with the acceptance of economic competition and freedom of economic activity. Combined with Article 34 which stipulated no monopolisation or 'unscrupulous competition' this is clearly a transition from the authoritarian centrally planned economic past of Russia to a new liberal market economy.Despite the liberal approach to the economy, Russia in the constitution defined herself as a 'social state' and clearly favoured a social liberal-democracy rather than the neo-liberal democracy that emerged in America and Britain during the 1980s. The structures of this socio-liberal democracy are evident in the provision of free schooling, healthcare, welfare benefits, worker rights such as minimum wage and maximum working hours and concern towards the environment. There are also fundamentalist scholars though who believe the word 'social'...


"Respiration is very similar to burning." Is this true? Illustrate your answer by describing 3 similarities and 3 differences between the two

603 words - 3 pages Respiration is a process which releases energy from energy-rich molecules such as glucose. The glucose is converted into energy which is usable for life processes. Burning, or combustion, is a reaction between a substance and a gas to release energy. These two reactions have many similarities but are not the same. This essay will identify some of similarities and differences between the two processes.The first similarity is that both respiration

How Democratic Is The American Constitution

1563 words - 7 pages examination of the Constitution and its shortcoming or we need to reduce the inequalities that occur in the political system. In the end of the chapter, when addressing whether change is truly possible, Dahl concedes that he cannot foresee how successful policies to create change would be. Also, our understanding of politics and the implication of policies are dynamic and will continue to evolve.Chapter eight addresses the sizes of states and the

How do we Amend the Constitution - Essay

1514 words - 7 pages against you · Right to a speedy and public trial · Right to an impartial jury · Right to face witnesses against you in court · Right to counsel (a lawyer) · Right to call witnesses in your defense In the era prior to the revolution, British courts could keep a suspect in jail without accusing him/her of a crime or bringing them into a court of law. Many suspects sat in prison for years awaiting trial, only to be found innocent an released. 7 Rights

State House Yard Speech On The Constitution

917 words - 4 pages the Constitution. Wilson, who was a delegate in the Federal Convention, was asked to speak to the people to explain the Constitution and answer to some of the criticisms that had been made.Wilson, a Federalist, and a firm believer in the validity of the Constitution, made his speech in response to the disapproval to the signing of the Constitution, on September 17, of the same year. People were afraid that a centralized government would be

How the Constitution Changed America - College US History - Essay

597 words - 3 pages When the Constitution of the United States was written in 1787 it changed the lives of many.  The constitution is such a famous piece of writing for many reasons. It is well known not just because it established a democratic government but, more of how it consistent it is with modern society. When the constitution was written the founding fathers made it in such a way that it would be able to relate to society as it modernized. As this new

Does the constitution Forbid Religious Displays on Public Property?

545 words - 3 pages Does the Constitution Forbid Religious Displays on Public Property?We look to the United States Constitution, to answer many questions about our government and our rights. It outlines the structure of our federal government, as well as the freedoms this country affords. When I first thought about the question, “Does the Constitution forbid religious displays on public property?”, I automatically assumed that it did not. But upon

What are your thoughts on heaven? Who are the five people you would like to meet in heaven? - English 207 - Assignment

842 words - 4 pages in that car when she knew he was drunk. I also want to ask her if she misses her sisters and misses talking and fighting with them, even though she Is in a perfect place now. If I were to meet one of my parents, I think they could tell me so many things about my life that I had not figured out before now. I know my parents would be probably the best people to tell me how great or how bad I lived because I know they would tell the truth. I have

How To Be A Governor,Or What You Would Do As One

476 words - 2 pages remove any of these officials he or she feels are incomplete.With the approval of the General Assembly the Governor may reorganize any executive agencies in the state which are responsible to the Governor.The Governor may grant pardons, commutations, and reprieves as he or she thinks proper.The Governor, at the beginning of each session, and at the close of the Governor's term of office, shall report to the General Assembly on the condition of the

Section 127 Of The Australian Constitution

1698 words - 7 pages colonists, whose guns gave them the advantage over the Aborigines, made it plain they intended to remain, and began altering the landscape, clearing trees and building fences, resistance grew among the Aboriginal people and they suffered increasing numbers of casualties. As the settlements expanded, Aboriginal numbers declined, and their ways of life in many areas were destroyed, with survivors beginning to live within or on the fringes of the new

The Declaration and the Constitution: Their Christian Roots

467 words - 2 pages The Declaration and the Constitution: Their Christian Roots. The Declaration of Independence indeed shows its Christian roots. However, the original draft of the Declaration, written by Thomas Jefferson, was very vague in showing religious connections. It only mentioned one embedded reference to God, "the laws of nature and of nature's God," which is a direct reference to the laws of God, described in John Locke's Second Treatise on Civil

Constitutional Law - The UK and its Constitution - Law - Assignment

3275 words - 14 pages Free constitution is a body of rules – some laws, some conventions – which regulate its system of government”.[footnoteRef:2] Suggesting that the UK Constitution is governed by laws and conventions, whether these are written or not. With regard to the current state of the UK Constitution, many believe that our dispersed constitution is anachronistic, this opinion was developed within the Political and Constitutional Reform Committee’s “Consultation on A new

the importance of the constitution - lab school 8 - essay

560 words - 3 pages president of the United States and was a U.S. senator for Illinois. In the A More Perfect Union speech Obama mentions the preamble and how to build on it today. “We the people, in order to form a more perfect union…but it also means binding our own particular grievances… it means taking full responsibility for own lives. (Obama, A more Perfect Union Pg.25)” Obama’s speech talks about the need to build upon the preamble and the need to take action. The

Rattification of the Constitution - US History - Research Paper

985 words - 4 pages Constitution did not provide for the acquisition of new land or negotiating treaties without the consent of the Senate”. The federalists opposed the purchase because they felt threatened because new states in the West and South would diminish their power because they were mostly New Englanders. They also felt that President Jefferson was mistreating presidential power because the Constitution did not give the president power to purchase land on his own

How Did The Nineteenth Amendment Come To Be Part Of Our Constitution And Why Was It Significant? A History Of The Female Right's Movement And The Importance Of The 19th Amendment

1560 words - 7 pages the amendment would not pass, but twenty-four-year-old Harry Burn cast his vote for ratification giving them the one last vote necessary in the Tennessee house. Tennessee became the thirty-sixth, and final state for ratification. On August 24, 1920, the Nineteenth Amendment was finally added to the US Constitution. It is commonly referred to as the "Susan B. Anthony Amendment," in honor of her works and efforts. Sadly, she died fifteen years before

Is the United States Constitution outdated - Composition - Essay

1356 words - 6 pages talks about how his son reacted to the Michael Brown news and how he did not comfort his son because he felt that it would be wrong. He remembers how his father beat him with more anxiety than anger in a fear that he would be lost in the jail system, on the streets, or even be killed. Coates recalls a boy pulled a gun and affirmed himself in the order of things making him realize how quickly he could lose his life. Later in the chapter, Coates