Balance Of Powers Between The Executive And Parliament Politics Essay

1291 words - 6 pages

Evaluate the extent to which the balance of power has shifted from the executive to parliament in recent years (30 marks)
This essay will highlight the extent of power in the UK political system in relation to the Executive and Parliament. The balances of power are often given in the form of powers that are exclusively composed to different legislative branches. The ultimate abilities of power exist between the branches of government as well as parliament. In terms of legislative power, it may be argued that the United Kingdom lacks a sustainable constitution due to an Elective Dictatorship whereby an elected UK government can do as they please and make changes without a consensus. Constitutional conventions are not legally binding and therefore may restrict the flexibility of powers amongst the Executive and Parliament. However, the UK constitution is unentrenched and statute law is much easier to enact through parliament via the ordinary legislative process (a parliamentary majority). The balance of powers could be argued to be equal due to this and there being no specific majorities or arrangements that are needed to pass a law.
It could be indicated that there is an extent to which the Executive has dominated parliament in terms of power in recent years due to the relative weakness of legislative committees. Legislative committees make up a significant role of the governmental process and provide an important part in scrutinising the UK political system. However, committees which are subject to partisan whipping show how the balances of power are greatly shifted over to the Executive. Some may see holding the government accountable based on political party lines as undemocratic. In addition, the opposition is in a minority and is highly unlikely to see any of its amendments adapted in the government. Furthermore, the strength of party loyalty contributes to the effectiveness in balances of powers by the Executive. MPs have a natural allegiance to the party they represent and will therefore support it most of the time. In any circumstances, MPs are whipped into supporting government policies as the ultimate price for disloyalty is deselection.
On the other hand, Ministers are unlikely to break a 3-line whip or revolt against parliamentary decisions therefore giving parliament the upper-hand in terms of powers. Legislative committees specifically Select Committees have an admirable record of bipartisanship and forcing government to be accountable. They also have the possibility of amending policies. Moreover, there is no legal obligation for Ministers to consult committees which now play such an important role in the policy making process. It is noted that the government could not function effectively without such a system of committees, although there is no legal requirement for them. Therefore, the balances of power between the Executive and Parliament has markedly shifted towards parliament. In addition, the House of Lords is more dive...

RELATED

Balance of Powers between the executive and parliament - Politics - Essay

1291 words - 6 pages Evaluate the extent to which the balance of power has shifted from the executive to parliament in recent years (30 marks) This essay will highlight the extent of power in the UK political system in relation to the Executive and Parliament. The balances of power are often given in the form of powers that are exclusively composed to different legislative branches. The ultimate abilities of power exist between the branches of government as well as

To what extent has the Westminster Parliament been marginalised by an overly powerful executive? - Politics - Essay

2114 words - 9 pages To what extent has the Westminster Parliament been marginalised by an overly powerful executive?   Kate Doyle – 7637213 Who Runs Britain? Power, Politics and Beyond - 1718 POL1100M-1718  Word count:1901 The legislative branch of the Westminister parliament consists of two chambers, The House of Commons and The House of Lords, the executive branch being The Government (the Prime Minister and the Cabinet). The extent to which the Westminister

How does Shakespeare maintain the balance between seriousness and comedy in the play "Much ado about nothing"?

357 words - 2 pages his comrades interrogate Conrade and Borachio. The comedy in this scene mainly comes through Dogberry especially after Conrad labels him "an ass". Dogberry wants this naming of him to be recorded so that Conrad will get a worse punishment. These two points show that the balance between seriousness and comedy is maintained by the use of both these points in conjunction with each other.The various types of characters in the play allow for different

Article II of the US Constitution grants the president numerous powers and responsibilities - Government - Paper

1437 words - 6 pages acts not only as Americas chief executive but also as the leader of nations belonging to NATO. Many of his other functions, such as controller of Americas atomic arsenal, give him great powers over many other people in the world. When the people choose a president, they first tend to look at which man supports most of their own rights and beliefs and interests. A man speaking the values and morals and that presents himself as a good and capable man

A creative writing piece on the relaxing powers of the woods - English composition - Creative writing essay

562 words - 3 pages I sit quietly in the woods, my back leaning up against the rough bark of the cottonwood tree. I can feel each groove and track running through the bark. Underneath me I can feel the planks of the the wooden platform I sit on. There is a breeze stirring through the barren branches of the forest around me. The rope suspended thirty feet in the air by a steel wire sways back and forth as if pushed by an invisible hand. The rope seems to call to me

How The Public Services Balance The Rights Of The Individual

680 words - 3 pages In this task I will look at the rights of the individual and how the public services balance these rights in order to keep society safe, and the individual still content and with full human rights.The rights of the individual are the same as people's human rights; these include things such as freedom of assembly, freedom of expression, the right to life and quite a few more. These human rights should always be aloud in society; no one should be

How the Beauty Industry Failed Women of Color - Binghamton University, Media and Politics - Essay

4211 words - 17 pages Christina Mille Professor Joseph Leeson- Schatz Media and Politics ENG 450V Spring 2018 How the Beauty Industry Failed Women of Color In the same way that the fashion industry continuously sets the standard of fashion in society, the cosmetics industry has defined beauty since the industry’s rise to success and popularity. Led by big name companies such as MAC and L’Oreal, the cosmetics industry is a breeding ground for all things beauty and

power and politics, it speaks of the different forms of power in the political system - varsity - Essay

1636 words - 7 pages means mindful of. Steven Lukes, characterizes Power as far as, what he calls 'Dimensions', these Dimensions are approaches that can be utilized to think about power relations and the theory of power as a whole. Steven Lukes argued that in order to properly understand the theory of power one must recognize the three dimensions of power, this essay will critically discuss this argument. The concept of power is ambiguous, and to this day it continues

World Politics Assignment Comparing the Difference between President Obama and President Trump - Melbourne Grammar, Year 10 - Assignment

607 words - 3 pages POLITICS ESSAY – Trump and Obama President Barack Obama will be replaced on Friday by a man who is his opposite in many obvious ways — party affiliation, upbringing and ethnicity. But the differences between the two men on tone and temperament are the most polarizing of all. It continues a familiar pattern in modern times in which the new president presents a clear contrast to the person he’s succeeding. In 1992, the Democrat from Hope, Ark

The American Dream And Politics

2459 words - 10 pages Akinwumi, Akinbola E. “A New Kind of Entanglement? Immigrants, The ‘American Dream’ and the Politics of Belonging.” Geografiska Annaler Series B: Human Geography 88.2 (2006):249-253. Academic Search Complete. 22 Oct. 2007Akinbola E. Akinwumi is a Nigerian scholar with interests in global studies, cultural geography and the politics of development. He is a researcher at the Information Aid Network (IFANET), Ibadan, Nigeria

A Study of South East Asian Politics Through the 20th Century - Politics - Politics

1923 words - 8 pages different path. The Cold war was the period of hostile relations between the USSR and the US, between the soviet bloc and the western powers after the second world war. This period of relations dominated global politics in the 20th and 21st Century. The reason for this hostility was due to their vastly conflicting beliefs and ideology, capitalist and communism. Also in the context of post world war two global politics, both states had the largest

the australian parliament should not have members with dual citizens - thomas more college 12 - essay

1254 words - 6 pages Stage one: legal studies “Should MP’s with dual citizenship be made to resign” There hasn’t been much excitement and interest in the constitution until now with the rise of dual citizenship occurring in the parliament. The thin majority of Australian prime minister Malcolm Turnbull's administration is under threat from a constitutional crisis. A progression of prominent MPs, including the deputy prime minister and another government minister may

Eerything Needed About The Articles Of Confederation, The Federalist, Anti-Federalist, The Elastic Clause, Federalism, Delegated, Express, Reserved, And Concurrent Powers

784 words - 4 pages 1. Articles of confederationIn Philadelphia, 1787 the articles of confederation where revised by 55 delegates. They agree that they needed to write a new constitution, that they where in need of a strong government, that there should be an executive branch (president), and that the states should not be as powerful as a national government. But they also had some disagreements like how many representatives should each state have in congress, how

changing work patterns for women, technology and life balance - school - explain essay

704 words - 3 pages patterns can include; · Flexible working conditions · Technology change · Changing employee expectations · Casualisation of the workforce · Feminisation of the workforce · Work-life balance · Your response needs to be supported with evidence from the ‘Australian Bureau of Statistics’ and other sources. · You must submit a completed bibliography and the scaffold at the start of the lesson. Students are not permitted to use the scaffold during the

The Correlation Between Science and Religion in Life Of Pi - English - Essay

1033 words - 5 pages the protagonist, Piscine (Pi) Molitor Patel, as he seeks meaning in his life through faith in both spirituality and reason. When put to the greatest test of survival, it becomes evident that his open minded attitude is what aids him. Martel uses Pi in order to portray that a balance of both religion and science in one is practical and essential. The encounter between Mr. Kumar, Pi’s biology teacher and the first devout atheist he meets, and Mr