To What Extent Has The Westminster Parliament Been Marginalised By An Overly Powerful Executive? Politics Essay

2114 words - 9 pages

To what extent has the Westminster Parliament been marginalised by an overly powerful executive?  
Kate Doyle – 7637213
Who Runs Britain? Power, Politics and Beyond - 1718 POL1100M-1718 
Word count:1901
The legislative branch of the Westminister parliament consists of two chambers, The House of Commons and The House of Lords, the executive branch being The Government (the Prime Minister and the Cabinet). The extent to which the Westminister Parliament has been marginalised by an overly powerful executive is often a polarising argument amongst academics with many arguing that that the main function of parliament itself is to hold the government to account and check the executive power whereas others argue that many aspects of the political process in the UK, including what they consider to be an overly powerful executive in the form of leadership style, constrain the power and overall effectiveness of parliament resulting in parliament becoming ‘totally irrelevant’ (King and Crewe, 2013, p. 361). Whilst the extent to which the parliament of Westminister has been marginalised by an overly powerful executive largely depends on each individual election, parliamentary term and Prime Ministerial style, the evidence I will present in this essay overwhelmingly suggest that The Parliament of Westminister has in fact not been marginalised by an overly powerful executive.
When discussing the supposed weakening or marginalising of parliament many people refer to the style of leadership undertaken in the premierships of former prime ministers Tony Blair (1997 - 2007) and Margaret Thatcher (1997 - 1990). The style of leadership of both of these past leaders of government have been widely compared to each other and often referred to as ‘presidential’ or ‘Spatial’. Meaning that their personal and individual role as head of the executive and party became a large part of their style of leadership. This has recently come to be referred to as the ‘cult of personality’. Furthermore, they were seen to be dismissive of the advice democratically elected officials such as members of parliament and more closely, members of their own party and even members of the cabinet, which they themselves had selected, on certain issues, e.g. under Blair the cabinet rarely met more than once a week’ (Jones and Norton, 2014). For example, one policy introduced under (Blair’s) new labour’s vision of modernisation with regards to the commons was the grouping of the two 15 minute Prime Ministers Questions sessions held each week, on Tuesday and Thursday since 1961 (Guardian, 1998), to a single weekly half an hour slot. The reason this is a clear example of a more presidential style is that the policy and reform were ‘introduced by diktat rather than consultation and agreement’ (Cowley, 2001). This is often a consideration highlighted by those who believe that to a large extent parliament has been marginalised by a powerful executive because with a majority of four hundred and eighteen...

Other Essays On To what extent has the Westminster Parliament been marginalised by an overly powerful executive? - Politics - Essay

To what extent was the German Reformation caused by humanist criticisms of the Catholic Church? - Essay Reformation - Essay

1283 words - 6 pages To what extent was the German Reformation caused by humanist criticisms of the Catholic Church? To say the German Reformation was caused by humanist criticisms of the Catholic Church is true to only a small extent. Despite some historians saying ‘no humanism, no reformation [?] this is incorrect. Although the criticisms made by humanists contributed to making the reformation more likely, to say it was the cause of the reformation is only true to

To what extent is traditional marriage an outdated concept in Singapore? - Nanyang Technological University - Essay

987 words - 4 pages To what extent is traditional marriage an outdated concept in Singapore? Unifying two heterosexual people legally in wedlock, marriage is a customary contract that institutes commitment between them. Recognised as the basis for reproduction, individuals are also bound in matrimony for various other reasons like religious and financial purposes. The institution of marriage is seemingly vibrant in Singapore, with 28,407 marriages registered in

To what extent was Diocletian’s Tetrarchy characterised by a rejection of dynastic principles? - univeristy - essay

1926 words - 8 pages To what extent was Diocletian’s Tetrarchy characterised by a rejection of dynastic principles? The notions of dynasty and hereditary rights were some of the cornerstones of Roman society from the earliest times. The view that clients, property and influence (among a great deal of other things) were inherited via your family was central to life in the empire. Since the initiating of the principate with Augustus in 27 BC, the emperors were

to what extto what extent are roles and responsibilities changing within the household - sociology - essay

1458 words - 6 pages To what extent are roles and responsibilities changing? (24 marker) Families are viewed by functionalists as a nuclear family structure, which consists of a father, mother and approximated two children. According to Murdock every society has a form of nuclear family structure, which is the majority type of family in every society that he investigated. However, family structures have gradually changed for several reasons, and different family

"To what extent did France promote the unification of Italy?" Short Essay - European History - Essay

668 words - 3 pages To what extent did France promote the unification of Italy from 1848 to 1870? During the Italian Unification, France was one of the most prominent countries present as the revolutions played out. However, it is arguable whether France helped or hindered Italy during its unification. It is true that the Franco-Sardinian alliance provided Italy with protection against one of their biggest enemies, Austria, and that France bore the majority of the

to what extent was romanticism a reaction to the enlightenment - University of Brighton - essay

1912 words - 8 pages they saw the child as close to nature. The child had access to a unique worldview, solely because a child has not yet rationalised and assimilated the nature of society the way an adult has, i.e. the child has not yet been corrupted by Enlightenment understanding. There is a crossover here however between Romantics and the Enlightenment thinkers; Rousseau, one of the fathers of the period was one of the first to represent the child as an

To what extent was homosexuality the norm in classical Athens - Ancient History - Essay

4303 words - 18 pages [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] 1693552 To what extent was homosexuality seen as a deviation from the norm for a classical Athenian male citizen? Athenian homosexuality is a huge topic, which has stimulated vast scholarly debate. The Athenians themselves were very confused regarding homosexuality, which makes our understanding of it even harder. It is important to recognize that their norm and our norm are vastly different ideas, they had no

To what extent did life improve for African Americans after the abolishment of slavery? - School - Essay

1757 words - 8 pages 'separate but equal'. In reality, black people’s facilities were almost always worse, in comparison to white facilities. The 15th amendment, had flaws as well, which limited the chance for African Americans to have an opinion. States did this by making it almost impossible for them to register. They introduced literacy tests, with questions such as; ‘How many bubbles are in a bar of soap?’. There was also the introduction of the Grandfather

Music as Influence: How has society been shaped by musical genres throughout history? - english - essay

1145 words - 5 pages and see if they correlate. I also wanted to reflect on the section in my poster featuring responses to the question: “what impact does music have on society”. There wasn’t one participant who had anything negative to say about music, which helped me to realize just how important it has and will always be. Keywords Music; Sociology; Musical Genres; Influence; History Abstract Musical genres have been an integral part in all societies, ancient and

What is Politics in Defence of Politics by Bernard Crick? - University First Year - Essay

1013 words - 5 pages power. They view politics as a universal process that affects more than just political parties and government; politics can be present anywhere from the parliament to the domain of families and friends. Bibliography – 1) Crick, B., In Defence of Politics (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1982), Ch. 1 2) Leftwich, A., ‘The Political Approach to Human Behaviour: People, Resources and Power’, in Leftwich, A. (ed.) What is Politics: The Activity and its Study (Oxford: Blackwell, 1984) 3) Schwarzmantel, J., Structures of Power: An Introduction to Politics (Brighton: Wheatsheat, 1987), Ch. 1

to what extent is a model penal system - criminology - essay

936 words - 4 pages deadline has passed and the Senior Tutor has not approved an extension request or if the SSPSSR template has not been use. Things you need to take note of when preparing/writing your essay: 1. Read the question and make sure that you understand what is required. For example, if the question asks you to ‘critically appraise’ then the answer requires you to formulate an argument and make a judgement. You’ll need to illustrate how you came to it by

Similar Papers

Balance Of Powers Between The Executive And Parliament Politics Essay

1291 words - 6 pages Evaluate the extent to which the balance of power has shifted from the executive to parliament in recent years (30 marks) This essay will highlight the extent of power in the UK political system in relation to the Executive and Parliament. The balances of power are often given in the form of powers that are exclusively composed to different legislative branches. The ultimate abilities of power exist between the branches of government as well as

Balance Of Powers Between The Executive And Parliament Politics Essay

1291 words - 6 pages Evaluate the extent to which the balance of power has shifted from the executive to parliament in recent years (30 marks) This essay will highlight the extent of power in the UK political system in relation to the Executive and Parliament. The balances of power are often given in the form of powers that are exclusively composed to different legislative branches. The ultimate abilities of power exist between the branches of government as well as

To What Extent Has The Modern Revolution Been A Positive Or Negative Force? John Cgrew Essay

647 words - 3 pages To what extent has the Modern Revolution been a positive or negative force? The modern revolution has been a positive force to a somewhat large extent. This is due to the various innovations that it brought such as steam locomotive and computers which have revolutionised the way humans interact with the world. The modern revolution also brought major advancements in medical science which improved the lives of millions and raised the average life

The Price Of Oil Has Been Increasing. What Would You Suggest To Solve The Crisis?

409 words - 2 pages Rising oil price has a profound impact on people's life everywhere. Therefore, an recent issue involving the price of oil and what should the government do has been brought up. Personally, I think the government should issue free public transit and encourage more people to ride their bicycles to work. The government should also search for other alternative sources a energy to replace oil in the near future.The reason oil price has been so high