Why The North Won The Civil War By David Donald: Reflection On The Economic, Military, Diplomatic, Political, And Social Reasons The South Lost

1391 words - 6 pages

Why the North Won the Civil WarHistorians have argued inconclusively for years over the prime reason for Confederate defeat in the Civil War. The book Why the North Won the Civil War outlines five of the most agreed upon causes of Southern defeat, each written by a highly esteemed American historian. The author of each essay does acknowledge and discuss the views of the other authors. However, each author also goes on to explain their botheration and disagreement with their opposition. The purpose of this essay is to summarize each of the five arguments presented by Richard N. Current, T. Harry Williams, Norman A. Graebner, David Herbert Donald, and David M. Potter. Each author gives his ...view middle of the document...

His theories and beliefs formed a basis for military strategy and technique that would be used throughout the war. The Confederacy takes blame for their failure to adapt and develop new strategy as the war progressed. Williams sums this up by saying, "Lee and the other Confederate commanders were pretty much the same men in 1865 that they had been in 1861." (p.53) The North, however, is given credit for their willingness to modernize and adapt more effective strategies. This played a large role in contributing to the North's upperhand of leadership. Aside from solely military leadership, Williams merits the North in that President Lincoln was "an abler and a stronger man than Davis." (p.56) Lincoln's boldly offensive strategy that was eventually carried out by Grant proved successful to Union victory.Norman A. Graebner, in his essay "Northern Diplomacy and European Neutrality", attributes Southern failure to a different cause. Northen diplomatics, Graebner points out, are what saved the Union. If the Confederacy had received aid from a European power, it would have likely made a drastic change in the outcome of the war; the North knew this. The South hoped to gain allies with its dominant power in the cotton industry. Southern trade relations had improved dramatically since the explosion of cotton, and they hoped to use this to their benefit. Unfortunately, President Lincoln's Secretary of State, William H. Seward, made it his personal duty to prevent the intervention of a foreign power. Seward explained to the foreign governments that they were allies of the United States as a whole, and that no "de facto governments" existed. He was very successful in his efforts to wane other powers away from intervention. Threats were even made by Seward towards the British government explaining that any acknowledgement of the Confederate government would "be regarded as a manifestation of hostility by the United States." (p.65) In addition, the South failed to recognize the North's economic importance to its desired allies as well. Edouard de Stoeckl, the Russian Minister, made it clear from the beginning that Russia was a long standing friend of the United States and the last thing they wanted to see was a collapse in the Union. The British, followed by France, Spain, the Netherlands, and Brazil, issued a declaration of neutrality at the beginning of the war in order to prevent her involvement. This angered the North because by declaring neutrality, the British had recognized the South as a nation separate from the North. All the while, Seward had continued to sustain pressure among the foreign powers, making threats and promising wars. He scared away possible Southern allies by promising them war, and even threatened military action if they so much as spoke with Confederate leaders, officially or unofficially.The social aspect of Confederate defeat is discussed in David Herbert Donald's essay "Died of Democracy". He begins by pointing out that the...

Other Essays On Why The North Won The Civil War By David Donald: Reflection On The Economic, Military, Diplomatic, Political, And Social Reasons The South Lost

Assess The Impact Of Social, Political And Economic Issues In Early Twentieth Century Russia In The Downfall Of The Romanov Dynasty

1212 words - 5 pages Untitled "Assess the impact of social, political and economic issues in early twentieth century Russia in the downfall of the Romanov Dynasty." The downfall of the Romanov dynasty was due to the impacts of bearing internal factors on Russia such as the social, political and economic issues present in early twentieth century Russia. These issues were largely manufactured by previous generations of Tsars but ultimately set

19th Century European Imperialism Data Based Essay; Identify And Explain The Political, Economic, And Social Causes Of European Imperialism In The 19th Century

406 words - 2 pages Imperialism, the period of powerful countries conquering and dominating less-developed countries (mainly pertaining to European nations), reached its all-time high from 1870 to 1920. This is due to the economic, political, and social factors of the time. Ranging from feelings of nationalism to the need for more cheap labor, European powers dominated the world, oppressing whomever they needed to.The economic cause of imperialism is mostly

Political And Social Consequences Of The Protestant Reformation

661 words - 3 pages Roman Catholicism. The Catholic Church was wealthy, powerful, and had maintained a tight reign on Europe's traditional society. Gradually, however, there developed political and social problems within the Church. The common people criticized the management of the church and began to doubt some of its teachings. As old methods of the church lost efficiency, and a new denomination of religion formed, political and social changes began to shake the

The Lost World

1021 words - 5 pages English 103October 1, 14In the book "The Lost World" by Arthur Conan Doyle, four men endeavor on a dangerous journey to a land that is not known to man to see if dinosaurs exist. These four men were named Professor George Edward Challenger, Professor Summerlee, Lord John Roxton, and Edward Malone. When the four men reach the plateau, they start to witness dinosaurs and other exotic creatures. The portrayal of these creatures is realistic in the

The Lost Pocket

957 words - 4 pages catches the window frame, and pulls himself against it. He can't open the window. He tries to break the glass with a coin, signal apartments across the street by setting fire to papers he finds in his pockets, drop coins onto the street below, but all of his attempts fail. He realizes if he falls, he has no i.d. The only thing to be found on his person will be the contents of his pockets: the page of data. He regrets the time he has spent away

The Events That Led Up To The Civil War

783 words - 4 pages The Events Leading Up to the Civil WarConflicts widened between the North and the South as two sides collided in every event before the Civil War. The North and the South were very different in many ways. They were known as two different countries because of their cultural and economic differences. The disagreements between the North and the South aggravated the separation that was soon to follow. When the North gained the control of the

Reaction Paper on the article: Leadership and the common good by Randy David : Public Lives, Philippine Daily Inquirer Sunday, Jan. 9, 2005

440 words - 2 pages our own right, to do our part of the job for us to move towards the achievement of our goals. We have always been reminded that we must carefully choose our leaders, sudden dissatisfaction are proven to be costly for the organization as a whole.Bibliography:Editorial article: Leadership and the common good by Randy David : Public Lives, Philippine Daily Inquirer Sunday, Jan. 9, 2005

Discuss The Role Of Media Studies In Making Sense Of The Political, Economic, And Cultural Meaning Of Everyday Life

1250 words - 5 pages , as of a country, household, or business enterprise (The Australian Oxford Dictionary). The Frankfurt/Marxist School has contributed understandings of economic meanings, as too has the Political Economy. In terms of the economic realities which limit and organise other considerationsCultural studies is an Australian tradition that is heavily influenced by British Cultural studies and helps us to understand what role culture plays in our society

"When Corporations Rule The World" By David Korten

2282 words - 10 pages effects of the threefold of human crisis, the deepening of poverty, the social disintegration and environmental destruction. At the heart of this destruction is the corporations. The are unaccountable for the polluting and driven by an addiction to economic growth, the serve the interests of a very small international elite and are harming the rest of us. He hopes on the co-existence revolution that is bound to come. He also looks to an awakening of civil society and the growth of more social movements.

Why Did The Cold War Start

682 words - 3 pages The event of Cold War was shocking and controversial event which is still being discussed today. It is necessary to examine the many reasons why it started and how. While the ’why’ of what happened is still being argued, the ’what’ is fairly clear. The beginning of the Cold War was a basis of deep ideological differences as well as a series of misunderstandings or actions taken during WWII. The two immense powers – USA

Clara Barton, Founder Of The American Red Cross And A Civil War Nurse

560 words - 3 pages obtained permission to travel behind the lines, eventually reaching some of the grimmest battlefields of the war and serving during the sieges of Petersburg and Richmond. Barton delivered aid to soldiers of both the North and South. Never before had women been allowed in hospitals, camps or on battlefields; initially, military and civil officials declined her help. Eventually, she gained the trust of these officials and began receiving supplies

Similar Papers

Political, Psychological, Economic And Social Aftermath Of The Black Death

2542 words - 11 pages against the Jews and tensions between the sick and the healthy. Psychologically the Black Death staggered the entire medieval world and death was now on feared by everyone and "For anyone who had lived through the Black Death, hysteria could never be far away."From 1250 until 1347 Europe suffered a succession of very wet seasons and Europe′s entire agricultural production collapsed. Arable lands were rotting and with an increasing population a

To What Extent Did Economic, Political, And Social Change Effect The Lives Of Colonists After The American Revolution?

547 words - 3 pages Although the colonists' lives changed significantly in many ways after the American Revolution, the economic, political, and social conversions are viewed to be the most dramatic. The American Revolution was the war between the American colonies and Great Britain from 1775-1783 . Most consider this war not to be a nationalist revolution, in which the aim of the revolutionaries was to overturn the existing system, but rather to set up the North

China, Indonesia And South Africa. The Different Cultural, Political And Social Dimensions Of The Countries And How They Affect International Business

3836 words - 16 pages a smooth transition. 'China has suffered years of political turmoil catalysed by the business aspirations of western civilizations', and for an Australian organisation operating in China, a number of legal and government policies need to be followed to be successful. A further complication for Australian organisation is that state government policies vary from North to South, and representatives need to understand the different state owned

Weapons Of The Civil War Essay

1424 words - 6 pages rifle was made in the North for 15 to 20 dollars at theSpringfield Armory in Massachusetts and 32 other private manufacturers. It was considered on ofthe more modern weapons used in the Civil War. The Springfield Musket's weight was around9.25Lb, had a length of 58.5in, fires .58 calibre conical mine ball, and has a muzzle velocity of950ft/sec. The Whitworth rifle was made by the British and used mainly by the Confederate army.It used hexagonal