The Metaphysical Puzzle Of The Ship Of Theseus: Persistence In Time King's College London Essay

1289 words - 6 pages

What is the puzzle of the ship of Theseus? Outline and evaluate one potential solution.
The aim of this paper is to give a possible solution for solving the puzzle of the ship of Theseus. I will first outline what the puzzle is about and its main metaphysical implications, and I will then proceed by taking into consideration one of the possible solutions, namely perdurantism and four dimensionalism. I will explain what being a four-dimensional object implies, and give an interpretation of why this might be a possible solution for the puzzle.
The puzzle of the ship of Theseus is a philosophical puzzle that has to do with problems associated with numerical identity and the concept of transitivity. The puzzle goes as follows. The ship that once belonged to Theseus was left in the Athens’ harbour for many years. In order to prevent it from deteriorating, once a year one plank was substituted with a new plank. It is now necessary to state that, for the purpose of this paper, the elements that constitute the ship will be reduced to the planks only, as this does not affect the consequences of the puzzle but it highly simplifies its understanding. Therefore, after 1000 years, the ship of Theseus, that will be referred to as ship A, or original ship, will have undergone a complete change of its components. I shall call this renewed ship ship B. The planks that were taken away from ship A were not dismantled but were preserved and reassembled to reconstruct a new ship, ship C, that was conserved in the local museum of Athens for visitors to see.
Therefore, on one hand, we have that A = B, because it is easily graspable that a ship can undergo a process of repair whilst still being the same ship. On the other hand, we hold that A = C, because a ship (C) made up of the same components as the original ship (A) is also the same ship as the original (A). However, and this is the core of the puzzle, there can’t be two ships of Theseus, namely B and C. As stated above, the problem is twofold. Firstly, it is a problem concerning numerical identity. Numerical identity holds that things are numerically identical if they are one and the same thing; but, according to this definition, both B and C are one and the same with A. Secondly, it is a problem of transitivity. If A = B, and A = C, then, by property of transitivity, B = C; however, we know that ship B and ship C are two different ships, being one in the harbour and the other in the museum.
One way of solving the puzzle is resorting to perdurantism and four dimensionalism.[footnoteRef:1] Before delineating how these concepts can, in actual fact, come as a helpful means in understanding the puzzle, I will give a definition of both. Four dimensionalism holds that objects are constituted not only of spatial parts but also of temporal parts, or stages. In this sense, they are four dimensional, being spread out not only in the three dimensions of space – height, width, depth – but also in time. Following from four dimensionalism, perdurantism holds that “an object persists through time in virtue of possessing successive temporal parts, so that [...] only part of a persisting object, its current temporal part, is present at any one time during its existence.” (Lowe 2002). Thus, objects’ persistence over time is possible because they have different temporal parts at distinct times. In a sense, it is as if an object is never fully revealed at different stages, but each time just a part of the object is revealed. Hence, for perdurantists, an object at t0 is the same at t1, but the part of the object shown at t0 is different from the part of the object shown at t1. [1: Ney, Alyssa, Metaphysics: an Introduction, p. 173-177. ]
This is in contrast with another view, that of endurantism, that is based on three dimensionality: objects are described in having only a spatial extension, and therefore they “persist over time by being wholly present at each time at which they exist”.[footnoteRef:2] [2: Ney, Alyssa, Metaphysics: an Introduction, cit. p. 174. ]
I will now examine how perdurantism and four dimensionalism link back to the puzzle. The reason for the incongruence before, namely that a) A was numerically identical both to B and C and b) B and C were different even though should have been the same in the name of transitivity, is that we held an endurantist, three dimensional view. This means that we thought A persisted over time by being a later object but always identical to it; so ship B was a later ship A, because it was identical to it, and also C was a later A because it was identical too.
However, if we change our perspective and analyse the puzzle through the lenses of perdurantism and four dimensionalism, then we have that A’s persistence over time is linked to its different temporal parts at different times and is not wholly present at each time; therefore, A needs not to be strictly identical to B or C.
In order to fully understand the puzzle, we need to clarify another step. Following Ney’s argument,[footnoteRef:3] most of perdurantists and four dimensionalists are also mereological universalists, meaning that they believe that “any non-overlapping material objects whatsoever compose some further object.”.[footnoteRef:4] Hence, we have two temporally extended objects: 1) one that includes A and B, and 2) another that includes A and C in their parts. Since both contain A’s parts, there is not a best candidate to be A. While this constituted a problem before, because both B and C were identical to A, here there is no such problem. Indeed, we don’t have to choose between B and C in the first place, because A’s persistence over time is not related to its strict numerical identity. [3: Ney, Alyssa, Metaphysics: an Introduction, p. 175.] [4: Ney, Alyssa, Metaphysics: an Introduction, cit. p. 175-176. ]
An objection might arise at this point. If we are to say that both B and C share a part of A, then we would need to accept that B and C are present in the same location at t0, meaning that there are two ships to start with in the same location at the same time. However, this, once again, does not constitute a problem. Indeed, perdurantists do not hold that there are two ships wholly present at the same location at the same time, but simply that a temporal part of each ship is present at the same location at the same time. This constitutes a case of temporal overlap, which is not different than a spatial overlap, that is easily understood in many other cases, e.g. roads overlapping when sharing a common part while still carrying their own name.
In conclusion, the puzzle of the ship of Theseus can be solved by resorting to perdurantism and four dimensionalism since this would solve both a) the problem of numerical identity and b) that of transitivity. Indeed, a) we wouldn’t have to choose between B and C in the first place, since for an object to persist over time it does not need to be strictly identical, and b) we can allow both B and C to be the same as A but different in regard to each other by saying that they only share a common temporal part (A) when they overlap.
(word count: 1254)
Lowe, J. 2002. A Survey of Metaphysics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Ney, Alyssa. 2014. Metaphysics: an Introduction. New York: Routledge.


weather in the time of the butterflies - English class - Essay

924 words - 4 pages Jason Green Ms. McElhatton Responding to Literature March 29, 2018 Not Just Rain The novel In The Time of the Butterflies, by Julia Alvarez, is a story told by four sisters living under the rule of dictator Rafael Trujillo in the Dominican Republic from 1938 to 1994. All four sisters alternate turns telling stories from their perspectives and fight for their entitled rights while they battle Trujillo who constantly creates setbacks and denies

Theseus and the Minotaur: Origins - Humanities - Essay

420 words - 2 pages Afshar 1 Niloofar Afshar Wendy Neeld Humanities 6413 30 November 2018 Theseus and the Minotaur: Origins The legend of Theseus and the Minotaur is one that has presumably originated, in the form of literature, as early as 46-120 AD, written down by Greek historians and Roman poets. However, the story itself is believed to be much older, having been passed down through the art of storytelling generation after generation. The legend; a myth as it

patton at the battle of the bulgue leader ship - ag school - essay

1276 words - 6 pages On December 16th 1944. Hitler had convinced himself that the alliance between Britain, France and America in the western sector of Europe was not strong and that a major attack and defeat would break up the alliance. Therefore, he ordered a massive attack against what were primarily American forces. The attack is strictly known as the Ardennes Offensive but because the initial attack by the Germans created a bulge in the Allied front line, it

How free were the free blacks in the north during the time of slavery - History - Essay

860 words - 4 pages Ryan Trybula Canul History 05 March 2018 How Free Were Free Blacks In The North So what kind of rights did the blacks that were free have in north? The blacks that were free in the northern states don't necessarily have the kind of rights that one might think. While they were free they were still discriminated against all the time. They had trouble politically and couldn’t get jobs very easily. Also whites did not allow the blacks to do anything

Essay On The Movie "Battle Ship Potemkin."

1516 words - 7 pages The movie Battleship Potemkin is said to be one of the best montage sequence movies ever made and when the movie was finished (1925) it got a lot of government attention and was banned by the bored of censorship. But when it was shown to the public in 1954 it was voted as one of the best movies in the history of cinema. But exactly, what made it such a controversial movie that at the time it had to be banned, and how did people react to the

Rigging the game: CPA as an illegitimate strategic business action - London School of Economics - Essay

2165 words - 9 pages legislation/regulation to be in compliance on time. Since I don’t see any harm in just being informed and observing the law, this paper will discuss the legitimacy of proactive CPA as a strategic action i.e. designed to achieve a long-term or overall aim of the enterprise (Chandler, 1962). First, this paper will explain how non-market CSR (integrating social and environmental concerns in the business operations and interactions with their stakeholder

In the time of Butterflies Final essay - Johnson high school - esssay

449 words - 2 pages “In the Time of Butterflies” By Julia Alvarez Final Argumentative Essay (_____/7) Prompt – Courage has been seen as an essential human virtue for centuries. Think about one of the Mirabal sisters as she is portrayed in the novel In the Time of the Butterflies. What kind of courage did she show? What was the source of this courage? How was it expressed? Did she ever fail to show courage at a critical moment? In essence, of the four sisters, which

What is Time: An Essay on the Concept of Time - Grade 9 Science - Essay

631 words - 3 pages closer to sea level. An experiment to test this theory was performed in the 1970s with one atomic clock in an airplane and one placed on the ground. The results showed that time went by slower by a fraction of a second for the clock in the airplane which was in motion compared to the clock on the ground. These results further proved that Einstein’s theory of the passing of time and how it could be affected was correct. Though there is no theoretical

viking ship essay about the sea splitter and how it sailed the sea in viking times - Humanities - History

485 words - 2 pages Carson Richards Mr. Moore Humanities 10 November 4, 2018 The Sea Splitter The famous “Sea Splitter” was built in the small city of Ribe, Denmark by a group of ten Danish men. The men spent countless amounts of hours working on building a ship that could hopefully lead them to a small island off the coast of Denmark that was filled with gold and treasures. Years later, the ship was built and ready to go to sea. The men packed up their supplies

The struggle of family income in college - Persuasive essay - Essay

715 words - 3 pages Nohely dela Rosa Duncan Hasell Enlish 1301 11 February 2018 The struggle of family income in college Every parent dream it’s for their son or daughter to go to college but, unfortunately is not everyone is lucky enough to be able to afford it and is not as easy as it seems when it comes to it. There are many obstacles to overcome and conquer throughout the experience and one of the biggest obstacle is money. Of course, money isn’t free and a

Comparative Essay of Othello and Handmaids Tale - American school in London - Research

1708 words - 7 pages conditions of the LON. Therefore, it could be argued that although the league of nations had maintained peace for many years, WW2 had brought the LON to an end, proving it had failed miserably. The losses of world war one emphasised the necessity of the league. Appeasement was in Britain's favour since the war created ‘devastation’ with deaths of 750,000 young men, debts were 7 billion, export markets lost industries (ship building & textiles

In Gothic Literature women are generally presented as victims - City of London Freemen's School - Essay

1683 words - 7 pages times. When the Marquis gifted her the necklace, she “saw how much that cruel necklace became me. And, for the first time in my innocent and confined life, I sensed in myself a potentiality for corruption that took my breath away.” The potential corruption of her innocence comes partly from the losing of her virginity, but results in the protagonist stating “No. I was not afraid of him; but of myself.” Kidd’s assertion that "at the heart of the

Iss London a good place to live - Queen Mary University of London - Essay

758 words - 4 pages Student name: Dinh Thi Ngoc Biet (Ria) Student ID: 180125973 IS LONDON A GOOD PLACE TO LIVE London is one of the megacities in the world where people want to be here in many purposes. Whether London is a good place to live has always been a topic of debate. While many people think that London is a terrible place, I believe that it is wonderful to live in London particularly in the areas of education, people, and transportation. First of all

Subordination of Women in The Yellow Wallpaper - College English - Essay

1223 words - 5 pages Talley 4 Elizabeth Talley Mrs. Turk English 1302.2 11 November 2017 The Subordination of Women in The Yellow Wallpaper For centuries, women have been viewed as helpless and simple minded by the controlling patriarchal society. In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wallpaper,” the narrator is being confined in her bedroom by her husband, John, who is a physician and believes she is suffering from temporary nervous depression. He

The causes of disease in Humans - Wymondham College - Biology Essay

1092 words - 5 pages people as it is due to cumulative damage over a long period, such as a life time of smoking. Other lifestyles choices like diet, amount of exercise, alcohol intake andthe environment you live in, can also cause disease. A combination of these factors can cause serious diseases, such as Atherosclerosis which is generally caused by a poor diet and lack of exercise. Both of these things can cause a build-up of fatty deposits in the arteries. The LDL