Civil War Essay Differences Of The North And South Monash University, Ats1320: Nations At War Essay

1649 words - 7 pages

By 1861, North and South had evolved separate institutions, interests, values, and ideologies that made it impossible for them to coexist as a single nation.’ Based on your readings of both unionists and secessionists, do you agree with this statement?
The growing political discontent present within America leading up to the outbreak of war at Fort Sumpter in 1861 highlights how there was a great divide between the North and South that made it impossible to coexist as one nation. The roots of this political discontent came from the incompatible economies of the North and South which perpetuated the political division within the nation. Furthermore, Northerners were predominately moderates and were not necessarily concerned with the moral aspects of slavery, and many agreed with the Southern attitudes towards African-Americans. However, the entrenched views on each side served to emphasise the gulf between the North and South making it impossible for them to co-exist as a single nation.
Northern political discourse was mainly centred around the support for the free-labour ideology. At the centre of this belief system was the desire to limit the expansion of slavery into new territories to provide wage earners with the ability to “rise to property-owning independence”.[footnoteRef:1] The North, specifically the Republican party, emphasised the economic growth and social mobility afforded by the free-labour ideology to justify the superiority of their society and extensively criticise the South. This is evident through conservative Bostonian Robert Winthrop’s remark that “the South is, upon the whole, the very poorest, meanest, least productive, and most miserable part of creation…”.[footnoteRef:2] Prominent politicians of the Republican party also promoted the superiority of the free-labour ideology such as William H. Seward who stated that: [1: Eric Foner, Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: the Ideology of the Republican Party Before the Civil War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1995), ix] [2: Robert Winthrop in Eric Foner, Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men, 43]
“The free-labour system educates all alike, and by opening all the fields of industrial employment, and all the departments of authority, to the unchecked and equal rivalry of all classes of men, at once secures universal contentment, and brings the highest possible activity all the physical, moral and social energies of the whole state”.[footnoteRef:3] [3: William H. Seward, ‘The Irrepressible Conflict’ (Rochester, 25 October 1858). In David Garrioch, ed. Nations at War: Revolution and Empire, (Clayton, 2018), 38-39]
Although the free-labour ideology dominated the political sphere, there were those in the North who endorsed the abolition of slavery. Owen Lovejoy was a prominent abolitionist who criticised Democrats and their racist justifications of slavery, questioning whether it is morally right to enslave those who perceived inferior.[footnoteRef:4] While representatives of ...

RELATED

Why The North Won The Civil War By David Donald: Reflection On The Economic, Military, Diplomatic, Political, And Social Reasons The South Lost

1391 words - 6 pages Why the North Won the Civil WarHistorians have argued inconclusively for years over the prime reason for Confederate defeat in the Civil War. The book Why the North Won the Civil War outlines five of the most agreed upon causes of Southern defeat, each written by a highly esteemed American historian. The author of each essay does acknowledge and discuss the views of the other authors. However, each author also goes on to explain their

Why South Sudan is Still at War - Comparative Politics - Essay

454 words - 2 pages Becca (Beier) Xu 10/15/18 Comparative Politics 015H Professor Irepoglu Carreras Why South Sudan is Still at War—Reflection South Sudanese civil war has meant ongoing for more than four years. The conflict between President Salva Kiir and Vice-President Riek Machar has turned South Sudan into a weaker state. Originally, South Sudan was born on very weak foundations where security, national development, and the economy did not meet the proper

Assignment On Weapons Of The Civil War

1424 words - 6 pages For four years, American blood spilled upon the soil of the so-called "United States". The cause of this bloodshed is known as the American Civil War, which lasted from 1861 to 1865. It put family against family, and neighbor against neighbor until the newly formed country split into the North and the South. The North, also called the Union, fought to keep the country intact. The South, also called the Confederate, fought for their right to own

Differences and similarities between Maryland and Baltimore - University of North Dakota History - Essay

520 words - 3 pages and write on top of many other things. In doing so, he states some similarities and some differences. One of many differences between Baltimore and rural Maryland Douglass describes is that the plantation had long working hours with less food. Overseers would give little to eat and little time to eat resulting in little energy and lots of labor. “ We were often less than five minutes taking our meals” (Pg. 71). As expressed, This is just one

Portrayal of masculinity in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Red Badge of Courage - Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II - Essay

1594 words - 7 pages Marthe Tanghe GL/EN 3472 Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II Portrayal of masculinity in ​Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ​and ​The Red Badge of Courage​: Two opposite sides of the spectrum. The representation of gender in literature has been studied in depth in the last half a century. We seem heavily engrossed in how gender portrayal can mean so many thing in novels; it can reveal plot points, character

Nationalist victory in the Spanish civil war - History - essay

4434 words - 18 pages Church has applied the full weight of her prestige, which has been placed at the service of truth and justice, to bring about the triumph of the National Cause.”[footnoteRef:40] [38: Casanova, J (2010). The Spanish Republic and Civil War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p.210] [39: Preston, P The Spanish Holocaust: Inquisition and Extermination in Twentieth-Century Spain (2012) London, Harper Press, p.210] [40: Raguer, H Gunpowder

The American Dream - Analysis of the Civil War generals - English - Essay

926 words - 4 pages slavery, be the primary driving force of the economy, or technical and machine-based manufacturing, backed by the expanding rail system, that would take the country into the 20th century. These two growing, and opposing ideologies embodied the two men who represented and lead the Union and Confederate states during the Civil War. Robert E. Lee, general of the Northern Virginia Army, manifested the noblest elements of the aristocratic ideal that

Essay on the effectiveness of British tactics in defeating Argentina at the Falklands War - History - Essay

1894 words - 8 pages Falklands War Essay Question: How effective were British air, land and naval tactics in defeating Argentina in the 1982 Falklands War? Britain were victorious in the 1982 Falklands war against Argentina, during the war they employed several successful tactics through their air, land and naval departments. Causes of the war include; Argentina’s devastating economic crisis and the invasion they staged of the Falkland Islands, which were under

Assess the reliability and usefulness of the documentary 'Prelude to War,' in determining the failure of the League of Nations

532 words - 3 pages The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key

The Importance of Marketing and Customer Value, in reference to T2 - Monash University - Essay

1702 words - 7 pages increase customer retention and satisfaction. The marketing team at T2 have managed to secure their place at the forefront of modern marketing intelligence, and it is clear to see why. The Importance of Marketing The essence of marketing is different to in every organisation across the globe. Some marketers believe it involves building brand equity by establishing a sufficient branch network, whilst others are convinced it primarily exists to solve

A cold war Culture: a philosophical dissection of Counter culture and its root in the cold war - American History; Colorado Christian University - Essay

835 words - 4 pages Running Head: CULTURAL LIES ABOUT SEX 1 Cultural Lies About Sex Ty Beaty Colorado Christian University Cold War Counterculture 2 Cultural Lies About Sex Since being expelled from the garden, humanity has been devastated by sin. In every corner of life, it lies dormant, waiting to be relished in and abused. As the generations have passed from the original sin, we continue to carry it in our bones, inherited from the beginning. “Behold, I was

Clara Barton, Founder Of The American Red Cross And A Civil War Nurse

560 words - 3 pages obtained permission to travel behind the lines, eventually reaching some of the grimmest battlefields of the war and serving during the sieges of Petersburg and Richmond. Barton delivered aid to soldiers of both the North and South. Never before had women been allowed in hospitals, camps or on battlefields; initially, military and civil officials declined her help. Eventually, she gained the trust of these officials and began receiving supplies

First world war key turning point in civil rights in the US? - History - Essay

899 words - 4 pages Black Americans with promises of a better lifestyle, higher wages and to end poverty. However, moving to the North did not mean the end of discrimination towards Black Americans. Although not as harsh as the South, many faced de facto segregation in housing and employment. Therefore, the first world war did have a major impact on the location of Black Americans and a change in the Black community and the stance towards civil rights issues affecting

Why the Civil war needed to happen? - Hist 4055 LSU - Essay

1669 words - 7 pages viewed as inevitable. The South desired its own identity and freedom to determine how they operated as a whole, which was due to the array of differences between the political, religious, economic, and geographic aspects between the North and South. With the secession of the South, the Confederate states of America were formed, and the South gained a sense of pride and independence that they had not experienced prior to the Civil War. The two

Reasons for Civil War Articles - David M. Potter and Micheal F. Holt Comparison - Austin Peay State University/History 2010 36 - Essay

1317 words - 6 pages of the land but the North wanted abolishment while the South did not. Others thought its cause was not directly the conflict of slavery or sectionals but a variety of other reasons. Some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political mistakes and that slavery did not cause it at all. Several others believe the expansion of slavery, and its entrance into the political scene was the real causation. In “The Sectional Divisions That Led